Question: Golden/Silver Age Costumes


Agonist_NA

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Redlynne View Post
Since you did the art for it David, this will be the easiest reference for you. Signature Story Arc 3 splash screen ... with Statesman in the foreground ... notice the texturing of the spandex on his shoulder, and how that LOOK of threaded cloth is completely impossible to achieve with Tights or Tights w/Skin ... at ANY camera distance.
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?


David Nakayama, Lead Concept Artist
COH Concept Art Gallery now open at
http://pixelsaurus.deviantart.com/

 

Posted

There were a few female crimefighters that went out and battled the forces of evil in evening wear.

Full length dresses and, perhaps, the accessories that go with them.

-Stoles
-Full length fur coats (they can actually be faux fur, as long as they look good)
-Full length evening gloves
-long cigarette holders (extra points if it actually gives off smoke)
-hats with veils over the eyes
-pince nez glasses (for those that don't know about these, they are glasses that do not have earpieces. they stay in place just by grqabbing the nose)

For both sides of the gender aisle...

-Loose trench coats. The ones we have now are a bit too tight in the upper body. I'm thinking of the classic Bogart look.
-More hat options (I think this has been said before but...)
-Walking sticks (bonus points if you can use it as an alternative power animation)


There might be more but these are the first things to come to mind.


Writer of In-Game fiction: Just Completed: My Summer Vacation. My older things are now being archived at Fanfiction.net http://www.fanfiction.net/~jwbullfrog until I come up with a better solution.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
Option A would be the most flexible, I think - people could use them for classic hero looks, or as the base for more complex outfits.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?

I'd prefer B and C. Though if you go with B, I'd ask that you not make things overly complicated still - a little texture and ribbing and such is great. A lot of it is too far, though.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
If it were up to me, (A), because, well, did you miss the thread we already did for this?

But I honestly think you'd get more sales from doing (B), even though I'm not an Ultimate universe reader, I've enjoyed its influence on the movies and I think more people would like that stuff.

Really, if you just did (B) with key parts of (A) thrown in (like real eye masks with white eyes, as in the comic books, please see the linked thread!), you'd probably make us all want to tell you to SHUT UP AND TAKE OUR MONEY!!!


@Captain-ElectricDetective MarvelThe Sapien SpiderMoravec ManThe Old Norseman
Dark-EyesDoctor SerpentineStonecasterSkymaidenThe Blue Jaguar
Guide to AltitisA Comic for New PlayersThe Lore ProjectIntro to extraterrestrials in CoH

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain-Electric View Post
...Really, if you just did (B) with key parts of (A) thrown in (like real eye masks with white eyes, as in the comic books, please see the linked thread!), you'd probably make us all want to tell you to SHUT UP AND TAKE OUR MONEY!!!
True. If we do a light version of B, it might work for the folks who want A. Maybe there's a sweet spot.


David Nakayama, Lead Concept Artist
COH Concept Art Gallery now open at
http://pixelsaurus.deviantart.com/

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
My vote is for new "domino" masks (Phantom, Robin, Spidey)

Followed by spandex options, especially something we can colour white without the skin tint going through.

- Raith


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
True. If we do a light version of B, it might work for the folks who want A. Maybe there's a sweet spot.
If you do make this set, please remember that spandex doesn't follow curves all the time - spandex across the chest doesn't totally follow the shape of the breasts - it sort of stretches over them at the front, so a spandex top costume part shouldn't have the huge dip between the breasts that the current ones have - either using new geometry for the costume chest, or faking the effect with shading like the witch top or Mother Mayhem's top.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
Mostly (A) with a little bit of (C).


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
A & C. (We've got plenty of alternatives to B already, including the nice-looking tights for the Olympian costume design.)


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
A major thing would be to have spandex and masks not look like they were painted on - actaully giving them an edge to make it look like they were separate from out bodies would be great.

Another thing would be to have an option for the classic white eyes on the masks, rather than the more realistic eye holes.
These, please.

Also, while this may be out of place in this thread, I will ask anyway, since you will actively be reading it; can we please fix bare feet so they don't look like boots with toes painted on? I have seen a number of other people ask for this of late, so it's not just me. And with Beast Mastery coming, I have a new need for it.


