Help with Helping


Ad Astra

 

Posted

My girlfriend has become interested in the game and I'm trying to help her play and I don't seem to be doing a good job. We're waiting on the laptop I ordered (should be here in a week or so) and we can play together, but right now she is playing and I'm providing "backseat driver" help. I don't seem to be doing very good. I can't imagine I'm the first to do this (although anything's possible), any suggestions?


 

Posted

It's hard to say, without knowing more about what/how you're doing apart from "not good"

I think the key is, don't try to force her to play the way you do, but focus on helping her find out how she likes to play. Start with finding out her goals, or at least getting an idea of what she'd like to see/do. From there, help her by giving her tips, while avoiding specifically trying to control how she does things.

Praise success, and minimize failures. If she makes a mistake, sympathize. If it's the same mistake you made when you were starting, say so.

My girlfriend and I like to talk and plan out our pairs of characters. We remain flexible, and try to accomplish some of each of our goals in each play session. We pretty clearly line up how each pair is going to be played (strictly together, together except a few times, or together or apart whichever seems more fun). Level Pacts have made our game a lot more fun. We still have our own characters, but almost everything we make is pacted so we can share. We like leveling up apart so we can give each other "pressie levels" sometimes.

That's just some general advice. If you want to describe where you're running into difficulty I'll be back to this thread soon.


"Null is as much an argument "for removing the cottage rule" as the moon being round is for buying tennis shoes." -Memphis Bill

 

Posted

Good help and yes, I need to be more specific, but wanted to "test the waters" before I went into detail. Two immediate areas that I think are probelmatic are controls and understanding (God this feels like I'm talking to Dr Drew). First, huge problem is controls. Let me first say I've tried to say at least a billion times how bad I sucked (and maybe still suck, comparatively) with movement and "controlling" my char. However, my girlfriend has the prob of not wanting to use "both hands" (can't seem to avoid sex metaphors) when controlling her char. She moves using one hand and attacks using the same hand. I have also told her how I used to do the same thing and she needs to try to use both hands but doesn't seem to be working. I guess I need to be patient on this one. The understanding might be the tough one. I mean the understanding of the game. I've told her about the abundant resources for the game (online resources), but I think she'd rather rely on me for info. This one might be a suck it up and deal with it, which I'm prepared to do, just thought I'd throw it out there.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by vinque View Post
Good help and yes, I need to be more specific, but wanted to "test the waters" before I went into detail. Two immediate areas that I think are probelmatic are controls and understanding (God this feels like I'm talking to Dr Drew). First, huge problem is controls. Let me first say I've tried to say at least a billion times how bad I sucked (and maybe still suck, comparatively) with movement and "controlling" my char. However, my girlfriend has the prob of not wanting to use "both hands" (can't seem to avoid sex metaphors) when controlling her char. She moves using one hand and attacks using the same hand. I have also told her how I used to do the same thing and she needs to try to use both hands but doesn't seem to be working. I guess I need to be patient on this one. The understanding might be the tough one. I mean the understanding of the game. I've told her about the abundant resources for the game (online resources), but I think she'd rather rely on me for info. This one might be a suck it up and deal with it, which I'm prepared to do, just thought I'd throw it out there.
... I move using my left hand WASD and then attack with the same hand, 1,2,3, etc...

You gotta let her find what works for her. One of my kids loves WASD, my other one is set on the arrow keys to get around. They can both move, so it doesn't matter who is using what.

Understanding the game takes time and practice, that's all. You can't expect a beginner to absorb all the info in a week, even with the resources available. I'm still learning new things and I've been playing this game for years.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by vinque View Post
Good help and yes, I need to be more specific, but wanted to "test the waters" before I went into detail. Two immediate areas that I think are probelmatic are controls and understanding (God this feels like I'm talking to Dr Drew). First, huge problem is controls. Let me first say I've tried to say at least a billion times how bad I sucked (and maybe still suck, comparatively) with movement and "controlling" my char. However, my girlfriend has the prob of not wanting to use "both hands" (can't seem to avoid sex metaphors) when controlling her char. She moves using one hand and attacks using the same hand. I have also told her how I used to do the same thing and she needs to try to use both hands but doesn't seem to be working. I guess I need to be patient on this one. The understanding might be the tough one. I mean the understanding of the game. I've told her about the abundant resources for the game (online resources), but I think she'd rather rely on me for info. This one might be a suck it up and deal with it, which I'm prepared to do, just thought I'd throw it out there.
Seems like you're on the right track, and you've already had a number of good responses. As someone who (after months of careful trying to get her to play) now has a wife who plays more than I do, I'll say this:

