what's the problem with Shadow Fall?


Ad Astra

 

Posted

I recently took Shadow Fall on my dark/dark defender. However, the few times I've used it on teams, the team has asked me to turn it off.

Why don't teams like Shadow Fall?


 

Posted

They're dumb.







No, really, Shadow Fall is freaking awesome. If you're not leading a hostage/rescuee to the door, there is no reason not to use it. If you're leading a hostage/rescuee, it interferes. It also makes people's costumes grungy and their toons translucent, which may be a legitimate complaint but IMO Shadow Fall is more awesome than their toons' costumes.


Paragon Wiki: http://www.paragonwiki.com
City Info Terminal: http://cit.cohtitan.com
Mids Hero Designer: http://www.cohplanner.com
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dispari View Post
I don't know why Dink thinks she's not as sexy as Jay was. In 5 posts she's already upstaged his entire career.

 

Posted

It's generally the look. I'd never ask anyone to turn it off in a fight, but it's got an annoying look when you're not and it's not necessary. I generally only turn it on for battle.


Dec out.

 

Posted

It doe smake tanks have to try a little bit harder to ensure he gets all the agro at the start of a fight for about 0.000000001 seconds, for a good tank.

Its an awesome power, and should only be turned off if you intend to be near the hostage or more accurately, the person the hostage is following.

It also has its uses for hostage stealing, if some gimp on your team is being dumb.


Quote:
Originally Posted by VoodooGirl View Post
[*]Watching out for the Spinning Disco Portal of D00M!*

 

Posted

Quote:
Mega_Jamie needs an addition:

Its an awesome power, and should only be turned off if you intend to be near the hostage or more accurately, the person the hostage is following.
Or you're not even fighting. It's particularly annoying in WW, where there is no reason for it to be on.


Dec out.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mega_Jamie View Post
It also has its uses for hostage stealing, if some gimp on your team is being dumb.
Steamy Mist is good for this too.


Sometimes you get the bear; sometimes he get you, rips your head off, sucks out your eyes, pulls out your spleen, humps your leg and pees in your boots

 

Posted

The problem with Shadow Fall are 1) Idiot team mates, 2) Idiot NPCs and 3) Idiots in Rikti Events. Only one of three is important.

1) I run Shadow Fall perma when I'm in a mission and travelling around. Great stealth and nice bonuses to resistance (and a little def). No reason for it to be off in a mission unless ...

2) Some NPCs escort hostages can't see through it and need it turned off so you can get the dumb rear to the objective.

3) I have been whined at to turn it off during Rikti Events because "It prevents heavies". This is nonsense and why I keep this post bookmarked.

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Dark Watcher View Post
Stealth powers have no effect on the Rikti's ability to select a Hero or Villain as a target and their counting scanners for determing threat levels are likewise not affected by stealth.
I do agree that powers on the Black Market/WW are annoying. I don't just mean Shadow Fall. Personally if I stood at WW with my spines/fire scrapper going full tilt with eight toggles I'd EXPECT someone to yell at me. (Not so much on a drive by 5 sec drop off but a long purchasing expedition.)

One thing I have noticed with SF and Steamy Mist is if your gfx card is struggling it can cause a little lag. Personally I always turn the number of particles down from 50k to 10k. Not sure if that's relevent but I like it.


Ignore the haters, you keep your SF up. My def thanks you.





SAVE CoX info:
Titan Network efforts
Saving CoX events/FB info

 

Posted

Quote:
Capa_Devans shows pity on the lesser equipped computer:

I do agree that powers on the Black Market/WW are annoying. I don't just mean Shadow Fall. Personally if I stood at WW with my spines/fire scrapper going full tilt with eight toggles I'd EXPECT someone to yell at me. (Not so much on a drive by 5 sec drop off but a long purchasing expedition.)
In the old WW interface, it would take upwards of 2-3 minutes after clicking for the screen to come up for me. If anyone running powers like that came near me...POOF, I was back to the login screen. Thankfully the new interface works a lot better now.


Dec out.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Capa_Devans View Post
The problem with Shadow Fall are 1) Idiot team mates, 2) Idiot NPCs and 3) Idiots in Rikti Events. Only one of three is important.

1) I run Shadow Fall perma when I'm in a mission and travelling around. Great stealth and nice bonuses to resistance (and a little def). No reason for it to be off in a mission unless ...

2) Some NPCs escort hostages can't see through it and need it turned off so you can get the dumb rear to the objective.

3) I have been whined at to turn it off during Rikti Events because "It prevents heavies". This is nonsense and why I keep this post bookmarked.
These.

