500th post and topic: Graphics upgrade, but what kind do you want to see?


Arcanaville

 

Posted

Hi out there!

500 posts is pretty significant for me, considering I do more reading and browsing than I do posting, so excuse this brief moment of achievement (however small) on my part. Yay!

Now that's dispensed with, let me get to what I meant in the thread title. I know that there are suggestions/rumors/uncomfirmed reports that there will be a graphics upgrade to this game, but of what sort we don't know. I myself have suggested we get a move towards body models with smoother lines, fingers and toes and a general '2009' appearance for the game, but then I was struck thinking the other day about just what that meant.

I was genuinely surprised when I was doing some research about Aion and discovered that the maximum requirement for the game was only an nVidia 7300 video card! And it's easily amongst the best if not the best looking MMO of this year (its' prior history in Korea notwithstanding). It reminded me that you can pull some amazing looking graphics out by using just good tools. So what does that mean for CoH?

I admit I love the graphics engine of Aion and the look of the game (it ultimately proved far too grindy in nature after reading several reviews for me to want to play it) and wondered if that would be the way I'd want the game to look, or perhaps more like the art style of the Going Rogue website? But then there's the promotional art for HeroCon and whilst looking a little more 'comic book' (and I mean that only in the sense that it's very stylised art), it too looks very attractive.

Most games these days are defined by their looks first and foremost (after all, that's what makes us pick up the box or watch a preview of a game), with customisation running nearly a dead heat in terms of what players want. I really do believe customisation is going to be the buzzword with a lot of games in the next few years, and a flexible graphics style surely must be part of that.

My own personal preference to make CoH dramatic and stand out tends to favor clean lines and great attention to detail. I'm under no illusions that CoH probably couldn't be adapted to the Aion engine, but if the game matched the Going Rogue trailer's style or promotional artwork, I would be very very happy. Another personal favorite is the website artwork which is just gorgeous to me, but may be just that.

What do other people think of the graphics style to hopefully come our way?

S.


Part of Sister Flame's Clickey-Clack Posse

 

Posted

Quote:
the maximum requirement
I was unaware that games have upper limits on how awesome your hardware can be (things 20 years old or more notwithstanding).

(Ordinarily I try to not call out tedious little mistakes that everyone, me included, make, but you had it bolded, so it kinda stands out).


@Morac | Twitter
Trust the computer. The computer knows all.

 

Posted

I'd be happy if they just cleaned up the big twelve-polygon hill next to the Talos tram and updated the textures on all the old costume pieces and faces. Graphics engine overhaul falls under the 'Don't you guys have anythinig better to do?' heading for me, though I play ASCII games, so I may not be the most representative gamer


Having Vengeance and Fallout slotted for recharge means never having to say you're sorry.

 

Posted

I agree with you Oz. I would be pleased with new graphics as well.
But of what nature?

Well in my opinion-I would like it to flow and be beautifully detailed. I guess the best way to describe it would be realistic. Flowing hair, detailed faces, light glimmering off of buildings and metallic objects. Basically fluid and natural looking.

EDIT: Yes the GR graphics would be very nice.


 

Posted

MORE TEXTURES!
more textures on the ground, on the buildings, on the water, on the sky if possible...

More textures on our super clothing, on our super hair, on our super sneakers!!!

A graphical update needs to happen and we need more detail!

We already have hands down the best color customization out of ANY MMORPG/Action!

Now we need more details from the ground to the heavens!

(FTR, I still think cell shading is kinda ugly compared to CoX - I know thats hard for some of you to swallow but its how I feel... )


 

Posted

As everyone's already stated; more, more, more.

I'm aware that there's a few people out there currently running the bare minimum of requirements and can barely see the jagged polygons of their already-blocky characters and refuse to update a PC model that's been outdated for years. I'm aware of these people and I sympathize with them to an extent.

I'm also aware that in terms of being high-and-mighty, Paragon Studios seems more along the lines of 'Mom and Pop' rather than McDonald's. They're friendly to the community and would like to avoid alienating any players to provide a more enjoyable experience to everyone! I'm aware of all of these factors when it comes to a graphical update.