Whatever you do, don't try to tell her how she should play or what she "needs to do". Instead, focus on making the play experience a fun one for her. Be there as a resource if she has a question, but keep it simple. Answer the question without going into unnecessary depth (unless she clearly wants you to, use your judgment).

Try to play something that will complement and support whatever character she makes. For instance, if she's playing a Blaster, you might play a Defender or Controller and run support. If she's playing a Stone tanker, you might consider playing Kinetics. And so on and so forth. Basically try to pick something that can support and empower whatever she's doing and give her center stage. Make new character to play with hers - this is more fun than playing with a high-level character, in my experience, because you're working together. I don't recommend dragging her along as an SK on higher level missions unless she brings up the idea.

Let her explore the game and find her own passions. You might like PvP and she might be more into badges. You might enjoy running characters quickly to 50 while she likes to fully explore contacts' arcs and is annoyed when she outlevels them. Don't assume your preferred way to play will be hers. Try to support whatever she's doing rather than trying to have her play your way. This isn't to say that you should completely abandon your own enjoyment (game needs to stay fun for you too), but let it take a backseat for now and maybe you'll find some points of intersection that you both enjoy a lot.

Also, don't try to plan her characters for her or tell her how to enhance, what powers to pick, etc. If she wants to pick Flurry, let her pick Flurry. Let her make her own mistakes and her own choices - more than likely some of the ones that you wouldn't have made may surprise you in how effective/fun they turn out to be.

My wife uses an entirely different interface from the way I like to play, from an inverted mouse to different movement keys to a completely different setup for her power trays, inspirations, etc. When she goes afk and I have to play her characters, I'm always baffled. But I wouldn't have it any other way.


With great power comes great RTFM -- Lady Sadako
Iscariot's Guide to the Tri-Form Warshade, version 2.1
I'm sorry that math > your paranoid delusions, but them's the breaks -- Nethergoat
P.E.R.C. Rep for Liberty server

 

Posted

As far as the movement keys go, show her the Keybind menu in the Options screen, and, if she's up to it, teach her how to use /bind. My girlfriend can't do the WASD thing, so she set up her keybinds, and as she found things she couldn't do in Options, I helped her set up binds and macros. Her setup is, IMO, insane... But it works for her.


@Roderick

 

Posted

Why does it matter that she uses the same hand to control movement and attacks? Is that "wrong"? It may be slower or feel amazingly awkward to you, Vinque, but if it's working for her, let it be. If she is finding it a problem, then use some of the suggestions offered by others here.

If she hasn't played an MMO before, there is actually a bit of a learning curve here - I know, because this was my first MMO 5 years ago. Stuff like "binds" is pretty exotic and it may be too soon to try those. I didn't know what a bind was when I first started playing and I still don't use them now.

But I found a way of moving that works for me, and a way of setting up my powers trays that works for me, and I always use the Arrow keys to move and click the power icons to attack, etc. It's probably a "noob" way to do it, but it was the easiest for me to "get". She will find the way that works best for her - let her experiment a bit until she gets the hang of of it.

You may just have to let go of your own ideas about the "best" or "most efficient" way to use controls, etc.

Help her find some other friends who are patient in answering questions in game, and she will turn to them in addition to you for all the other stuff you mentioned. At first she will probably be focussed on getting hang of the "how" of playing, but she might get more into the details over time (and then go check out the Wiki, etc.).

