The Walking Dead returns...
That did it...
I officially hate TV Carl now. Little *******.
Story arcs:
The Golden Scepter: #9852 [Winner of American Legion's July 2011 AE Author Contest]
Let your voice be heard! Sign the petition to keep CoH alive.
wow...did not see that happening....poor Dale....r.i.p.
You only fail if you give up. - Dana Scully
Time Jesum Transeuntum Et Non Riverentum - Nick Cave
We're not just destroyers, at the same time we can be saviors. - Allen Walker
I'll miss Dale. It sounds like he had a better death in the comic.
I guess Carl didn't take Shane's advise to stop trying to get killed, only this time he got someone else killed.
Now that we know more about Randall's group, I'd probably be in favor of getting rid of him as well...
Agua Man lvl 48 Water/Electric Blaster
"To die hating NCSoft for shutting down City of Heroes, that was Freedom."
Having avoided any spoilers for the show...
That was unexpected.
Excellent performance by Jeffrey DeMunn in this episode. What a great hour role that would have been as an actor - running a real range of emotions and interactions.
Dale's voice will be missed when it comes to regulating the group.
Rick and Company need to think in terms of leaving the farm. Randalls' group sounds like a group of Shanes, and they definitely sound local.
Carl... um, has some issues to sort out. And I can certainly see that we may be building to dramatic role in his life.
Zombie cow!
Notes about Dale: While I honestly didn't expect to see him to check out during last night's episode it almost made sense for him to get killed at this point. Of the entire group I think he always represented "the past", the time before the ZA when there was law and civilization. Clearly the group has been slipping away from that as more people die and the truth that things are never going to return to "normal" is finally driven home.
Dale, as a character, served his purpose. He made his point known to Shane, Rick and the others that the world as they knew it was over. In order to "prove" his point he really had no where to go character-wise other than to get killed in a senselessly sad way. His death verified that the world has in fact changed and that the group is broken. It'll be up to the others to pick up the pieces and recreate a new world that Dale could have never been a part of.
Notes about Carl: Opposite to Dale we have Carl who represents "the future". He's growing up in a world where things have literally become survival of the fittest. He's learning that individual human life is almost meaningless, where random friends or strangers can end up dying at any moment. He's now even learned (or at least feels guilty about) what it's like to let someone die due to his actions. I suspect Dale's death may be the tipping point that'll crush any last ideas about him just being a carefree innocent child.
Some may think that he'll turn into some kind of maladjusted sociopath, and if the world was still in pre-ZA mode that might be one way to summarize it. But I think that given the circumstances of the post-ZA world that he's learning exactly the kinds of harsh lessons he'll need to survive. He won't be able to afford the luxuries of second-guessing and compassion that got Dale killed (at least indirectly).
In a weird sort of way I see Dale's death almost akin to that classic scene when Luke Skywalker watched Obi Wan get killed by Darth Vader. It was a pivotal scene in Carl's life that'll galvanize him into becoming the kind of man he'll need to be in order to survive.
Notes about Randall: I'm fairly convinced that he's completely full of crap and a definite threat to the group. First off he didn't really seem that innocent when Daryl was beating him. Sure he was whimpering and begging Daryl to stop, but he was acting more like a captured enemy soldier rather than a purely innocent kid. He only told Daryl things -after- Daryl beat he more. If he was truly innocent/repentant he'd be telling Daryl everything instantly instead of trying to keep his mouth shut.
Also there was that scene where Carl snuck into barn and Randall was trying to get him to let him go so that he could "go back to his group". Why does Randall have so much loyalty to that other group which supposedly did all those evil things that he tried to claim he didn't do himself?
Let's just say if Randall actually ends up being an innocent kid that's true to his word then I'll be surprised at this point. I think Shane's assessment of Randall's threat is spot-on.
Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀
*** SPOILERS from March 4th episode ***
I find it amusing that Dale shuffles on, and apparently the next episode we find out how wrong he might be about Randall. Shane will get in his "I told you so"s for sure. Some rather large divergences from the comics at this point, which is really cool. I wasn't expecting Dale to die this fast; he managed to live quite a bit longer in the book.
OK, zombie behavior question: We've never seen a zombie animal of any sort, so I have to assume that the cow was still alive, but in a lot of pain. Why did the zombie leave the "feast"? We've never seen any of them leave a still living person/animal unless they were forced to. Isn't it a bit odd that this one decided to wander away long enough to surprise Dale?
I find your lack of signature disturbing.
OK, zombie behavior question: We've never seen a zombie animal of any sort, so I have to assume that the cow was still alive, but in a lot of pain. Why did the zombie leave the "feast"? We've never seen any of them leave a still living person/animal unless they were forced to. Isn't it a bit odd that this one decided to wander away long enough to surprise Dale?
|
If this had been a "real" zombie encounter Dale would have just simply walked up to see the zombie chowing down on the cow and would have easily been able to pop it in the back of the head. Somehow we are supposed to believe the zombie left the half-eaten (not even quite dead) cow to be able to sneak up behind Dale.
