Is Superior Invisibility's endurance cost a bug?


Aggelakis

 

Posted

Superior Invisibility, which uses 1.04 endurance per second and 0.53 at the ED cap of 3 SOs, seems more expensive in endurance than it should be.

A) I remember a patch a while back that adjusted incorrect and too expensive endurance costs. I'm not sure if this was one of the powers adjusted or to what.

B) It really doesn't seem worth an endurance cost higher than 2 applications of Shadow Fall or Time's Juncture or the same as Enervating Field.

Sure, the power has some benefits, but the benefits are extremely limited.

1) Any stealth radius over 65ft is wasted because the special enemies that can see farther usually negate stealth entirely, such as Rikti Drones.

2) The controller stealth cap cuts it almost in half in pvp anyway. Anybody with a single perception buff can then see the controller a long way off, perhaps beyond the controller's own perception. This should be considered a bug since the single best stealth power is not even close to what it should be in pvp, but that's a different topic.

3) It doesn't provide any more defense than the power stealth from the concealment pool.

4) It doesn't provide anything but stealth radius and a small amount of defense, unlike powers such as Steamy Mist and Shadow Fall which have half the endurance cost of SI and provide more always on defense and 15% resistance to each of 3 exotic damage types AND ARE AOE.

5) The stalker power Hide provides about the same benefit, at least in PVE, but doesn't cost any endurance.


Sure, Superior Invisibility provides stealth that is easily high enough for all but special enemies and doesn't suppress in combat, but that does not seem like it earns it one of the highest endurance costs of any toggle power ever.
Just look at Shadow Fall and Steamy Mist. Combine those 2 on a team and your WHOLE LEAGUE has 70ft of stealth(more than needed for most of the game), much more defense and a LOT of resistance to 5(?) damage types, all for half the endurance cost per character using those powers and costing the league nothing as far as endurance.

I think Superior Invisibility either must be bugged or needs an adjustment down to 0.52 endurance per second, maximum 0.66 endurance per second(double Stealth's cost).






Now, I know there are certain arguments that will be used to say "its endurance cost is fair and right where it should be", but a couple of the above points, namely the ones about Steamy Mist and Shadow Fall, refute some of them.

1) Illusion Control has Deceive, a confuse power, to go with Superior Invisibility.
So? Does that hurt Arachnos Widows who go down the Fortunata path and get Mask Presence, 40ft stealth, plus mez protection and high defense with very high scaling resistance and the exact same confuse power all while doing more damage?
Confuse also doesn't help you get experience without fighting. You still need to do damage to each and every enemy to get experience from them. It may be safe, but it's not the fastest or best way to lots of experience without a lot of damage(which drains endurance a lot too) to back it up.

By the way, confuse can be used for the same thing regardless of having stealth or not. It pretty much is stealth, if cast from far enough away which is easy due to its long range of 80ft.

The argument that they have confuse doesn't justify the huge endurance cost.

2) It doesn't suppress in combat.
Yes it does, but not "actual" suppression. First, the defense benefit is cut in half(which is the same benefit as the cheaper Concealment.Stealth in all situations) as soon as you attack or are attacked. Second, every enemy that is part of the same spawn group will immediately notice you as soon as you use anything on them besides confuse.
Pretty much you just avoid extra aggro which is easily already provided by being aware of your surroundings. It's not exclusive to Superior Invisibility.
Most ambushes can also see right through your stealth, and they follow you through the entire mission.

Lack of suppression in combat is both practically untrue and not worth the endurance cost when other characters get the same benefit without using endurance at all through obvious and simple strategy.

3) You can stealth missions.
First, this is not exclusive to SI because even Stealth alone can do this so long as you keep some distance from enemies, even Teleport can do this without even being hidden by porting past enemy groups.
Second, you're not getting experience for the enemies you pass by.
Third, most ambushes can still see right through your stealth.
Fourth, specially perceptive enemies can still see you.



Superior Invisibility is the single most expensive buff toggle I can think of. It really should not be that expensive, especially considering the comparatively little it can do versus other powers and what players can do with more than half a brain.

Superior Invisibility must be bugged or in need of an endurance cost adjustment to about half of what it currently costs.
It would still cost more than any other stealth toggle by about double, before and after enhancements, but it would be more in line with the benefits it provides.
It would definitely improve the low level capabilities of Illusion Control which frequently drains my endurance dry before and after DOs.
It would also make it easier to use secondary powers and more of the primary powers, without having to toggle off SI to be able to stay in a fight that is guaranteed to last longer than the already intended length of fights for every archetype(because controllers are slow and Illusion is slower).



Why is it so expensive to use Superior Invisibility for such obviously little benefit above other cheaper powers and strategies?


 

Posted

Ok, it has to be a bug.
I HATE the fact that every group of just 3 enemies on lowest difficulty uses up all ym endurance in about 30 seconds, unless all I use is confuse and let them take out themselves.

Even if I don't use Superior Invisibility, the default 3 powers(Spectral Wounds, Deceive and Blind) take all my endurance(before slotted with at least one DO endurance reduction) all too fast.



I have always hated the way this game handles the enhancements we are supposed to use.
And the developers wonder WHY we don't use things like range enhancements?

I'll tell you why. There is no room for them.

1) We start out with a pitiful one enhancement slot per power, which does not increase very fast and certainly always lags well behind our amount of powers.

2) Power Numbers, as far as accuracy and endurance and recharge, do not scale with level. They always suck.

3) Every power needs at least one SO worth of accuracy(enemy affecting powers of course) and one SO of endurance reduction, but most are made to need at least 2 SOs of accuracy and 2 SOs of endurance reduction.

4) The more recharge you slot the more endurance you need, at least somewhat, so slotting recharge makes the endurance reduction demands higher.
(It seems endurance cost is more tied to recharge than anything else like actual effectiveness of the power, which is stupid.)

5) In a power that has damage as its primary function, enhancing for any secondary effect is usually a stupid move. The only time enhancing for anything besides damage is a good thing is when the mez effect of the power is more valuable or the power has another valuable effect like resistance or defense buffs.



Here is my standard basic slotting for every attack, minimum:
2 accuracy, 2 endurance reduction, 1 recharge, 1 damage

I need accuracy and endurance reduction, so those never change. I slot 1 recharge in one because almost every power is purposefully designed too slow, but I can't slot more recharge because I don't have the slots. I slot 1 damage because damage is the most important aspect of an attack, after accuracy and sustainable endurance usage.


Here is the average slotting for every toggle:
2 endurance reduction, 0-3 main effect(resistance/defense/to-hit debuff)

Too many toggles, like Superior Invisibility, require too much endurance so they get 3 endurance reduction, but I would slot 4-6 endurance reduction if it would work in toggles like Superior Invisibility.







I think every power needs to be rebalanced to need maximum of one SO accuracy(maybe 2 SOs for incarnate stuff and other +5-10 level enemies) and maximum of 1 SO endurance reduction, period.

