Go to Redside.


Another_Fan

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
What I'm actually saying is the burden of proof lies on solely... you.
No, your post said nothing about burden of proof. It said nothing constructive. It was a clear attempt to troll and restart a fight. I've already clearly stated several times I'm not interested in doing any sort of market research, so this post as well is nothing but an attempt to further drag out the discussion to see if you can't milk more drama out of it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
From what I've seen in this thread so far is that you're the only person who has presented anecdotal experience. I'm still waiting to see these overpriced circuit boards of yours.
Nothing about burden of proof there, just an outright lie that completely ignores several other people in the thread relying on anecdotal experience, including yourself.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
You do realize the sales history is not the actual going price, right? It's just idiots paying too much. Ten to one there are merchants still selling items at the same low prices they always are.
Anecdotal

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
Redside Market seems as fine as Blueside Market in my experience. Redside, I noticed, even manages to be slightly cheaper than Blueside.
Anecdotal

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
I probably spend a total of 10 to 15 minutes a week on the Black Market. There's nothing tricky about using it all and I can usually buy and sell things very easily on it.
Anecdotal

Interesting how you started out your presence in the thread by calling me a liar, then make a statement like that which is a clear lie by your own posts in the thread.

Or did I miss where your post actually brought something new to the thread? Cause I didn't see anything but just another troll post to throw fuel on the dieing fire.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post

Interesting how you started out your presence in the thread by calling me a liar, then make a statement like that which is a clear lie by your own posts in the thread.

Or did I miss where your post actually brought something new to the thread? Cause I didn't see anything but just another troll post to throw fuel on the dieing fire.
I wouldn't call you a liar. Just a misinformed hypocrite.

Wow, I can't believe this thread is still going on. Welcome to the darkside humility. You'll soon learn to farm tfs and sfs in under 15-30 minutes for merits. Once you accomplish that, it's just a matter of marketeering and using the profit to outfit your character with the IOs you want.

Congratulations, you're ebil. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ujzp9ffPwPM


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
I wouldn't call you a liar. Just a misinformed hypocrite.

Wow, I can't believe this thread is still going on. Welcome to the darkside humility. You'll soon learn to farm tfs and sfs in under 15-30 minutes for merits. Once you accomplish that, it's just a matter of marketeering and using the profit to outfit your character with the IOs you want.

Congratulations, you're ebil. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ujzp9ffPwPM
I would challenge the integrity of his posts in a heart beat, like how he said he placed a bunch of bids for random IO lvls several days ago , about 1 day after getting called on not having any hard evidence.

raises my eyebrows a lil' is all.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gearford View Post
I would challenge the integrity of his posts in a heart beat, like how he said he placed a bunch of bids for random IO lvls several days ago , about 1 day after getting called on not having any hard evidence.

raises my eyebrows a lil' is all.
I'm too lazy to challenge his integrity. If he is willing to learn and put forth the effort to farm merits and play the market instead of kvetching, he's good in my book. d;D

p.s. Ya, i'm an Asian Jewban.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
I wouldn't call you a liar. Just a misinformed hypocrite.
That was actually a direct response to someone else who assumes I'm not being truthful specifically regarding the damned circuit boards no one can seem to see past.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
Ah, then he's a liar.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
Wow, I can't believe this thread is still going on. Welcome to the darkside humility. You'll soon learn to farm tfs and sfs in under 15-30 minutes for merits. Once you accomplish that, it's just a matter of marketeering and using the profit to outfit your character with the IOs you want.

Congratulations, you're ebil. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ujzp9ffPwPM
I'm not actually interested in marketeering at all. As I have stated more than once, making money isn't tough at all. Heck, I've only been blueside a couple weeks and I've got somewhere around 150 mil liquid, another 20 in bids and another 50 in posted ios waiting to sell. That's based solely off of drops and ae tickets rolls I made while leveling and I still kept a bunch of choice bits for myself (regenerative tissue regen, steadfast res/def global etc) as well as buying a couple 5 piece Crushing Impacts (plus the beginnings of two more sets) and starting on some doctored wounds sets. Everything else in my build is frankenslotted or has basic common IO's (fast healing and the like get common IOs until the build has enough slots open to use them as a set mule or something) Making money, even without "playing the market" isn't difficult in the least, and I never tried to say it was. It's a matter of not having anything to spend it on when playing redside that is the issue here.