That being said? I would be happy with a complete overhaul of everything we've got graphics-wise. Our costume creator looks... Decent at best, what with it's mittens and mutant feet. We need a massive change to compliment such a paramount expansion, which will be the first in several years, and a tremendous opportunity for Paragon to increase it's subscriber base, and to appeal to a wider audience; those who are attracted to the shiney bits and pieces.

Work on the polygons; give them a major overhaul to smooth them out. Add more options, like adding hair to hoods, hats, etc. Freshen and liven things up, but don't overload us with OMGBLOOMEFFECTS. Give us some more realism in our proportions and make the creator look like something human. Some more idling poses, and some smoother animations (although most are relatively smooth as it is).

I know, I know, people want to stone me for this; it's not fair that they should have to update their PC after all this time playing and being a loyal customer only to find that their rig isn't up to specs, but such is life. Paragon needs to think about a larger consumer market, and the market is gaining; the market is growing more and more advanced, and if it's interests don't keep up with it, then the interests won't remain interesting for long.



 

Posted

I'd like to be able to adjust hands and feet size, leg and arm thickness independant of the main body, torso width. Stuff like that pertaining to the character models.

A few more character model polygons so that when a character crouches to rest for example, one doesn't see jagged knife edged angles at the hip that could jab someone. more polygons might fix seeing breasts on the females that look like cardboard boxes or polygon balloons.

But overall, I like the graphics as is. Right now things seem fairly crisp and good, without overlagging somewhat older machines like a few friends of mine have. I'm willing to forget my above wishes if the performance cost would be too much. I can upgrade my computer a bit more even, but many can't, and it might not be worth it.

If they can "graphically update" and still let those who like things as is stay that way, and let people with heftier gaming computer specs take advantage of the new stuff at the same time, then maybe.


 

Posted

Yeah, for the most part, cell shading does suck, but there are a few games out there that have managed to make it look good to the point where it's not really an issue. and flowing hair would be pretty cool; hell, even wind in general would be cool. Something to send your hair/cape/auras to wave/flicker would be a nice addition. (instead of it just being when you're moving)

From what I've been told however, with the release of Going Rogue, Heroes will be "upgraded" to the requirements of Villains. (Heroes currently has half the requirements of Villains) Nothing has been said for certain though, but I don't even see much more than that coming into the picture.

The engine for CoX is actually pretty old, much older and harder to work with than say the Champions Online engine(as far as I'm told anyways) So that means that there are certain built in limitations, so for example the highly coveted "power customization" was something that was asked for for years. It wasn't possible until they created a work around for it(allegedly anyways) So adding something that we might think of as simple/not that hard like flowing hair might actually be a b*$@h and a half to do.

Then there's also what has priority to consider. Do you imagine the general game populous would prefer new powersets, or flowing hair? or new zones/TFs, or flowing hair? The devs take into account what they want to see happen, what we want to see the most, and what can be done in a reasonable amount of time and find a balance between the 3. That doesn't mean that flowing hair won't ever happen, just it'll likely be a while depending on where it falls on the devs list of "things to do".


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
I wonder if the GR sneak peak at Hero Con will include antyhing about the graphics?
Well, there is a thread I started with questions to specifically ask the devs at HeroCon, and the graphics question is among them. So as long as a few people bring that list with them, the majority of questions we'll have will be answered, even if the GR teaser doesn't


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by crimsonwings3689 View Post
Yeah, for the most part, cell shading does suck, but there are a few games out there that have managed to make it look good to the point where it's not really an issue. and flowing hair would be pretty cool; hell, even wind in general would be cool. Something to send your hair/cape/auras to wave/flicker would be a nice addition. (instead of it just being when you're moving)

From what I've been told however, with the release of Going Rogue, Heroes will be "upgraded" to the requirements of Villains. (Heroes currently has half the requirements of Villains) Nothing has been said for certain though, but I don't even see much more than that coming into the picture.

