Opinion Poll: Bases and Redesigns.
Don't you touch my base! Resorting raid functionality means at the very least removing the ability to block rooms with objects and stack things artistically. At that point, they'd likely rather redo the code and render current bases unusable. That's likely too much work to be worth the return. Also, ragequits galore.
All I want for bases is universal access (heroes in villain bases) and maybe a few more items.
Where to now?
Check out all my guides and fiction pieces on my blog.
The MFing Warshade | The Last Rule of Tanking | The Got Dam Mastermind
Everything Dark Armor | The Softcap
don'T attempt to read tHis mEssaGe, And believe Me, it is not a codE.
Allright, since i asked the question regarding bases at today's coffee table talk i suppose i should elaborate on my question, now that the time constraints of a livestream don't apply.
My question to Zwillinger was this "Would a ground up re-design of bases be possible sometime in the future?" To which i was given the response that many base builders have recieved, which is that base code is spaghetti, full of uncommented sections, impossible to work with, and "Like playing jenga on fire." I understand all of this, i understand that it is essentially a legacy system and will never get any more love EVER, but my idea was a ground up redesign, by which i meant, create an entirely NEW base system, essentially identical to the old, but with properly commented code, things that actually work together and wont cause vast swaths of meticulous base art to vanish into the ether when something small gets changed. To completely redesign the bases would be a massive undertaking, not gonna lie, and I admittedly don't have the foggiest about the types of coding involved apart from standard coding knowledge, so i was trying to get a dev to comment on what would be essentially, the resource requirements to make a redesign happen. Also it should be noted that Synapse did say that he really wanted to do things with bases. So Poll time then: Do you enjoy Supergroup Bases and would you like to see a redesign that would include raid functionality and a recoded building system? Y/N |
The problems with this course of action however:
Existing bases would probably need to be rebuilt. Now while you and I might not mind this, Many people have spent thousands of hours building something and to have all that work swept away, even retaining all the prestige, would probably upset many.
Next up base storage inventory. If the base system is redesigned and bases have to be rebuilt, what happens to all the salvage/enhancements/inspirations stored in those bases? If they were to be lost I think there'd be a mass exodus from the game. If the devs gave warning players would still have to somehow manage to get all that stuff out of storage and on to characters even if only temporarily.
How the devs could deal with these issues is anyone's guess. Expecting them to magically be able to ensure the data for stored items won't be lost or necessitate having players move items to characters and/or somehow remembering the base layouts so players dont have to rebuild them is probably too much to hope for.
Jem - Ill/Rad Controller Lv 50+3 Nic - Mind/Psi Dominator Lv 50+3 Lady Liberation - Invuln/SS Tanker Lv 50+1 Invicitx - Demon/Pain Mastermind Lv 50+1 Celeste - Emp/Arch Defender Lv 50+1 Nightsilver - DB/WP Scrapper Lv 34 Dusk Howl - StJ/Regen Brute Lv 32 Kyriani - Time/Energy Defender Lv 41Psifire - FF/Psi Defender Lv 50
Star Lighter - LB/LA Peacebringer Lv 30
RE: Dechs
okay, but even considering not restoring raid functionality, they said that bases will get NO love, which means, no new items, the loss of any raid effects from defensive items (the animations were useful in decor), no universal access, nothing.
Wouldn't it be acceptable to at least inquire as to what a recode of the current system (leaving out raid pathing and such) would take?
"You, dear sir, are a legend. "- nelly. "PIE DOESN'T HAVE TENTACLES!"
Bladewing Draconian lvl 30 KAT/SR scrapper
DarkNinjutsu lvl 50 DM/REG scrapper
Dajoji Hino lvl 50 elm/ela scrapper
Bloody Byakko lvl 20 claws/sr scrapper
Here's my idealistic-to-the-point-of-naive take on the base system:
Implement an entirely new base system from the ground up, but give SG leaders the option to "Leave my base as-is"/"Update to new system" (or even wipe it out and start from the beginning).
Leave the legacy system in place, but flatout state that NO MORE WORK is going to be done on it... EVER. If you love your base to pieces and don't want to use the new system, fine - but don't grouse that it's not getting any more support.
At any time, you can switch to using the NEW system, but you cannot revert to the old one - once you upgrade, it's gone, too bad.
Michelle
aka
Samuraiko/Dark_Respite
THE COURSE OF SUPERHERO ROMANCE CONTINUES!
Book I: A Tale of Nerd Flirting! ~*~ Book II: Courtship and Crime Fighting - Chap Nine live!
MA Arcs - 3430: Hell Hath No Fury / 3515: Positron Gets Some / 6600: Dyne of the Times / 351572: For All the Wrong Reasons
378944: Too Clever by Half / 459581: Kill or Cure / 551680: Clerical Errors (NEW!)