Est sularis oth Mithas

 

Posted

Along with everyone else I'd like to see tights with better texturing. Obviously keep the existing and just add something new.

Something I didn't see posted, and if it was and I missed then just add my name to that list as well, more generic tights patterns. The ones we have are good, great even, but more is always better. We seem to have a lot of design focused patterns and those are awesome for a character that fits that design. But, I'd really like to see some more generic patterns made available.

As far as voting goes: I'd vote option A. But, I'm OK with the compromise of finding a sweet spot between A and B. I think C should also be done just because masks are such an important part of that era of comics. So...I guess in the interest of pleasing everyone you now have to do all three!


your = Belonging to you.
you're = Contraction meaning "You are."
Ur = The name of an ancient Mesopotamian city.
ur = This is not a word.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
C c c c cccccc.

I am all about new pieces. New pieces are the happiest thing of all.

Pretty please!


In the room the women come and go
Talking of Michelangelo.

 

Posted

A major issue for me is the painted on tights/masks. The worst offender of which are full masks that cover the ears yet you're left with those ugly ears sticking out.

Simple spandex texturing would be nice. Masks with lens options would also be nice. But for Buddha's sake get rid of/flatten the ears when they're covered by spandex.


Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
My priorities for these (in order) would be A, C, B.

Also, here's some more reference material pics for you, gleaned from "recent" comic book movies ...



And it's hard to get more "Golden Age" of Heroes than this sort of thing ...


It's the end. But the moment has been prepared for ...

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
I'm still not even sure I understand what you mean by "Golden/Silver Age" here. Golden Age, to me, says loose fitting super hero costumes, puffy sleeves (eg. Green Lanter Alan Scott), and the 1940s hair styles posted earlier. Silver Age, to me, says slick, form-fitting full body suit tights with no seams at all (not much different from what we have now, honestly). The more modern movie tights you describe sound cool, but they don't sound like they're either Golden or Silver Age, but from a more Modern Heroic Age.

If we're just talking in general about better tights and mask details, I'm all for it, regardless of how it happens or what you call it. But I'd never consider referring to "Ultimates/Marvel Movie" style tights as Golden/Sliver Age. That's a lesson (hopefully) learned from the Gunslinger pack.

d


 

Posted

Masks:

  • Eye mask details that update what we have in our current library under full masks. This category has not been added to or updated since initial launch nearly 8 years ago now. And all of these should have been made available for "with hair" options years ago.
  • Masks with white eyes as has been suggested above repeatedly.
  • Adaptable details like a tie for the back of the head (tied on mask is very Golden Age versus a blend pull over mask)
  • White. Something needs to be done about the white on masks for faces. It blends with skin as if it were a very thin white watercolor wash rather than opaque fabric.
  • Keep the "painted on" look available for face masks but if possible update many of the mask textures we have to add a simple bump map or shadow of a seam around the edges
  • Signature details and gimmicks (see category below for ideas) for foreheads and full masks--can be symbols or dimensional objects.
  • Take a good look again at the super science goggles, especially in a full mask setting. This is a good starting point. Could use a few goggles like this that color well to blend with full mask colors and carry even more eye shapes: Cat eyes, sneering eyes, dot eyes, etc.

Tights:
  • Not painted on is good but as several posters above point out, just like the new tights you've included in i22, the cinematic textures--i.e. the scale or hightech weave fabric details all stray from classic comic looks. So just like the face masks getting help from a touch of texture just at the liminal edges where fabric then becomes skin, tights could use this minimal treatment.
  • SIMPLE base tights for below patterns that take advantage of new tech introduced since launch:
    • A base tights layer with a modest uniform glow to it using glow tech.
    • A base tights layer with a modest uniform reflectance map to it using that tech.
    • A base tights layer with a uniform reflectance map equal to that of the metallic skin.
  • Some more "with skin" options for lower body tights for men.
  • A female base skin with more defined musculature.
  • A "cotton" base layer. "Smooth" works okay for this now. But the softer texture may benefit people trying to capture this look.

