Posi Confirms: COH Largest and Most Active MMO Ever Shut Down
The "Save COH" motion took NCSoft by surprise? My opinion of them has been pretty poor following the announcement, but that little snippet makes me genuinely angry.
I would try to sum up my feelings in words but I don't think there are enough expletives in the English language to sufficiently convey my frustration.
A circle forms, everybody comes round
Just to hear the incredible sound
Of a genius smashing expectations
- Jonathan Coulton
Pancakes.
Galaxies was a different situation because Galaxies was shut down so it wouldn't cannibalize TOR (or so they say). One could argue that it was shut down because of the large size of its player base.
|
As a subscriber of SWG from launch and until a little after their NGE debacle in 2005, I don't believe that the game's population was enough to sustain it. SOE (possibly their only positive) is pretty stubborn in keeping titles running (especially after the disaster they created there... it would have looked even worse on them if the game was cancelled right after their ultimate game changes in '05), but the exodus from that game (who's population wasn't all that great after WoW and CoH came along anyway) left things pretty bad over there. I'm sure, after the server consolidation and the people remaining banded together, it seemed like a nice thing for those who enjoyed it, but it still wasn't what it was and I doubt it compared to our population.
Indeed, their Station Pass setup allows for inflated numbers and more people who may be around, but not necessarily subscribers/frequenters to that particular game. So, that may make calculating such things a bit difficult.
Anyway...
and round up everyone that knows more than they do"-Dylan
The thing that struck me was the fact that NCSoft has been paying Matt and the others for the last two months, but wouldn't let them finish off Issue 24 (which must have been close to release) and organise some quality farewell events for the last month or so of the game. Shutting down all development completely on August 31st seems even more mean-spirited to me now. Everything we know about the Paragon Team would suggest that given the chance, many of them would have been willing to give City of Heroes a proper send off.
|
It also may just be standard corporate policy being applied, that once someone is fired, they're out of the office unless there's a compelling need to keep them on. If they're still in the office, they've got access to servers, email systems, other things that a revenge minded person might choose to abuse. Less likely in the case with the whole office being shut down (to say nothing that from what I know of the people who worked at Paragon Studios, they wouldn't do it), but sometimes corporate policy gets set to handle some specific conditions and becomes the Word Of God to be applied in all conditions.
My arcs are constantly shifting, just search for GadgetDon for the latest.
The world beware! I've started a blog
GadgetMania Under Attack: The Digg Lockout
The "Save COH" motion took NCSoft by surprise? My opinion of them has been pretty poor following the announcement, but that little snippet makes me genuinely angry.
I would try to sum up my feelings in words but I don't think there are enough expletives in the English language to sufficiently convey my frustration. |
I suspect the surprise more "Holy *bleep*, these people are angry, and they're ORGANIZED. They're getting the word out in ways that make us look bad."
My arcs are constantly shifting, just search for GadgetDon for the latest.
The world beware! I've started a blog
GadgetMania Under Attack: The Digg Lockout
I'm just going to add that it irks me a little that their October 2nd press release ("exhausted all efforts") was so successful in quieting a lot of people and hopes around here.
I really felt like that was the time to shout right back louder than we had before.
What does that mean? Just simply continuing as much publicity as we could muster. Oh, believe me, there were many people still trying, but a large amount of our playerbase was simply gone and our turnouts seemed to be far smaller than previously. Believe me, that is all understandable... we were here for fun and to play a game... not to fight an impossible fight against a billion-dollar corporation via the press, media and any publicity stunts we could create. I just would like to see NCSoft's reactions to further negative press and public out-crying after their statement that that was that and all attempts had been exhausted.
Of course, people are still trying to do these very things and failure never happens until all efforts cease. So, you never know. And if you ever feel like helping out, every little bit counts.
and round up everyone that knows more than they do"-Dylan
The thing that struck me was the fact that NCSoft has been paying Matt and the others for the last two months, but wouldn't let them finish off Issue 24 (which must have been close to release) and organise some quality farewell events for the last month or so of the game. Shutting down all development completely on August 31st seems even more mean-spirited to me now. Everything we know about the Paragon Team would suggest that given the chance, many of them would have been willing to give City of Heroes a proper send off.
|
Not saying they WOULD but they sure COULD. Not worth the risk....safer to mothball the code as-is.
