THE LEAGUE: Season 1


Artic_Chill_44

 

Posted

All I know is there was a cut-off date and the first matches started last weekend. I believe they're discussing having anyone that wants to sign up as a free agent is going to be out there to be drafted. That's a wait and see and up to them really.

Artic really did go around and post to the active PvP community and let them know it was going on and all were welcome to sign up. I have no qualms with anyone of whatever level of experience participate, the more the better and I can guarantee you the majority of this league feel the same way.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Braije View Post
All I know is there was a cut-off date and the first matches started last weekend. I believe they're discussing having anyone that wants to sign up as a free agent is going to be out there to be drafted. That's a wait and see and up to them really.

Artic really did go around and post to the active PvP community and let them know it was going on and all were welcome to sign up. I have no qualms with anyone of whatever level of experience participate, the more the better and I can guarantee you the majority of this league feel the same way.
Apparently I type my posts in Greek, no matter how many times I state that a cut-off date is not a good enough excuse to bar an entire team of new, roster ready players from playing, people just seem to keep throwing it at me. On top of: "X person advertised to every member of the community, this was advertised here, that was advertised there".

Clearly not enough advertisement was done, as every single player from my team had no idea about the existence of this league prior to my bringing it up to them. And I myself had no idea about it either. Face it, the idea of bringing in an entirely new team happened after a deadline, but that fact alone does not defeat the benefit of having at least 10 new players (at least) join the league.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by super deveron xxx View Post
Fixed for accuracy.

PvPEC Freedom League:
1 Good team:
U2BG
1 solid team:
SMD
Everyone else was mediocre/bad

Ladder following the Freedom League:
1 good team:
becalm
1 solid team:
soco
1 decent team:
anti social
1 half decent team:
dUmb
Everyone else was bad

Bud Bowl:
1 almost decent team:
Steve
1 almost half decent team:
RFR
1 okish team:
Artic and the Chills
Everyone else was terrible

FML:
1 half decent team:
BFG
1 almost half decent team:
dUmb
Everyone else was terrible

I've seen this somewhere else how interesting though this one is edited......and posted from a temp account.....so let me guess Hai Peril?


and to the person who posted this on the hidden forums I pointed out even for the worst team in any other league never lost 31-1. The disparity between the teams is huge, not that it matters it is what it is, but that's the reason people have been pointing out the difference between the teams.



"Play Nice and BEHAVE! I don't want to hear about any more of your shenanigans brought up in our meetings at Paragon"
-Ghost Falcon @Tritonfree @Philly's 2nd Convenient CIGAL BoBC/INOANN Arts&Crafts Sporks
Average Joes FAP THE MENTOR PROJECT Justice Events

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phillygirl View Post
so let me guess Hai Peril?
Good guess, but no dice.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Braije View Post
All I know is there was a cut-off date and the first matches started last weekend. I believe they're discussing having anyone that wants to sign up as a free agent is going to be out there to be drafted. That's a wait and see and up to them really.

Artic really did go around and post to the active PvP community and let them know it was going on and all were welcome to sign up. I have no qualms with anyone of whatever level of experience participate, the more the better and I can guarantee you the majority of this league feel the same way.
None of that matters. Read my last post and respond to it please.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phillygirl View Post
Heh was trying to figure out who had access to the privet forums and would post from a temp account lol
I'm not sure that the person that posted on the temp account has access to the private forums anymore.


 

Posted

Both of your posts were read and once again, there was a cut off point. Now there has been talk of extending it and I'm sorry you got to the party late and the beer and chicks are spoken for so to speak.

Have you ever considered maybe it's your attitude and your approach that is just off putting? I'm certain you're not here to make friends, but you're sure as hell not making any ground the way you're going at it. Just a suggestion.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Braije View Post
Both of your posts were read and once again, there was a cut off point. Now there has been talk of extending it and I'm sorry you got to the party late and the beer and chicks are spoken for so to speak.