I would however really like some sweet sweet merit shiny toys like lotg 7.5s and the like. Because I like to put shiny things on my character.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gearford View Post
I would challenge the integrity of his posts in a heart beat, like how he said he placed a bunch of bids for random IO lvls several days ago , about 1 day after getting called on not having any hard evidence.

raises my eyebrows a lil' is all.
And I would challenge your integrity for being more interested in trolling the thread than adding something to it. I still didn't put forth any hard evidence, and don't intend to. See, everyone said something that disagreed with my personal experiences so I tested it. Not for them, not for you, not for proof... because I like the red ATs and play environment a bit better. I would prefer to play red, but have not found the market serviceable to do so. It really doesn't much matter if you or anyone else believes me, because I wasn't testing for you, I was testing for me.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
That was actually a direct response to someone else who assumes I'm not being truthful specifically regarding the damned circuit boards no one can seem to see past.





I'm not actually interested in marketeering at all. As I have stated more than once, making money isn't tough at all. Heck, I've only been blueside a couple weeks and I've got somewhere around 150 mil liquid, another 20 in bids and another 50 in posted ios waiting to sell. That's based solely off of drops and ae tickets rolls I made while leveling and I still kept a bunch of choice bits for myself (regenerative tissue regen, steadfast res/def global etc) as well as buying a couple 5 piece Crushing Impacts (plus the beginnings of two more sets) and starting on some doctored wounds sets. Everything else in my build is frankenslotted or has basic common IO's (fast healing and the like get common IOs until the build has enough slots open to use them as a set mule or something) Making money, even without "playing the market" isn't difficult in the least, and I never tried to say it was. It's a matter of not having anything to spend it on when playing redside that is the issue here.

I would however really like some sweet sweet merit shiny toys like lotg 7.5s and the like. Because I like to put shiny things on my character.



And I would challenge your integrity for being more interested in trolling the thread than adding something to it. I still didn't put forth any hard evidence, and don't intend to. See, everyone said something that disagreed with my personal experiences so I tested it. Not for them, not for you, not for proof... because I like the red ATs and play environment a bit better. I would prefer to play red, but have not found the market serviceable to do so. It really doesn't much matter if you or anyone else believes me, because I wasn't testing for you, I was testing for me.

I promise you..if you can manage a few tfs on redside, (200 merits isn't difficult to manage in a week) you can make twice to 3 times more on redside than on blueside by purchasing a lotg and selling it on the market. It takes VERY little effort..trust me, i'm REALLY, really, lazy.

With that cash you can

a) start outfitting your toon with IO sets or generic/common IOs. (Ask someone from your VG that has memorized the generic/common IO to craft it for you, you supply the difference and the salvage. NEVER purchase generic/common IOs from the market.)

b) Find a niche for a few crafted IOs and buy up the recipes and start crafting and selling (try not to supply more than how many are bidding, it keeps demand up. Never use whole numbers when posting prices, however post slightly lower than the going price.

I'm just asking you to try, take a bite..I promise you'll like it.


 

Posted

I've been watching this thread for a little while, and I have to ask this.

What makes people think that the villain market is fine? Really, I want to know. What is it about the villain side market that is fine? Prices? nope. Item availability?

I sure haven't seen it.

Real quick check on some items needed for a couple of toons


Numi + Regen. lvl 30 57 bids 5 for sale. Last sale 251 mil Red side
Numi + Regen. lvl 30 99 bids 3 for sale. Last sale 150 mil Blue side

LOTG 7.5 lvl 30 42 bids 0 for sale. Last sale 155 mil Red side
LOTG 7.5 lvl 30 38 bids 2 for sale. Last sale 101 mil Blue side

LOTG Def lvl 25 8 bids 0 for sale. Last sale 100 mil Red side
LOTG Def lvl 25 33 bids 2 for sale. Last sale 10 mil Blue side


Nucleolus 44 bids 4 for sale. Last sale 100 mil Red
Nucleoulus 1 bid 1 for sale. Last sale 45 mil Blue side.

Comparisons as of 2:00pm EST on 2-18-10

I see a discrepancy



"Sorry bucko, but CoH and CoV are the same game." -BackAlleyBrawler
"Silly villain, CoX is for Heroes!" -Saicho

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vega View Post
I've been watching this thread for a little while, and I have to ask this.