But some people will never try to use the on-line resources. It took me several months to find the forums and then a few more before I found the Wiki - but again, I was new to MMOs and never realized their purpose. I didn't know that these sources of info were way, way more helpful than any manual that came with the game or the in-game "help". Note: My Reg date here is actually about 6 months after starting to play.

If she doesn't want to use them and is never interested in the rich backstory and just wants to "flip out and kill stuff", that's a perfectly valid way of playing as well.

I guess my advice about helping is to back off a bit and give it time.


Altoholic - but a Blaster at Heart!

Originally Posted by SpyralPegacyon

"You gave us a world where we could fly. I can't thank you enough for that."

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by vinque View Post
Good help and yes, I need to be more specific, but wanted to "test the waters" before I went into detail. Two immediate areas that I think are probelmatic are controls and understanding (God this feels like I'm talking to Dr Drew). First, huge problem is controls. Let me first say I've tried to say at least a billion times how bad I sucked (and maybe still suck, comparatively) with movement and "controlling" my char. However, my girlfriend has the prob of not wanting to use "both hands" (can't seem to avoid sex metaphors) when controlling her char. She moves using one hand and attacks using the same hand. I have also told her how I used to do the same thing and she needs to try to use both hands but doesn't seem to be working. I guess I need to be patient on this one. The understanding might be the tough one. I mean the understanding of the game. I've told her about the abundant resources for the game (online resources), but I think she'd rather rely on me for info. This one might be a suck it up and deal with it, which I'm prepared to do, just thought I'd throw it out there.
I'm going to focus on understanding the game. The issues with movement can sort themselves out pretty easily. Just remind yourself that as long as she's having fun, it doesn't matter if she's as efficient as you are. Hand-eye coordination is a very personal thing. My girlfriend ends up being almost totally a 1 hand mostly mouse player, because for her and her cat, computer time= cuddle time (I wouldn't have it any other way).

As for info, you will end up much happier if you accept that she's going to rely on your for the info. She may not like looking things up just for a game, she may just want to do it to talk to you. However there are two things to remember:

1) Avoid lecturing (in tone if not intent)- it's really hard for me being the son of a teacher and also being familiar with almost every aspect of the game, but you have to have a careful eye for how much info is too much. Sometimes she'll want a simple answer, sometimes she'll want to understand more fully. If she asks something you don't know, look it up together.
2) Don't get frustrated repeating things- Under normal circumstances, I don't like repeating myself. However in terms of some things about the game, I've come to understand it's just better to get over that about myself. One main thing is how to get from one zone to another. I've had 4 years to get used to the layout and understand how the city and isles fit together. I have a mental map and strong spatial awareness. My girlfriend is very smart, but not when it comes to fantasy maps and the easiest way from one place to another. So I remember that and when we're on a team, or even just the two of us, I'll slip her a tell with a little reminder nudge about where's easiest ('you can go to our base' or 'Pocket D works for that')

The key is, remember she's your girlfriend, not just someone you play with. Like I said, my girlfriend is very smart, but it takes some effort on my part to be sure she knows that I don't for a second think that "not smart about the game" doesn't equate to "not smart period" I'd never think that, however I have to be aware that I can be a real punk if I'm not careful.

The game can be a huge source of fun as a couple. I played WoW for 6months because being there with my girlfriend made it fun. She plays CoH for some of the same reasons. It's not her favorite game, but we love spending time together, and this game lets us pick it up, put it down, and have fun without the stress of guilds and raids and endgame grind.

I wish you good luck in making this work out with your girlfriend. It's worth it.


"Null is as much an argument "for removing the cottage rule" as the moon being round is for buying tennis shoes." -Memphis Bill

 

Posted

One thing about movement - I personally move with WASD, using the mouse to aim the camera. I attack with the regular number keys, which is the same hand as the WASD keys, but it doesn't slow me down at all as I'm used to it. So basically ignore what she is doing on the kyboard unless she specifically asks for help with something on the keyboard.

The only thing I would ask/show her is about the Alt and Ctrl keys and how they act as shortcuts to the second and third main power tray.