I'm not big on raids.
But here's what I'd suggest considering:
Lock the current legacy code and make all current bases "legacy bases". Barring a real game destroying bug, no more base changes, no fixes, no changes.
Create a new base system from scratch. Prices way down. Decorative rooms are essentially free and elements are free.
Add in personal areas for members (an elevator that you click on and go to the level for that member). In personal areas, a little storage, decorate at will, display the souvenirs you picked up in your career, mannequins with your various costumes.
Kill "control", there's only power to charge functional rooms.
Other times from the wish lists we've had for years.
Once the system is in place, the red star leader of the SG can go to registrar and convert the base. Whole lotta prestige back, get a base with an entrance and a "legacy vault" holding all items stored in the old base.
Hmm, great minds think alike. (edit)
My arcs are constantly shifting, just search for GadgetDon for the latest.
The world beware! I've started a blog
GadgetMania Under Attack: The Digg Lockout
I don't care about bases. I don't even use my SG base for the teleporters.
but at least bases don't ruin the game like incarnate powers
Bases by themselves just aren't worth doing over (and I say this as an avid base-builder). Base "creation/modification" is an activity limited to too few people (just the base builder) for too limited a purpose and uses far too many resources (its been acknowledged that the current way the base tracks & communicates assets makes these maps painfully resource-intensive.
To make a base do-over viable, it needs to cover a wider base of players and have a broader purpose.
- Make it a "custom map creator" for architect entertainment
- Make it a "danger room creator" for PvP arena play.
- Make it a "personal hideout creator" for each and every individual player to participate in, somehow.
- Make it a "trophy room" with most souvineers in the game having assets that can be put on display.
- Make it a "social spaces" type of system, where (for example) a host could load the "Atlas park fashion show" map, tweak it with a few additional placeables, and open it to public (with the option to "kick" griefers that show up) for use as a costume contest, RP event, or similar activity.
Do something like that and *maybe* you've broadened the appeal and usefulness for such a project. Otherwise, you're just wasting resources that could have been invested in things with much more impact.
![](https://sites.google.com/site/chasyork/_/rsrc/1286288783877/home/chasebanner.jpg)
It really depends on how you ask the question:
People who like bases and are into doing stuff with bases are clearly going to be the people who respond to this question -- folks who don't care won't really care (duh)! And most people who are heavily into bases know that there are longstanding base issues that range from the irritating to the hair-pullingly frustrating.
So if you ask "Would you like to see bases completely redesigned from the ground up?" most would enthusiastically agree.
If you ask, "Would you like to see bases completely redesigned from the ground up, with no guarantees that your favorite feature will be implemented and that your existing base will continue to function after the redesign?" most would probably change to a hedging 'no' to an enthusiastic 'PANCAKE no!'
And given that about the only way a base redesign would be affordable from a development standpoint would be to make it VIP content (i.e.: only VIPs would be able to purchase, edit, and modify bases), I think most folks would prefer to stay with the system we have.
Just my $0.02US, though.
--
Pauper
To make a base do-over viable, it needs to cover a wider base of players and have a broader purpose.
- Make it a "custom map creator" for architect entertainment - Make it a "danger room creator" for PvP arena play. - Make it a "personal hideout creator" for each and every individual player to participate in, somehow. - Make it a "trophy room" with most souvineers in the game having assets that can be put on display. - Make it a "social spaces" type of system, where (for example) a host could load the "Atlas park fashion show" map, tweak it with a few additional placeables, and open it to public (with the option to "kick" griefers that show up) for use as a costume contest, RP event, or similar activity. Do something like that and *maybe* you've broadened the appeal and usefulness for such a project. Otherwise, you're just wasting resources that could have been invested in things with much more impact. |
--
Pauper
No. Leave it to the new project they are working on instead.
I'm with the devs on this one: it isn't worth the resources.
My new Youtube Channel with CoH info
You might know me as FlintEastwood now on Freedom
![](http://www.jaybonaut.com/Stuff/heroes/Samuraiko.jpg)
I must throw my hat in with the "new system".
My honest base condition for allowing for a new base editting system would be: As long as I can do as much as I did with the previous editor and more.
Click here to find all the All Things Art Threads!
I don't care about bases. I don't even use my SG base for the teleporters.
but at least bases don't ruin the game like incarnate powers |
/shrug to each their own.
As to bases: not worth the return on the investment unless they suddenly allow every single member of an sg to modify their base.
Blazara Aura LVL 50 Fire/Psi Dom (with 125% recharge)
Flameboxer Aura LVL 50 SS/Fire Brute
Ice 'Em Aura LVL 50 Ice Tank
Darq Widow Fortune LVL 50 Fortunata (200% rech/Night Widow 192.5% rech)--thanks issue 19!