If you have to deal with a hostage, turn it off. Other than that, go nuts. (And as for #3, I found that just funny the last time someone whined about that. "Shadow fall prevents heavies!" "No, it doesn't," (provided dev info.) "They're wrong. We won't get any heavies because of him!"

And when the heavies came up?

"Hey, guess what I'm still running."


 

Posted

The only time my Darky turns off Shadow Fall is if there's already a huge abundance of defensive buffs going on in the team.. In which case it's just draining my End for little return.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
Or you're not even fighting. It's particularly annoying in WW, where there is no reason for it to be on.
IIRC, the graphic for shadow fall is not "contageous" anymore. Only the person with the toggle on will show the graphic. Other people are still granted the benefits and slight translucency, but they wont have the colored shroud that many people think is annoying.


 

Posted

Shadow Fall prevents you from escorting hostages, that's the only time during the mission where you should turn it off (and I'm willing to bet those are the only situations where people have asked you to turn it off)


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silverado View Post
Shadow Fall prevents you from escorting hostages, that's the only time during the mission where you should turn it off (and I'm willing to bet those are the only situations where people have asked you to turn it off)
That's what I'm thinking what happened. I've never told anyone to turn SF off. Except for my buddy I usually team with if he's deep into a sammach or something and the hostage won't follow. Best secondary out there! I love DM for my Masterminds.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
It's generally the look.
This. As the owner of a Dark/Ice defender, I always turn it off when we're just waiting around/not in battle/escorting a hostage

And especially at the auction house/around contacts/trainers. TURN YOUR TOGGLES OFF AT THE AUCTION HOUSE PEOPLE!!!!

Er...ahem...where was I?

Yeah, it's not the nicest looking power in the world.


 

Posted

It can be laggy at times, even at 100 particle count. Yes, I often play at 100 particle count and it can be frustrating. That said, if we're fighting anything that it gives me that nice +Res to I just deal with the drop in FPS.

And yes, turn off your annoying toggles (AND AUTOS) in WW and the Black Market, please. And if you're a Mastermind - do you REALLY need to have your pets right next to you blocking the person for everyone else?


 

Posted

It's your game, if you like it leave it on. You don't pay for the game AND the subscription just so some random noob can tell you how/when to use your powers.


 

Posted

Quote:
Master-Blade says it's now minor:

IIRC, the graphic for shadow fall is not "contageous" anymore. Only the person with the toggle on will show the graphic. Other people are still granted the benefits and slight translucency, but they wont have the colored shroud that many people think is annoying.
Frankly, I don't want even the "slight translucency" or that black around my feet either. Really, it should be common courtesy in a well-known laggy non-combat area to shut EVERYTHING off, but I realize I'm in a minority in that view.

EDIT: **looks up at last several posts** OK, at least I'm not alone.


Dec out.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by SPiNE View Post
It's your game, if you like it leave it on. You don't pay for the game AND the subscription just so some random noob can tell you how/when to use your powers.
Next time I'm teaming with you, I'll be sure to spam Grant Invisibility on everyone when you're attempting to escort a hostage out of the mission.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ShadowNate
;_; ?!?! What the heck is wrong with you, my god, I have never been so confused in my life!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mega_Jamie View Post
It doe smake tanks have to try a little bit harder to ensure he gets all the agro at the start of a fight
Actually, it doesn't. At all. Shadow Fall (and Steamy Mist/Arctic Fog) has no affect on any character's ability to generate Threat.


http://www.fimfiction.net/story/36641/My-Little-Exalt

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune Knight View Post
Next time I'm teaming with you, I'll be sure to spam Grant Invisibility on everyone when you're attempting to escort a hostage out of the mission.
Obviously, I was talking about the person who said that you shouldn't have Shadow Fall on when you're just idling in WW. It's stupid to be an a-hole about it for the purpose of making a point.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by SPiNE View Post
Obviously, I was talking about the person who said that you shouldn't have Shadow Fall on when you're just idling in WW. It's stupid to be an a-hole about it for the purpose of making a point.
It's sooooo obvious when you don't quote or make any direct references


And even still, there's nothing wrong with saying people should be considerate enough to avoid screwing other people over (they paid for the game and subscription fee, after all, if they want to use it to implore others to reduce lag, that's their prerogative).


Quote:
Originally Posted by ShadowNate
;_; ?!?! What the heck is wrong with you, my god, I have never been so confused in my life!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune Knight View Post
It's sooooo obvious when you don't quote or make any direct references


And even still, there's nothing wrong with saying people should be considerate enough to avoid screwing other people over (they paid for the game and subscription fee, after all, if they want to use it to implore others to reduce lag, that's their prerogative).
I guess you can make a point for the lag issue.