Have you ever considered maybe it's your attitude and your approach that is just off putting? I'm certain you're not here to make friends, but you're sure as hell not making any ground the way you're going at it. Just a suggestion.
My post obviously wasn't read because you haven't responded to any of the questions in it. If I ask you why it's important that the rules be enforced so strictly, and you respond by telling me what the rules say, it's clear you either haven't read or haven't understood what I wrote. The rules were put in place to ensure certain principles of fair play were encouraged, and to allow for simple organisation of the league. If a compromise could be found that breaks the rules, but nonetheless maintains the principles the rules were created to enforce, then any reasonable person should have no problem with it.

The reason you are refusing to actually answer anything in my post is because you are being unreasonable and you don't want people to realise. You don't want to play with Vince and myself. And for that reason you keep saying the same things over and over again ("the rules say x/there was a cutoff/the event was advertised") without actually trying to progress the discussion forward. You are hiding behind this to mask your true motives here. If you actually admitted that you simply do not want us to play and that you're making things hard for us because you want us to leave...then we'd probably just leave. But most of you guys (& gals!) are saying you're keen on us playing, but adding "Aw shucks, it's a shame the rules won't let you!"

That's just bad form.

I'm obviously here to make friends. Or at least that was my original intention. To come over here. PVP with the few people left in this game who actually PVP. And have a good time. Obviously when I get such a negative response just for wanting to participate I'm going to respond equally negatively, perhaps even confrontationally. But I would not be so quick to say this attitude was undeserved. Or, even, indicative of my levels of sportsmanship when PVPing. To try and imply it is is little more than an attempt at stereotyping me as a "1337 PVPer" that wants to do nothing but trash talk. Again this speaks more about your perception of me than it does about who I actually am.

For some reason you guys don't want to let me take part. I get that the rules say no. I get that the event was advertised. I get that. I understand that. Stop telling me that.

What i'm asking now is why is no-one is prepared to BREAK the rules?

Please answer me. As my ex-girlfriends will tell you...it's the quickest way to make me shut up


 

Posted

Maybe you should heed your own advice and read what was posted yourself. Let me again say I have no qualms with any other teams of any experience joining at this juncture. So, your Ex may have been on to something, wasn't so much shutting you up as it was reading, digesting and taking what others say before your mouth fires off into another tirade.

You seem very hung up on it being some sort of conspiracy, to which I am trying to convey to you the opposite. A changing of rules to which others had to adhere to up and to this point would throw a lot of things out of whack. Again, I am not fully against this but it's just the way things are done. These are not my rules, but they are rules others adhered to none the less.

It's a short season, and there are 2 very strong competitive teams there presently. So, it's not to say there isn't any 'competition' for those of us who are new to the experience, on the contrary. They are not only there to compete with us, but several have offered their personal time to improve those not so 'schooled' in the ways of PvP.

Now, that's not to say your request and idea is fully out of the picture. Again though I submit to you that your approach and attitude isn't doing you any justice. I personally welcome any new teams/players, all the more to learn from. But seriously man, Conjecture; you're doing it wrong!


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Please forgive me for not responding to the majority of your post. It was largely just you repeating yourself and being unnecessarily inflammatory. I'm genuinely sorry if anything I wrote in my last post offended you and caused you to respond in the way you did.

I'm getting annoyed, perhaps it's starting to show.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Braije View Post
A changing of rules to which others had to adhere to up and to this point would throw a lot of things out of whack. Again, I am not fully against this but it's just the way things are done. These are not my rules, but they are rules others adhered to none the less.
What are these "lot of things" you reference?
How exactly would they be "thrown out of whack"?

Because right now all i'm hearing is "following rules for the sake of rules".

A reasonable person knows when to break rules as well as follow them.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
Please forgive me for not responding to the majority of your post. It was largely just you repeating yourself and being unnecessarily inflammatory. I'm genuinely sorry if anything I wrote in my last post offended you and caused you to respond in the way you did.