![Big Grin](images/smilies/biggrin.gif)
I'd be willing to sacrifice my current base if it meant they would bring back base updates. I can always rebuild, but at the moment all we have is all we're ever going to get. I don't like that.
The Paladin
Steel Canyon, Virtue
Exalted
@Paladin
I think they'd be more likely to look at some kind of new system of personal player housing rather than touch the base system.
@Golden Girl
City of Heroes comics and artwork
I'd be willing to sacrifice my current base if it meant they would bring back base updates. I can always rebuild, but at the moment all we have is all we're ever going to get. I don't like that.
|
this
BUT - absolutely not on bringing back base raiding as part of the package. Raiding puts restraints on what I build and I was ecstatic when they removed raid-pathing in I13.
Altoholic - but a Blaster at Heart!
Originally Posted by SpyralPegacyon
"You gave us a world where we could fly. I can't thank you enough for that."
Id rather have more decorative choices than an all new base building system. The game is too old to reinvent the wheel unless they're creating CoH 2 (in which case, put it there - not here).
Here's my idealistic-to-the-point-of-naive take on the base system:
Implement an entirely new base system from the ground up, but give SG leaders the option to "Leave my base as-is"/"Update to new system" (or even wipe it out and start from the beginning). Leave the legacy system in place, but flatout state that NO MORE WORK is going to be done on it... EVER. If you love your base to pieces and don't want to use the new system, fine - but don't grouse that it's not getting any more support. At any time, you can switch to using the NEW system, but you cannot revert to the old one - once you upgrade, it's gone, too bad. Michelle aka Samuraiko/Dark_Respite |
Obviously, any changes will likely result in some data leakage as atleast I've observed in the costume creator over time. But the upside is that we'd get less buggy (one would hope) bases and room for improvement.
I'd be all for a redesigned base system for a number of reasons, but the primary one is this: bases as coded and designed are a literal can of worms.
As the Devs have said a few times now, the coding for bases isn't documented. The person who did the coding no longer works for the studio, and therefore any change (and that means any in the most literal sense of the word, including new objects, pieces, functionality, placement, and so on) is risking breaking the system totally. The bug where base guns were opening fire on the people who owned the base is a very good example.
It cannot be fixed, it will not be fixed. That is the ultimate bottom line. It wouldn't matter if they had unlimited resources, the problem is they simply don't have the tools to do the job. Bases as we know them would have to be scrapped on the coding level in their entirety to make them work again.
The best alternative is to do just that; offer an alternative base or personal housing system that is well documented and featured. Positron has gone on record saying he would like this, but he acknowledges that bases are also a huge resource hog, more than just about anything else in the game in terms of stored information. So you have a double edged sword in how to deal with them. Adding a second base system would bloat a system already bloated by bases that much more, and it seems unlikely on that basis that they'd want to do that.
So yes, I'm favor of an alternate system if they can do it in a feasible and reasonable way.
S.
Part of Sister Flame's Clickey-Clack Posse
Don't you touch my base! Resorting raid functionality means at the very least removing the ability to block rooms with objects and stack things artistically. At that point, they'd likely rather redo the code and render current bases unusable. That's likely too much work to be worth the return. Also, ragequits galore.
All I want for bases is universal access (heroes in villain bases) and maybe a few more items. |
Questions about the game, either side? /t @Neuronia or @Neuronium, with your queries!
168760: A Death in the Gish. 3 missions, 1-14. Easy to solo.
Infinity Villains
Champion, Pinnacle, Virtue Heroes
So, i'm not a coder....and i admit i have no idea here, but something strikes me strangely.
The old bases are resource intensive-- however, we can have 60 billion missions in the mission AE system with custom maps, custom mobs, custom dialogue.
I don't see the difference between saving all that information for the AE and then having bases being resource intensive. People have asked for maids/butlers or SG members that are logged off roaming the halls or doing tasks in the SG base like they are "hanging out there" in their time off. (I do realize that tracking logged off characters might be an issue though....it is a tad different...but perhaps we have work arounds?)
I don't see why that's difficult compared to the AE missions of having characters in it, saying and doing things.
Perhaps there needs to be a tweaking on the code to make it less intensive? A more efficient way for it to work?
What I'd love is if we get access to inspirations (without the badges!) and a hospital that fully heals you (without the badges!) and personal space.
Personal space, like someone mentioned, going up an elevator and then allowing members to decorate their own spaces.
Perhaps give permission for people to decorate their own areas or other parts of the base. This is a BIG reason why I left my previous 2 SGs.....and started my own SG base. I wasn't able to change anything ever.
I started it just after (unfortunately) the SG prestige give-away back when. All my alts are in my SG....and I've literally gotten to the point that I have SO much prestige that I don't know what to do with it now.
My base doesn't have everything (mostly limited by stupid badges) but it has a lot for only me being the contributer to the prestige. I'm....2 or 3 base sizes away from the biggest base. However, after getting all the TPers....and putting an Ouroboros crystal in....and some storage stuff......I don't know what else I can do with it.
As someone mentioned above: A pvp arena area, a "danger room," and other functionality can be added.
I DEFINITELY vote for working up SG bases from scratch. Bases should make our lives way more convenient-- the current ones only do so marginally.
EDIT: and I DEFINITELY vote for the legacy base idea where you can have your old base and upgrade to the new base when you are ready.
Level 53: Arrows/Devices/Munitions Blaster
....and hopeless Science-Natzi.
So, i'm not a coder....and i admit i have no idea here, but something strikes me strangely.
The old bases are resource intensive-- however, we can have 60 billion missions in the mission AE system with custom maps, custom mobs, custom dialogue. I don't see the difference between saving all that information for the AE and then having bases being resource intensive. People have asked for maids/butlers or SG members that are logged off roaming the halls or doing tasks in the SG base like they are "hanging out there" in their time off. (I do realize that tracking logged off characters might be an issue though....it is a tad different...but perhaps we have work arounds?) I don't see why that's difficult compared to the AE missions of having characters in it, saying and doing things. |
When I decide to "rez" in my base- the system needs to load the map, load the 10,000+ resources I use to make my base's unique appearance, load the x, y, z, and rotational value of each asset, and send all that info to me to display... it then needs to track my movement on that map's mapserv as I run from the medibay to the teleporter and leave... and then unload all that from the mapserv.
That's what I believe Positron was referring to when he commented on how bases were so resource-intensive. it's not only about disk storage (storing the locations of up to 20,000 free-standing-items' positions per base probably doesn't help), it's about what it takes up when the map is loaded and what it's used for.
I'm actually somewhat surprised that, as a "QOL" improvement, they haven't just given us the ability to click on a zone's base portal and access the menus for all our teleporters, storage containers, vaults, crafting tables, empowerment stations, etc. that we have in our bases. It'd save them the resources used every time I use my base to craft, teleport around, etc.
![](https://sites.google.com/site/chasyork/_/rsrc/1286288783877/home/chasebanner.jpg)
Ah, that makes sense: thanks Chase_Arcanum
Maybe they can just give us "canned" items.....like, for a recreational room: one object that has a pool table, sofa, TV, loveseats.....or such items that people would like in a recreation room.
Sure, not everyone would want "canned" items....but if they are made nice enough, I'd see me using them I'm not a big stickler on having to spend billions of hours to make my base look "different." Cool is one thing, different is meh
At any rate, I hope they can figure ways around things. We always hear stuff is impossible to do....and, like Water Blast, we now have it!
Level 53: Arrows/Devices/Munitions Blaster
....and hopeless Science-Natzi.
![](http://img838.imageshack.us/img838/9217/acroyearsig2.jpg)
Founder/Leader of the JUSTICE F0RCE
http://JusticeForce.guildportal.com
Allright, since i asked the question regarding bases at today's coffee table talk i suppose i should elaborate on my question, now that the time constraints of a livestream don't apply.
My question to Zwillinger was this "Would a ground up re-design of bases be possible sometime in the future?" To which i was given the response that many base builders have recieved, which is that base code is spaghetti, full of uncommented sections, impossible to work with, and "Like playing jenga on fire."
I understand all of this, i understand that it is essentially a legacy system and will never get any more love EVER, but my idea was a ground up redesign, by which i meant, create an entirely NEW base system, essentially identical to the old, but with properly commented code, things that actually work together and wont cause vast swaths of meticulous base art to vanish into the ether when something small gets changed.
To completely redesign the bases would be a massive undertaking, not gonna lie, and I admittedly don't have the foggiest about the types of coding involved apart from standard coding knowledge, so i was trying to get a dev to comment on what would be essentially, the resource requirements to make a redesign happen.
Also it should be noted that Synapse did say that he really wanted to do things with bases.
So Poll time then: Do you enjoy Supergroup Bases and would you like to see a redesign that would include raid functionality and a recoded building system? Y/N
"You, dear sir, are a legend. "- nelly. "PIE DOESN'T HAVE TENTACLES!"
Bladewing Draconian lvl 30 KAT/SR scrapper
DarkNinjutsu lvl 50 DM/REG scrapper
Dajoji Hino lvl 50 elm/ela scrapper
Bloody Byakko lvl 20 claws/sr scrapper