Issue 19: Incarnates


Adeon Hawkwood

 

Posted

The whole idea of 'Incarnate Levels' still strike me as raising the level cap. Granted, I'd change this up a bit if I had heard that it can affect alts, but we've been told that this is end-game content. Plus, I don't honestly envision being able to go into Level 1 Atlas Park and being able to unleash Zeus' Lightning.

If it's only available at level 50, what different does it make what you call them? You can call them Praetorian Advancement Stages for all I care, but if it's making you stronger- more capable of dealing and avoiding damage, better Def/Res, then it is an additional level. Just because your contacts still like you doesn't mean their arcs won't have fell significantly along the difficulty curve.

On the flip side, the entire system of getting further in 'levels' strikes me as the opportunity to pull a WoW-style 'Heroics' content for missions/arcs.
"Would you like to set this at Incarnate level?"



 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigium View Post
The whole idea of 'Incarnate Levels' still strike me as raising the level cap. Granted, I'd change this up a bit if I had heard that it can affect alts, but we've been told that this is end-game content. Plus, I don't honestly envision being able to go into Level 1 Atlas Park and being able to unleash Zeus' Lightning.

If it's only available at level 50, what different does it make what you call them? You can call them Praetorian Advancement Stages for all I care, but if it's making you stronger- more capable of dealing and avoiding damage, better Def/Res, then it is an additional level. Just because your contacts still like you doesn't mean their arcs won't have fell significantly along the difficulty curve.

On the flip side, the entire system of getting further in 'levels' strikes me as the opportunity to pull a WoW-style 'Heroics' content for missions/arcs.
"Would you like to set this at Incarnate level?"
I think they might add some new type of Incarnate scaling for the enemy mobs, otheriwse, the current high end content will become way too easy.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

One of the Devs has specifically mentioned, at Hero Con, that the new End Game system would allow characters to 'trivialize' the current content.


"The side that is unhappy is not the side that the game was intended to make happy, or promised to make happy, or focused on making happy. The side that is unhappy is the side that is unhappy. That's all." - Arcanaville
"Surprised your guys' arteries haven't clogged with all that hatred yet." - Xzero45

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MajorPrankster View Post
One of the Devs has specifically mentioned, at Hero Con, that the new End Game system would allow characters to 'trivialize' the current content.
Do you have a quote or link for that?
If it's true, then that would mean that the new enw Incarnate content would be similar to the high end stuff we have now, and the current content would let us go all pre-ED on their butts


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Dont know how much is true but MMORPG.COM said that the name of issue 19 might be changed.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jacks Assortment View Post
Dont know how much is true but MMORPG.COM said that the name of issue 19 might be changed.
Positron said at PAX that "Incarnates" was what they were calling it right now - probably because that's the easiset title to use that lets people know what's in it

Once GR goes live and we get the full details of I19, they might change the name.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigium View Post
If it's only available at level 50, what different does it make what you call them? You can call them Praetorian Advancement Stages for all I care, but if it's making you stronger- more capable of dealing and avoiding damage, better Def/Res, then it is an additional level.
Um, purple IOs are only available at level 50 and make you stronger than other level 50s, does that mean purple IOs are a level cap increase?

I don't care how much more powerful the Incarnate system makes one character compared to other level 50s, as long as the "level" field still says "50", it's not a level increase.




Character index

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MajorPrankster View Post
One of the Devs has specifically mentioned, at Hero Con, that the new End Game system would allow characters to 'trivialize' the current content.
Again, link for that quote?

Trivializing all the current content seems like an unwise and, more importantly, uncharacteristic move on the devs' part. It also sounds like a functional increase in the level cap, which has been vetoed a gazillion times. (Of course, the devs could have changed their minds, too.)

I really hope this doesn't mean CoX is falling into the level escalation trap that troubles so many MMO's.


"Bombarding the CoH/V fora with verbosity since January, 2006"

Djinniman, level 50 inv/fire tanker, on Victory
-and 40 others on various servers

A CoH Comic: Kid Eros in "One Light"

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr_Darkspeed View Post
One intriguing thing that was mentioned in that video, is that the Incrnates system can be used to obtain rewards for your alts.

I wonder what that could be?
Yeah that will be interesting. WoW has Heirloom items, basically moderate rarity items that scale to your level and are bound to your account and that approach COULD potentially work although given how little increase there is in gear quality over the levels it would need to be something pretty spectacular (like Hamidon enhancements useable at any level). Personally I think it'll be temp powers that are either very long duration buffs or increase XP gains for a few days worth of playtime.


 

Posted

I am afraid I do not have a specific link, I simply remember reading it during Hero Con. Don't recall if it was an interview or just something someone overheard. I think it was Castle or Posi, if that helps anyone else find it.


"The side that is unhappy is not the side that the game was intended to make happy, or promised to make happy, or focused on making happy. The side that is unhappy is the side that is unhappy. That's all." - Arcanaville
"Surprised your guys' arteries haven't clogged with all that hatred yet." - Xzero45

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silver Gale View Post
I don't care how much more powerful the Incarnate system makes one character compared to other level 50s, as long as the "level" field still says "50", it's not a level increase.
Personally I'd say for it to be a "level" increase it needs to increase the combat attributes. If it doesn't do that then it's basically just new toys to use without an actual power increase.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Adeon Hawkwood View Post
Personally I'd say for it to be a "level" increase it needs to increase the combat attributes. If it doesn't do that then it's basically just new toys to use without an actual power increase.
The thing is, how mnay new toys do you have to get before it becomes like an extra level?


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

I think the difference between a level cap increase and a bonus for 50's is where the rubber would meet the road to an incarnate: A level 49 when they turn 50 gains a boost in damage and hitpoints, and a greater advantage vs. all foes in game. (They essentially gain defense/resistance/damage vs. lower-con targets, and at 50, it's the final step to lower-con stuff.) A boost for 50's would not necessitate all of these, especially if they take the 'bonus-ish' route, where you are choosing between new strengths. (Sacrificing the opportunity for a different strength.) We see something like this in-game: with IO sets, you can boost your damage further, but focusing solely on damage bonuses means you aren't gaining hp/defense/recharge/etc.

The new powers thing is intriguing. If 'incarnate' stuff was more closely bound to characters than, say, power pools or patron pools, would they exemplar down? Having a pool of always accessible extra powers in a game that encourages revisiting older content would be a bonus not to be overlooked.

The notion of incarnate powers being custom/signature powers would be awesome, but could give the devs a headache, so I dare not hope for that.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
The thing is, how mnay new toys do you have to get before it becomes like an extra level?
It's academic. Activation times mean that you can't use all of your powers every time they recharge anyway. Combat Attributes and the Purple Patch mean that even with new abilities/slots if your combat level doesn't increase you aren't significantly more powerful unless the new powers are powerful enough to render existing powers obsolete.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Adeon Hawkwood View Post
It's academic. Activation times mean that you can't use all of your powers every time they recharge anyway. Combat Attributes and the Purple Patch mean that even with new abilities/slots if your combat level doesn't increase you aren't significantly more powerful unless the new powers are powerful enough to render existing powers obsolete.
So what about a "speed up time" Incrante power?


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Seldom View Post
The notion of incarnate powers being custom/signature powers would be awesome, but could give the devs a headache, so I dare not hope for that.
Well, with the current power customization, we can select animations and colors - that's not too big a step away from giving us generic powers with no effects or animations, just stats, and letting us chose the animation and colors - think Hami-Os, only as customizable, slottable powers.

For example, you unlock an Incarnate power than gives you a damage and accuracy boost - you go into the customization screen, and pick the costume change emote "lightning" as its animation, and tint it green - that's what the damage/accuracy boost will now look like when you activate it - or you could pick the "Aid Self" animation, and tint it blue, and so on.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

I see incarnates as probably being fluff at best. What its going to end up being is just all those suggestions for things that we wanted but they are just end up being universal enhancements that you get at level 50. It will be something like anti-knockback enhancements that turn knockback into knockdown. Something that gives more regen or more defense or more hp. I doubt its going to be full powers like in some of the power pools. I would be shocked if it was.

As for as the powersets go, I think electric control will do nicely, its still not illusion for dominators but I will take what I can get. As for as kinetic melee, I dont see it doing well at all. You would think by now the devs would know knockback on teams = bad. Most players simply do not know how to position critters to minimize knockback or they scatter everything to the 4 winds. Essentially what we have been given is energy blast but at a closer range. So unless they allow these incarnate levels to be given at level 1 I see kinetic melee being phail. Now if all of the powers do knockdown instead of knockback that might be a different story here.


Bump and Grind Bane/SoA
Kenja No Ishi Earth/Empathy Controller
Legendary Sannin Ninja/Pain Mastermind
Entoxicated Ninja/PSN Mastermind
Ninja Ryukenden Kat/WP Scrapper
Hellish Thoughts Fire/PSI Dominator

Thank You Devs for Merits!!!!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MajorPrankster View Post
One of the Devs has specifically mentioned, at Hero Con, that the new End Game system would allow characters to 'trivialize' the current content.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Olantern View Post
Again, link for that quote?

Trivializing all the current content seems like an unwise and, more importantly, uncharacteristic move on the devs' part. It also sounds like a functional increase in the level cap, which has been vetoed a gazillion times. (Of course, the devs could have changed their minds, too.)

I really hope this doesn't mean CoX is falling into the level escalation trap that troubles so many MMO's.
Is it sure that content=emenies/mishes?
Maybe they meant we get so awesome/customizable powers that you'll actually laugh everytime you activate Smite or read Azuria's mission descriptions

Quote:
Originally Posted by EvilRyu View Post
I see incarnates as probably being fluff at best. What its going to end up being is just all those suggestions for things that we wanted but they are just end up being universal enhancements that you get at level 50. It will be something like anti-knockback enhancements that turn knockback into knockdown. Something that gives more regen or more defense or more hp. I doubt its going to be full powers like in some of the power pools. I would be shocked if it was.
The devs actually said "Incarnate abilities". If they turns out to be just some universal IOs(Incarnate Origins), then that was a very poor word-picking in action. Not much of a point, but CoH devs are somewhat now for their whitty expressions.

Quote:
Originally Posted by EvilRyu View Post
As for as kinetic melee, I dont see it doing well at all. You would think by now the devs would know knockback on teams = bad. Most players simply do not know how to position critters to minimize knockback or they scatter everything to the 4 winds. Essentially what we have been given is energy blast but at a closer range. So unless they allow these incarnate levels to be given at level 1 I see kinetic melee being phail. Now if all of the powers do knockdown instead of knockback that might be a different story here.
Based on what the video showed us, I can't see where you got kb from...I only show knockdown component in every power.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by xhris View Post
Based on what the video showed us, I can't see where you got kb from...I only show knockdown component in every power.
Actually the very last power had both. He does a ground-smash which is an AoE. One enemy is knocked down and the other is knocked back. I'm curious of the mechanics on that one. Knockback if defeated? 50% KD, 25% KB? Who knows?

Here, check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFQPqPwayfI#t=0m20s


Quote:
Originally Posted by PRAF68_EU View Post
Dispari has more than enough credability, and certainly doesn't need to borrow any from you.

 

Posted

Considering that Incarnates are the End Game system, and it wouldn't be an end game system if you could permanently max out your Incarnate level, it seems reasonable to think you'll have to maintain your Incarnate levels somehow.

Also, just like you don't get to keep your level 50 powers when doing a Posi TF, then if Incarnate abilities trivialize current level 50 TFs, I wouldn't expect to be able to keep them while running those TFs.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dark Quill View Post
Considering that Incarnates are the End Game system, and it wouldn't be an end game system if you could permanently max out your Incarnate level, it seems reasonable to think you'll have to maintain your Incarnate levels somehow.
I assume you mean like WoWs system of introducing an ever lengthening treadmill of new gear? Personally I'd be very surprised if they did something like that, iit just seems out of character ofr the dev team. Additionally it hits the same problem WoW style raids always had, the higher the entry requirements for content the fewer people do it.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daemodand View Post
Powers that degrade just because you can't play for a while? No thanks!
Don't worry - you'd be able to power them back up by earning the Shadow Shard TF Commander accolade.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigium View Post
On one hand, I'd LOVE for there to be a requirement of killing a Giant Monster or three before achieving Level 50+1, but then you've got the misanthropists who hate the idea of having to team up and kill things just to progress.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
I really want to know what the new zone events involve - like now
You know, Matt Miller's comments about I19 and the Incarnate system at the PAX East panel (per the video at this link) really do make me think that zone events will be the way to earn the Incarnate levels. Watch the vid and Matt says, and I quote, "brand new zone events which is the content that you play through in order to earn all this cool new stuff that we've got coming for you".

Of course the question is what kinds of zone events does Matt mean? New fixed location raids like the Hamidon/Mothership raids? New dynamic zone-wide raids like the Halloween Zombie and Rikti Dropship raids? New Giant Monsters? Maybe even new dynamic zone events like the Steel Canyon fires & Talos/IP Ghost Ship that soloers would be able to do to earn Incarnate rewards instead of always having to group for GMs/raids? Or maybe all of the above?

Will lots more dynamic content be added to existing outdoor zones? Will the Incarnate "rewards" be retroactively applied to existing zone events? Maybe if you do events like those as a sub-50 you earn normal xp, but if you do them as a level 50 you earn Incarnate xp /shrug.

It would certainly satisfy my desire for more dynamic outdoor content.