What makes people think that the villain market is fine? Really, I want to know. What is it about the villain side market that is fine? Prices? nope. Item availability?

I sure haven't seen it.

Real quick check on some items needed for a couple of toons


Numi + Regen. lvl 30 57 bids 5 for sale. Last sale 251 mil Red side
Numi + Regen. lvl 30 99 bids 3 for sale. Last sale 150 mil Blue side

LOTG 7.5 lvl 30 42 bids 0 for sale. Last sale 155 mil Red side
LOTG 7.5 lvl 30 38 bids 2 for sale. Last sale 101 mil Blue side

LOTG Def lvl 25 8 bids 0 for sale. Last sale 100 mil Red side
LOTG Def lvl 25 33 bids 2 for sale. Last sale 10 mil Blue side


Nucleolus 44 bids 4 for sale. Last sale 100 mil Red
Nucleoulus 1 bid 1 for sale. Last sale 45 mil Blue side.

Comparisons as of 2:00pm EST on 2-18-10

I see a discrepancy
So, what's wrong with the market?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
I promise you..if you can manage a few tfs on redside, (200 merits isn't difficult to manage in a week) you can make twice to 3 times more on redside than on blueside by purchasing a lotg and selling it on the market. It takes VERY little effort..trust me, i'm REALLY, really, lazy.

With that cash you can

a) start outfitting your toon with IO sets or generic/common IOs. (Ask someone from your VG that has memorized the generic/common IO to craft it for you, you supply the difference and the salvage. NEVER purchase generic/common IOs from the market.)

b) Find a niche for a few crafted IOs and buy up the recipes and start crafting and selling (try not to supply more than how many are bidding, it keeps demand up. Never use whole numbers when posting prices, however post slightly lower than the going price.

I'm just asking you to try, take a bite..I promise you'll like it.
Ok, perhaps I was unclear at some point... I have a 50 brute, 39, 37 and 32 masterminds and a few other vils of various levels. My brute is pretty much completely IO'd out (not purples or anything, but respectable sets and uniques) and the MM have at least common IO's for everything and I have something in the neighborhood of 500 mil in liquid and stored IOs. By no means an ebil marketeer but I'm not a pauper redside. Making the money isn't tough, finding useful things to do with it for a non 50 character is the issue. My redside characters were IO'd out two years ago before I left the game for a while, which is good because I wouldn't want to try to do it in the current market (I prefer 30-35 IOs for the flexibility of ex'ing down).

Making the money is not tough, the only people trying to say that are those who were trying to act like I was incompetent at the market without any information in that regard. In regards to your above points specifically, I never buy IO's period. Common or otherwise. Always, ALWAYS ALWAYS buy recipes and craft your own. As for posting yeah, slightly under the going rate is my approach. Something going for 20 I would probably post for 17-18 depending on what it is, posted as 18,000,777 or something similar so a bit of 18 won't get it and the lazy bid creeper will tack on another 500K-1mil or so usually. Making money is as easy as playing the game and not licking windows in your off time. My issue, stated again and again in this thread is one of supply. There simply is not access to fun shiny toys for leveling characters redside. This detracts enough from the play for me that I don't want to play red in that environment.

Can't wait for vigilante status from GR.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
So, what's wrong with the market?
What do you feel is right with it? This is really a curiosity question. I'm not looking for debate or to start fighting. I really want to know what it is that people feel is good about the red market.

For me, its nice that it is bare when I am trying to sell, but horrid when I am looking to buy. I'm cheap, and have a lot of toons that need stuff, so I hoarde enough that I have to visit the market rarely.



"Sorry bucko, but CoH and CoV are the same game." -BackAlleyBrawler
"Silly villain, CoX is for Heroes!" -Saicho

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
Ok, perhaps I was unclear at some point... I have a 50 brute, 39, 37 and 32 masterminds and a few other vils of various levels. My brute is pretty much completely IO'd out (not purples or anything, but respectable sets and uniques) and the MM have at least common IO's for everything and I have something in the neighborhood of 500 mil in liquid and stored IOs. By no means an ebil marketeer but I'm not a pauper redside. Making the money isn't tough, finding useful things to do with it for a non 50 character is the issue. My redside characters were IO'd out two years ago before I left the game for a while, which is good because I wouldn't want to try to do it in the current market (I prefer 30-35 IOs for the flexibility of ex'ing down).

