Insanity of moving blue spots while you have powers that root you.


Adeon Hawkwood

 

Posted

The blue patches don't bother me, they are easily avoidable unless you run into someone elses patch without realizing it.

What annoys me about Apex (and it's not a huge annoyance) is the sewer section in the first mission with the rikti pylons protected by Toxic spewing tentacles.

They seem to ignore defenses and hit my /SR and /Shield character where they are weakest - Toxic resistance.

It felt a lot like a sewer run on a 1st level toon.


 

Posted

I still don't particularly enjoy Apex and find Tin mage much more fun but I have learned to fight and run and yesterday managed 5 Apex TFs with only one failure.. Of course that is the first failed WST attempt I have had since week one when on two straight days I managed to wind up teamed with the SAME inept leader that got us into situations in the last mission of the STF where we simply could not finish. The first was due mainly to him insisting on attempting a Master of run with a team composition that clearly wasn't strong enough.. we failed that attempt in mission two and then were forced to go without temp powers the rest of the way. Then when our tank proved a little too squishy to stand toe to toe with LR and it was suggested he hover.. "I don't have fly and I can't use my RAPTOR pack we can't access temps" DUHHHHHHH

One thing I have noticed already this week ... We are into weel #5 and all any character needs to craft two rares and one very rare are four Notices of the well. The RWZ is not jam packed with people desperate to find an APEX and I pulled out my new 50 level Blaster and easily found an STF and an ITF to get enough shards so I could slot her Alpha and then make her my 4th Incarnate to complete the APEX as the WST. A lot of players are simply saying.. Okay Apex is the WST? See you next week when its something that doesn't frustrate and annoy me.

Yeah I know people are saying they love Apex cause its more of a challenge but I think my problem with it is this... I spend more time running around trying to save my own skin than I do actually fighting anything. As I mentioned I did 5 yesterday.. one with my Crab Spider (Set up as an AoE machine), 3 with Blasters and one with my Bots/DM Mastermind. Three guesses which At was on the lone failed attempt... WRONG and WRONG it was the MM. My pets didn't last more than a few seconds and after a while I just stopped even trying to rez them. That left me with 5 attacks (including my Epics) and my DM debuffs. Half the time I couldn't get close enough to BM to even use most of those thanks to the placement of the Blue Clouds of Almost Instant death and when I did manage to find a spot to use one .. as soon as I got off one debuff 3-4 of those stupid flying swords appeared out of no where and I'd face plant AGAIN.

Can ANYONE see how this might be considered annoying by most of the player base? Forget usng half of your powers (which you worked through 50 levels to obtain), Keep moving constantly or risk almost certain death, spend half your time trying to find a spot you can fire off a couple attacks before its time to run away again, oh and JUST to add to the frustration when you do get off an attack HARRY POTTER has sent a thousand magic swords to one shot shot. HAVE FUN!

I have been on Beta previewing Issue 20 and while the BAF is a challenge at least we can actually ATTACK and use all the powers we have there. THAT is infinately more fun to me than the nightmare that APex sends us into. I LOVE mission one but they can take BM and her clouds of death and shove it. LOL I am done for the week and will concentrate on other TFS that give good shards and components.


�We�re always the good guys. In D&D, we�re lawful good. In City of Heroes we�re the heroes. In Grand Theft Auto we pay the prostitutes promptly and never hit them with a bat.� � Leonard
�Those women are prostitutes? You said they were raising money for stem cell research!� � Sheldon

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by _Caliban View Post
What annoys me about Apex (and it's not a huge annoyance) is the sewer section in the first mission with the rikti pylons protected by Toxic spewing tentacles.
Thats actually my favorite part, just confuse the tentacles and they kill the pylon for you


"I have ridden the mighty moon worm!"
-Al Gore
Fiery Aura is only good for farming, I'm cereal

@Caucasiafro

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deus_Otiosus View Post
I ran this three times last night on a Brute, a Fort & a Corr.

And while I agree with others that it's not super hard or ridiculous, I also feel that if the goal is to make the game more fluid and less tank and spank that the game's mechanics should reflect that.

I would love it if the game became a more mobile, fluid experience where things like travel suppression and being rooted during animations didn't exist.

Will it happen? Unlikely.
This.

If they want fluid and ADAPTABLE then lets drop the rooting. It reminds me of the changes to PvP when they implemented supression. Take a quick flowing game and slow it down. I am saying using power rooting to kill off people who due to clipping, lag or teammate colored animations miss the flash cues for the fire is a cheap "challenge."