I'm just going to add that it irks me a little that their October 2nd press release ("exhausted all efforts") was so successful in quieting a lot of people and hopes around here.
I really felt like that was the time to shout right back louder than we had before. What does that mean? Just simply continuing as much publicity as we could muster. Oh, believe me, there were many people still trying, but a large amount of our playerbase was simply gone and our turnouts seemed to be far smaller than previously. Believe me, that is all understandable... we were here for fun and to play a game... not to fight an impossible fight against a billion-dollar corporation via the press, media and any publicity stunts we could create. I just would like to see NCSoft's reactions to further negative press and public out-crying after their statement that that was that and all attempts had been exhausted. Of course, people are still trying to do these very things and failure never happens until all efforts cease. So, you never know. And if you ever feel like helping out, every little bit counts. ![]() |
embarrass NCsoft until they hire everyone back?
I understand the concern to show NCsoft they can't treat companies and consumers like this but...I severely doubt they care.
NCSoft may have been legally obligated to continue to pay people like Matt for a few months but they had zero obligation to keep the live servers up and running for -any- period of time after their final decision to kill the game. The servers could have been instantly shutdown on August 31st and that would have been all she wrote.
I am by no means saying I'm happy with NCSoft's decision to shut CoH down. But in the grand scheme of things I'm happier we got to play the game for 3 extra months (without updates) than not. *shrugs* |
Could you imagine the lawsuits?
People had just purchased points and a new powerset. Closure without being able to use those purchases would've been grounds for litigation.
No. The 3 months wasn't a 'we feel bad for you loyal customers'. It was a 'we don't want to get sued'.
If they really cared, they would've softened the blow with all number of giveaways and sendoffs. Instead they fired the dev team and left the game open 3 months to close out accounts and send out refunds.
Please buff Ice Control.
I'm just going to add that it irks me a little that their October 2nd press release ("exhausted all efforts") was so successful in quieting a lot of people and hopes around here.
I really felt like that was the time to shout right back louder than we had before. What does that mean? Just simply continuing as much publicity as we could muster. Oh, believe me, there were many people still trying, but a large amount of our playerbase was simply gone and our turnouts seemed to be far smaller than previously. Believe me, that is all understandable... we were here for fun and to play a game... not to fight an impossible fight against a billion-dollar corporation via the press, media and any publicity stunts we could create. I just would like to see NCSoft's reactions to further negative press and public out-crying after their statement that that was that and all attempts had been exhausted. Of course, people are still trying to do these very things and failure never happens until all efforts cease. So, you never know. And if you ever feel like helping out, every little bit counts. ![]() |
as a side note, i'm really glad to hear about the weight thing. that was a significant step for his health, and I'm betting he feels significantly better because of it.
I simply find it hard to believe that there is a such a large player base available and no one is out trying to create a game that caters to them.
"Samual_Tow - Be disappointed all you want, people. You just don't appreciate the miracles that are taking place here."
I simply find it hard to believe that there is a such a large player base available and no one is out trying to create a game that caters to them.
|
When it comes to super hero mmos theres nothing to...aspire to. Both the current super hero mmos can only be described as....."alive" (although DCOU is getting player housing soon)
'
any potential publisher or developer looking at making a new super hero mmo is just going to look at those two flops and assume that there isn't any money in it
But what exactly is the end goal here
embarrass NCsoft until they hire everyone back? I understand the concern to show NCsoft they can't treat companies and consumers like this but...I severely doubt they care. |
![Smile](images/smilies/smile.gif)
Just quickly, the end goal would basically be to get them to sell the game/IP/code so that it could still be played.
Indeed (as frostdrake mentions below), the original intention was to get them to sell as quickly so that as much of Paragon Studios (and our game and community) could stay intact and continue on after the bump/detour in the road of NCSoft ditching us.
Even at the October 2nd mark, there was still a chance of us keeping such things. I'm under no delusion that NCSoft would change their minds ealiy, but it was always worth a shot.
At this point, yeah, it is likely way too late to salvage most of the team (although, perhaps my assessment of the job availabilities for them are overly optimistic). And this community and former playerbase is also likely fractured beyond what could have continued.