1) They're "needed" which means they are guaranteed to take slots away from "choices" we have.

2) Who do you think is going to not slot accuracy and endurance reduction, especially in sets that suck endurance like a starving animal such as Illusion Control?

3) You would not need the stupid low level inherent accuracy buff if you just raised the base accuracy of everything so that they needed less enhancement. You also would not need inherent fitness with stamina at level 2 if endurance cost wasn't so horrible before endurance reduction SOs with plenty of slots to put them in.
(Which still isn't enough, so I would have completely hated Illusion Control before both of these additions.)



We have plenty of enhancements to choose from, all of which we will want to use to fill 3 slots each.
How about you reduce the "need" for the "necessary" accuracy and endurance reduction enhancements so we can actually "choose" other enhancements to slot?

It's like you designed the game to focus on combat and then designed most of the power sets to completely fail at combat until maximum level when they can finally be fully enhanced with HOs to a "satisfactory level" instead of a "super" power level.


If you want to see where you got the balance and fun right in this game, look at brutes. They're fun because Fury makes up for the lack of slots to put damage enhancements in and the fact that they get great damage and great defenses.
You gave the melee archetypes everything and left the support archetypes to suffer, mostly, because they "can affect others".

I think melee archetypes, with all their high defense/health/resistance/damage, should not have mez protection and the ranged and support archetypes are the ones who should get mez protection because of their lack of damage/resistance/defense/health.
It's the non-melee archetypes that really need mez protection.

Also, why is it that minions get 1 magnitude mez protection, lieutenants get 2 mag, bosses get 3 mag and so on yet players, who are supposedly boss class(for Fury calculation for example) get 0, ZERO, magnitude mez protection unless they're a melee character???
No wonder we feel a lot less "super" than "ordinary thug" NPCs.







So in summary:

1) Reduce accuracy and endurance reduction enhancement NECESSITY across the board to ONE single origin enhancement, at most, per power.
OR
Recalculate accuracy and endurance usage based on "effectiveness per animation time", such as "damage per animation second", and actual effectiveness in comparison to other powers(like Superior Invisibility is about the same as Stealth yet costs 3 times as much) rather than recharge time and "arbitrary expensiveness".
(Actually, you should do both so that sets actually function well rather than getting as bad on endurance as Illusion Control or Radiation Emission. It's funny that even though melee archetypes have a lot more toggles they still use a lot less endurance, while doing more damage and surviving much easier.)

2) Give every player boss class magnitude 3 mez protection, minimum.
(Players should probably be considered at least Elite Boss level though, with the same mez protection Elite Boss NPCs get.)

3) You probably should take mez protection away from melee archetypes and give it to the support and ranged ones, or rebalance support and range all to compensate for the obvious lack of everything(much more defense, much more resistance, much more health, more damage) melee archetypes have.



Edit:
Actually, you should essentially do for PVE what you did for PVP(but without the mistakes) so that every power set combination is viable and fun, though not every build because it would still be possible to avoid taking damage powers or whatever weird idea.

There is a reason first person shooter games are so fun, despite the obvious lack of variety or customization in powers. They are so well balanced, with players being much more powerful than NPCs(yet still needing to be careful), that players don't ever think about number balance. They just have fun and can work out strategies to overcome even the most powerful weapons and enemies.


 

Posted

This should be in Suggestions and Ideas


H: Blaster 50, Defender 50, Tank 50, Scrapper 50, Controller 50, PB 50, WS 50
V: Brute 50, Corruptor 50, MM 50, Dominator 50, Stalker 50, AW 50, AS 50
Top 4: Controller, Brute, Scrapper, Corruptor
Bottom 4: (Peacebringer) way below everything else, Mastermind, Dominator, Blaster
CoH in WQHD

 

Posted

Solution: Don't run Superior Invisibility all the time. Are you off your nut? It's practically worthless once you're in combat anyway (you lose a very minor defense buff by turning it off).


"You don't lose levels. You don't have equipment to wear out, repair, or lose, or that anyone can steal from you. About the only thing lighter than debt they could do is have an NPC walk by, point and laugh before you can go to the hospital or base." -Memphis_Bill
We will honor the past, and fight to the last, it will be a good way to die...

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by newchemicals View Post
This should be in Suggestions and Ideas
Or in the circular file.


Quote:
Originally Posted by T_Immortalus View Post
I think every power needs to be rebalanced to need maximum of one SO accuracy(maybe 2 SOs for incarnate stuff and other +5-10 level enemies) and maximum of 1 SO endurance reduction, period.
Seriously? Every power needs to be rebalanced to suit you? Get real.

P.S. My illusion controller kicks butt.


Paragon City Search And Rescue
The Mentor Project

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ironblade View Post
P.S. My illusion controller kicks butt.
Same here.

T, maybe you're playing it wrong. It's a controller, they don't do a lot of damage, it takes a while to defeat. That's the AT. Controllers are agonizingly slow if you've been playing with scrappers, brutes and blasters.

As for the powerset, don't shortchange Deceive, it's the key power for Illusion, make your enemy your pet. You only really have to damage powers and they are slow to recharge. On top of that some of Spectral Wounds damage is temporary (~40%) and if you don't finish off the target in 10 seconds

PA is good for drawing aggro but isn't that useful in defeating mobs due to the illusionary damage they do, similar effect to Spectral Wounds.

Spectral Terror is a good way to lock down a group and Phantasm is obviously your primary controller pet that can do a heck of a lot more damage than you but has a tendency to attack when standing next to you.

Flash isn't all that useful IMO. An AoE sleep mez with very low starting accuracy (you need a +3 SO in Acc just to get it up to the base for SW and Blind).


Father Xmas - Level 50 Ice/Ice Tanker - Victory
$725 and $1350 parts lists --- My guide to computer components

Tempus unum hominem manet

 

Posted

flash is a good "oh ****" power, i dont really use it on my ill cold but it has saved me a few times (its also a mass hold not a mass sleep)

leveling up my ill cold was bloody awful because of the low dmg output, once i got heat loss end problems started to dissipate and now that i have a fully decked build with 218% rech, perma heat loss means i have 0 end problems and perma PA means i rarely take aggro

the phantasm ive found kind of meh, he actually doesnt seem to do all that much dmg and is your only pet that can actually die, but he is great for keeping the aggro while your PA is resummoning especially since he spawns his own decoy

just using blind->spectral wounds is prolly the best attack chain you will have till you get epic powers (and even then its pretty much one of the best attack chains illusions has)


 

Posted

You're making the mistake of comparing powers in a vacuum. Don't do that. Sets are balanced as a whole, not on a power-by-power basis.

One of my first Heroes (and my oldest remaining) was an Illusion/Storm Controller. The endurance is fairly heavy, but it's definitely managable (and I did this with only SOs! no IOs back then). Hilariously enough, it violated your rule of needing 1/2 SOs worth of endurance reducation (I slotted 2 acc, and then either went 3 damage 1 recharge, or 2/2 split), and Ill/Storm is hardly an... endurance fiendly powerset combo. Oh, and I ran SI pretty much 24/7


Quote:
Originally Posted by ShadowNate
;_; ?!?! What the heck is wrong with you, my god, I have never been so confused in my life!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Father Xmas View Post
Same here.

