THE LEAGUE: Season 1
Original League Stance: League is closed.
Vinny's stance: We want in the league as a full team.
-----------------------
Leagues compromise: We'll let you in as free agents
Vinnys compromise: We want in the league as a full team
-------------------------
See a problem here? I'll draw it out with crayons if I need to.
Bottom line, you guys havent compromised. And furthermore, if you guys were SO willing to help teach newer players like you've said you were, joining as free agents would be the best method in which to do so.
You think some of these new players will go out of their way to ask vets advise when they havent a clue as to who you are? Right.
@War Admiral - Nice to meet you as well. You seem like a very friendly chap. It is a shame we won't be able to spend any quality time with you. I can tell you and Vincent would become great friends.
@Cherry Cupcakes - No chance am I going to get drawn into an internet argument about word definitions. Once we end up hitting the old "arguing about what words mean" it's quite clear the conversation has run it's course. I shouldn't have posted that link. Just felt like being snarky I guess.
You're right though. We definitely were being uncompromising in our desire to join this league.
Either way, I wish you would out of good faith move some toons and join us for some practice. Our team practices vs other willing teams and internal drills @9pm EST in PD most days of the week.
One thing I've come to know for a fact is you will never know it all and the day you assume you do, it's likely it's gonna be a very hard lesson. Even the people you'd think have nothing to offer you are usually there with the simplicities often overlooked.
Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"
"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead
Actually, as an outside observer it seems neither side is very willing to compromise.
Side A says you can join but only on condition X, side B says we won't agree to condition X.
Side B says let us join under condition Y, side A says we won't agree to condition Y.
The whole thing has gotten absurd, really. Never change, pvp threads.
The Melee Teaming Guide for Melee Mans
[U][URL="http://boards.cityofheroes.com/showthread.php?t=251594"][/URL][/U]
We practiced making rainbows. It was epic.
Fiery, unlock the rainbow trail aura before the next match or you are benched.
I'm not sure about last night, but our team has been trying to practice this past week with no luck.
|
P.S. I guess you better get your rainbow on
Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"
"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead
Artic and the Chillz - Champion PvP League
Exile - Champion PvPEC 3v3-5v5 League
Exile - Freedom 5v5 PvP League 2012
Exile - Freedumb PvP League 2011
Exile - CAPE PvP League
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/compromise
3. something intermediate between different things: |
a final proposition, condition, or demand; especially : one whose rejection will end negotiations and cause a resort to force or other direct action.
I ask to let a full team join the league.
You say no, providing no relevant reason outside of an inflammatory remark and then give one option and one option alone.
My counter is that our team would like to play together, you stand by your one option. A compromise is meeting me halfway on both my proposed option and yours.
Example: Your team joins with 4 preset players, the rest of your team is absorbed into the draft and players are distributed accordingly. You will more than likely get the majority of the rest of your team, but some of the wealth will be spread to teams that need it as well.
That is a compromise as it means that you have met me halfway understanding what I have presented, while still maintaining a moderate portion of your proposal as well.
Originally Posted by Cherry Cupcakes
if anyone is leveling an ultimatium here its you.
You're being uncompromising in your desire to join the league. |
I'm not in a position to level an ultimatum, what part of that do you not understand? I have stated at least 3 times that you have made absolutely no attempt to contact me in order to find some sort of actual compromise; a middle-ground. The accurate determination is that you have presented one and only one option. Are you completely incapable of having any form of reasonable discourse? Survey says yes.
You're done. Posting inflammatory, accusing remarks without taking the time to peruse the thread and take a gander at someone's honest perspective is a clear indication of your true outlook on more PvPers entering your league.
Originally Posted by War_Admiral
Original League Stance: League is closed.
Vinny's stance: We want in the league as a full team. ----------------------- Leagues compromise: We'll let you in as free agents Vinnys compromise: We want in the league as a full team ------------------------- See a problem here? I'll draw it out with crayons if I need to. Bottom line, you guys havent compromised. And furthermore, if you guys were SO willing to help teach newer players like you've said you were, joining as free agents would be the best method in which to do so. You think some of these new players will go out of their way to ask vets advise when they havent a clue as to who you are? Right. |
For the sake of chronology, let me help educate you a little bit.
1: I Cue poses a query regarding a new team entering the ladder, he is told (for all intents and purposes) that an entirely new roster will not be allowed to enter the ladder. When I ask him what the reasoning is, I do not receive a definitive answer.
2. Being that I am to be the captain of said new team, I bring it up on the boards, and am subsequently told that I missed the deadline. My counter-argument is that a roster lock date is a flimsy excuse, and that rules are malleable; said conclusion is evident due to my previous experience in other leagues that were run quite successfully.