I love the attacks though - and the Learn to Play advice. It always the same if you dare to criticize the great and powerful Oz. Look I have not played the BAF trial yet but I see they make some enemies immune to status effects - EXACTLY like I suggested is possible to do and all while not making it unbalanced.

I have said for 7 years now that status effect reliance is laziness. Tougher enemies can have armor, use attacks that aren't slows or stuns and let the enviroment be fluid and fast. Does anyone facing what I have read of the BAF Trial say its slow and stilted or is it at times seemingly too fast?

There is a place for status effects and it used to be only Lts and Bosses had them now every minion does something.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wicked_Wendy View Post
I still don't particularly enjoy Apex and find Tin mage much more fun but I have learned to fight and run and yesterday managed 5 Apex TFs with only one failure..
Funny, the ONLY time i have ever failed an apex was when we had an ******* on the team that was too stupid to dodge the patches and kept saying we could finish even though it was clear we could have.
But it seems tasks like LRSF or states are almost impossible as a pug, i actually had to make a mind/dom, get it to 50, IO it out to get perma. Then and only then, when I’m on this toon, has there been a decent chance that pugs I’ve done will complete. (But i have been told by many i have just had very bad experiences with the LRSF)

Quote:
One thing I have noticed already this week ... We are into weel #5 and all any character needs to craft two rares and one very rare are four Notices of the well. The RWZ is not jam packed with people desperate to find an APEX and I pulled out my new 50 level Blaster and easily found an STF and an ITF to get enough shards so I could slot her Alpha and then make her my 4th Incarnate to complete the APEX as the WST. A lot of players are simply saying.. Okay Apex is the WST? See you next week when its something that doesn't frustrate and annoy me.
You must be on a less populated server. Yesterday guardian was packed, we had 2 groups forming in RWZ and 2 others that were starting up in global channels when i ran one. And then there were enough people to start up another, so i ran them back to back. One took 44 (had a pretty crappy team, imo) another took 20:59.

Quote:
Can ANYONE see how this might be considered annoying by most of the player base? Forget usng half of your powers (which you worked through 50 levels to obtain), Keep moving constantly or risk almost certain death, spend half your time trying to find a spot you can fire off a couple attacks before its time to run away again, oh and JUST to add to the frustration when you do get off an attack HARRY POTTER has sent a thousand magic swords to one shot shot. HAVE FUN!
I can, i think. A lot of people aren’t used to having to use strategy and skill in order to complete a task; everyone is just used to punching stuff until it is dead. Now they are mad that they have to pay attention.

But the thing is, i only need a 2-3 attacks to have a full attack chain in the first place. So i am able to still use plenty of powers and dodge patches.

What most teams end up doing with swords is you kill all but one (if you keep killing them all they just respawn) which makes swords a non-factor for the most part. However it does suck that you can’t confuse them. >.<


"I have ridden the mighty moon worm!"
-Al Gore
Fiery Aura is only good for farming, I'm cereal

@Caucasiafro

 

Posted

I ran this for the first time last night w/o getting killed in that fight on my Son/Son. Helps that he has (some) mez protection and is S/L resist capped (not to mention ranged def). I usually die a few times in there though, even w/my Stone tank in Granite, cuz I'm too busy, rooted, or just plain don't notice the blue death patches before it's too late. I accept it's just part of that particular fight, hosp it and get on w/life. The most frustrating part for me, at least, is that I can't type any messages to the team like, "stop whining, hosp it, and get back in the fight!" (This is not what I'm accusing the OP of doing, btw.)

I appreciate the wholesale hatred of rooting animations, since I mostly share them, and yeah, getting mezzed in that fight pretty much = death. I also don't appreciate the fact that controllers & doms are neutralized a bit, since immobs & holds (and slows) are counterproductive against BM. It's not a perfect fight, but I think it gets a lot more negative press than it deserves. Are the insta-deaths kinda cheap? Sure. Handle it correctly and I think the encounter's a lot of fun.


An Offensive Guide to Ice Melee

 

Posted

I played it for the first time ever last night. I used my dark/dark tank. We had a lot of deaths but universally the complaint was about the swords, not the blue circles of death although those got people sometimes too. Unfortunately I was the only taunter in the group with 1 controller and there was no way we could keep Battle Maiden on me and control all the widely dispersed minions running around.

I had read the guide but I was absolutely NOT prepared for how many blue circles show up. It seemed like we had 2 or 3 on the ground almost all the time with another forming. At times there were literally only small corridors between circles that were clear in the battle zone. To me flying was not the answer because it is sometimes hard to tell exactly what patch of ground you are hovering over.