Patterns:
  • Some of these need to be uprezzed. Not changed. Just go back to the original art and get crisper lines. Many of the original tights patterns look like lo-res jpgs that got tripled in size and have all sorts of weird dithering artifacts.
  • Take a good look at the radioactive chest and upper leg patterns. This is perhaps one of THE most silver agey of all the patterns in game. It fits what I go into below about gimmicks. It has a baked in symbol. It is very graphic. The lines are crisp. The areas of color are large and blocky. Too many of the post i4 or so tights patterns have too many fine areas of detail to qualify as GA or SA.
  • Missing some basics like a good checker board pattern. Suits of cards patterns with some baked in symbols but room for a chest emblem. Question mark patterns.
  • From prior threads I know big graphic asymmetric patterns are out of the question. But the game could use 'em if it were possible.

Boots and Gloves:
  • Taking a cue from above in case it is possible: a set of gloves and boots that are colored asymmetrically.
    Edit to be clear: By this I mean left boot is color A while right boot is color B. Or a few very simple mirrored patterns such as the "fat stripe" pattern but inverted on each boot.
  • All the GA & SA type boots in game all date back to i0 (except the rubber boots and gloves from super science is adaptable at times). When you can, consider revisiting the boots and gloves with spikes, fins & folded. A geometry revamp (or new ones that fill some adjacent gaps designwise) of those with versions that are not overly textured would be appreciated IMO.

Gimmicks and Signature Items:
  • Most GA and SA characters, SA in particular, are built around a schtick. We need more generalized items that can be turned into dimensional face masks, forehead details, shoulder baubles, chest details, emblems worked into full tights patterns, etc. These items should not try to look realistic but instead should have a gimmicky logo feel about them.
  • Some of these items we already have in one category or another, but I'm repeating things that could be made more symbolic where I think the in game ones try to convey a realism rather than a logo object. Try to think as each of these on a Venture Brothers hero or villain--pasted as an object to their forehead, turned into a uniquely shaped eye mask, neck brooch, etc.:
    • Dice
    • Dominos
    • Leaves (not like the ones we have but a stylized oak leaf or two around the eyes)
    • Heart
    • Cross
    • X
    • Question Mark
    • Smiley Face
    • Bomb with fuse
    • Fist
    • Atom
    • Spider
    • Beetle
    • Crab
    • Bat
    • Moon
    • Sun
    • Comet
    • Ringed Planet
    • Feathers
    • Horseshoe
    • 8-ball
    • Numbers
    • Infinity sign
    • Swirl

    All of the above (and more) could then be blended with the existing (and forthcoming) more "realistic" and less stylized pieces from other sets to create a range of signature looks allowing for a range of various heroes and villains from all eras of superhero comics.
  • The suggestion above regarding all existing and future hats to have a no hair option allows any and all hat assets you make to do double duty as a hat and as a signature costume item. That pilgrim hat this past thanksgiving? Missed opportunity. With no hair for his, her and huge, anyone could have thrown that onto a plain-jane tights color combo and instantly they have a visual schtick with which to build a costumed character around.

Edit: Related to the final category of logo-like gimmicks and signature items: don't forget weapons sets when producing such assets. i.e. if you were to produce an big die that can go on the forehead, consider also putting a slightly larger version of that die at the end of a walking stick and giving it to mace sets or replacing the ball on the hilt of a blade with the die. Suddenly now you've opened up a range of new schticky classic comic book options for all "Lucky ______" characters.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noble Savage View Post
You guys are talking about a lot of different sets here. When I hear "Golden/Silver Age Comics," I think of super-heroes (jungle girls, for example, would be an entirely different genre--but a fun one!). If we're talking strictly about super-hero costumes, as I see it there are 3 possible ways to expand on the category:

A) revamped old school/spandex tights similar to the ones we already have (adding a few details like seams but still mostly plain)

B) modern tights (w/ ribbing, surface texture(s), subdivided surfaces) a la Ultimates 1 or Marvel movies

C) pieces we just haven't made before (e.g. domino mask)

What are you guys most interested in?
Your comment went up when I stepped away from the keyboard mid-draft of my first list of suggestions. Based on this, I'd agree with Golden Girl that B is quite covered at the moment. A combination of both A and C would be welcome.

Personally, considering that this is a superhero game first and foremost and since the sort of pieces we are talking about are more graphic in nature, I'd like to see at least two classic items folded into each set, whatever the theme. A facemask. A chest emblem. A new classic tights pattern.

