How would the worlds media real handle Superheroes


Anti_Proton

 

Posted

The US Government is not the Evil Empire you see in the X-Men movies. Superheroes would not be dragged off to containment centers for vivisection, dissection, or any other brutal surgeries.

Why? Because it's an incredibly public figure doing an incredibly public service. Sure you can make Joe Schmoe, cornerstore deli owner vanish without -too- much trouble. But do me a favor and disappear Paris Hilton. The backlash of her disappearance and societal upset would be pretty harsh. And if the conspiracy theorists were right, and they would be, there's a -chance- that the action would be traceable back to the government. One "Daily Show" book-push later and the Government's got a huge issue.

Ultimately it would be in the Government's best interest to handle the situation -delicately-. Not only for the PR/backlash from the populace. But the last thing anyone wants is to create a super-villain. For the most part I imagine the government would handle costumed crimefighters like it would handle war heroes. So long as they're not -too- destructive and actually save people, rather than endangering them.

At least some portion of the government would want to quantify the superheroes, of course. And you'd wind up with a Hero Registration act on the floor of congress. Who knows if it would actually -pass- or not. But it would be there.

But no. They would not capture, contain, quarantine, study, and vivisect or dissect a superhero. Supervillain? Plausible. Vigilante? Possible but not Probable.

-Rachel-


 

Posted

No organization, not even the US Government, is monolithic.

Within any government there are various agencies working at cross purposes. There would be some people trying to capture and analyze super powered beings...these people would get ahold of any villains that were captured.

Within the same governments, there would also be agencies working for the welfare of the super beings they saw as useful or helpful; trying to hinder press releases of sensitive information, honest attempts to give them resources and data, etc.

The tide of public opinion will rise and fall, but the fact is that there would eventually be a scenario similar to Marvel's Civil War. After a large, unignorable disaster, there would be a movement to identify and register heroes, and force them to work as government agents. Some heroes would comply, others would go underground and become vigilantes, hunted alongside the villains they protect us from.

Eventually, the vigilance against the vigilantes would subside, the vigilante heroes would become 'cool' again...until the next big disaster.

As Doctor Manhattan put it, "nothing ever ends."

However, as to the OP; the media would handle them like they handle everything else: with one hand reaching for unbiased journalism, and the other reaching for money.

Every powered being or spandex wearer would have to deal with Paparazzi; the villains would not be able to kill enough to get the others to back off. The heroes and villains' responses to the press would vary like stars today; some would break down under the pressure (young RDJ or Drew Barrymore) while others thrived (current RDJ and Drew Barrymore).

One factor is that powers or no, anyone who puts on a spandex suit (unless it's a ninja outfit) wants to be seen (even a reluctant Hancock). Some heroes would try to operate underground 'in plain clothes' if their powers supported that, but by and large, all kinds of people who wanted their 15 minutes of fame would be putting on the colorful spandex, powers or not. Kevlar prices would skyrocket.

The real fun would be when various agencies would be staging events for the press to create a 'brand' for their hero, much as celebrities perform publicity stunts today. "Hey, homeless guy. I'll buy you a bottle to put on this suit and rant over on that corner about conquering the world. A guy in red spandex will knock you down, try to make it look good, but don't actually fight back. Don't worry, we won't press charges."

What I wonder is whether superheroes would eventually hit a longtime equilibrium of acceptance, as anime seems to have, or would it continually rise and fall, like the 'waves' of superhero movies we get?


Story Arcs I created:

Every Rose: (#17702) Villainous vs Legacy Chain. Forget Arachnos, join the CoT!

Cosplay Madness!: (#3643) Neutral vs Custom Foes. Heroes at a pop culture convention!

Kiss Hello Goodbye: (#156389) Heroic vs Custom Foes. Film Noir/Hardboiled detective adventure!

 

Posted

detainment and experimentation.... investigative reporting.


 

Posted

The Marvel Civil war thing was a bunch of BS.

The Stanford incident? The only big players on the enemy team, required power suits, they attacked before said villains could suit up. The guy who exploded, he'd never shown that much power before, hell he's only infamous for accidentally giving a super hero cancer.

In turn, the government passes a law, a law that they'd already passed during the 'everyone hates mutants' days, passed and had thrown out for being unconstitutional.

