Buff Trick Arrows!


Adeon Hawkwood

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
No that's not what I am saying. I'd play with a TA as any AT. You have to take words and then not add assumptions to them. I dont have time to elaborate for those who like to pick an argument for the sake of getting their post counts up or whatever.

With all the negative attention to TA needed some postive things said. It's not as limited or as useless as people could be falsely concluding. Jumping to false conclusions is quite epidemic around here.
Well personal attacks aside for a moment. Thank you for finally becoming clear on the reason you decided to muck up this thread. I can understand wanting to say something nice about TA because it is a set that most people pass over. This thread however is just about juxtaposing the effect TA has against other defender sets. I wont reprise everything that has been said throughout this thread about how the debuffs of TA underperforming against the debuffs of other sets. The point being this thread is about constructive criticism on the set not about bashing the set and those who play it. I love my TA character. Would I like to be able to perform like some of the other defense sets? In survivability yes but I enjoy how TA plays and I can supplement IOs for some of my survivability.

As far as the conclusions made in this thread they have not been hastily decided upon playing the set for the first 10 levels. They come from comparing the real numbers in game of powers from all the defender sets. This includes the AT changes from Defender to Controller to Corruptor to Mastermind. Trickshooter and many others have put in a considerable amount of time on this.

Now, to come back and attack me by saying you don't have the time to elaborate on the very nature of whatever argument you are trying to make because I am here saying something trying to raise my post count is insane. Check my post count and join date it's defiantly not that. This only is made more apparent by your constant replies to everything that types in this thread. None of it even giving the slightest bit of thought to the actual content of the post.

So I will say this again. Please just walk away from the thread unless you have the time to make a decent post about the merits or shortcomings of TA.


Virtue
--Blazing Tiger-- 50 Invulrn/Fire Tank
<<Virtues Tankiest Kitty>>
Try my Arcs: #4892 and #112548
@Blazing Tiger and @Aqua Fox

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
With all the negative attention to TA needed some postive things said.
Wait... the only reason you're doing this whole rigmarole is because there are posters here saying an underperforming set is underperforming?



Wut?


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rush_Bolt View Post
Wait... the only reason you're doing this whole rigmarole is because there are posters here saying an underperforming set is underperforming?



Wut?
No one is saying that it is not currently underperforming but it's still a good defender set. I merely said what can be done with TA, it's good points. That is all. Points others have failed to mention in the past.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
No one is saying that it is not currently underperforming but it's still a good defender set. I merely said what can be done with TA, it's good points. That is all. Points others have failed to mention in the past.
Do these good points make it not underperform?


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rush_Bolt View Post
Do these good points make it not underperform?
The very fact that Oil Slick is currently broken just shows TA to underperform.

I worried about the negativity and the effects of. It might underperform but its not out.

Another point, a fixed OS means we can an all be quiet about it really because then there is nought much wrong.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
The very fact that Oil Slick is currently broken just shows TA to underperform.

I worried about the negativity and the effects of. It might underperform but its not out.

Another point, a fixed OS means we can an all be quiet about it really because then there is nought much wrong.
Is that a no?


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Just FYI, the point of this thread has never been "ta is teh sux".

The point of this thread was to point out that Trick Arrows falls behind all the other buff/debuff sets. It gets the job done, but choosing anything else would get the job done easier and faster.

Martial Arts is the same way when it comes to the Scrapper Primaries, but that doesn't make it impossible to defeat enemies when you pick that set.

Nobody cares whether TA is the "worst" set or not, there will always be someone at the bottom of the totem pole. Most of the people in this thread just want to make sure that the difference between TA's performance levels and the rest of the sets isn't as big a gap as it currently is. Don't confuse that with "bashing". TA can stay the "worst" set to pick as long as it's only "worst" by a smaller margin. Especially on the non-Defender ATs.


Trickshooter's Characters | @Trickshooter @Brightside

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silas View Post
I personally am a fan of the suggestion that Luminara, Rush_Bolt and Trickshooter would be jumping to conclusions about TA.
Did you mean 'wouldn't be'? Because folks like Luminara and Trickshooter have obviously played the set to death and aren't 'jumping to conclusions' about anything, IMO.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Trickshooter View Post
Just FYI, the point of this thread has never been "ta is teh sux".

The point of this thread was to point out that Trick Arrows falls behind all the other buff/debuff sets. It gets the job done, but choosing anything else would get the job done easier and faster.