As for the overall reasons for fighting back, there is the microcosm and the macrocosm. We have/had the talented workers to fight for, the game to fight for, our community to fight for; We also have the ideals to fight for. Is this how we want the mmorpg landscape to be shaped? Profitable and relatively sizable games/communities that are highly enjoyed by loyal, paying customers/participants (and studio employees/designers) being shut down due to billion-dollar companies refocusing, because the profits the product makes (while quite a lot to some of us) is too small a hill for their mountain range?
I just saw someone mention recently, "NCSoft was selling a game. We were paying for access to a community". While, obviously, most of us were certainly paying for a game, first and foremost, the true community aspect is simply collateral damage to NCSoft's views. And, that's all fine... They should have separated themselves from the game (et all) and given it a much better chance to survive and continue. And our influence could (and possibly still can) alter the outcome of all of this.
to be fair, a lot of people were helping initially because we wanted to help the efforts of brian clayton and presumably a part of our dev team get the game back. with october being the great "go screw yourselves" from ncsoft, that goal mostly vanished, they weren't selling, and no crying westerners were going to change that. I am all for generating what negative publicity that I can for them, and have been preparing reader reviews of guild wars 2 for gamefaqa, amazon, gamerankings and metacritic to try and hurt them where i can, and I have been active on kotaku making sure people know what ncsoft did in every ncsoft related post that would make sense, they wont blink now, and the devs wouldnt be there if they did, so pretty much all I could do is go from "work with ncsoft" to "hurt ncsoft" and I can be persistent.
|
Even offering an announcement that no negotiations will tak place is a part of negotiating... otherwise, there'd be zero communication.
My final point is that, unfortunately, their tactic (with that announcement) worked like a charm for them.
"Stop protesting! You cannot win!"
And the majority of people walked away saying, "Oh, okay, that's over!".
Just boggles my mind that people would take that reaction.
![Big Grin](images/smilies/biggrin.gif)
as a side note, i'm really glad to hear about the weight thing. that was a significant step for his health, and I'm betting he feels significantly better because of it.
|
I simply find it hard to believe that there is a such a large player base available and no one is out trying to create a game that caters to them.
|
Unfortunately, companies want the big, easily-marketed-to, most-ideal (according to our research) masses and not the hard to define, (somewhat) sensible, mature (somewhat), casual and loyal group of people with money in-hand.
Welcome to the crossroads of entertainment and business!
and round up everyone that knows more than they do"-Dylan
[B][SIZE="3"]In the first 20 minutes of the podcast, Positron mentions what are arguably the three most salient points for City of Heroes fans. Firstly, they (Paragon Studios) tried everything, and anything that wasn't tried was at least thought about and brought up in a meeting. In every case, when reading the forums, Facebook, Twitter, PMs or Twitch commentary by COH fans saying things like, "Why haven't you tried this?" Or, "Have you thought of that?" Or "Please do this before it's too late," the first thought to go through Matt's head was "Yes, yes, and yes," it's been on the table and either thought through or actually tried. Paragon Studios was just as caught off-guard by NCSoft's surprise realignment of focus as their fans, and just like many of their fans, they worked their tails off on their end to try and save the game. Secondly, as a matter of fact, City of Heroes is the largest and most active MMO ever to be shut down. Specifically, it had more active and average concurrent daily users than any MMO ever to be shut down. ... |
I also take it as further evidence that NCSoft was being unreasonable, when Positron takes the time to tell us that CoH is the largest MMO ever killed. Take that air in a second... Positron, who is in the industry, says that CoH is the most healthy MMO ever killed.
I'm still sick to my stomach. I hope that Positron does work on a CoH2 (Super Hero MMO) for some other gaming developer other than NCSoft. It would be wonderful to have a new improved Super Hero game.
My arcs are constantly shifting, just search for GadgetDon for the latest.
The world beware! I've started a blog
GadgetMania Under Attack: The Digg Lockout
Corporate policy 101 dictates that once you give someone notice you do NOT give them freedom to do what they want. Posi and crew could have just as easily coded a virus into the launcher as disgruntled employees, exposing NCSoft to huge liability.
Not saying they WOULD but they sure COULD. Not worth the risk....safer to mothball the code as-is. |
Edit: the notion that the way Paragon Studios was shutdown would be considered reasonable in the corporate world is something that's just not true. The fact that NCsoft had no *contractual* obligation to its customers to gracefully sunset the game has no bearing on whether or not the way they are going about it would be considered reasonable. I could legally liquidate my company tomorrow and walk away from all of my customers, and that would be legal. It would also severely impact their operations. I would also probably never work in this field again, because while "Corporate 101" says you can do whatever you can legally get away with, "Corporate 401" says forgive and forget is for greeting cards.
