Empty Zones


Agent White

 

Posted

With issue 23's announcement on another new zone "night ward?" something like that I just have to give a huge *sigh. It so unfortunate that many zones already that are extremely cool like:

First Ward
The Pretoria area
All the hazard zones blueside specially the shadow shard
Faultline

and many more are almost completely barren of actual players. I am not much for thinking of ways to help this if it needs to be helped, but I feel like it is such a shame that such cool looking zones go unused by the majority of the playerbase.

Why do you think that is? Will this new zone become more wasted space? What would you do to bring in more players to these areas if you think we should be even bothering to go to them?

I'll be honest though I've never read any of the npc text boxes fully in my whole time playing cox, tl;dr lol for the most part cause it doesn't really have incentive for me. Maybe that has something to do with it, being part of the player base that's like me and not caring for the story they give us. Though I do appreciate a cool looking zone that clearly says its story almost just by looking at it.


 

Posted

I think it's because they've walled everything off.

Heroes can't see what zones villains are in, villains can't see what zones heroes are in. Neither can see where Praetorians are and vice versa. Kind of hard to get together for some cooperative action when you're not even sure if anyone is around doing anything before you make the trip.


 

Posted

Faultline used to be really crowded post-rebuild when I was last here, though I suppose with the shakeup of the old mission structure, less people are being sent there. (that and since it's not on the train line, who cares?)


 

Posted

I think it will continue the trend. A lonnng time ago, street-sweeping was the way to level but they changed missions to be more desireable. I don't see this changing so unless they get some new tech to make the zones more interactive, seeing empty zones will continue for all except the most populated servers. I feel the same way as I travel through zones but at the same time, missions/trials/TFs are where the action lies.

Just as an example, unless I see a building being physically demolished(physics tech) by a monster, a humongous water spout in IP about to hit land and heroes need to gather items from the zone to build a dehumidifier on crack or a large group of citizens attacked at random(and being 'defeated', i.e. they disappear), then I don't foresee any interest in a zone besides it being something I have to travel through or a nice backdrop to look at as I go from mission to mission. Even the re-occurring Monsters seem to not gather much interest in zone-events, at least on the servers I frequent.

It's sad and I wish it could change but I think the effort along with the level of tech in the game engine versus the ROI would prevent seeing anything different happening than we have in the past few years as far as zones are concerned.


 

Posted

Zones will remain ghosted until there's good reason to inhabit them, otherwise folks will use them for their arcs or just because there's a mission door there they have to go to. Task forces, zone events that don't suck, etc. Faultline used to get run fairly often because you get access to Yin-Os and the Ouro badge as you go through it, now we've got DFB dropping SOs and anyone can ask for an ouro portal at 14. otherwise, you're just running stuff for story and badges.


 

Posted

Night Ward is a bit unnecessary, when apparently the story is just "First Ward with ghosts." A few new mission maps could've easily done the same job without having to turn it into a new zone.

In my opinion, the devs need to hold off creating new zones for awhile, focus more on new maps since that's where all the action actually goes on (maybe give us those maps in AE so we can use 'em as well), and just start making new content that takes place in existing zones. Maybe even spruce up a visually lacking zone every now and again, like Skyway City or something.

It would also help to make zone events worth running more than once. Increase their rewards a bit. Like have Lusca dish out five or ten merits, or maybe two per tentacle and five for the head, considering she takes a generous amount of coordination and time to beat. Have preventing the Clockwork Paladin's construction give out ten merits, since there's a small window of opportunity to actually pull it off that often gets overlooked. Have the Ghost of Scrapyard dish out five merits, and maybe a bonus two merits if you defeat all of his Scrapyarders. I'm sure that'll really help get people more motivated to go out into the zones.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by twistedlogic77 View Post
With issue 23's announcement on another new zone "night ward?" something like that I just have to give a huge *sigh. It so unfortunate that many zones already that are extremely cool like:

First Ward
The Pretoria area
All the hazard zones blueside specially the shadow shard
Faultline

and many more are almost completely barren of actual players. I am not much for thinking of ways to help this if it needs to be helped, but I feel like it is such a shame that such cool looking zones go unused by the majority of the playerbase.
I go through full zones all the time, like Atlas Park... and they might as well be empty for me. I don't interact with the other people training up or selling or running in circles simple because they're (virtually) next to me. They're not the folk who will be on my next mission or TF or Trial.