Martial Arts is the same way when it comes to the Scrapper Primaries, but that doesn't make it impossible to defeat enemies when you pick that set.

Nobody cares whether TA is the "worst" set or not, there will always be someone at the bottom of the totem pole. Most of the people in this thread just want to make sure that the difference between TA's performance levels and the rest of the sets isn't as big a gap as it currently is. Don't confuse that with "bashing". TA can stay the "worst" set to pick as long as it's only "worst" by a smaller margin. Especially on the non-Defender ATs.
I'll actually disagree with you here on a couple of points. I think the standard whether a set is any good or not is clearly how it compares to other sets. By that standard, ta clearly is 'teh sux'. Sure you can play it and kill stuff, but that's not really the standard. Also, the assumption that Defenders have it worst I think is a wrong one - Corruptors are even worse. Don't forget, for some strange reason, Corruptors only get Defender damage on RoA, meaning that in general, TA/A Defenders actually do more damage than A/TA Corruptors.

You can play TA and have fun - it's powers are graphically excellent, and the idea behind the set is original and cool. The problem comes when you team with people and find yourself to be rather irrelevant.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MaxLongstreet View Post
Did you mean 'wouldn't be'? Because folks like Luminara and Trickshooter have obviously played the set to death and aren't 'jumping to conclusions' about anything, IMO.
Read a little closer.

Silas was being a bit facetious by saying he(?) was a fan of New Dawn's implication that Trick, Lumi and I were jumping to conclusions in our assessment of Trick Arrows.

Also, you just agreed with Trick in your second post there.


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rush_Bolt View Post
Read a little closer.

Silas was being a bit facetious by saying he(?) was a fan of New Dawn's implication that Trick, Lumi and I were jumping to conclusions in our assessment of Trick Arrows.

Also, you just agreed with Trick in your second post there.
I suspected Silas was being facetious, but I wasn't sure . I read Trick as saying that Defenders had it the worst, but maybe I misread it. And I actually don't think TA is all that bad for Controllers - I haven't played a TA Controller, but increased hold times make it not too bad, it would seem. Defenders, Corrs and MMs though - Uggh.

I think there's only one person here arguing that TA is basically fine...due to their secret tech that they can't tell us about


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silas View Post
I personally am a fan of the suggestion that Luminara, Rush_Bolt and Trickshooter would be jumping to conclusions about TA.

No one has accused them of jumping to conclusions about TA.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rush_Bolt View Post
Is that a no?

I used the word might because it is about perception. We all differ. With OS broke its underperformance is a given but I haven't said that it doesn't need tweaks yet. At the very start of the thread I was posting ideas for improvements too from my own perspective.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
I used the word might because it is about perception. We all differ. With OS broke its underperformance is a given but I haven't said that it doesn't need tweaks yet. At the very start of the thread I was posting ideas for improvements too from my own perspective.
So TA underperforms?


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rush_Bolt View Post
So TA underperforms?
Not for me.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
Not for me.
So you did not say:

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
I used the word might because it is about perception. We all differ. With OS broke its underperformance is a given but I haven't said that it doesn't need tweaks yet. At the very start of the thread I was posting ideas for improvements too from my own perspective.
?


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

From my perspective. It suffices. It does the job. I could play it and be happy with it. I could go on with their never being another change to it. However from other peoples perspectives I'd like to see fixes. I'd like to see tweaks thinking of a couple of areas with which would make the set perform better. Currently it doesn't perform as well as it should. Then by reading of peoples limitations and from seeing what limitations some people give themselves from looking at their builds I see additional areas where they won't be getting as much out of TA as they could be. However you trade one power for another and so one flexibility for another. Really they could fix one power and pretty much leave it at that. Then the set is pretty much performing as intended. It's common knowledge that it isn't performing as intended. It's still a good set to play and team with.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
From my perspective. It suffices. It does the job. I could play it and be happy with it. I could go on with their never being another change to it. However from other peoples perspectives I'd like to see fixes. I'd like to see tweaks thinking of a couple of areas with which would make the set perform better. Currently it doesn't perform as well as it should. Then by reading of peoples limitations and from seeing what limitations some people give themselves from looking at their builds I see additional areas where they won't be getting as much out of TA as they could be. However you trade one power for another and so one flexibility for another. Really they could fix one power and pretty much leave it at that. Then the set is pretty much performing as intended. It's common knowledge that it isn't performing as intended. It's still a good set to play and team with.
No one's saying it isn't a good set to play/team with.