Making the money is not tough, the only people trying to say that are those who were trying to act like I was incompetent at the market without any information in that regard. In regards to your above points specifically, I never buy IO's period. Common or otherwise. Always, ALWAYS ALWAYS buy recipes and craft your own. As for posting yeah, slightly under the going rate is my approach. Something going for 20 I would probably post for 17-18 depending on what it is, posted as 18,000,777 or something similar so a bit of 18 won't get it and the lazy bid creeper will tack on another 500K-1mil or so usually. Making money is as easy as playing the game and not licking windows in your off time. My issue, stated again and again in this thread is one of supply. There simply is not access to fun shiny toys for leveling characters redside. This detracts enough from the play for me that I don't want to play red in that environment.

Can't wait for vigilante status from GR.
I agree, supplies tend to be lower redside.

However, I don't see that as a market problem as much as I do a population problem.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vega View Post
What do you feel is right with it? This is really a curiosity question. I'm not looking for debate or to start fighting. I really want to know what it is that people feel is good about the red market.

For me, its nice that it is bare when I am trying to sell, but horrid when I am looking to buy. I'm cheap, and have a lot of toons that need stuff, so I hoarde enough that I have to visit the market rarely.
I don't see the point in comparing the two markets.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
I agree, supplies tend to be lower redside.

However, I don't see that as a market problem as much as I do a population problem.
The root cause is a population problem, but there is no question it creates a market problem.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
The root cause is a population problem, but there is no question it creates a market problem.
ehhh... You're getting into the gray. The markets state is a symptom of low population. I wouldn't call it a problem.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
ehhh... You're getting into the gray. The markets state is a symptom of low population. I wouldn't call it a problem.
Well, I already stated that population was the root cause of the market issue, which is functionally identical to saying the market issue is a symptom of population issues. As for it being a problem...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dictionary
–noun
1.
any question or matter involving doubt, uncertainty, or difficulty.
2.
a question proposed for solution or discussion.
3.
Mathematics. a statement requiring a solution, usually by means of a mathematical operation or geometric construction.
Clearly, lack of supply does cause difficulty. So in a technical sense it is without question, a problem. You may not consider it a problem, but clearly others do, and that only serves to drive more people away from red, further exacerbating the problem.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vega View Post
What do you feel is right with it? This is really a curiosity question. I'm not looking for debate or to start fighting. I really want to know what it is that people feel is good about the red market.
I've outfitted four of my toons on redside with IOs. Elec/Inv Brute, Widow, Necro/Dark MM, Axe/Shield Brute. I didn't have any problems getting the IOs I wanted. I didn't have to pay out the wazoo for them. I don't farm drops or play the market. I only did a bit of meriting to get some really expensive or in-demand ones like LotGs (which are just as bad blueside). So... I don't see anything wrong with it?

This is all subjective. And your mileage may vary. For me? Seems fine.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PRAF68_EU View Post
Dispari has more than enough credability, and certainly doesn't need to borrow any from you.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
Well, I already stated that population was the root cause of the market issue, which is functionally identical to saying the market issue is a symptom of population issues. As for it being a problem...


So in a technical sense it is without question, a problem.
No, in a technical sense it is still the symptom of the problem.

Quote:
You may not consider it a problem
I don't see it as a problem in the same context that you see it as a problem.. because it isn't.

I am willing to agree that you have a dissenting opinion if you can agree that your opinion is flawed.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
No, in a technical sense it is still the symptom of the problem.
My cold is the root cause of my sneeze. My sneeze is a symptom of my cold.
Low population is the root cause of the supply problems. Supply problems are a symptom of low population.

Functionally identical.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tokyo View Post
I don't see it as a problem in the same context that you see it as a problem.. because it isn't.

I am willing to agree that you have a dissenting opinion if you can agree that your opinion is flawed.
For this usage of the word, it is not possible for an opinion to be flawed, just different than your own. A nuance that seems lost on many posters.