I'm getting annoyed, perhaps it's starting to show.



What are these "lot of things" you reference?
How exactly would they be "thrown out of whack"?

Because right now all i'm hearing is "following rules for the sake of rules".

A reasonable man knows when to break rules as well as follow them.
Again, sorry if this passed you by. These were the rules all adhered to up and to this point. That is how things could be thrown out of whack. Because you suddenly want to join (and I'm glad you're interested) after the fact means going back and restructuring teams. Again, they had to adhere to rules you're asking to be impervious to. And there were weeks to get signed up it's not as though it was a spur of the moment thing.

You're taking this all the wrong way. I'm explaining to you that there are ways to go about it and the way you're going about it isn't the best course of action. If you view or take this as 'inflammatory' I have responded no differently than yourself. Inflection is lost in text, let's just chalk it up to that.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

And just for the record, you're barking up the wrong tree. I am only going by the rules and requirements that were laid before myself and many others. You're now on the CAPE site and I encourage you to take it up there. If it doesn't work out I hope that we get more on whatever server in whatever league down the road, as I said the more ppl the more experience and fun to be had.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
Please forgive me for not responding to the majority of your post. It was largely just you repeating yourself and being unnecessarily inflammatory. I'm genuinely sorry if anything I wrote in my last post offended you and caused you to respond in the way you did.

I'm getting annoyed, perhaps it's starting to show.



What are these "lot of things" you reference?
How exactly would they be "thrown out of whack"?

Because right now all i'm hearing is "following rules for the sake of rules".

A reasonable man knows when to break rules as well as follow them.


Hell, I would have been all for you guys showing up, since it would give us some more perspective. Unfortunately, I am not the one making decisions in this league, so I cannot help you, however, I look forward to test my mettle against you guys in the future. Just got into PvP again since I13 and I'm starting to like it, actually.


"I never said thank you." - Lt. Gordon

"And you'll never have to." - the Dark Knight

 

Posted

I don't understand how one brand new self-contained team being added to the league would mean any other teams have to be "restructured". I can't imagine a scenario where that would be required at all.

I don't think I've really got the energy to keep going back and fourth like this. I'll pester the CAPE guys and see what they say.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
I don't understand how one brand new self-contained team being added to the league would mean any other teams have to be "restructured". I can't imagine a scenario where that would be required at all.

I don't think I've really got the energy to keep going back and fourth like this. I'll pester the CAPE guys and see what they say.
I would adress your concerns directly to Mah and Cherry as they are the ones making the rules and running the league.

It doesn't really matter who says yes or no since they have the final say.



"Play Nice and BEHAVE! I don't want to hear about any more of your shenanigans brought up in our meetings at Paragon"
-Ghost Falcon @Tritonfree @Philly's 2nd Convenient CIGAL BoBC/INOANN Arts&Crafts Sporks
Average Joes FAP THE MENTOR PROJECT Justice Events

 

Posted

Just trying to help here, as far as why it would be an issue. By a certain date teams of 8 had to be submitted, after such time a team of 4 could form and select players from a draft that was held. That's really the stance that is being taken, because everyone else had to do so. I thought the original post that MAH made here advertised that, it has been some time so I might be mistaken.

It's not to say that you as individuals could not register at the site and join as free agents and you're more than welcome to come indulge in the PvP experience that is currently going on and I encourage and welcome you to. As you previously posted, sadly it's a dwindling aspect of the game and one I would personally hate to see deteriorate anymore or disappear altogether from CoH. It may not be ideal, but that allowance was made to get those not drafted or those late coming involved.

Here is to hoping you guys sign up and get involved, the more experience out there we have the better as you also stated previously. If not then I understand and it's a short season so maybe we'll have the chance to enjoy such an untapped resource in the game down the road.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Am I right in thinking wanting to play with each other is going to be considered "selfish"?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phillygirl View Post
I would adress your concerns directly to Mah and Cherry as they are the ones making the rules and running the league.