For example: Chinese New Year could have a dragon tights pattern--not highly textured like anything we've gotten since the Stealth set through Olympian Guard. But a simple bold graphic tights pattern. Or a dragon eye mask or dragon brooch or something like that.

Another example: The Gunslinger set could have also included a full masks forehead detail that was a horseshoe. Two in fact: one right side up and one upside down. Or a simple belt--not a bullet belt--with a horseshoe on or crossed pistols on it. Again as per my prior post--symbolic logo like versions of these items, not a detailed piece with precise wear marks in the metal, etc.

A third example: With the coming space set, people had proposed a number of belts with a Saturn or atom or some sort of symbol on it. These assets could and should also be repurposed and relocated to the forehead. Maybe single shoulder or arm jewelry details (jewelry for all three body types!) as well. Or even use them as cape brooches. (Some of the original cape brooches, though VERY small, do a good job--saturn and stars in particular. And the new bat brooch was very welcome.) Additionally, I think a good simple bold tights pattern, similar to the radioactive one I point you to in my earlier post that bakes in some rocket or ringed planet logos and also has an accompanying cape would be very welcomed.

I think nibbling away at expanding the more adaptable (but SPECIFIC in symbolism, not GENERIC!) classic characters in tights options as you guys continue to do sets would be the best way to introduce new never been done bits.

Meanwhile, I personally think a revisiting of the old assets (patterns and white on skin issues in particular) and updating them to have crisper lines is kinda necessary at this point.

Lastly, I think some of the BASIC full body skins suggested in my prior post should be targeted for roll out in a 1/2 issue or spread over several issues and 1/2 issues. (uniform reflectance maps, uniform glow maps.) These are basic lego pieces that shouldn't take too many development hours but will be used as widely if not more so than some highly specific tailored pieces seen in the current trend in costume set design.


 

Posted

Men's shorts!



Not only would they work with Golden/Silver age outfits as the amateur or beginner or fashionably impaired hero, but they would also work for the Wrestler or casual wear. We just don't have good short pants options for men. And they need to work over tights and with bare legs, please.


Speeding Through New DA Repeatables || Spreadsheet o' Enhancements || Zombie Skins: better skins for these forums || Guide to Guides

 

Posted

The thing I want more than anything else is the ability to stack more than one pattern on my tights at a time.

The most obvious use for that would be the ability to have some of the stripe patterns AND a chest emblem background (like the circles or squares)

Let us worry about clipping issues. The way I envisioned it working is the base, Pattern Layer 1, and Pattern Layer 2. Layer 2 would go over the top of layer 1, so anything that shares space on the layers would be covered up by layer 2.

It would open up literally thousands more possibilities, and you wouldn't have to design any new patterns.

I would like to see this in addition to anything else the community comes up with. I can't even tell you how many times I've thought "Man, it would look awesome if I could combine this pattern with that pattern."


Quote:
Originally Posted by Dechs Kaison
See, it's gems like these that make me check Claws' post history every once in a while to make sure I haven't missed anything good lately.

 

Posted

My two biggest desires in this category:

- Lenses/White eyes options for masks (a la Batman the Animated Series)
- Actual textured masks (versus the painted on effect we have now)


@Winter. Because I'm Winter. Period.
I am a blaster first, and an alt-oholic second.

 

Posted

I would echo the 'face detail masks,' 3d masks that stand out from the face, rather than simply patterns.

"Spandex" textures with slight wrinkles. Not baggy-like, but enough to differentiate from the 'every crack and cranny' bodypaint look.

Collars:



Swoop-pointed boots, and the pretty-darned common cape broaches with rope:


...and of course, the 'golden age' briefs. The ones that aren't painted speedos, but actually shorts on top of the spandex.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by TrueGentleman View Post
A & C. (We've got plenty of alternatives to B already, including the nice-looking tights for the Olympian costume design.)
Very useful to know. I figured that the Defense set would've covered it as well, yet there were still requests for more super-hero stuff after that shipped. Wanted to figure out exactly what you guys were after.


David Nakayama, Lead Concept Artist
COH Concept Art Gallery now open at
http://pixelsaurus.deviantart.com/

 

Posted

I'd also go with A and C. The Olympian and Defense already do a good job of showing a "modern tights" sort of thing, and we REALLY need Robin-style white eye Domino masks.




@Amarlex in game, on the Virtue server.