Orc&Pie No.53230 There is an orc, and somehow, he got a pie. And you are hungry.
www.repeat-offenders.net

Negaduck: I see you found the crumb. I knew you'd never notice the huge flag.

 

Posted

The movement thing would be the least of my concerns as far as helping her goes. If it works for her, it's fine.

I'm a pure keyboard player, I only use the mouse when I'm forced to to click on someting or drop a patch power. Otherwise I set up my trays and use the number keys for my powers, with Alt+number for the second tray being the less used powers. I use the arrow keys for movement and my left thumb rests on the space bar, where it can easily hit the alt key for a tray 2 power. It works great for me, and I've been doing it so long now that it is instinctive.

My wife plays with WASD and the mouse, clicking the powers in her tray with the mouse as well. It seems awkward and clunky to me, but it is intuitive for her, so it's not even an issue. The only advantage my control style seems to have is in PvP, where reaction time matters, and since she doesn't PvP, it isn't a detriment to her.

Basically, be helpful, but keep your mouth shut as much as possible. Don't explain how every little thing works unless she asks. Be a resource instead of an instructor. There is a very high likelyhood she will not play the game the same as you, remember that SHE is playing and not you, Her way is the best way for her to play, not yours.

I sometimes forget that my wife is every bit as knowledgable about the game as I am, and put my foot in my mouth telling her something she already knew, or purposefully did differently. That ruins her enjoyment when she feels like I'm telling her how to play, and makes me feel like a jerk when I realize I'm being overbearing. Trust me, getting into an argument over a video game is about the dumbest thing ever, and it would behoove you to avoid it.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Dechs Kaison
See, it's gems like these that make me check Claws' post history every once in a while to make sure I haven't missed anything good lately.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by ClawsandEffect View Post
Be a resource instead of an instructor.

A thousand times, this. Basically what I was trying to say above, but more succinct.


With great power comes great RTFM -- Lady Sadako
Iscariot's Guide to the Tri-Form Warshade, version 2.1
I'm sorry that math > your paranoid delusions, but them's the breaks -- Nethergoat
P.E.R.C. Rep for Liberty server

 

Posted

I agree with the above posts. She'll figure out movement quickly enough, don't worry about it too much. I do have one specific bit of advice. If you're playing redside at all, suggest she roll up a stalker.

The second character I ever made (and first villain) was a stalker. I had no idea at all what I was doing, and her build eventually got so screwed up I chose to re-roll her rather than try and respec that rat's nest of bad choices, but having Hide, and being able to run around (and learn *how* to run around), take in the sights, listen to dialogue and just generally enjoy and learn the game without worrying about a bunch of purple-cons beating me into the ground because I ran around the wrong corner was a great experience.

That toon taught me more about the game than anything else. Things like "take Stamina" and "Council bases have jails" came later, and that's stuff she can figure out on her own, or get from you without it seeming like a lecture.


 

Posted

One rule: being right is not always the right thing. Different strokes for different folks, so some things are definitely not worth disagreeing on.


If you ignore rule 1, wear a helmet.


My Deviant Art page link-link

CoH/V Fan Videos

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by SunGryphon View Post
... I move using my left hand WASD and then attack with the same hand, 1,2,3, etc...
And I move using ESDF. I could never get comfortable moving with WASD because my index finger needs to be on the little bump on F to feel comfortable. And I never understood the advantage of being closer to the edge of the keyboard where there's less keys anyway.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PRAF68_EU View Post
Dispari has more than enough credability, and certainly doesn't need to borrow any from you.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dispari View Post
And I move using ESDF. I could never get comfortable moving with WASD because my index finger needs to be on the little bump on F to feel comfortable. And I never understood the advantage of being closer to the edge of the keyboard where there's less keys anyway.
The idea of using ESDF is really appealing to me but I'm not sure if I could do it. Old dog, new trick and all that.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by vinque View Post
My girlfriend has become interested in the game and I'm trying to help her play and I don't seem to be doing a good job. We're waiting on the laptop I ordered (should be here in a week or so) and we can play together, but right now she is playing and I'm providing "backseat driver" help. I don't seem to be doing very good. I can't imagine I'm the first to do this (although anything's possible), any suggestions?
Don't.