It doesn't really matter who says yes or no since they have the final say.
True story.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xanatos View Post
Am I right in thinking wanting to play with each other is going to be considered "selfish"?
Why would you think that? Possibly perverse, (I keed, I keed). Nah a few teams got some friends together regardless of experience so nothing at all wrong with that.


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Seems to me this thread IS pvp.

Is there any reason other PvP events can't occur while the official League matches are going on? I know we're all trying to get some practice in, so if there's an issue with a new team joining at this point, why doesn't that team hook up with others for 'practice' fights?
We'd all get to PvP; us newer folks can continue to benefit from the experience of others; and I think it provides a reasonable solution to the current issue--Xanatos' team gets to fight matches with the others without affecting the League, which should (I think) make MAH and Cherry happy.

Some more kickball maybe? Or a night or two a week when all comers can meet in PD (or where ever) and start laying smack downs?

Sort of like a major league sports team playing an exhibition game.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaytanah View Post
Seems to me this thread IS pvp.

Is there any reason other PvP events can't occur while the official League matches are going on? I know we're all trying to get some practice in, so if there's an issue with a new team joining at this point, why doesn't that team hook up with others for 'practice' fights?
We'd all get to PvP; us newer folks can continue to benefit from the experience of others; and I think it provides a reasonable solution to the current issue--Xanatos' team gets to fight matches with the others without affecting the League, which should (I think) make MAH and Cherry happy.

Some more kickball maybe? Or a night or two a week when all comers can meet in PD (or where ever) and start laying smack downs?

Sort of like a major league sports team playing an exhibition game.
Mhm!

P.S. LYF!!


Champion Server-"Play like a Champion today!"


"True courage is not the brutal force of vulgar heroes, but in the firm resolve of virtue and reason." - Sir Alfred North Whitehead

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Phillygirl View Post
I would adress your concerns directly to Mah and Cherry as they are the ones making the rules and running the league.

It doesn't really matter who says yes or no since they have the final say.

Listen to Philly. She has the right of it.


"I never said thank you." - Lt. Gordon

"And you'll never have to." - the Dark Knight

 

Posted

I can see where they're coming from, a lot of people had no idea this league existed and I'm certain there's really no other organized PvP going on elsewhere. Artic did post in other forums about the league, but the threads were quickly deleted for cross posting. Even the whole team of 8 signups was only posted on the CAPE forums and when it was finally posted on these forums, only teams of 4 were allowed to signup.

Bringing in another team will never be a bad thing. Nobody wants more people to join the free agent list, let alone a whole nother team. I know my team doesn't want to pickup more people, we have to sit out a couple people each match as it is.

I commend the efforts of the league organizers, I really do. However, always abiding by the rules isn't good if it's just for the sole purpose of following the rules. Remember the saying Budweiser used in his league regarding the rules (which he stole from me)? "If you don't like the rules, quit." Everyone was against a lot of his rules and the fact that only a select few that he picked were coming up with the rules.

If you want to be different from Bud's league, I say let them join! I mean rules were already broken on the first night, as minor as they may be, with lineup submissions and time in between matches. Why not break some more to let people who truly want to PvP, PvP.


[U][URL="http://boards.cityofheroes.com/showthread.php?t=251594"][/URL][/U]

 

Posted

People really seem to be missing the whole point of the CAPE PvP League. This PvP League was intended for Champion server PvPers. Not for City of Heroes PvPers as a whole. It was never intended to be advertised outside of the Champion server forum and the CAPE forums. Exit asked about advertising the PvP league on other servers and in the PvP forums, but was specifically told not to and that this PvP league was for Champion server players. Artic advertised it all over anyway.

How many of the 8 people that want to join ever played on Champion outside of a PvP league?


@Celestial Lord and @Celestial Lord Too