So, empty zones are not problematic for me.


Speeding Through New DA Repeatables || Spreadsheet o' Enhancements || Zombie Skins: better skins for these forums || Guide to Guides

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xzero45 View Post
Night Ward is a bit unnecessary, when apparently the story is just "First Ward with ghosts." A few new mission maps could've easily done the same job without having to turn it into a new zone.
They're looking to avoid the problem of Croatoa, where it wasn't obvious which part was in the spirit world and which part was still in the real world.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zombie Man View Post
I go through full zones all the time, like Atlas Park... and they might as well be empty for me. I don't interact with the other people training up or selling or running in circles simple because they're (virtually) next to me. They're not the folk who will be on my next mission or TF or Trial.
I'm right there with the Zombie Man. I couldn't give a crap about outdoor zone population even if I had a crap to give, because this contributes nothing to my gameplay experience. Other players currying about in zones are just background noise and functionally indistinguishable from NPCs, aside from the few times they get in my way. I'm not sure when MMOs stopped doing this, but the idea that you'd interact with people you randomly ran across, make friends and go do something together was never at the heart of City of Heroes.

The zones are not the "melting pot" of the game where people meet, banter and for teams. That's what Global channels and, if they ever add a server-wide LFT channel - what that'll be for. In the age of global communication, it's only natural that people would meet through chat and not by physically running into each other, and yes, I mean that for in-game.

Zones are pretty to look at, zones are cool to fight in and zones are great for setting the mood and providing a fitting atmosphere. Zones, however, don't need random players running about them to do any of that.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcanaville View Post
Samuel_Tow is the only poster that makes me want to punch him in the head more often when I'm agreeing with him than when I'm disagreeing with him.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
They're looking to avoid the problem of Croatoa, where it wasn't obvious which part was in the spirit world and which part was still in the real world.
I've never seen that as a problem. Splitting any potential player base into two separate zones is a larger one IMO.

Mind you Croatoa and Striga are another 2 good examples of what's going to happen with this new zone after about a week or so, as is First Ward

I still cannot work out why they won't give us a proper Public Team system instead of messing around with adding more new Global Channels (we already have Help, shunting the LFT talk from there to a LFG channel is pointless : These zones will still be empty)


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
They're looking to avoid the problem of Croatoa, where it wasn't obvious which part was in the spirit world and which part was still in the real world.
Heh, I thought that was the point.


 

Posted

I would really like to see more to do in some of those empty zones.

For example, how often does anyone go to:

Boomtown. Other than one TF (?) and some 'kill x' missions. there really isn't much going on here.

OR:

Crey's Folly. Same thing. one or two door missions, some street sweeping for 'kill x'.

OR, since the change:

2/3 of Mercy Island.

You get the idea there. This is not the same as the zones I think of as forgotten zones. Those zones have plenty to do it's just that people tend to overlook them.

Places like:

The Hollows
Perez Park
Skyway City (BIG zone that most people just use to get to...)
Faultline (one of the best blueside mission chains in the game)
Founders Falls (it seems like every contact I have that is actually in zone, sends me to missions outside of it)

I think I'd be happier seeing more done with those zones before we start adding more real estate.


Writer of In-Game fiction: Just Completed: My Summer Vacation. My older things are now being archived at Fanfiction.net http://www.fanfiction.net/~jwbullfrog until I come up with a better solution.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
They're looking to avoid the problem of Croatoa, where it wasn't obvious which part was in the spirit world and which part was still in the real world.
How is this an important problem when most of the game's story takes place in instanced missions?