NCsoft is shutting down Paragon Studios and City of Heroes in a manner not consistent with caring what the people of the studio and the people who are the game's customers attitudes and perceptions are. And maybe that won't hurt them in the long run in a material way, but that's irrelevant to the fact they don't in fact believe any of those people are worth any real consideration beyond pro-forma.
[Guide to Defense] [Scrapper Secondaries Comparison] [Archetype Popularity Analysis]
In one little corner of the universe, there's nothing more irritating than a misfile...
(Please support the best webcomic about a cosmic universal realignment by impaired angelic interference resulting in identity crisis angst. Or I release the pigmy water thieves.)
I wonder if NCSoft has considered what this closure will mean to their ability to find development studios that will be willing to work with them.
Where would a dev team trying to design and market a new game pitch their idea first for a NA and European release? NCSoft doesn't instill me with confidence that they can handle this side of the globe.
Please buff Ice Control.
They haven't "worked with" a development studio since Cryptic, they now simply buy them outright or set up a studio themselves.
Father Xmas - Level 50 Ice/Ice Tanker - Victory
$725 and $1350 parts lists --- My guide to computer components
Tempus unum hominem manet
I don't believe Plan Z will really get anywhere - I think people are being very unrealistic.
My new Youtube Channel with CoH info
You might know me as FlintEastwood now on Freedom
![](http://www.jaybonaut.com/Stuff/heroes/Samuraiko.jpg)
I don't believe Plan Z will really get anywhere - I think people are being very unrealistic.
|
"Cryptic? Who the heck are they?"
They're both just groups of people who decided to make a superhero game. And one of those groups has been fanning the fires of outrage against the forces of injustice since August 31st besides. I'd imagine that could be a pretty potent motivator.
![Wink](images/smilies/wink.gif)
I simply find it hard to believe that there is a such a large player base available and no one is out trying to create a game that caters to them.
|
Those members of SaveCoX who are continually spouting the 'if we don't get our way, we're just going to keep screaming at NCSoft until we hurt them forever' line are also doing a pretty good job of making sure it never happens. Strange as this may seem, companies aren't really interested in saddling themselves with a group of consumers who have been proven to make a stink at the first sign of injury, real or imagined. It just not worth getting into a position where you have to appease people who have demonstrated that they'll attack your image at every opportunity if you don't bow to their demands.
At this point, yeah, it is likely way too late to salvage most of the team (although, perhaps my assessment of the job availabilities for them are overly optimistic). And this community and former playerbase is also likely fractured beyond what could have continued.
|
Sure, but, at that time, instead of taking their "go screw yourselves" as the end of it, I felt like we should have stepped up and countered it with a larger show than we did at the initial announcement.
Even offering an announcement that no negotiations will tak place is a part of negotiating... otherwise, there'd be zero communication. My final point is that, unfortunately, their tactic (with that announcement) worked like a charm for them. "Stop protesting! You cannot win!" And the majority of people walked away saying, "Oh, okay, that's over!". Just boggles my mind that people would take that reaction. ![]() |
It doesn't help that the SaveCoX has never really had anything like a unified mission statement or measurable goals that an interested party could be directed to and identify with. Ask ten people what 'Saving CoX' means, and you'd get five different answers and five combinations of those answers. Keep NCSoft from shutting down Paragon. Get them to sell the IP. Shutter Paragon but keep the servers on. Release the code for emulators. And so on.
And sorry to say it but "Do *insert whatever my permutation of wants is here* by Nov 30th" isn't a measurable goal, it's just an ultimatum.
Take the Call to Actions. I applaud the concept, but not the execution. Which of the several definitions of 'saved' were they supposed to enable, and what measurement was used to determine how successful they were, or, just as important, weren't, at bringing those ends to pass?
Did anyone do any research on letter writing campaigns, for example, to determine what the effectiveness threshold was? Statistically, how many needed to be sent? What, historically, has been the best format? or Tone? or Content? Is it better to send them individually, or get a lot of them together and send them all as one package? Was there even an attempt to keep an accurate tally of how many were sent? And the letter writing campaign is followed up with the capes and masks attempt, which is basically the same thing. And what do you have to show for either? That the company set up an email account for you to send to directly, and speculation as to why that might be the case? So you have no idea who did what, or what it did or didn't accomplish, and nothing real to use as good or bad press.