Backseat driving, I have come to learn, only annoys and angers spouses. It's better just to let them figure it out on their own, letting them know you'll be happy to help them with any questions they may have.

Trust me, it's better this way.


Quote:
Originally Posted by eltonio View Post
This is over the top mental slavery.

 

Posted

Lemur has mentioned a few things about us learning to play together and I will weigh in with some thoughts of my own as the learnee.

Lemur has done a great job of meeting me where I am at with the game. He's right, I don't love CoH, which pains him and for his sake I do really, really try. I just can't get around having more fun playing other games but that just doesn't work for US. I do, however, love playing with him.

Here are some things that worked for me and didn't.

Getting around CoH is still the thing that frustrates me most. No matter what key set-up I try it still feels clunky for me. I move with my mouse and fight with my right hand most of the time. I also invert the camera. I tried setting things up the way I played SWG years ago and I set my screen up as close as possible to how it would look in WoW. Once I realized this worked for me, Lemur helped me figure out keybinds to keep me from auto-running or flying when I used my mouse for prolonged travel. So, while people are telling you not to worry about how she uses the keyboard or mouse, having Lemur help me work it out was the single biggest obstacle we over came. Who wants to play when just trying to move makes them want to quit forever? The key is finding out how to help her move the way she wants to move. Fortunately, Lemur could remember the default set-up for SWG and was able to work with me there. I am not sure how much time he spent on the forums searching for a way to stop the auto-move that would happen when I used the mouse and he will likely never tell me.

A main difference between Lemur and I is this; I play for US, he plays because he loves CoH. I have fun when I play, don't get me wrong, there are things I like a lot. This means one important thing though when we play, quite often I am more interested in playing casually, chatting between fights, character hopping, changing plans when something interesting comes along or quitting completely to go snog on the couch. We both have to be flexible. Sometimes I have to go with the momentum we have and let him 'be in the game' and sometimes its just something for us to do together while I decompress to him about my horrible day at work. He is very good about taking a deep breath, pulling his head out of the game and putting me first. He also takes time to stop and compliment me on new costumes and character concepts and this is a great source of fun for us. As he said before, developing characters and ideas together is the glue that keeps ups playing together. As silly as it is, I am always proud to be out in gameland with him as his partner and I am happy when we are on two characters that obviously look good and play well together.

I will re-advice some things Lemur said. Make her feel smart, accomplished, let her know that she's the funnest person you know and let her know she's got the sexxiest character in Pocket D. Its hard to worry that Lemur could be having more fun with someone else or that he'd had better game partners in the past who were more into the game and better players. Those sorts of feelings can carry over outside of game time and bum out the relationship and that's the last thing you want to do. The game is expendable, your relationship is not.

Lemur's tells reminding me how to get places helps a lot, even when I grump at him "I know that." I am only interested in learning enough about the game to get through a play session with him. My "real" life is far too stressful, too busy, too full of responsibility and too interesting to make the game into work or effort. I like borrowing Lemur's brain to store game stuff in and I like that he's available to be my easy button. He's learned not to lecture me or to try and make it stick and I've learned to focus when its important to him.

Try and be what she wants more than what she needs when it comes to the game. If she wants you to slot all her builds so she doesn't have to think about it, do it, make her happy then oo and aah over how powerfull she is. You might also by her something big and shiny for her favorite character. You might also have to let her know how big and shiny it is.

Let her be in the spotlight sometimes. Lemur can pretty much solo everything. He never needs me. Its nice sometimes though when he lets me FEEL needed. When you play with her, don't run off to the next group until the last guy is down. It sucks to be left whacking away on one guy while your partner is off creaming a whole crunchy group alone. It also sucks to be half a map behind while your partner runs ahead and gets started on the action. (one tip Lemur gave me that helped with this is to have the map window open) I had to play around with a lot of travel powers until I found ones that worked for me. Superspeed is too fast, flying is slow...jumping was just right, in the beginning. I do fine with Superspeed now though.