3. I am told that I should have "gotten my **** together" and that I missed the deadline. The league organizer that says this to me does not take the time to consider account inactivity, forum inactivity, and completely skips the fact that a new team of PvPers has interest in their league, choosing instead to make inflammatory remarks alongside several other individuals that offer "perspective" (see: you) without doing any actual reading.
4. I make it plain and simple that my team (as a personal preference) would prefer not to join a draft and would like to play together. We are familiar with one another, and have known each other long enough that such a desire is neither harmful, nor completely unreasonable. If you, sir, are telling me that it is, you're about as delusional as Lord Stryker. However, I do not pose an ultimatum of any sort. As again, I am in no such position to do so. However, do to the passive-aggressive nature of several perspectives regarding my desire to enter the league with a new team, I enter into a prolonged debate regarding leagues/rules/and what's helpful/harmful to a dying PvP community.
5. I've already come to the conclusion that our team gaining entry is impossible, and state that our team would love to come play and practice outside the boundaries of the league with other active teams, but conclude that having everyone I know reactivate their accounts under good faith is not a wise option for many of us. It is a gamble that I know I have personally taken before, and more often than not, I have lost. At this point, that is my attempt at compromising with the PvP community that is active in the league, it is an option that differs from my team just entering the league (As we would have no league involvement whatsoever, and would be playing with teams for fun GASP!). Therefore:
Originally Posted by War_Admiral
Leagues compromise: We'll let you in as free agents
Vinnys compromise: We want in the league as a full team |
Originally Posted by Silas
Side A says you can join but only on condition X, side B says we won't agree to condition X.
Side B says let us join under condition Y, side A says we won't agree to condition Y. |
The assumption that teams wouldn't practice with us doesn't just come from me, but also came through speaking with other individuals that would be coming back to play as well. Unlike the league organizer, I attempt to gain the perspective of my peers in order to reach a fair & accurate conclusion.
My team will practice with u guys like usual starting next week, this week we r all taking a break since holiday coming up, also **** yea who esle is going to Venice or Newport Beach?
|
Who knows, maybe we'll issue unofficial official challenges to some teams for matches?
That's how it worked in the olden days.
Again, it's pretty straightforward that you guys have the right to stick by your rules. You don't need to be rational about it, you have that right. I'm not being sarcastic when I say that. Essentially, it's your league, you have the right to dis-allow our admittance, even if it does go against the expressed perspectives of virtually every veteran PvPer that still plays.
What I don't get (Actually, I do get it) is why rather than a frank answer, we get all of this passive aggressive crap.
Somehow, we're trash talking elitists who claim that our stacked team would crush everyone.
What we've actually said is that we aren't elitists, that the concept of "elite" PvPers is a joke, and that our team has lots of RPers in it.
We don't have to back up any trash talk, War Admiral, because we haven't talked any. We have nothing to prove in CoH. If we did, many of us proved it long ago, and the rest of us are RPers...
Why put words in our mouths? Really, why? Please explain why you've decided to type cast us and come near lying about things we've said.
The closest thing to game-related trash talk was Vinnie saying he could out-call anyone in this league. I'm not talking trash when I say that he could. Big deal. Is he a better human being than any of you because he can out-call you in a superhero game? Why get mad over something like that?
Let's not act like any of us are perfect, or even normal for that matter. We all played/have played CoH. We chose to play CoH over other games out there that are infinitely better on paper. At some point, most of us have left and come back, against our better judgement, after saying we never would return. We are out of our minds for even playing this game, let alone PvPing in it. Most of us, at one time or another, have had a semi-serious discourse on the forums of an online superhero game - that's just plain unfortunate. None of us have the logic or moral grounds to justify being able to hate on a battle-rapping, nasally-voiced, mega-man tattoo wearing RPer, who happens to be the best Rad, best Sonic, and best RPing wizard to ever play the game that we, for some reason, hold so dear.
Artic and the Chillz - Champion PvP League
Exile - Champion PvPEC 3v3-5v5 League
Exile - Freedom 5v5 PvP League 2012
Exile - Freedumb PvP League 2011
Exile - CAPE PvP League
Why not put it up to a captains vote?
theres not enough popcorn in the world to cover this thread LOLz.... and Vince, WB... damn good to see you on Champ again
DEAR CHAMPION, DEAR CHAMPION, II Protectors of Neverland
"8 years Guys....What a Ride"
224 LvL 50's
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/compromise
3.
something intermediate between different things: