What is the purpose of rep...???


BBQ_Pork

 

Posted

As a VERY casual forum poster (something like 300 + posts in 5 years).....what should I think of rep on the forums..???...I noticed I had 3 when I logged in today from 3 months ago (first time I logged in since that last post to wish Posi well)....2 negative and one positive....I am just curious as I do not post here much at all....what is it all about...???

And I am sure someone will call this post garish and give me bad rep for it...LOL


"A great love is alot like a good memory. When it's there and you know it's there,but it's just out of your reach. It can be all that you think about. You can focus on it and try to force it but the more you do, the more you seem to push it away. But if you're patient and hold still...maybe...just maybe...it will come to you. I just need to be somewhere she can find me" - Church from Red vs Blue

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Fallen_Angel View Post
As a VERY casual forum poster (something like 300 + posts in 5 years).....what should I think of rep on the forums..???...I noticed I had 3 when I logged in today from 3 months ago (first time I logged in since that last post to wish Posi well)....2 negative and one positive....I am just curious as I do not post here much at all....what is it all about...???

And I am sure someone will call this post garish and give me bad rep for it...LOL
Just a game...


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. NoPants View Post
Just a game...
Where *WE* are the pieces.

Bags being a Rook. No pawning for me!


 

Posted

The Purpose(s) of Rep:

* To make (insert random adjective here) people ask (repeat adjective here) questions.

* As a means of allowing people the freedom to critique (grief) you in an anonymous (safe) manner thereby providing you with insightful (insulting) commentary (ridicule) without concern for debate (retribution).

* A function by which we, the forumites, can give the Moderators migraines.

* A means by which we can string red or green Christmas lights under our names in the margin. Less indicates you're a few lights short of a Christmas Tree. In my case my bulb has just plain ol' burnt out.

* We were going to cal it "street cred" but that seemed inappropriate given how many dedicated forumites rarely see direct sunlight much less an actual street.

* The purpose of Rep is to give each person a voice in a democratic society by electing an individual to represent them in a forum of peers... oh... wait... wrong Rep.

* A method of supporting a favorite poster privately when you think supporting them publicly will earn you your own negative rep.

* R.E.P. = Ridicule Emitting Pinhead


My mind wanders so often you've probably seen its picture on milk cartons. - Me... the first person version of the third person Steelclaw

 

Posted

There is no point. It COULD have been a useful indicator of whether or not someone speaks with veracity and credibility, but the "rep farmers" did away with that utility some time ago.


 

Posted

The same purpose as forum tags serve



Forum PVP.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Westley View Post
There is no point. It COULD have been a useful indicator of whether or not someone speaks with veracity and credibility, but the "rep farmers" did away with that utility some time ago.
Pfffft, no. It really wouldn't have regardless of "Rep Farmers". I find it interesting you mention the Rep Farmers, given that one of the most frequent Tags I've seen about in the last week is "The Undrn3t is everywhere" though

Quote:
The same purpose as forum tags serve



Forum PVP.
If you go to Advanced Search you can see a Tag Cloud of the most popular tags. For some weird reason "Eggs vs Bacon" is our most prolific / "useful" tag Although I see the forementioned Undrn3t tag has been getting around too.


 

Posted

Quoting from Niviene:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Niviene View Post
The Rep system is nothing more than a forum game and a way for you to have fun with each other.


 

Posted

For me, the point is to receive anonymous comments from people who wouldn't comment otherwise, directed to me, personally. I don't use it as a measuring stick because I have mine off and pay no attention to how many squares of what colour other people have.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcanaville View Post
Samuel_Tow is the only poster that makes me want to punch him in the head more often when I'm agreeing with him than when I'm disagreeing with him.

 

Posted

What is the purpose of... 11-03-2009 08:49 AM Keep on beating that dead horse. Perhaps you will get a rise out of it eventually.

Fascinating. I wonder if someone is taking it personally and perhaps feeling guilty? That's what this comment says to me.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Carnifax View Post
If you go to Advanced Search you can see a Tag Cloud of the most popular tags. For some weird reason "Eggs vs Bacon" is our most prolific / "useful" tag Although I see the forementioned Undrn3t tag has been getting around too.
They are the most "Searched" tags. Eggs vs Bacon got modsmacked a few days back, along with Tunnel Rats Rule!. This leaves Cobra! and a few others at the top of the most popular to use list.

The fact that people are actually searching on Eggs vs Bacon does surprise me a bit. I am going to have to work on that...


I mean.....what?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Calash View Post
They are the most "Searched" tags. Eggs vs Bacon got modsmacked a few days back, along with Tunnel Rats Rule!. This leaves Cobra! and a few others at the top of the most popular to use list.

The fact that people are actually searching on Eggs vs Bacon does surprise me a bit. I am going to have to work on that...


I mean.....what?
I'm not sure that's working properly - it looks more like thje 70 most frequent tags, rather than the 70 most searched for ones.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steelclaw View Post
* A method of supporting a favorite poster privately when you think supporting them publicly will earn you your own negative rep.
Or, as I often use it for:
* A method to support a poster who has posted something that you like, without derailing the thread with "QFT!" and such.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Twilight_Snow View Post
Quoting from Niviene:
Quote:
The Rep system is nothing more than a forum game and a way for you to have fun with each other.
Yeah, but so what? Niv neither designed nor implemented the system so that's really just an opinion. It may be the OFFICIAL POSITION of the management but, since they didn't create the board software, it's still just their personal opinion of what the rep system is 'for'.


Paragon City Search And Rescue
The Mentor Project

 

Posted

Couple of good cracks on what Rep is for, what it's good for, and what it's not so good for.

There are a couple of caveats to using rep though. While you, as a player, can't see who left rep, the moderators can. The moderators also have removed rep that contained insulting comments, inflammatory comments, obscene comments, and vulgar comments. So it's not really a safe way to grief somebody in private. Too many insults through the rep system, and there could be a ban-hammered response.

Also, rep as a farming tool is somewhat... well. If you click on the name of somebody whose posting you have an option to view their profile.

This link, for example, is the profile of Back Alley Brawler : http://boards.cityofheroes.com/member.php?u=418012

Under the profile you'll find a Statistics Tab, and in the statics tab an option to search for all the posts a player has made. This link, for example, is all the posts Back Alley Brawler has made: http://boards.cityofheroes.com/searc...archid=1191089

In practical way then, you can find out whether or not somebody has posted in a rep farming thread.

***

My own personal viewpoint is that the forum moderators would be better off enabling the rep system in a different way. The example I've used before is the forums at www.mepislovers.org which also uses vBulletin.

The forums there are set to display the names of people who have left rep, positive or negative, as well as allow players to visibly Thank various posts... like this one : http://mepislovers.org/forums/showth...742#post198742

We found that being able to Thank Posts successfully cut down on the number of Quoted For Truth and This Post! responses. We also found that by listing the names of people who left rep, either way, prevented griefing as well.

The hope is that the moderators will at one point re-examine the use of the forums reputation and rating system and see how other sites have handled the same software solution. I know the way MepisLovers is set up works. I think it would work here to.


 

Posted

To address the rep comment I got which should have been here to begin with:

Quote:
If you don't care then why turn it off?
I never said I don't care about the system or how it works so much as that I don't care for my reputation being represented by a number on the screen. I keep it hidden exactly because I don't want it to influence people more so than my actual posts, and it's not negative if that's what you're implying. That's all I'm going to say about how much I have. I would personally like nothing better than for everyone else to turn theirs off, because it's our deeds and the impressions of others that should represent our reputation, not numbers on the screen.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcanaville View Post
Samuel_Tow is the only poster that makes me want to punch him in the head more often when I'm agreeing with him than when I'm disagreeing with him.

 

Posted

The purpose of rep is so that in an environment where there is a false sense of anonymity -- which brings out all sorts of bad behavior -- there may be an even greater illusion of anonymity so that they can be even worse behavior. Think of it as turbojerking.

It's best to shut it off from displaying and never looking at the comments others left... it just enables the trolls.


Speeding Through New DA Repeatables || Spreadsheet o' Enhancements || Zombie Skins: better skins for these forums || Guide to Guides

 

Posted

I tend to use it as a mini-PM system, and a game. My "fun" way of using it is by repping someone with no rep (or occasionally 0 rep when it balances out, which I've seen twice) and leaving my comment as "Death to the grey rep blocks!" Personally, I've gotten generally positive rep with a couple "wth?" negative reps thrown in. And most rep has come from the top link in my sig.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Calash View Post
The same purpose as forum tags serve



Forum PVP.


That's nonsense. Everyone knows the PVPers are safely in their own land of number crunching and whatever they do for fun.

We don't have to worry about tha-ASSASSIN'S CLAW!!

Respawn Now?


 

Posted

ooo, I got -rep saying"

Quote:
Those with regulatory authority get to define purpose.
To which I say, "Feh!" Those with regulatory authority, by definition, get to regulate how the system is USED. They don't get to define the purpose for which it was DESIGNED unless they are also the designer.


Paragon City Search And Rescue
The Mentor Project

 

Posted

The purpose? why to make people believe that their opinion matters of course! XD