T, maybe you're playing it wrong. It's a controller, they don't do a lot of damage, it takes a while to defeat. That's the AT. Controllers are agonizingly slow if you've been playing with scrappers, brutes and blasters.

As for the powerset, don't shortchange Deceive, it's the key power for Illusion, make your enemy your pet. You only really have to damage powers and they are slow to recharge. On top of that some of Spectral Wounds damage is temporary (~40%) and if you don't finish off the target in 10 seconds

PA is good for drawing aggro but isn't that useful in defeating mobs due to the illusionary damage they do, similar effect to Spectral Wounds.

Spectral Terror is a good way to lock down a group and Phantasm is obviously your primary controller pet that can do a heck of a lot more damage than you but has a tendency to attack when standing next to you.

Flash isn't all that useful IMO. An AoE sleep mez with very low starting accuracy (you need a +3 SO in Acc just to get it up to the base for SW and Blind).
Flash is actually a hold, but you are correct that it isn't very useful.


H: Blaster 50, Defender 50, Tank 50, Scrapper 50, Controller 50, PB 50, WS 50
V: Brute 50, Corruptor 50, MM 50, Dominator 50, Stalker 50, AW 50, AS 50
Top 4: Controller, Brute, Scrapper, Corruptor
Bottom 4: (Peacebringer) way below everything else, Mastermind, Dominator, Blaster
CoH in WQHD

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune Knight View Post
You're making the mistake of comparing powers in a vacuum. Don't do that. Sets are balanced as a whole, not on a power-by-power basis.

One of my first Heroes (and my oldest remaining) was an Illusion/Storm Controller. The endurance is fairly heavy, but it's definitely managable (and I did this with only SOs! no IOs back then). Hilariously enough, it violated your rule of needing 1/2 SOs worth of endurance reducation (I slotted 2 acc, and then either went 3 damage 1 recharge, or 2/2 split), and Ill/Storm is hardly an... endurance fiendly powerset combo. Oh, and I ran SI pretty much 24/7
my first hero was an ill/storm and it was awful end wise lol, about 2 years after i got the toon to 50 i rerolled it into the ill cold i have today


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Father Xmas View Post
Same here.

T, maybe you're playing it wrong. It's a controller, they don't do a lot of damage, it takes a while to defeat. That's the AT. Controllers are agonizingly slow if you've been playing with scrappers, brutes and blasters.

As for the powerset, don't shortchange Deceive, it's the key power for Illusion, make your enemy your pet. You only really have to damage powers and they are slow to recharge. On top of that some of Spectral Wounds damage is temporary (~40%) and if you don't finish off the target in 10 seconds

PA is good for drawing aggro but isn't that useful in defeating mobs due to the illusionary damage they do, similar effect to Spectral Wounds.

Spectral Terror is a good way to lock down a group and Phantasm is obviously your primary controller pet that can do a heck of a lot more damage than you but has a tendency to attack when standing next to you.

Flash isn't all that useful IMO. An AoE sleep mez with very low starting accuracy (you need a +3 SO in Acc just to get it up to the base for SW and Blind).
Father X-mas -- you may be the guru on hardware, but I disagree with you on several of your points on Illusion.

An Illusion controller is one of the better damage controllers . . . assuming you know how to take advantage of the mechanics. That Illusory damage you mention allows Illusion to do lots of damage, as long as you can do it quickly before the heal-back. This is why I worked out the strategy of killing Minions FIRST, then Lieutenants and then Bosses.

The usual practice for many characters, especially melee fighters, is to take on the Boss first since he is the most dangerous to you and will do the most damage to you. But Illusion can distract the Boss with PA or Deceive. That's the key, and why PA are the REAL key power for Illusion. PA pull the attention of foes while you pick them off one by one. If you cast PA into a group, random chance (and a little positioning) determines if the PA will attack Minions, Lieutenants or Bosses. When you use your attacks on Minions first, you can usually wipe them out in one or two attack chains (depending upon your level and your build). If one of the PA were going after that Minion, then you wipe him out faster AND get to keep that Illusory damage from PA and your Spectral Wounds before the heal-back.

As you wipe out the Minions and then the Lieutenants with your Blind-SW-vet attacks, or later Blind-SW-APP Blast-SW attack chain, the PA will then concentrate on the Bosses, keeping the bosses distracted. Then you can use your attack chain on the bosses. PA's damage combined with yours can really add up, especially since the Illusory damage done in the last few seconds won't heal back if the foe is defeated.

Ultimately, PA do a substantial amount of damage (shown by Herostats). And you can increase that damage by using the strategy I described because then you keep more of the Illusory damage.

Deceive, while one of the better powers, is not the KEY power in Illusion. Phantom Army is. While Deceive can be skipped in a build (you would be missing out on a great control power), anyone who skips Phantom Army has a gimped build. That would be like skipping Seeds of Confusion on a Plant controller or Static Field on an Electric Controller.

Flash can be a decent control power and is more useful that you suggest. 2 Accuracy (SOs or better) is enough while leveling up (standard slotting is 2 Acc, 2 Hold, 2 Rech). After Flash can be fully slotted with at least SOs, Flash makes a good control filler for when PA are recharging. Run in while invisible, hit Flash, and then attack -- and add Spectral Terror only if you can't wipe them out before Flash expires. Then in upper levels, Flash lets you set AoE Containment for an AoE damage power from your APP set. It is skippable, but can be very useful.


LOCAL MAN! The most famous hero of all. There are more newspaper stories about me than anyone else. "Local Man wins Medal of Honor." "Local Man opens Animal Shelter." "Local Man Charged with..." (Um, forget about that one.)
Guide Links: Earth/Rad Guide, Illusion/Rad Guide, Electric Control

 

Posted

(Edit: I don't have IO access. I'm limited to SOs, as are most players other than VIP or those willing to pay for a "psuedo-subscription" now. So perma-PA is a myth for me and them.)
First, this isn't just a change "for my own selfish wants". This is a change to the design of this game that NEEDS to happen for everyone to have more fun and have the options given to us actually be "options".

How many times have you ever actually had to decide "should I add another accuracy or should I add a hold duration to Total Focus?" ?
That "choice" never comes up because you either need accuracy or you don't. The same situation happens with endurance reduction. You slot as much as you need and then you "use the leftovers" for actual enhancement choices.


And you can't tell em that you find it possible to play with only the base single slot in every power. Try that sometime, even just below level 12 when it is guaranteed to be the way you play.

City of Heroes is the only game I know of that makes attacks and other abilities unsustainable and weaker than necessary unless you "make choices" to add to them.


This game is supposed to be about "which power do I want to make better?" and not "which power do I want to make 'not horrible' while leaving the others worthless?" as it actually plays.