The engine for CoX is actually pretty old, much older and harder to work with than say the Champions Online engine(as far as I'm told anyways) So that means that there are certain built in limitations, so for example the highly coveted "power customization" was something that was asked for for years. It wasn't possible until they created a work around for it(allegedly anyways) So adding something that we might think of as simple/not that hard like flowing hair might actually be a b*$@h and a half to do.

Then there's also what has priority to consider. Do you imagine the general game populous would prefer new powersets, or flowing hair? or new zones/TFs, or flowing hair? The devs take into account what they want to see happen, what we want to see the most, and what can be done in a reasonable amount of time and find a balance between the 3. That doesn't mean that flowing hair won't ever happen, just it'll likely be a while depending on where it falls on the devs list of "things to do".
This is all well and nice, but where do you get your information from, if I may ask? Link to the devpost if you don't mind?



 

Posted

Power Customization was never "impossible" it was "bloody difficult" since they would've had to convert a massive number of FX doodads manually. What made PC, according to BAB some time ago, was one of the crew coming up with an automatic script.

As for me, I'm not really looking for much. Update a few low-res costume textures, spruce up a few zones, fix a few more bugs (Snake Caves were never rejiggered - they still have the polygonal landscapes), and that's about it.


Never surrender! Never give up!
Help keep Paragon City alive with the unofficial City of Heroes Tabletop Role Playing Game!

 

Posted

The devs have said the engine in more powerful than they realized - so that might give a bigger scope for the kind of upgrades they can do.Even updating some of the older mobs would be good - like compare the Cimerorans with the Outcasts, for example.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
The devs have said the engine in more powerful than they realized - so that might give a bigger scope for the kind of upgrades they can do.Even updating some of the older mobs would be good - like compare the Cimerorans with the Outcasts, for example.
Its weird that this engine is so powerful... and yet Cryptic 2.0 is less powerful over all >.>
I wonder how that works out >.<


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
The devs have said the engine in more powerful than they realized - so that might give a bigger scope for the kind of upgrades they can do.Even updating some of the older mobs would be good - like compare the Cimerorans with the Outcasts, for example.
See, that's the weird thing. Cimerora is damned pretty, but without doing anything elaborate that I'm aware of. Just a good view, some high-res texture work, and so on.

Bringing the graphical quality of the rest of the zones up to the level of Cimerora would be time-consuming, but presumably not nearly as taxing on GPUs.


Never surrender! Never give up!
Help keep Paragon City alive with the unofficial City of Heroes Tabletop Role Playing Game!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Perfect_Pain View Post
Its weird that this engine is so powerful... and yet Cryptic 2.0 is less powerful over all >.>
I wonder how that works out >.<
I think the CO engine is actually more powerful, but the way it's being used might make it seem weaker - like they're not optimising it.
The core CoH dev team have had way longer to get to know their engine, and find out all the little tricks and tweaks that make it run much closer to its potential.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Seeing as how I'm only running on an ATI HD2600 XT/256, I wouldn't want to see it jacked up too much....

....but asymmetrical costuming (like - shhh! - CO has) would be a nice upgrade.


 

Posted

The biggest change I'd want to see is a complete overhaul of the lighting system. It doesn't have to be completely cutting edge, but it should be dynamic and have objects cast shadows that look like said object's shadow instead of a blob or nothing at all. Plus individual fingers and feet that don't look like flesh covered boots.


Branching Paragon Police Department Epic Archetype, please!

 

Posted

I just want my hair and any tails my toons have to move and my eyes to blink.. that's all I really want.. **sniffs**


 

Posted

So long as it's after I get my nice new rig sometime this year, then I don't mind
But yeah, upgrading the textures to the level of Vanguard and Cimerorans would be very nice.