One thing I did learn (besides not to ever use Shadow Maul if I hadn't just moved) was to move less. After reading the various guides I thought I needed to constantly moving and maybe that's true about everyone else but I didn't think it worked well for me as the tank.

I found that I needed to pick a a clear space that was well away from the rest of the party. Then taunt Battle Maiden continuously until she moved toward me or the blue circle appeared on me. If she got to me I'd hit her with fast attacks or the envenomed dagger until a circle appeared. Once I was the center of a circle I'd move just enough to be outside the circle, being sure not to be near anyone else in the party, and start the process over. Things went much faster after that as the blue circles started overlapping and taking up less of the battleground and folks were able to fight more/move less.

It didn't keep blue circles from showing up around the high dps folks sometimes but it did help I think.

I'm not sure if I should be proud or ashamed that my tank lived when everyone else was dying all around me but I was the only one in the party that didn't die. Lots of minions + Dark Regen = win. Gotta love Dark Armor.


 

Posted

I love the Battle Maiden fight 'cause it takes tank 'n spank tactics and throws them out the window. Ideally, you'd have someone getting aggro and drawing BM out of the blue patches as they appear. During half-time (when she chickens out) it's just a matter of focusing on the Champions and avoiding the blue patches, which I'll admit is slightly tricky, especially since the Champions seem to blend in with the surrounding environment. After several runs I can pick out the warning patches pretty easily. Plus they have an ominous sound effect.


@Demobot

Also on Steam

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden_Avariel View Post
I played it for the first time ever last night. I used my dark/dark tank. We had a lot of deaths but universally the complaint was about the swords, not the blue circles of death although those got people sometimes too. Unfortunately I was the only taunter in the group with 1 controller and there was no way we could keep Battle Maiden on me and control all the widely dispersed minions running around.
This. The TF really plays up the gap between squishy and non squishy archetypes.


 

Posted

Small tip on the BM fight. If you're ranged, try to hang out near the walls of the zone. That way when the halberd spawns, it only takes up about 50% of the floor it otherwise would.

Done it 3 or 4 times on various Controllers and never died to a halberd. Once to a sword before I knew they couldn't be controlled. Super Speed helps a lot. As do IOs, obviously.


 

Posted

When I heard about this Taskforce, I feared the worse for my Mastermind Primary and spec'd up a second build that used Group Teleport to force my henchmen to move as soon as I needed them to.

First time I ran it, perhaps because it was post-level shift for many, I had no issues with my standard Hover-build and just commanding the henches to move away. I only lost a drone or two.

More of an issue is the darn Greater Swords who kept chasing me around. Battle Maiden's patches themselves really haven't been any issue.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deus_Otiosus View Post
I ran this three times last night on a Brute, a Fort & a Corr.

And while I agree with others that it's not super hard or ridiculous, I also feel that if the goal is to make the game more fluid and less tank and spank that the game's mechanics should reflect that.

I would love it if the game became a more mobile, fluid experience where things like travel suppression and being rooted during animations didn't exist.

Will it happen? Unlikely.
Ummm... no. The reason for rooting is the same as it has been for a loong time: Risk vs Reward. If you could run-n-gun with all of your attacks, there would be barely any risk at all, since the attacks are guaranteed to (have a chance to ) hit on each activation. So you run up, you animate the power, then you run away, just like usual. I and I believe most others are not interested in a zippy ADD flashfest. That sounds more like Call of Duty and its ilk - which is ok, but it is not this game.

The game does not 'have to change to suit the mission'; the players have to adapt to the mission. Isn't the other way around just silly?


Arc #6015 - Coming Unglued

"A good n00b-sauce is based on a good n00b-roux." - The Masque

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden_Avariel View Post
One thing I did learn (besides not to ever use Shadow Maul if I hadn't just moved) was to move less.
That is actually a GREAT point, it is generally best to just move just those few meters that you need to in order to get out of the patch (jumping does not help, it just makes to look stupid :P) then get back to taunting, debuffing, attack etc.



I can’t confirm this in anyway because i haven’t run apex with my MM and haven’t actually tested it out. But i think pets just might actually have some res to patch dmg. At least when i saw a pet standing in a patch it looked like they were taking less dmg per tick. Shivs and HVAS only take tick dmg of about 60ish last I remember. Just sayin'


"I have ridden the mighty moon worm!"
-Al Gore
Fiery Aura is only good for farming, I'm cereal

@Caucasiafro

 

Posted

Strangely enough - I could deal with the swords fairly easily.