Unfortunately there seems to a lot of scenes like this in this show where you just have to set your common sense aside and let things happen for the purposes of the story.
Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀
FINALLY!
Hated Dale.
Hate people who constantly whine about others behind their back, even when told to shut up.
Don't count your weasels before they pop dink!
Just watched Talking Dead, which had an interesting factoid: The director stated that they intentionally filmed that zombie such that his eyes never blinked.
So, do zombies never blink? Is the autonomous reflex in a part of the brain which does not "reactivate"? And, if this is the case, will it be a nation of blind zombies in a few months?
I find your lack of signature disturbing.
Just watched Talking Dead, which had an interesting factoid: The director stated that they intentionally filmed that zombie such that his eyes never blinked.
So, do zombies never blink? Is the autonomous reflex in a part of the brain which does not "reactivate"? And, if this is the case, will it be a nation of blind zombies in a few months? |
For what it's worth they've apparenetly established that the zombies in this show have a pretty good sense of smell (for blood for instance). I'd guess they'd still be pretty dangerous even if we found out that they are mostly blind at this point.
Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀
They didn't say on Talking Dead that they don't blink. The director was merely pointing out that the particular person playing that zombie didn't blink for that particular zombie to give it more of a "skull like" effect. But I didn't gather that meant all zombie's don't blink. It sounded to me like a specific decision made for dramatic effect.
@Mental Maden @Maden Mental
"....you are now tackle free for life."-ShoNuff
They didn't say on Talking Dead that they don't blink. The director was merely pointing out that the particular person playing that zombie didn't blink for that particular zombie to give it more of a "skull like" effect. But I didn't gather that meant all zombie's don't blink. It sounded to me like a specific decision made for dramatic effect.
|
Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀
They didn't say on Talking Dead that they don't blink. The director was merely pointing out that the particular person playing that zombie didn't blink for that particular zombie to give it more of a "skull like" effect. But I didn't gather that meant all zombie's don't blink. It sounded to me like a specific decision made for dramatic effect.
|
Yeah the director was just doing a specific "no blink" thing for this episode. But it might be reasonable to assume that most of them don't blink in general anyway, especially when you consider lots of them probably have enough face damage/rot to make that impossible anyway.
|
I find your lack of signature disturbing.
Regarding the issue of zombie degredation - I know point was made in the comic that it was safer for the humans in the winter because the cold air slowed down, or perhaps in some cases even froze the zombies solid. Still, they seemed to survive that when spring came.
Another thing that came to mind was the issue I think that was mentioned here about how easy it seems to be to stab through their skulls to kill them, and I knod of came up with a personal justification for that: osteoporosis. The zombies aren't drinking enough milk, so their bones are getting brittle!
(Sometimes, I wish there could be a Dev thumbs up button for quality posts, because you pretty much nailed it.) -- Ghost Falcon
I'd be more concerned with how there was no real sound indicitive of an animal in distress, other than that little bit of mooing Dale heard.
Well, there was that zombie munchin' on a deer in season one. Gotta imagine that a deer is harder to catch than a mobile vegetable. The cow could've been sleeping though.
I'd be more concerned with how there was no real sound indicitive of an animal in distress, other than that little bit of mooing Dale heard. |
Actually in regards to the deer in season one I believe that Daryl had actually killed it and the zombie got to it before Daryl could come and take it back to the rock quarry campsite....In regards to the cow....it could have been that the cow had bedded down and that is how the zombie was able to get to it.....although I am not sure why the zombie wandered off...perhaps something caught its attention and it went off to investigate....
I read somewhere (or it was on Talking Dead) that originally Dale was supposed to have found another member of the group dead instead of the cow....
ZOMBIE COW!!!!!! MOOOOOOO!!!!!!
You only fail if you give up. - Dana Scully
Time Jesum Transeuntum Et Non Riverentum - Nick Cave
We're not just destroyers, at the same time we can be saviors. - Allen Walker
I don't recall, but didn't Shane and Rick come upon the deer and then Darryl shot the zombie in the head with his crossbow? It's very fuzzy.
Even if the walker started munching on the cow as it was asleep, you'd think at some point, the cow would wake up. I mean, I know cows are not exactly the sharpest knives in the drawer, but you'd think the stink alone (presuming they are stinky) would be enough to rouse the cow to make some noise.
Also, what the heck was Dale doing wandering way out there past the corpse pile in the first place?
I see Carl has inherited some of his mother's traits.
Poor Dale. It'll be interesting to see how this affects Andrea.
Father Xmas - Level 50 Ice/Ice Tanker - Victory
$725 and $1350 parts lists --- My guide to computer components
Tempus unum hominem manet
Great death scene. Loved Dale in this episode. Most times I find him cloyingly dramatic and sometimes wished he'd shut up but this time around his presence was absolutely necessary. Decent episode but Carl is now neck and neck with Andrea for characters I hate because they don't know how to listen. Seriously, someone put a bell on that kid.