"A bunch of people sent letters" is mumbled heresay. "We received 10,000 letters and packages from fans that we sent on to NCSoft" is a usable data point.
People and groups seriously working towards meaningful outcomes have defined and measurable goals, and systems in place to do those measurements. It's what makes them effective, because they know exactly how well something did or didn't work, and can focus their efforts appropriately.
Further, because the movement is fractured, anything short of a complete reversal of the decision to shut down Paragon/CoX (which is impossible now in any case) leaves you with a portion of the group feeling like their want wasn't catered to. That's a no-win situation for NCSoft.
And since there are still no clearly defined and measurable goals, how will you know you are successful in whatever you choose to do post-Nov 30th? How will you know your efforts had an effect on Blade and Soul, or Wildstar, or GW2? If Blade and Soul fails, for example, how will you know it's because of the negative press against NCSoft, and not because it is a crappy game, or even just a game that doesn't fit the current market? Or are you just going to take credit regardless of the truth and 'prove' it with anecdotes? Is there any consensus on when NCSoft has suffered enough? One different style game sunset? One failed game? NCSoft leaving the Western market? NCSoft going bankrupt? What's the unified end goal? When does the group think "justice" is done?
I find it highly unlikely a unified goal or a way of measuring the success of the post closure actions will suddenly emerge from the confusion. And honestly, without real focus you're going to be easily dismissed as just more random internet rage amongst the sea of it that shows up on every single comment thread ever made.
That has been the most frustrating part of the SaveCoX movement to me. I understand, respect, and agree with not wanting something you care about to go away. That is a fine and worthy sentiment. But without structure, that's all it is. Sentiment. And right now, the only thing that seems to be a unifying factor in the SaveCoX movement, at least if you go by the vocal posters, is general anger at NCSoft, and that's not really going to be an effective catalyst for change.
Unfortunately, companies want the big, easily-marketed-to, most-ideal (according to our research) masses and not the hard to define, (somewhat) sensible, mature (somewhat), casual and loyal group of people with money in-hand.
|
Just to be clear, I'm not trying to convince anyone not to be angry. Anger is a perfectly respectable response to what's happened and motivation to change it. I just don't think venting anger is a useful method to get what you want. I think it's the exact opposite, in fact. And if people are just waiting for Dec 1 to unleash some vaguely defined internet justice on NCSoft, that says to me that they've already given up on CoX and any potential future iterations of the Super Hero MMO that, in time, might have replaced it.
Well, you never know. When Cryptic launched City of Heroes, everyone on earth said,
"Cryptic? Who the heck are they?" They're both just groups of people who decided to make a superhero game. And one of those groups has been fanning the fires of outrage against the forces of injustice since August 31st besides. I'd imagine that could be a pretty potent motivator. ![]() |
I've said it several times before: even if all of Paragon Studios were working on this, or even on reverse-engineering instead of Plan-Z, it might never happen, and if it did, we are talking years.
![Wink](images/smilies/wink.gif)
My new Youtube Channel with CoH info
You might know me as FlintEastwood now on Freedom
![](http://www.jaybonaut.com/Stuff/heroes/Samuraiko.jpg)
I get reminded of an old bit of poetry. I'll have to paraphrase a bit...
They came for exsteel... and I said nothing, becuse I didn't play.
They came for dungeon runners... and I said nothing because I didn't play.
THey came for Auto Assault... and I said nothing because I didn't play.
They came for Tabula Rasa... and I said nothing because I didn't play.
then they came for City of Heroes... and there was nobody left to speak for me.
At this point, barring a miracle or two, this is where we are. Even if we can't save this game, we must continue making noise so that maybe the next game that gets shut down gets treated a little better.
Its not about NC Soft anymore, we know all that we need to know about them, its about the gaming community as a whole. All of those people who play Guild Wars, or Aion, or LoTRO, or STO, or Secret World, or any of the dozens of other games out there, they are listening and they are wondering...
Who will speak for me?
We will. Because we are heroes, this is what we do.
Writer of In-Game fiction: Just Completed: My Summer Vacation. My older things are now being archived at Fanfiction.net http://www.fanfiction.net/~jwbullfrog until I come up with a better solution.