They zoom around but really they aren't any different than any other foe. On my scrapper I died once while peeling BM off a squishie and a blue patch dropped.

On my Fire/Dark corr I never died and was able to keep moving around the edges and debuff BM while dropping tarpatches to slow the champions and swords.

On my ice/Storm troller - I died multiple times as the swords aren't knocked back and they just mobbed me as i sought to slow BM. The blue patches while you are running white and blue Ice storms and Ice slick............


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by galadiman View Post
Ummm... no. The reason for rooting is the same as it has been for a loong time: Risk vs Reward. If you could run-n-gun with all of your attacks, there would be barely any risk at all, since the attacks are guaranteed to (have a chance to ) hit on each activation. So you run up, you animate the power, then you run away, just like usual. I and I believe most others are not interested in a zippy ADD flashfest. That sounds more like Call of Duty and its ilk - which is ok, but it is not this game.

The game does not 'have to change to suit the mission'; the players have to adapt to the mission. Isn't the other way around just silly?
I thought we were rooted because we HAD to be. Because it's part of the game engine, but i could be wrong.


"I have ridden the mighty moon worm!"
-Al Gore
Fiery Aura is only good for farming, I'm cereal

@Caucasiafro

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Infernus_Hades View Post
This.

If they want fluid and ADAPTABLE then lets drop the rooting. It reminds me of the changes to PvP when they implemented supression. Take a quick flowing game and slow it down. I am saying using power rooting to kill off people who due to clipping, lag or teammate colored animations miss the flash cues for the fire is a cheap "challenge."

I love the attacks though - and the Learn to Play advice. It always the same if you dare to criticize the great and powerful Oz. Look I have not played the BAF trial yet but I see they make some enemies immune to status effects - EXACTLY like I suggested is possible to do and all while not making it unbalanced.

I have said for 7 years now that status effect reliance is laziness. Tougher enemies can have armor, use attacks that aren't slows or stuns and let the enviroment be fluid and fast. Does anyone facing what I have read of the BAF Trial say its slow and stilted or is it at times seemingly too fast?

There is a place for status effects and it used to be only Lts and Bosses had them now every minion does something.
Nice. "If they want us to adapt, Let's make the devs remoev the things they want us to adapt around." Brilliant. "Learning Calculus is hard. Remove the integration part, because that will make it easier."

"Status effect reliance is laziness. Tougher enemies can have armor..."
Another idea for dynamic play: "Take away all the things that make killing the enemies a thinking process - just make them all huge bags of hit points."

Like many of these kinds of posts, no one is saying that CoX is not to be questioned... mostly, (I) am saying, "Differentiate between 'I don't like this playstyle' and 'No One likes this playstyle'." Because there are plenty of people out there that DO like the playstyle shift.


Arc #6015 - Coming Unglued

"A good n00b-sauce is based on a good n00b-roux." - The Masque

 

Posted

I can't agree that people take time to die and its easy to move away at any point, everybodies healthpoints goes down at different speeds for usually more than one reason. The usually more than one reason is due to free aggro, blue patches and an AV who could be being fought in melee by Brutes without aggro glue taunt. With chaos being rooted for a lil while is a bad thing.

I am not yet sure if any team mix is fully capable of Mo'ing it like I might be with STF etc.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

New Dawn: The Master of Apex badge is different than the Master of Stateman/Lord Recluse/etc. There is no zero deaths requirement; it's a completely different set of criteria. Link: http://paragonwiki.com/wiki/Master_o...sk_Force_Badge

I really have trouble understanding the point you are making in the first paragraph above.


Arc #6015 - Coming Unglued

"A good n00b-sauce is based on a good n00b-roux." - The Masque

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
I am not yet sure if any team mix is fully capable of Mo'ing it like I might be with STF etc.
Except getting Master of Apex requires you to kill BM quickly, it doesn't require you to kill her without dieing. The two are very different problems, for Master you need people who can handle attacking BM while moving more than anything else.

Now assuming you meant "do it without any deaths" rather than master I agree that would be tricky but I think it would depend more on player skill than particular team composition. The thing to remember is that most of the adds have limited or no ranged attacks. So what you need more than anything is for squishy characters to move around a lot and to make good use of AoE slow/immobilize powers to provide clear spaces to move to. A FF or Cold Dom character would also be handy for ranged defense and a few characters with suitable patch powers.


 

Posted

The other point that might be made is this: The Devs designed the Incarnate content to be Hard. Not Easy. So when you don't defeat it on the first try, WAI. And when you get on a pug that has had no real thinking put into whether it can meet the challenges posed by the TF, and you fail, WAI. It's Top Level Content.