Magus Prime- lev 50 kin/ elec defender
Meta-Human- lev 50 fire/ ss tank
Cabal Bravo- lev 50 merc/ ff master mind
Schwarzchild- lev 50 grav/ ff controller
Shanghai Storm- lev 50 ma/invinc scrapper
Nicodemus- lev 50 db/ regen scrapper
Dragonhyde- lev 50 wp/ sm tank
On The Pinnochle server!
Carl's probably only going to get worse. He has no one his own age to relate to anymore. Having Sophia around probably acted as a brake on his idiocy.
PS: Walking Dead is literally the only NEW show I've picked up in the last few years that I salvate to watch the next episode of......last time it was season 1 Heroes.....
|
Also, I wish they'd go ahead and shoot Shane. I can't stand arrogant 'alpha males' like him. I really enjoyed this episode.
|
So, I'm seeing things from Lothic's point of view and have been thinking about it for a short while since catching a thread about who you would want to lead the group... Rick, Shane, Hershel, or Dale.
- Dale most certainly represented Civilization with a big C. Justice and Humanity. Unfortunately, justice and humanity, that higher-level philosophy/outlook, is a luxury that one simply can't afford when very basic survival is on the line. A generation of men have to make compromises in order to sow the seeds of "civility". Dale's death most certainly represented the end of civilization as we know it (and it died horribly).
- Hershel was pretty much a good Samaritan with misplaced values in regards to the Walkers. He's not a leader, but simply a guy with resources (for now).
- Shane adapted to the new world quickly. Dale said something to the effect of "You're perfect for this world" and I think that was an unfair characterization, especially considering how Shane was portrayed as keeping the group together. When Andrea claimed, "you're decisions are mostly good, it's just how you go about it that is problematic" was far more appropriate. Something that was bothersome was how quickly everyone latched onto the "Shane killed Otis" theory, which is really all it was and it felt very mechanical. Until Daryl's comment that Shane came back with Otis' gun, there really wasn't any reason to give credence to that line of thinking. As an audience, we knew more, but the characters in the story really didn't. Shane does have flaws, like his obsession with Lori, but as a leader, his judgement give the circumstances is pretty sound.
- Rick somehow took over leadership of the group as soon as he arrived and that was annoying, especially given the wishy-washiness he presented. I'm assuming Shane must have been a deputy to Rick and that structure just fell into place, with everyone falling into line behind Shane's lead. The problem is that Rick got people killed. He's wishywashy, slow to decide, and making decisions for the group based on what he feels is right for his family. Ultimately, Rick does the things that Shane would do, alebit with more deliberation.
Darryl's whineness/passive-aggressiveness -- he's feeling a bit like the Boba Fett of the group (an ancillary character with moments of "coolness"); I think he survived because he had his big brother looking out for him (Merl? -- the guy that cut off his hand to escape the roof).
Lori bugs me as much as everyone else I think. I think the characterization that she's the self-entitled queen of the group is pretty much on the mark. I applaud her attitude that they need to try and keep the "home life" going, but I also question her mothering ability since Carl seems to be everywhere he shouldn't be. What does she do with her day?
Which leads me to the group. Cattle break through the fence and none of them are doing a single thing to help out--that's a food source the group will need, especially if stocks are thin already. Sure, someone keeps watch and occasionally you see the women help cook a dinner, but if the group is committed to staying at the farm, why aren't they actually working. I know Hershel recognizes the importances of having guards after the encounter at the bar, but he should be asking more people to step up, especially given the losses he's suffered to his family who helped maintain the farm.
Anyway, I'm enjoying the show -- For now I find it more compelling to watch and see what happens next. Hopefully it doesn't turn into another Heroes, although without a set ending already in place, I can see it fading away.
@Texarkana
@Thexder
I was kind of surprised that they decided to put Dale out of his misery like that. Other than being in pain/shock, is being disemboweled fatal? I've heard of people being stabbed or wounded in the abdomen and their intestines coming out and surviving. I guess the doc must have seen more ripped stuff inside Dale than just the skin and knew it was beyond his capability to fix.
Also: looking forward to seeing the ZOMBIE COW!
The virus or whatever probably only effects human brains or something....
@Joshua.
I was kind of surprised that they decided to put Dale out of his misery like that. Other than being in pain/shock, is being disemboweled fatal? I've heard of people being stabbed or wounded in the abdomen and their intestines coming out and surviving. I guess the doc must have seen more ripped stuff inside Dale than just the skin and knew it was beyond his capability to fix.
Also: looking forward to seeing the ZOMBIE COW! The virus or whatever probably only effects human brains or something.... |
Also for you guys wondering why would the zombie leave the cow when it's fresh meat well maybe he was full. Ya I think zombies like people also get full or there wouldn't be nearly as many of them cause they would just eat the whole human first.
I think we are glossing over the most important thing...
ZOMBIE COW!
It stumbles around the pasture moaning out, "Miiiiiiiiiillllk"...