Blazara Aura LVL 50 Fire/Psi Dom (with 125% recharge)
Flameboxer Aura LVL 50 SS/Fire Brute
Ice 'Em Aura LVL 50 Ice Tank
Darq Widow Fortune LVL 50 Fortunata (200% rech/Night Widow 192.5% rech)--thanks issue 19!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
They're looking to avoid the problem of Croatoa, where it wasn't obvious which part was in the spirit world and which part was still in the real world.
Like others have said I never really had a "problem" with the way Croatoa's spirit world thing was handled. *shrugs*

To follow along with what Xzero45 was talking about I think it might have been a better idea for the Devs to have concentrated on some really solid instance maps that could have "built upon" what First Ward started to create a meaningful spirit world version of it. By simply cutting-n-pasting First Ward into a "new" cloned zone they've just doubled-up on the same big open zone that was already becoming fairly empty to begin with. A few weeks after I23 we'll have a -pair- of nearly identical zones that are mostly empty instead of one zone full of content.

Basically Night Ward was quick-n-dirty way to allow the Devs to "claim" that they've added a whole new zone to the game because saying that sounds better marketing-wise than saying they just added a few new mission arcs and enemy groups to fight.


Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀

 

Posted

The old abandoned hazard zones would make for good zones if the GMs spawned even faster than they do now, or if they would perhaps revamp it with new lowbie missions. I don't know, though. Some of these zones do seem better just left the way they are. I'd just like access to Faultline without using my SG base/Skyway/Pocket D. Does the i23 tunnel system offer Faultline? I forgot.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lothic View Post
Basically Night Ward was quick-n-dirty way to allow the Devs to "claim" that they've added a whole new zone to the game because saying that sounds better marketing-wise than saying they just added a few new mission arcs and enemy groups to fight.
^:/



http://www.virtueverse.net/wiki/Shadow_Mokadara

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by jwbullfrog View Post
I think I'd be happier seeing more done with those zones before we start adding more real estate.
I said this when folks were screaming for more zones for redside.

More zone don't do anything to help with teaming, if it means folks are split across more zones.

If I'm in new villain zone number 1323232 and you're in Mercy, i'm not going to see your "lft" b-cast.

We need to add more content to do (mission doors and/zone events) in zones, not spread out the population even more.

One idea is to have a contact that gives out repeatable mission arcs that deal directly with a zone's overall enemy groups and story. The arc would be 5-10 missions long and would repeatable DAILY. The reward for completing the arc could be a random rare purple or orange recipe+20 reward merits. (The whole too many merits for this or that argument is old and useless since superpacks [which are now FREE for most long term vets] drop reward merits like a street vendor who has a hole in his hotdog stand).

I just think there should be more focus on improving zones like the Shadow Shard so there is even a reason to go there in the first place, versus adding more useless real estate.

We've tried it the "we need more space" way, lets try another.


Blazara Aura LVL 50 Fire/Psi Dom (with 125% recharge)
Flameboxer Aura LVL 50 SS/Fire Brute
Ice 'Em Aura LVL 50 Ice Tank
Darq Widow Fortune LVL 50 Fortunata (200% rech/Night Widow 192.5% rech)--thanks issue 19!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Prof_Backfire View Post
Faultline used to be really crowded post-rebuild when I was last here, though I suppose with the shakeup of the old mission structure, less people are being sent there. (that and since it's not on the train line, who cares?)
There's to much content that gives good rewards that doesn't require you to run all over multiple zones to cause people to bother running the less rewarding content that does send you all over the place. If they want people to run "regular" mission content, they need to up the rewards by a significant amount. I'm not suggestion they do that. I don't think there's a particular problem that needs fixed. The game has evolved. There's no reason to try to devolve it back to a design intent that's no longer valid.

People go where the train goes... and they mainly stick to the high population zones where they can make teams to do repeatable content for good rewards.

I'm curious what the Dev's feeling is about the fact that the entire world of Praetoria was basically made completely obsolete by the fact that the DFB trial created a way to skip past the early levels so fast that you'd be crazy to do anything else.

I do agree, however, that it's a shame some great content is just sitting out there relatively unplayed.


I gotta make pain. I gotta make things right. I gotta stop what's comin'. 'Least I gotta try.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
I'm right there with the Zombie Man. I couldn't give a crap about outdoor zone population even if I had a crap to give, because this contributes nothing to my gameplay experience.
I completely disagree. I like seeing other players around. The NPC's walking here and there are also nice. But seeing actual players going about their business (street sweeping, sitting or standing around with other players chatting, etc.) makes me feel like I'm in a real world. It helps a lot with immersion for me.


 

Posted

there are 2 types of "empty" zones

zones that people play in but not a lot and don't stand around in the zone
hollows, faultline, striga, Sky, etc - There are reasons to go to the zone and things to do there. But given instanced missions you don't spend much time in the zone itself and not a lot of people are there

dead zones that you only go to if sent
Crey's Folly, Boomtown, Perez

I don't have a problem with zones that have content but not a lot of players. Dead zones are just sad. I would like to see something done with them.

my solution is to create zone arcs by theme or story. Which they seem to be doing with Praetoria. It has lvl 1-20 starting area, First Ward for 20-30 and now will get Night Ward 30-40.

I really want to see a science set of zones, magic set of zones, gritty set of zones, 4 color hero set of zones. Then you could choose your style/theme and play 1-50 in the content type of your choice.


 

Posted

I think the devs are kind of shooting themselves in the foot with some of these new zones.

Making lovely new zones, but then filling them with annoying mobs that a lot of people would rather not fight just seems like bad logic.

Now I've never actually run First Ward, but I've talked to a few people who have, and they all said pretty much the same thing. "Nice zone, but annoying mobs, only ran through there once to see what it's like and won't go back".

That was my main issue with Praetoria. I felt like I was fighting mobs which were designed to be fought in the 30s, not in the early teens..


 

Posted

I wasn't entirely surprised when I read about that myself as it truely makes sense. They're trying to build up content Gold side to the point that they can bring it up to par content wise (level I mean) so that they can finish what they started. Atleast, that's what I gathered out of this and other discussions/speculations over the past year or so.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aura_Familia View Post
I said this when folks were screaming for more zones for redside.
To be fair, red-side does need at least one new zone, just because it has so few I get sick to my head of looking at the same god damn black sand piles in Sharkhead Island. Blue-side may have empty and unused zones, but there are still at least two per level range, and my contacts tend to send me between them so I'm not looking at the same five houses for 10 levels straight.

There is such a thing as TOO MANY zones, but City of Villains is nowhere near that. A new zone might make red-side feel a little bit less like Lemmings Earth, as well. Right now, it feels like someone took multiple zones, cut them down to just the basic landmarks and then slammed them together to form one island, so you have a tiny factory, a tiny town, a tiny Arachnos fort, a tiny graveyard, a tiny dig site, a tiny Freakshow fort and a tiny dock all bunched up together in the same island, even though there's enough material there for at least three zones.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcanaville View Post
Samuel_Tow is the only poster that makes me want to punch him in the head more often when I'm agreeing with him than when I'm disagreeing with him.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Indiramourning View Post
I completely disagree. I like seeing other players around. The NPC's walking here and there are also nice. But seeing actual players going about their business (street sweeping, sitting or standing around with other players chatting, etc.) makes me feel like I'm in a real world. It helps a lot with immersion for me.
Back in i3, I was such a newb that the only way I could start a team was to go to the Hollows and ask the other players I saw standing near Wincott. When I got a team invite from someone I could not see, I would ask them How On Earth did they see me to ask me. After a number of "looked at me like I had lobsters coming out of my ears" responses, a kindly vet explained Search.

I enjoy seeing all the costumes and reading the bios (not too many of those, it seems). Some times you just cannot form a team (you know it's a bad night when even Blasters turn you down ) so seeing a group of heroes in a venue is a nice touch when I see it.


"How do you know you are on the side of good?" a Paragon citizen asked him. "How can we even know what is 'good'?"

"The Most High has spoken, even with His own blood," Melancton replied. "Surely we know."

 

Posted

I will admit that CoV swung the pendulum back a bit to far in terms of zones.

What I think would be neat is to use Praetora zone tech to tear down most of the walls.


Father Xmas - Level 50 Ice/Ice Tanker - Victory
$725 and $1350 parts lists --- My guide to computer components

Tempus unum hominem manet