Quote:
Originally Posted by gec72 View Post
I thought prevailing sentiment was that the BM was a problem -- and that's why there are constant calls to merge the BM and WW.
You would think that the regularity of such threads might be an indication of a problem. Apparently a topic so common it brings responses of groans and ridicule is pure coincidence and not an indicator that at least part of the player base seems to think there is a problem.

Of course... Scythus doesn't seem to believe that common salvage regularly hits prices of 150K which leads me to believe he doesn't actually use the market.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vega View Post
What do you feel is right with it? This is really a curiosity question. I'm not looking for debate or to start fighting. I really want to know what it is that people feel is good about the red market.

For me, its nice that it is bare when I am trying to sell, but horrid when I am looking to buy. I'm cheap, and have a lot of toons that need stuff, so I hoarde enough that I have to visit the market rarely.
How much are you hoarding? I usually have a couple of pieces of common salvage on hand for those times when they marketeers do drive prices up (on both sides of the good and evil fence). But if you are hoarding a LOT of stuff, that is contributing to the problem of supply redside. By all means, hang on to some stuff, but don't hoard it all.

I will join you if someone suggests that supply isn't lower redside for things like recipes. But I think most people will agree with that, even the ebil marketeers. Salvage, on the other hand, is much cheaper. I love that part of redside... I don't have to pay through the nose to make recipes, and I can actually have lowbies afford to make their own accuracy enhancements, as Luck Charms don't cost you an arm and a leg (which is what it feels like at low levels blueside).

I'm not a marketeer, either. I don't like taking risks. I tend to save up my merits to buy an expensive recipe and either use it or sell it, rather than rolling... even though I know I could make more money rolling (though my knowledge of how bad my luck is suggests otherwise). Tokyo's "buy a LOTG +recharge and sell it for cash" thing worked for my Stalker. I had maybe 1/3 of the enhancements I needed on him before doing the same thing, and I was able to buy the rest in a space of a few weeks afterwards... and I have a good chunk of the money left over, too.


Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc:
Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory

 

Posted

....?

Redside has concise, diverse stories and missions. Redside has archetypes with a wide range of roles and abilities. Redside has easy travel. Redside has a unique atmosphere.

...and people are complaining about it because of its market? C'mon. Firstly, villain archetypes don't need IO's to function well and be fun. As a rabid inventor, I know the bonus in performance those shinies bring. But with as many villain alts as I have, I can truthfully say they can be plenty fun on 'merely' SO's. Yes, the smaller supply makes it easier for 'flippers' to do their thing. So ignore them. Put up bids for what you think you'll want in advance, the niches fall over eventually. Play AE arcs, so when you need salvage NOW, you can grab some for tickets. Keep a few of everything in the vault/storage/BM slots.And the expensive stuff? Play, and when you find expensive things, sell it well and the profit can be traded for a desired expensive thing.

Seriously guys, the market is just a darned bad reason to avoid the redside. There are too many good stories and builds to enjoy to skirt all that content over your bid for that uber recipe taking forever to come in.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grey Pilgrim View Post
But if you are hoarding a LOT of stuff, that is contributing to the problem of supply redside. By all means, hang on to some stuff, but don't hoard it all.
Good point, but I think it requires players to exercise a degree of rational behavior infrequent in games and in real life. I also confess to being part of the problem. I look up what salvage I might need ahead of time and hoard the bejeezus out of it. Everyone else can have the leftovers when I'm done.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Seldom View Post
Firstly, villain archetypes don't need IO's to function well and be fun.
No AT requires IOs to be effective, at least by official statement. However, if players feel the redside market is borked and don't want to use it, that is a piece of the overall game that is missing and makes it less appealing. This may be exaggeration, but imagine if base building didn't work as well for one faction as it did for the other. I think that would be a disincentive for anyone interested in base building to play on that side of the fence.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
No, your post said nothing about burden of proof. It said nothing constructive.
I wrote...

Quote:
I'm still waiting to see these overpriced circuit boards of yours.
This is a request for evidence.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Scythus View Post
I wrote...



This is a request for evidence.

If you've never seen common salvage hit 150K, I don't believe that you regularly use the market.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Humility View Post
If you've never seen common salvage hit 150K, I don't believe that you regularly use the market.
I did say I'm only on it for about 15 minutes a week. I only buy what I need and sell what I don't. And you still owe us evidence since the majority of us are skeptical.