Also Kitsune,

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune Knight View Post
You're making the mistake of comparing powers in a vacuum. Don't do that. Sets are balanced as a whole, not on a power-by-power basis.
That is the problem. You CAN'T design powers as a set that way because it will break the powers individually, especially when paired with pool powers.
Imagine if Power Boost was allowed to function with toggles for the full "always on" duration of a toggle, or imagine if any other power combination purposefully nerfed was allowed to work again because they balanced as a set rather than individually. It would be a broken mess.

And anyway, I'm not even comparing different sets. I'm talking about the performance, as a whole, of Illusion Control.



What am I supposed to do with Superior Invisibility?

....run to the end of a mission and "not defeat anybody" and somehow complete a mission that always requires defeating at least one group, especially on newspaper and radio missions that require clearing the end room for a blinky mission?
....not use it to avoid aggro from extra groups other than the one I am attacking because it would cost too much endurance to attack and use it?
....not use it at all because I have to escort an NPC that can't follow me stealthed, while others can, even though it would work "in the story" because I would be speaking "turn left", "keep following me or I'll kick your butt" and other directions even while stealthed that would let the NPC know I'm still there?
....use only Deceive(confuse) with it, because the endurance cost of using anything else with a 1 endurance per second toggle is much too high, until the last guy is dead(after a really long time because they miss each other so often and do so little damage to each other often) and then only get xp for the last guy which is a LOT LOT LOT slower than every other character gets xp?


Either they purposefully designed Illusion Control to be super slow and painful to use or they designed it to work ina game that is not City of Heroes's combat based gameplay.

When has this game ever rewarded "non-combat" gameplay and avoiding combat?
When has this game ever encouraged avoiding combat?
When has every ambush in the entire game not seen through stealth and followed players everywhere in the mission?




They need to admit that they made mistakes, like they did with PVP originally and with the most recent changes, and make an effort to improve things.

The first thing they can do is make accuracy and endurance reduction less necessary so we don't waste at least 1/3 of our slots on just those.
The second thing is they should either make non-combat gameplay or make every power set viable in combat.

Those are not suggestions. They are necessary to the design of this game since it is already combat based.




FYI:

1) I don't use flash. It sucks.
1a) Flash can and does miss often, requiring more accuracy than normal powers and leaving me wide open for far too long.
1b) Flash has such a long recharge that it can't even be made close to "half up-time". That means it is absolutely useless as an "everyday use" power.

I don't need panic buttons because I should not be panicking. Seriously, do we panic every few minutes in real life? Do we see a need for 911 every 4 minutes, or even every 4 hours?
No, we avoid the situations where we would tend to panic or need emergency help.

2) Flash sucks compared to its Peacebringer cousin Pulsar that is actually made correctly and a lot better.



3) I don't care if you insult me or laugh at what I post or whatever.

I have given this enough thought, along the lines of "what would make this game more fun?", "how can they change the powers to keep what they do and what the archetypes are meant to do the same while making them as fun and viable as they need to be?" and "where does paper beat scissors seemingly inexplicably all too often?".

I came to the conclusion that melee archetypes have it much too good(coming from someone who loves playing brutes, and Fortunatas, for that reason).
1) They get much higher defenses and resistance and health and regen(which is proportional to health).
2) They get practically unbreakable mez protection on top of #1, not just "mag 3 protection" or some other basic number like the NPCs get. They regularly get 10-16 mag protection to everything that matters and then some.
(Honestly, mez protection powers should cost a full 1 endurance per second, at least, because they're 10 times as valuable as any other toggle.)
3) Melee powers, especially on melee archetypes, get great damage. Scrappers get often enough critical hits for double damage. Brutes get Fury for consistent up to 200% damage boost. Stalkers get guaranteed criticals at least periodically. Every other character that uses melee powers gets high numbers for them(and blasters get the ability to use some attacks while mezzed, unique among squishies).


You know what everybody forgets about ranged and support characters?
1) They can't attack or use support powers while mezzed, and every offensive toggle turns off(and waits for the annoyingly long recharge).
2) Their support powers affect everyone but them as much or more than they affect the support character.

You have melee archetypes that can solo things the support and ranged characters need a team for. They just become godly with a team while support and ranged characters finally become "normal" while teamed.
(Yes, you can't tell me that a support or ranged character becomes better than a melee character with the same buffs. They have a lot more to start with and then you just stack buffs on top. Support and ranged characters are just catching up finally when on teams, and they still need mez protection to do so.)


So, either melee characters need a sever nerf, with a small buff to ranged and support characters, or ranged and support characters need a huge buff, which could mostly be done with the enhancement necessity changes I posted here that would affect everyone equally.





Tell me?
How do you judge a character's strength in this game?

Is it how fast they go through enemies?
Is it how much "reward per time" they get?

Is it how safe they are stealthed and using only confuse when they could be just as safe by sitting in Ouroboros hiding from the world and never playing the game while getting about the same "reward per time" rate?

The latter doesn't sound very fun being forced into. It certainly is not what most people view as "fun" and "awesome performance".
At best, stealth and confuse is a "novelty", outside of PVP, because it is fun to say "stop hitting yourself" a few times until you have done it 1 million times and would actually like to feel like a "superhero" or "supervillain" for once.





You know what would solve the problem? I do:

Make confuse grant full xp to the player for any enemy the confused enemy defeats. They kill each other slower than the players do(aside from Illusion Control and other rare situations) so they wouldn't get more xp. It would just be more cautious.


If you don't want to do that then you should find a way to actually make "avoiding combat" rewarding and more fun, without making it annoyingly more complex and risky.(I HATE ambushes that see through stealth, especially on the missions they just keep coming and too fast. It just breaks all immersion and "suspension of disbelief" and throws the character concept of stealth out the window. Rikti Drones and other such enemies also do that.)
If you are going to have stealth then you need to make it work as advertised(no aggro, even from other enemies in the same group as your target), or you need to remove most of the other "sacrifices" you baked into the powers the stealthed player is using because they are just "adding insult to injury" at that point.






Edit:
FYI, nerfing melee archetypes wouldn't even make them unplayable. At worst, it would encourage them to team, thus giving support and ranged characters the help they need for those annoyingly difficult ambushes, mezzing bosses and Elite Boss/Archvillain/Hero enemies.
Something is seriously wrong when melee archetypes can commonly and easily solo Elite Bosses and, all too often, Giant Monsters while ranged and support characters need "the best build with the best power sets" to even get close.
I had an old Willpower/Super Strength Tanker that I almost soloed Babbage with just SOs. I could keep Babbage at or below 50% health, after getting him there myself, but I just could not bring him below 5% for some reason. Maybe I just got tired after 5 minutes and had to renew my focus.
I haven't yet tried to solo Babbage on a Willpower Brute with SOs, but I bet I could finish him of then.