And a corollary to this is: If you're hung up on being defeated, if you think it's shameful to faceplant, if you think bringing Wakies is not a good idea, well, that won't work. It's why the devs made the Reqs for MoApex NOT include 0 deaths. So embrace your Inner Blaster, Pile up a few Wakies, and Roll On.


Arc #6015 - Coming Unglued

"A good n00b-sauce is based on a good n00b-roux." - The Masque

 

Posted

I'm not crazy about the 'blue thingies' either. Why not? They're freaking invisible to me. There is absolutely zero graphical clues as to when I'm about to faceplant... but there are audio clues. Once I picked up on those it became much, much easier to avoid the blue thingamabobs unless I flew into one by accident. So, while I'm not crazy about them, I'm not angry about them either.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by galadiman View Post
Ummm... no. The reason for rooting is the same as it has been for a loong time: Risk vs Reward. If you could run-n-gun with all of your attacks, there would be barely any risk at all, since the attacks are guaranteed to (have a chance to ) hit on each activation. So you run up, you animate the power, then you run away, just like usual. I and I believe most others are not interested in a zippy ADD flashfest. That sounds more like Call of Duty and its ilk - which is ok, but it is not this game.
You are confused.

The reason for the rooting is because it's a part of the game engine.

You're not interested in a zippy ADD flashfest and yet that's nearly what the BM fight is.


Quote:
Originally Posted by galadiman
The other point that might be made is this: The Devs designed the Incarnate content to be Hard. Not Easy. So when you don't defeat it on the first try, WAI. And when you get on a pug that has had no real thinking put into whether it can meet the challenges posed by the TF, and you fail, WAI. It's Top Level Content.
Read further up the thread.

3 Runs back to back on 3 different ATs, 1 Death total on all 3 runs, 3 Mo Badges Earned - Total of 90 minutes.

It's not hard, it's a gimmick.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by galadiman View Post
New Dawn: The Master of Apex badge is different than the Master of Stateman/Lord Recluse/etc. There is no zero deaths requirement; it's a completely different set of criteria. Link: http://paragonwiki.com/wiki/Master_o...sk_Force_Badge

I really have trouble understanding the point you are making in the first paragraph above.
Point was to posts further up and inline with somewhere towards what OP is getting at but saying with chaos rooted animations do become a problem.

Yeah I mean't Mo'ing as in the normal way I always mean Mo'ing it, no defeats. I am not a badger so couldn't give a toot. I aint ever even looked at the badge for it.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deus_Otiosus View Post
You are confused.

The reason for the rooting is because it's a part of the game engine.

You're not interested in a zippy ADD flashfest and yet that's nearly what the BM fight is.
Perhaps I am mistaken, but I can jump/cue attack/fly past an opponent/attack animates/I fall to the ground, far from the opponent. And any number of powers have been changed from 'rooting' to 'not rooting'. So please explain what it is you mean by 'it is part of the game engine'. As far as I can tell, it is something that can be controlled by the Devs.

It is not anything like what I consider to be a 'zippy ADD flashfest', as I stated. It IS much more dynamic than other content in the game, which is a very different thing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deus_Otiosus View Post
Read further up the thread.

3 Runs back to back on 3 different ATs, 1 Death total on all 3 runs, 3 Mo Badges Earned - Total of 90 minutes.

It's not hard, it's a gimmick.
It seems the people above in the thread are having difficulty with the content. So I submit that their frustration with how difficult it is for them is the source of their angst. Seeing as how others do not feel the frustration, it seems the problem lies with the poster, not with the game.


Arc #6015 - Coming Unglued

"A good n00b-sauce is based on a good n00b-roux." - The Masque

 

Posted

I did this TF for the very first time last night on my tank, and I enjoyed it. The blue flames were not as hard as I expected them to be. Our team was not very experienced. It was the first time for a few guys, including me. But thankfully we did have some that knew what to do. They explained to me what would happen before we started the TF, and it sounded pretty scary. In reality it wasn't as bad.

Being on a tank, I barely even had to worry. At some points I actually jumped into the flames to kite BM. Having a PvP background, moving around while attacking is totally second nature to me.

The biggest problem was actually doing damage to BM. I have a theory that -speed debuffs actually hurt the team. I was desperatly trying to taunt her out of the patches so we could attack her, but she was practically running in one spot from all the slows. So there was simply no way to get her out of the blue. Every time we just had to wait for the patch under her to disappear. The whole fight took probably 30 mins. Overall, definitely fun. But I may have had a different opinion if I had been on a squishy