Never mind putting a known drug addled madman in a position of power.


Brawling Cactus from a distant planet.

 

Posted

Yes, the execution of the Civil War story was horrible. However, the concept was sound.


Story Arcs I created:

Every Rose: (#17702) Villainous vs Legacy Chain. Forget Arachnos, join the CoT!

Cosplay Madness!: (#3643) Neutral vs Custom Foes. Heroes at a pop culture convention!

Kiss Hello Goodbye: (#156389) Heroic vs Custom Foes. Film Noir/Hardboiled detective adventure!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune9tails View Post
Yes, the execution of the Civil War story was horrible. However, the concept was sound.

The concept was what City of Heroes has.

"You want to fight crime, you need to register with the government."

However then it became, you need to register your real life details.

Which was bad, given how many secret organizations have infiltrated the government in Marvel, not counting the aliens that do so too.

Then it became, you have to register if you have super powers.

At this point it became illegal by Marvels own cannon. They did this with mutants, the law was thrown out because it was un-constitutional.

Then it became, if you have powers, the government owns you.


Brawling Cactus from a distant planet.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Risko_Vinsheen View Post
Superman (still fail to see how he could hide his identity with just a pair of glasses).
It's not just glasses, but posture/demeanor as well. Plus, he's on record as needing Lois's help to open jars of peanut butter.

Quote:
Originally Posted by EnigmaBlack View Post
lol you used "Privacy" and "Government" in the same sentence
No, the issue is "register with the government" and privacy. Things registered with the government tend to be accessible via public info requests. At least here in the US.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
The government in real life protects the privacy/identity of some CIA agents - so it'd do the same for superpowered agents too.
But such agents wouldn't be "registered" they would be recruited. You wouldn't find them on any lists, due to things like "plausible deniability," etc.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scarlet Shocker View Post
In the Marvel Universe, most people believe Spider-Man is a villain because of the press power of J. Jonah Jameson, and in a real world situation most right thinking people would be appalled if a masked vigilante took to the streets and acted as de facto judge, jury and executioner.
Do they? I get the feeling most people seem to regard JJ as a sensationalist/a person in a love/hate relationship with Spider-man.

And most heroes in don't go the Judge Dread path, so that would help them as well.


Orc&Pie No.53230 There is an orc, and somehow, he got a pie. And you are hungry.
www.repeat-offenders.net

Negaduck: I see you found the crumb. I knew you'd never notice the huge flag.

 

Posted

i think the world of professional sports would want to know which of the linebackers are juggernauts, which swimmmers are aquamans and which boxers are ironfists...

everone would need dna testing for the meta gene.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by RiOTWRAiTH View Post
i think the world of professional sports would want to know which of the linebackers are juggernauts, which swimmmers are aquamans and which boxers are ironfists...

everone would need dna testing for the meta gene.
I forget where I saw this, but super-beings who wanted to play sports had to do so in their own leagues, as they had extremely unfair advantages over normal athletes. Imagine running-backs in the NFL with super-speed, an invulnerable boxer, an NBA player who can freeze time, et al. It would make normal professional athletes look like amateurs. Very few people without powers can compete with those who possess super-powers, and even then, it has to be technology that closes that gap......or be a very well trained martial artist on the level of Shang Chi.


http://www.seventhsanctum.com/index-anim.php
Can't come up with a name? Click the link!

 

Posted

This is even before you get to what the internet would do to you. I am NOT having:

- Perez Hilton sniping at my costume sense or revealing if I'd had a couple of shots after work
- People setting up TwitFaceSpaceBook accounts in my name, trashtalking other heroes and hinting at saucy antics
- ANYONE photoshopping my head onto Power Girl's "leaked" sex tape stills


Is it time for the dance of joy yet?

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kitsune9tails View Post
Every powered being or spandex wearer would have to deal with Paparazzi; the villains would not be able to kill enough to get the others to back off.
EvilVillain: "And at last my superweapon is complete, and not even you can stop me, Noblehero! With the press of a single button, I shall kill every paparazzi on Earth! MWAHAHAHAHAhahahaha...ha? Why...why are you just standing there?"

NobleHero: "Well, c'mon, press the damned button already!"