Edit 2:
I do use Deceive, but I don't get xp if I don't use the other powers. I also get less xp per unit of time than other characters even when I use confuse, unless I skip to the end of the mission(if possible) and do the absolute minimum(feeling real "super" about "running and hiding" rather than "having my way with enemies that can't see me").

Spectral Terror comes too late int he set to be very useful when it is needed most, at lower levels with fewer enhancements. It also aggros everything and sends one enemy at a time running out of the AoE fear to snap out of it and take pot-shots from range. It just makes stealth useless.
Illusion needs an actual AoE immobilize or something to keep the enemy in range of Spectral Terror, but it doesn't have that.
Sure, you can use confuse on the guy who ran out, but it's still painfully slow and requires a lot of attention and endurance to defeat as fast as you can as well. Other characters don't have that much trouble or at least defeat foes much faster, earning faster rewards.

And that only works if the enemies are susceptible to fear and no enemy has a leadership power.

As for Phantasm, he is too stupid right now to be of much use. He just pushes enemies out of Spectral Terror's fear AoE and gets killed. He also comes much too late to help the poor low level or exemplared performance.
(I absolutely hate exemplaring for Ouroboros arcs because I need to get help before starting them if I need help. I lose most of my effectiveness as well and all the SOs degrade to less than what they should be individually at the level I am exemplared to. Essentially, I end up needing more accuracy SOs while exemplared than I needed when actually at that level.)


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Local_Man View Post
An Illusion controller is one of the better damage controllers . . . assuming you know how to take advantage of the mechanics. That Illusory damage you mention allows Illusion to do lots of damage, as long as you can do it quickly before the heal-back. This is why I worked out the strategy of killing Minions FIRST, then Lieutenants and then Bosses.
There are a few problems with that.

1) You don't have many slots at lower levels when this is most important. That makes Spectral Wounds weak. Even a minion needs Blind, Spectral Wounds and one more application of Spectral Wounds at least to be defeated. That sucks.
It may have started out where I could use Blind and then SW and the enemy would be dead, but it did not last long.

2) They have annoyingly long recharge. Most other sets at least have a faster 4 second recharge power first. Those sets also aren't as risky because they mez or do more damage outright.

3) Bosses are a pain to mez. They require 2 applications usually, unless they have mez protection(hate those Destroyer Big Dog bosses downgraded to lieutenants).
Because they aren't mezzed right away, they are my first target or I'll die. Or, I could let the minions miss and hit for piddly damage for 5 minutes to take down the boss while I die of boredom.
That isn't fun, nor is it as easy as you seem to be saying.

4) I'm still going to slot at least 2 accuracy in everything because missed powers are annoying and huge problems when you miss the mez that would keep you alive.
Deceive doesn't last that long at low levels(because endurance cost and recharge don't scale with level but duration sure does, sadly) so you can barely keep 3 enemies confused early on. If you miss then you're under attack if you used any other power on any other enemy in the group.
Then, there are the groups of 4 linked enemies, which happens often in Praetoria and later levels of other places.

5) Other characters can increase difficulty. Illusion Controllers, at least with SOs and at lower levels, can't.
That is one reason they take out bosses first. They can, and minions are not a threat to them.




I actually think that they designed the game as a whole(and NPCs especially) from a combat-based and balanced perspective and then they designed melee archetypes after the NPCs and the ranged and support characters were an afterthought that seem to have been designed for a "non-combat-based" perspective. The ranged and support just fail at the game compared to melee because "they were designed for the wrong style of game".

I really do think this game needs a relatively drastic change.
The competing games aren't afraid to change even the oldest and most basic stuff up in order to make it better.
New games aren't afraid to do something better from the start rather than copying this old system that obviously has a lot of faults but still apparently "works well enough to sell".

Sometimes you really do need to break out of the stubborn rut you're in. The developers of this game definitely need to rethink "Jack Emmert's design" and make the game better than it was 7 years ago, rather than just making newer sets a little better and trying not to change "the sacred cow".


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by T_Immortalus View Post
First, this isn't just a change "for my own selfish wants". This is a change to the design of this game that NEEDS to happen for everyone to have more fun and have the options given to us actually be "options".
Really, everyone? Even people who have Ill/X controllers and are perfectly happy with them?

Quote:
What am I supposed to do with Superior Invisibility?

....run to the end of a mission and "not defeat anybody" and somehow complete a mission that always requires defeating at least one group, especially on newspaper and radio missions that require clearing the end room for a blinky mission?
Well, you can use SI to get to that room, then use Phantom Army to defeat that single group or room, so sure, that seems like a viable use of the power.

In addition, the way some Day Jobs reward you based on mission completion means that if you can complete more missions in a given period of time, you get a bigger benefit from the Day Job, so using SI to churn through more missions lets you take better advantage of those Day Job benefits.

Quote:
....not use it to avoid aggro from extra groups other than the one I am attacking because it would cost too much endurance to attack and use it?
Not sure why you'd be getting aggro from extra groups anyway, so not sure how SI is preventing you from aggro-ing those groups. And again, if you've got groups that are really close together, you can PA to draw them all together and weaken them first, or Confuse them to weaken them down to the point where you can handle them.

Quote:
....not use it at all because I have to escort an NPC that can't follow me stealthed, while others can, even though it would work "in the story" because I would be speaking "turn left", "keep following me or I'll kick your butt" and other directions even while stealthed that would let the NPC know I'm still there?
There you have a reasonable argument, in that if you stealthed in to get an NPC and then realized you had to escort them back out, you've still got to fight all the mobs between the NPC and the exit anyway, but at that point you're switching to combat mode, where SI is admittedly not the best option.

Quote:
....use only Deceive(confuse) with it, because the endurance cost of using anything else with a 1 endurance per second toggle is much too high, until the last guy is dead(after a really long time because they miss each other so often and do so little damage to each other often) and then only get xp for the last guy which is a LOT LOT LOT slower than every other character gets xp?
Well...see your next statement.

Quote:
Either they purposefully designed Illusion Control to be super slow and painful to use or they designed it to work ina game that is not City of Heroes's combat based gameplay.
I think they designed SI (and specifically SI + Confuse) for a City of Heroes in which XP debt is a much bigger factor, which it was in the early days. On a different character, a tougher-than-expected mission that resulted in a couple of defeats would put you in a serious XP deficit, and being able to SI/Confuse the toughest groups to avoid being defeated was a classic example of 'short-term loss for long-term gain'; you took less XP for that mission up-front to avoid the XP penalty for being defeated, which left you to the good on the whole.

These days, with XP debt less significant than it was (even if you manage to take on significant XP debt, given that Patrol XP cancels debt, there's an XP debt cap), there's less of a reason to use alternate tactics to finish missions that allows you to avoid XP debt.

In addition, there are players who do enjoy creating 'concept' characters and playing them according to their own concept of the character, regardless of whether or not that's the most efficient way of doing so. That the CoX devs allow builds that encourage that kind of play is, in my mind, a credit, not a reason to bash them for not being combat-oriented enough.