Oh, and upgrading some of the older costume pieces. Even running on minimum graphics (Laptop. Thats all Im going to, and should have to, say) the newer costume parts STILL look better quality than the old ones.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Zwillinger View Post
GG, I would tell you that "I am killing you with my mind", but I couldn't find an emoticon to properly express my sentiment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Photon View Post
NOTE: The Incarnate System is basically farming for IOs on a larger scale, and with more obtrusive lore.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tayla Ewa View Post
I just want my hair and any tails my toons have to move and my eyes to blink.. that's all I really want.. **sniffs**
Before that, they need to start whipping Jay some more until he gives us real tails. None of these belt-slot, string wire stuck on things that look awful.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Zwillinger View Post
GG, I would tell you that "I am killing you with my mind", but I couldn't find an emoticon to properly express my sentiment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Photon View Post
NOTE: The Incarnate System is basically farming for IOs on a larger scale, and with more obtrusive lore.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelenar View Post
I'd be happy if they just cleaned up the big twelve-polygon hill next to the Talos tram and updated the textures on all the old costume pieces and faces. Graphics engine overhaul falls under the 'Don't you guys have anythinig better to do?' heading for me....

ditto.
Our graphics aren't spectacular, but they do the job. Improving sub-par legacy graphics would be nice (especially the costume bits, which suffer greatly compared to more recent additions to the editor), but if the goal is to lure in new players with eye candy we'll never measure up to games built on more modern engines.


The Nethergoat Archive: all my memories, all my characters, all my thoughts on CoH...eventually.

My City Was Gone

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cynical_Gamer View Post
The biggest change I'd want to see is a complete overhaul of the lighting system. It doesn't have to be completely cutting edge, but it should be dynamic and have objects cast shadows that look like said object's shadow instead of a blob or nothing at all. Plus individual fingers and feet that don't look like flesh covered boots.
Lighting is, really, the big clincher for me. Dynamic lighting, more specifically. I don't need to see lens flairs, dynamic shadows or anything fancy. Just Tomb Raider 2 dynamic, coloured lights. And it's not just to add more LIGHT to the game, but also so we can add more DARKNESS.

Here's the thing - the darkest any area in the game can be is limited by how dark it can be while still letting you know where you're going. This is bad in two ways - firstly, dark places aren't really dark, they're more dim and secondly, the places that ARE dark (Sharkhead Island at night... Ugh!) are REALLY dark and you often have no idea if you're walking along a road or running against a building. With dynamic lights, you can let heroes bring their own light (have them self-illuminate the surroundings like in Diablo), which means both more and better lighting, as well as the ability to make REALLY dark places with the knowledge that we'll just illuminate them and still be able to see. In fact, you can give powers with a perception debuff a more powerful lighting effect, so that when you turn on, say, Minerals, you see better in the dark.

Those street lights would have a purpose, when we start surging with electricity, it would REALLY show, Vanessa DeVore's party can be even darker and more atmospheric, and even the D can be made darker. CoV at night can stay as dark as it is (it's already too frikkin' dark!) and we'll still be able to move around without tripping over the street curbs.

And, really, in a game with so much coloured lights as City of Heroes, how do we not have actual coloured lights? That alone would double the apparent quality of the graphics, in my opinion.

Of course, I suspect a LOT of this graphics update will have to do with actually optimising the engine. Multi-core support is already problematic (last I heard, the game couldn't utilize more than two cores, and even getting it there was a problem) and City of Heroes tends to lag more than it should, especially in specific locations. Optimizing the maps, themselves and culling excess geometry would probably go a long way. After all, there are two ways to up your graphics - make better graphics, or optimize the game so people can just up their settings.

I wouldn't expect any MAJOR changes to in-game models and maps, however, and I would definitely not expect a new engine. That sort of thing would simply require that all graphics be remade from scratch in the new engine, and that's just not doable. I WOULD be up for an overhaul of all age-old pieces to sharpen up their edges and to give them higher-res textures. Better hands and feet would probably be nice, though this goes more into extra costume pieces than graphical updates.

Generally, the biggest thing I would expect a graphical update to bring is better performance at CURRENT settings, and then maybe something else on top.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcanaville View Post
Samuel_Tow is the only poster that makes me want to punch him in the head more often when I'm agreeing with him than when I'm disagreeing with him.

 

Posted

if i could have the game redrawn Joe Mad style....kk.

i know it would never happen.