Arc #40529 : The Furies of the Earth

 

Posted

I'm surprised no one has linked to this site yet.

Check it out, there's some cool stuff in there that might answer some of your questions.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Westley View Post
I'm surprised no one has linked to this site yet.

Check it out, there's some cool stuff in there that might answer some of your questions.
I like the name of this one, linked from that site:

Superheroes Anonymous

"Hello, my name's Jason Todd and I'm a recovering superhero."


 

Posted

Supreme Power by Marvel in 2003 would probably be a good starting point for our governments reaction to supers.

Indoctrination and manipulation as long as they are useful and compliant, (attempted) extermination when they stop being useful and compliant.


My Deviant Art Page

 

Posted

You may disagree with me, but with all the crap someone would have to go through, whether with a secret identity or not. If they had super Powers, I actually think there would end up being many more super Villains then Super Heroes.

After so much crap, a Hero might eventually give up, or turn to some other path. With great power, comes great responsibility and all that jazz. One to many times though, it's been shown that once a single individual gains so much power, it tends to go to their heads.

So I think Villains would outnumber the Heroes at the least.


"He who controls the Past commands the Future, he who commands the Future conquers the Past."

 

Posted

Pawn Shop Owner: So, Skull-Crusher McEvilton, what brings you into my shop today?
SCM: Got, um, like twenty digital cameras. Like new, only dropped once.
PSO: Been farming Tech Salvage. eh?


 

Posted

John Mayer might accidently reveal Jessica Simpsons' alter ego:
- Sexual Napalm.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by TSCM_Hudson View Post
You may disagree with me, but with all the crap someone would have to go through, whether with a secret identity or not. If they had super Powers, I actually think there would end up being many more super Villains then Super Heroes.

After so much crap, a Hero might eventually give up, or turn to some other path. With great power, comes great responsibility and all that jazz. One to many times though, it's been shown that once a single individual gains so much power, it tends to go to their heads.

So I think Villains would outnumber the Heroes at the least.
This is a very possible reality... Though it's not a matter of what a person with powers goes through so much as what a person goes through. People are more prone to the shortest route as opposed to the "Best" or most moral. If you asked someone the first thing they'd do if given the power of teleportation -many- would immediately discuss teleporting into banks or places of wealth, stealing something, and leave.

However, I like to imagine that people would take a higher or more noble road and, instead, live out their childhood power fantasies by becoming the hero. Perhaps I'm too much of an idealist!

-Rachel-


 

Posted

There was a PnP RPG game called Aberrant, that had this same question...

The world was amazed at the supers... and they trully became the focus of the world. The media was hungry for then, for any kind of scandals involving then. They pratically shaped many aspects of the world...

War was changed by the supers. Companies of super-beings were formed, everyone of then able to tackle any government.

Fashion was changed by the supers. What was cool was directly tied with then and their visual styles.

Entertainment was changed by the supers. Television, movies, art, sports... all with a "super" touch...

When I first created a toon, I remembered that game. And I started a minor thing on its honor... On the Aberrant games the supers were called "Novas"... So all my toons have Nova on their names...


** Guardian�s Crazy Catgirl **
************* 22 XxX 10 *************

Yes. I can get lost on a straight-line map.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by DreamWeaver View Post
- ANYONE photoshopping my head onto Power Girl's "leaked" sex tape stills
I'd pay money for that.

Suprised no one's brought up this?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by TSCM_Hudson View Post
You may disagree with me, but with all the crap someone would have to go through, whether with a secret identity or not. If they had super Powers, I actually think there would end up being many more super Villains then Super Heroes.

After so much crap, a Hero might eventually give up, or turn to some other path. With great power, comes great responsibility and all that jazz. One to many times though, it's been shown that once a single individual gains so much power, it tends to go to their heads.

So I think Villains would outnumber the Heroes at the least.
But wouldn't that be one of the main reasons governments would help out heroes, to make sure that they weren't put under so much stress that they'd snap?


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
She's way too classy to make one of those
That's what they all say.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by ObiWan View Post
That's what they all say.
There are a few superheores who might do something that dumb - but she isn't one of them


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
There are a few superheores who might do something that dumb - but she isn't one of them
Nice rack.