Quote:
The first thing they can do is make accuracy and endurance reduction less necessary so we don't waste at least 1/3 of our slots on just those.
That sounds like a personal problem -- there's already plenty of ways to improve your accuracy that have nothing to do with slotting accuracy enhancements:

- Use inspirations. Not only do they drop regularly, but you can combine three of any inspiration to make an Insight inspiration to up your accuracy if you want to.
- Use auxiliary powers. The Leadership tree includes Tactics, which is a to-hit buff for both you and any allies (including your Illusion pets). Hard for me to imagine any Illusion controller not at least considering Leadership for that alone.
- Lower your difficulty level. There's nothing in the design of the game that says you're supposed to be able to solo to level 50 with all combat level-shifted +2 and with all end-bosses set to be arch-villains. If you're not hitting often enough at the difficulty level you're playing at, lower it. And if you're at level-1 and still not hitting often enough, then you've got more problems than the devs can fix.

I'm not even getting into Strikebreaker.

Quote:
I came to the conclusion that melee archetypes have it much too good(coming from someone who loves playing brutes, and Fortunatas, for that reason).
If that's what you enjoy playing, then why not play more of those and leave the Illusion controllers to those of us who enjoy playing them? Why does every powerset and archetype have to play exactly the same way in order for the game to be 'fun'?

Quote:
If you don't want to do that then you should find a way to actually make "avoiding combat" rewarding and more fun, without making it annoyingly more complex and risky.
Here's the thing -- some of us LIKE complex and risky missions. I'm glad the devs give us options to create characters that challenge us the way we want to be challenged. If you want to play an Illusion controller that just flat out show up and solos Babbage, then why not just play a brute or some other archetype that does that? Why do you feel the need to make every archetype and powerset into exactly the same experience?

In my mind, having an Illusion Controller that plays differently from a Superstrength Brute is a feature, not a bug.

--
Pauper


 

Posted

Here is the heart of the problem with the numbers of this game:

Certain numbers are binary(on or off, good enough or not good enough) while others have gradations(slow, faster, fastest).

Accuracy is binary.
You either have enough accuracy to hit every time(or at least as often as possible) or you don't. So, players enhance to a "minimum amount" of accuracy for every situation they would get into.

Endurance is binary.
as long as you have enough endurance to keep everything you need/want active and activate powers then you don't need to worry. Players just enhance endurance reduction and modification as much as they need to be sustainable then ignore it.

Recharge is both binary and has gradations.
You don't need recharge most of the time. You just use some to make things faster. Sure, some powers encourage slotting to the ED cap to make them "perma", but it's not necessary and sometimes not possible even then. You can have "good enough" but it's also rarely "not good enough".

Damage has gradations.
Powers are all designed to do a basic amount of damage, if they do damage at all. They'll defeat enemies if you can survive long enough to do so. More damage just means "faster".



Essentially, there is no choice whether you enhance for accuracy and endurance or not. You either have enough or you don't.
That's not a choice and not fun. It just takes away from other choices that actually are choices.

Choosing whether to enhance for damage or recharge or mez duration or resistance debuff are all choices and vary wildly. There are reasons for each one that make them at least as valuable as any other choice.
It's the same choice somebody makes when they choose either a defense based armor power set or a resistance based set. They each have advantages and disadvantages.



There is only disadvantage to accuracy and endurance. You either have enough or the disadvantage of not having enough.
And, you still have to find a way to slot the actual "choices" of enhancements.





Now, if they wanted to make accuracy and endurance gradient choices they could change how they work.

Accuracy could be changed from "hit or miss" to "how much of the damage hits", like 75% accuracy would mean the attack hits for 75% damage.
That avoids that annoying "MISS" with a PbAoE in the face of the enemy while making it much easier to balance.

Endurance could be changed to work in a similar metering way to recharge. In the same way that weaker powers have such a short recharge as to be negligible, weaker powers that are used often could have no endurance cost so that they could be used at all times.
That would eliminate the issue of "no endurance = dead" for both players and NPCs. They could still fight for their lives even if they use a big endurance crash nuke.
The stronger powers would drain endurance still, making slotting for endurance reduction still worthwhile, while making the crashing nuke powers more commonly used.

As for toggles, the ones that affect only the user, and do not detoggle when mezzed, should probably be made auto powers for 3 reasons.
1) They're always on anyway, especially for melee archetypes with mez protection.
2) It would reduce the "particle effects overload" of the game as well as network lag somewhat. It's one less thing to track. The graphical effects could all be rolled into the remaining toggle powers such as aggro toggles, as customization options possibly, s players can keep them if they choose.
3) It would make aggro toggles easier to pick out and check to see if they are still active, without looking at the power trays.


I think there are a lot of changes for this game that would only improve it, and some, like the idea of changing "beneficial self only toggles" to auto powers, are long overdue.
Both of the above ideas actually work out well for the competing superhero games, making their combat fun and never "I'm held so I'm dead".







I truly just want CoH to be the best it can be.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pauper View Post
In my mind, having an Illusion Controller that plays differently from a Superstrength Brute is a feature, not a bug.
You misunderstood me.

I was not asking for it to "play the same". I was asking for it to be "just as fast and fun", or at least "just as good on endurance".


Why do melee archetypes get so many awesome toggles that provide HUGE number boosts, especially mez protection, that only cost them 0.26 endurance per second each or less?
Superior Invisibility is almost 5 times as expensive as Energy Cloak(from energy Aura), or the stealth from Dark Armor, but only has, effectively, double the stealth(anything above 65ft is wasted because anything that can see you farther likely sees completely through light years of stealth) with a little less, or the same, defense. Energy Cloak also does not suppress unless clicking a glowy, just like Superior Invisibility.

That's just not right.

Oh, it is an apt comparison since characters that have Energy Aura get higher damage on top of less worry about endurance, while it is also a secondary which still has to work with an offensive primary. What does Illusion Control get in exchange for not being able to do squat to gain XP while SI is on?



Edit:
Maybe the problem with Illusion Control is that it has a power normally found in a secondary set, stealth in SI, in a primary set of attacks that also need to use a lot of endurance for balance reasons. Maybe they forgot that Superior Invisibility is as essential to Illusion Control as Hide is to Stalkers, so therefore it should have a much lower endurance cost like Hide has a lower endurance cost(though Hide has no endurance cost).
Superior Invisibility already has the same disadvantage as all stealth powers as well. The stealth is gone if you attack any enemy in a group, for that group anyway. The endurance cost seems to have been made so huge to make it like Phase Shift or Quantum Flight or any other "turn this on only for panic situations and then it must turn off soon" powers. It's like Superior Invisibility was never intended to even be used with Deceive, let alone any other powers.

They seem to have forgotten how they designed aggro to work in this game when they set the endurance cost of SI.

Edit 2:
Phantom Army lasts only one minute, and doesn't come until level 20.
It has a recharge of 4 minutes. That gets down to 2 minutes with 3 SOs.

I only have access to SOs, as do most people as only SOs are guaranteed for free and every set needs to be balanced and playable for even free players.