I always forget to turn off my toggles when I first enter a mission and Lemur is good about NOT reminding me sometimes. I will figure it out for myself when I constantly have no endurance. He won't let me die from it though.

Lemur also helps us avoid maps or mobs that I hate as much as possible. Its a good use of his vast game knowledge and I appreciate it a lot.

I tried a lot of characters before something stuck and it happened to be a fire/fire dominator. I realized ranged characters were much easier for me than melee and compensated for some of the clunkiness I felt when trying to navigate.

On a side note, if she's not meeting people to play with, Lemur and I play on Pinnacle and would be happy to hang with her.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dispari View Post
And I move using ESDF. I could never get comfortable moving with WASD because my index finger needs to be on the little bump on F to feel comfortable. And I never understood the advantage of being closer to the edge of the keyboard where there's less keys anyway.
I use the arrow keys to move - letters are for emote binds


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

OP: Whenever someone new comes to the forums, I restrict myself to mentioning one thing they should know.

You might want to do the same... one unrequested piece of advice per night. It's amazing how much fun you can have even if you're not perfectly optimized and deeply knowledgeable about the game. Sometimes there are problems (my first character was a scrapper who didn't have mez protection till level 33 or so... my second was an En/Fire blaster. That's a terrible combination TODAY- imagine it when the tier 1 took twice as long to go off.) But sometimes there's really only RAR! and BOOM! and STAB! and WIN!

If there's RAR! and BOOM! and STAB! and LOSE! you might want to roll up a support character for duoing. Rad/Sonic defenders are justly famous.


Mini-guides: Force Field Defenders, Blasters, Market Self-Defense, Frankenslotting.

So you think you're a hero, huh.
@Boltcutter in game.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by vinque View Post
However, my girlfriend has the prob of not wanting to use both hands when controlling her char. She moves using one hand and attacks using the same hand. I have also told her how I used to do the same thing and she needs to try to use both hands but doesn't seem to be working.
Does it work? If so, it doesn't matter if she uses one hand, two, or her nose and feet. The game is set up so that you press a key to move. It doesn't care HOW you press the key, and neither should you.

I'm a professional trainer and have been for decades now. I find that when it comes to friends/significant others/family members, it's too easy to let your own bias gets in the way of the facts. There is often more than one way to get something done. Your game doesn't have audits, there are no regulations to follow, and you can't get sued based on how you move your character around. That gives you all the room in the world to get things done and not worry about how.

If she's not as efficient or as effective as she could be, it's not a big deal. Team up with others so she can see the differences. When she asks questions, then give her more tips to help out.

I'm a button clicker and my friend is a key presser. We both kick *** and no one cares how.

If she's having a good time, let her be. If you keep trying to correct her, you risk doing far more harm than good and risk both resentment and a disinterest in the game.


~Missi

http://tinyurl.com/yhy333s

Miss Informed in 2016! She can't be worse than all those other guys!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by StormyPinkness View Post
...too much good stuff to quote it all...

Great post! I know of a few couples that play on Pinn, as well, and others that are close friends, and playing in a group more concerned about each other and about having fun is a great thing to be a part of.


My Deviant Art page link-link

CoH/V Fan Videos

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MissInformed View Post
Does it work? If so, it doesn't matter if she uses one hand, two, or her nose and feet. The game is set up so that you press a key to move. It doesn't care HOW you press the key, and neither should you.
I actually play with one hand on homerow (left), and one hand on the mouse. The way I play, I can actually do everything I want using just my left hand. I don't need the mouse to move, jump, turn the camera, or use any powers. I keep all my powers comfortably on 1-6 and alt+1-6 for ease of use. The only time I have to stop to use the mouse is to hit a glowie or a door, and sometimes if I'm using a toon with Shield Charge or Lightning Rod.

Point being, I can play a whole mission with just one hand, and have done so for years. So I agree with MI; doesn't matter if she does it one way, as long as it works for her.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PRAF68_EU View Post
Dispari has more than enough credability, and certainly doesn't need to borrow any from you.