Therefore, Phantom Army is not very useful for a whole room, especially the larger rooms like the layer-cake cave, unless I want to take it much slower than I already need to.


Edit 3:
Inspirations do not drop reliably enough to count on, unless you happen to be defeating enemies(without confuse) very fast which Illusion Control can't do easily if at all.
Also they drop into the tray in a certain order that ends up really messed up to use unless you click them with the mouse. They require organization which takes time and is annoying.

Also, my brutes and tankers and even my rad/time corruptor, and especially my masterminds, do not need inspirations. I don't use them then.
The fact that Illusion Control "needs them" is a bad thing. It proves the design is flawed.

Leadership toggles use more endurance, not what I need.



I'M TALKING ABOUT LOWEST DIFFICULTY!!!

Maybe you should realize that endurance costs SUCK even at the lowest difficulty and player level because they do not scale with level.


Honestly, the way enhancements work is completely stupid. They should just let us buy SOs at level 5 and delete TOs and DOs because we need SO level enhancement at low levels even more than we do at mid levels when we finally get them.




As for "streakbreaker", it's complicated but it fails if you use a power with a lower chance to hit than the previous power(according to Arcanaville's post on it) and only affects the 3rd power of every 3 miss streak.
It's about 33% accuracy, or one hit out of every 3, at best. If you are counting on that then your character is already face down on the ground.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pauper View Post
Really, everyone? Even people who have Ill/X controllers and are perfectly happy with them?
"for everyone TO HAVE MORE FUN"

Meaning = "more fun will be had by everyone, even if they already have fun".


You = "I like to take one word out of a sentence and completely change the meaning of it to suit my point."


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pauper View Post
If that's what you enjoy playing, then why not play more of those and leave the Illusion controllers to those of us who enjoy playing them? Why does every powerset and archetype have to play exactly the same way in order for the game to be 'fun'?



Here's the thing -- some of us LIKE complex and risky missions.
1) You can choose your risky and complex missions if you want. I'm talking about RISKY AND COMPLEX CHARACTERS where there is no choice. It's always risky and complex for them because the way they play is not tied to a mission; it is tied to their very soul.

2) I WANT TO LIKE ILLUSION CONTROL AND OTHER NON-MELEE SETS!

I like brutes because they are strong, not because they are the most interesting to play or have the coolest looking powers because they aren't and don't.

The coolest looking power to me is Propel, with Phantasm and Spectral Terror a close second and Superior Invisibility third and Time's Juncture fourth...etc.
The coolest concept set is Time Manipulation, followed by a tie between Illusion and Gravity.
The most power is not from those sets. In fact, those sets are weaker than other controller sets even. Gravity just got a buff, but Illusion still needs a buff ASAP.





I play what I like best out of the characters that I can actually tolerate.
I barely tolerate Illusion Control because the endurance cost sucks and the expected method of play is SOOOO SLOOOOWWWW(to level and get rewards and even finish single missions even when stealthing them if the mission doesn't make it hard to stealth like with Rikti Drones and ambushes).

So, don't say "play what you want" when my answer is "I gladly would if it wasn't so frustratingly poorly designed".


 

Posted

As for a response to the Original Poster: I would love to see the endurance cost of Superior Invisibility reduced, but it is not nearly as bad as you describe.

First, comparing SI to Steamy Mist, Arctic Mist or Shadowfall isn't really a proper comparison. Those powers provide half-stealth instead of full stealth. They work great from a short distance away, but you can't /e dance right in the face of most foes the way you can with SI or GI. To reach the stealth cap with those powers, you need more stealth, like Super Speed or a Stealth IO in a travel power or Sprint. When you combine the endurance cost of both Steamy Mist and Super Speed, the endurance cost is nearly that of SI -- SI is 1.04 per second, Steamy Mist+Super Speed is 0.975 per second.

You really shouldn't fight with SI running until you have higher levels of Recovery. The defense is cut in half and the endurance cost doesn't merit the small benefit you get. SI works great to give you a chance to Deceive a foe or two, and then throw out PA or an AoE control. Then drop out of SI to do your attacks. If your secondary has some kind of endurance or Recovery buff (like Rad's AM or Cold's Heat Loss), it makes running SI easier. But with some proper management, the endurance situation can be managed without having to slot 2 EndRdx in each attack. Just turn it off once you have used your first attack or control that disrupts the invisibility.


LOCAL MAN! The most famous hero of all. There are more newspaper stories about me than anyone else. "Local Man wins Medal of Honor." "Local Man opens Animal Shelter." "Local Man Charged with..." (Um, forget about that one.)
Guide Links: Earth/Rad Guide, Illusion/Rad Guide, Electric Control

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Local_Man View Post
As for a response to the Original Poster: I would love to see the endurance cost of Superior Invisibility reduced, but it is not nearly as bad as you describe.

First, comparing SI to Steamy Mist, Arctic Mist or Shadowfall isn't really a proper comparison. Those powers provide half-stealth instead of full stealth. They work great from a short distance away, but you can't /e dance right in the face of most foes the way you can with SI or GI. To reach the stealth cap with those powers, you need more stealth, like Super Speed or a Stealth IO in a travel power or Sprint. When you combine the endurance cost of both Steamy Mist and Super Speed, the endurance cost is nearly that of SI -- SI is 1.04 per second, Steamy Mist+Super Speed is 0.975 per second.

You really shouldn't fight with SI running until you have higher levels of Recovery. The defense is cut in half and the endurance cost doesn't merit the small benefit you get. SI works great to give you a chance to Deceive a foe or two, and then throw out PA or an AoE control. Then drop out of SI to do your attacks. If your secondary has some kind of endurance or Recovery buff (like Rad's AM or Cold's Heat Loss), it makes running SI easier. But with some proper management, the endurance situation can be managed without having to slot 2 EndRdx in each attack. Just turn it off once you have used your first attack or control that disrupts the invisibility.
1) I 3 slot Stamina with DOs and SOs ASAP.

2) It's endurance cost should be manageable from the very first level it is available. If you can't use it "at some times" then it either needs to not be available at those times or needs to be changed to be manageable.

3) Stealth over 65ft doesn't matter because anything that can see farther likely sees you at all times. Therefore, comparing it to Shadow Fall and Steamy Mist is apt since it only gets, effectively, double the stealth and doesn't get most of the other benefits, let alone the AoE usage.
Also, it is very apt to compare SI to Stealth and Energy Cloak, which both behave very similarly with "half the stealth" and about the same defense benefit with one-third to one-quarter the endurance usage.
Super Speed and a stealth IO is even cheaper on endurance for the exact same benefit, and others. Super Speed plus Stealth is the same at 2/3rds the cost of SI.




If I'm not supposed to use Superior Invisibility in combat then why don't they just make it an "only affect self" power?
If I'm not supposed to use it then take it away or make it completely undesirable in most situations, like Afterburner with the "only affect self" stipulation and high endurance cost on top of Fly's high endurance cost.

When was the last time Illusion Control ever saw any changes even?
I bet it's time that it was changed, just like Gravity was well past due for a change.



Edit:
What is the point of half of the defense of SI dropping in combat, but retaining half, if it is not meant to be used in combat?
If we're just meant to use it to avoid aggro and run from aggro then the defense should be high all the time.
What is the point of the stealth not suppressing in combat if it is not meant to be used when you have aggro? Obviously, it won't do any good against anything that sees you unprovoked, so it must be for in combat use.

How are we supposed to use any other toggles while SI is active? Combine SI with Fly and you have 2 endurance per second down. That's more than default endurance recovery which is only 1.67. SI plus Time's Juncture is bad enough at about 1.56 per second endurance usage.
How did anybody use SI at all before inherent Stamina? This is rhetorical. They either didn't use it or used it sparingly until SOs and Stamina at level 20.

They really don't want Illusion Control users using much of their primary, let alone any of their secondary, when using SI, do they?


 

Posted

Other then the Aura stealths, which as said before arn't full stealth, people don't run with them on all the time. I can say that for my dark armor characters that SI is far better on end. And SI is for stealthing what about that do you not get. Either stealth to a boss you have to kill, avoid aggroing till your ready, or like I did a travel power. Mine is Illusion/Kinetics and as soon as I got SI I could travel without being seen and could stealth TF/SF before anyone else. You get SI at a low lvl so it makes me think it was to help you with how back in the day it was dangerous to get from point A to point B. Many people would take hover just so they were safe low level and take forever to get where they needed to be. Illusion is a old set of course it could get some refinement but complaining about a set that is really easy on end use. Summon pets then do what you want till you need to summon them again. Oh for reference I started playing the game with the release of City of Villians. The game has gotten way way way easier since then and endurance management was a big thing you were supposed to have to deal with.

PS:SI is the best stealth power out there and it is by far better then all the other self stealths endurance wise.

And why do you like to spam post after post after post in a row?


 

Posted

SI isn't that great when you consider how stealth works in this game. It suffers because of the "200ft stealth" when it really only needs 65ft because that is how it works in almost every situation.


I post multiple times, rather than making a LOT more edits, because I think of other things to post. It keeps things a bit easier to read and makes it less easy to miss things I would have edited in.



Edit:
I, for one, keep powers like the Dark Armor stealth on, same as Energy Cloak and Stealth, if I have the endurance simply because they add defense in addition to making it easier to start combat on my terms.
Superior Invisibility is even more likely to stay on for combat because of the fact that it does not suppress the stealth. I can avoid additional aggro from close groups and ambushes without "heat-seeking noses".


 

Posted

Here's why I believe SI is as expensive as it is:

1) It is CHEAPER than pool power invisibility and BETTER.

2) SI hides you from virtually every mob in the game including snipers. The only things it can't hide you from are things that ignore stealth entirely... which consists of 3 types of mobs: Rularru Watchers, Rikti Drones and Knives of Artemis (who are going extinct it seems thanks to the talons of vengeance).

3) SI let's you get close enough without aggro to any of the mobs who ignore stealth to Deceive them and walk right past them. Deceived mobs do not alert those who cannot see you.

4) You can turn it off. In fact the prohibitive cost indicates you are likely intended to do so. It's not intended to be a "turn on and leave on forever" toggle. If there happens to be a nearby mob tough it out and pop a blue for that one and leave on SI if you have to or simply adjust your position so as not to aggro them.

There's really nothing wrong with the cost. What is wrong is how you seem to want to use it. SI + Deceive when dealing with those 3 mob types lets you bypass ANYTHING. There is NOTHING you can't bypass through use of those two powers. Stealth won't hide you in cramped quarters where you can't help but get close to mobs. At least not without stacking either an IO or super speed. Stacking those two powers would cost you .79 end per sec unenhanced and won't hide you from snipers.

Ultimately you're acting like a monkey crying that his hand is stuck in a jar by a fistful of cookies. The answer to any end issues you may be having is to simply turn off SI once you engage your foes. It's what I did before IO's were a twinkle in the devs eyes.

If all else fails you can still either spring for VIP or an invention license to use IO's and build for recovery. Unlike you my ill/rad can run SI all the time without endurance issues even when running ALL her other toggles (enervating field, radiation infection, hover, temporary invulnerability, combat jumping) Though to be fair I DO turn off SI when I hit EM Pulse because my recovery stops for a lil bit and I am still running my debuff toggles.


Jem - Ill/Rad Controller Lv 50+3 Nic - Mind/Psi Dominator Lv 50+3 Lady Liberation - Invuln/SS Tanker Lv 50+1 Invicitx - Demon/Pain Mastermind Lv 50+1 Celeste - Emp/Arch Defender Lv 50+1 Nightsilver - DB/WP Scrapper Lv 34 Dusk Howl - StJ/Regen Brute Lv 32 Kyriani - Time/Energy Defender Lv 41Psifire - FF/Psi Defender Lv 50
Star Lighter - LB/LA Peacebringer Lv 30

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Father Xmas View Post
Flash isn't all that useful IMO. An AoE sleep mez with very low starting accuracy (you need a +3 SO in Acc just to get it up to the base for SW and Blind).
Quote:
Originally Posted by newchemicals View Post
Flash is actually a hold, but you are correct that it isn't very useful.
Well, it starts off shabby, but you can make it worth taking and using. You just want to get accuracy, hold duration and recharge up to ED limits. And yes, you can do that without IO's. My illusion controller doesn't have IO's since they didn't exist until long after he was 50. He uses HO's.


Quote:
Originally Posted by T_Immortalus View Post
What am I supposed to do with Superior Invisibility?
Use it situationally. If someone came in here and complained that they kept running out of END because they kept Flight on during battles, we'd tell them to shut it off when they don't need it.

Quote:
Either they purposefully designed Illusion Control to be super slow and painful to use or they designed it to work ina game that is not City of Heroes's combat based gameplay.
Entertain the notion that "you're doing it wrong". I solo a lot with my illusion controller and he is not at all "painful" to play. And, per my previous comments, he uses SO's and HO's. If he had IO's, he'd be even more epic.

Quote:
When has this game ever rewarded "non-combat" gameplay and avoiding combat?
Pretty much forever. Stealthing missions is extremely efficient, due to the end of mission bonus.

Quote:
They need to admit that they made mistakes, like they did with PVP originally and with the most recent changes, and make an effort to improve things.
True, but illusion control is not one of those places. It's not broken.

Quote:
The first thing they can do is make accuracy and endurance reduction less necessary so we don't waste at least 1/3 of our slots on just those.
Then we would have to have less slots.

Quote:
The second thing is they should either make non-combat gameplay or make every power set viable in combat.
It's already like that. No change required.

Quote:
Those are not suggestions. They are necessary to the design of this game since it is already combat based.
They ARE suggestions, and they are bad ones. They would be detrimental to the game.


Paragon City Search And Rescue
The Mentor Project