I'm glad you agree it's underperforming though and should get tweaks which is the entire purpose of this thread.


Head of TRICK, the all Trick Arrow and Traps SG
Part of the
Repeat Offenders

Still waiting for his Official BackAlleyBrawler No-Prize

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
It's still a good set to play and team with.
No, it's not. My friends basically don't want to team with my TA Corruptor, because it slows their xp gain, since they split xp with me for MOBs defeated without getting any significant boost to MOBs defeated by the presence of my toon. My best friend plays a bots/traps mm - he refers to my TA toon as his 'third most effective pet'.

Go ahead, give some lame 'l2p' reply. It's funny though how no one complains when I play any of my other toons...


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by New Dawn View Post
Not for me.
Besides the fact that you should realize "not for me" does not necessarily represent the playerbase as a whole and you shouldn't be considering balance issues like this...

You also said that no team anywhere needs a Defender ever, and you'd be happy to run an STF with no support whatsoever. To that I point up to the above paragraph about "not everyone."

So a Defender who stands at the entrance and picks his nose in every mission still wouldn't be underperforming to you. Because it's impossible to underperform "not even necessary or needed at all in the first place." You're saying TA doesn't underperform, while at the same time saying nobody needs Defenders anyway. So their performance level is completely irrelevant in your argument. If you already play at a level where no degree of support whatsoever is EVER necessary, then the amount of support given by ANY character is completely irrelevant.

You saying it doesn't underperform means nothing, since your expected performance level is already zero. Unless the Defender ran around aggroing enemies while running Group Fly or something, no player according to you could ever underperform.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PRAF68_EU View Post
Dispari has more than enough credability, and certainly doesn't need to borrow any from you.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silas View Post
Silas Clarification Time:

Yes, I was being facetious.

Yes, I am a hombre

I agree that TA is decent, but underperforming relative to other sets.
Forgive my literal-mindedness. This game is easy enough to the point where you can play anything IMO, so my definition of 'le suk' isn't 'you'll die instantly when you play it'; it's more 'you'll suk compared to other sets'.


 

Posted

My views on the OP's suggestions:

Entangling Arrow: This power is just fine IMO. It's easily able to stack enough to immobilize some of the more annoying AV's (read ones that love to run). It's no web grenade, true. But then the sets with web grenade don't have a plethora of -run speed and -recharge powers either. By the way, don't all powers with redraw (aka weapon sets) tend to have a small acc mod boost?

Flash Arrow: Ok, this I could almost agree with. It's a rather meh power. It's unresistable -tohit is the only real reason to use it usually. And that's a small amount. Ideally I would rather the -acc get boosted and the -perception be removed.

Glue Arrow: Say what?! Are you looking at the enhanced values or unenhanced values? You did know this power use to have a 6 second recharge and either 45 second or 1 minute duration when initially on test right? And the devs (possibly correctly) decided that a self stacking -recharge was too strong. Mind you, I'd love to see it's -recharge boosted. I'm not seeing it happening though. By the way, what is the other -runspeed power in trick arrow that gives -90% to run speed? It's not Oil Slick, that gives -3.20 max run speed but no run speed penelty other then that. Glue does that, plus a base of -90% runspeed.

Ice Arrow: Yeah, I'd like the debuffs increased. I'm rather doubting it'll happen though.

Poison Gas Arrow: Say what?! Allow it's sleep effect to stack? And how pray tell are you going to do that? Why would you want it to do that? With a duration that's half the recharge rate, you have to be heavily slotting recharge to get this perma to begin with. You'd then have to have insane +recharge from other sources in order for it to be self stacking to begin with. But then if your doing that glue arrow doesn't need a stronger -recharge debuff. It's self stacking already.

Acid Arrow: I could aprove of the aoe increase. But why are you asking for a nerf to it's recharge? The devs have stated in the past that it and disruption arrow have lower -resist values because they can stack together. And I'm not sure, but I think acid arrow can self stack.

Disruption Arrow: Uhm, as far as I know it doesn't have a cap for how many foes it can affect at once. As for adding -acc to it, erm... probably not. See my suggestion for flash arrow instead. Enemies would either run out of the disruption arrow's effect radius quickly (thus lose the -tohit) or die extremely quickly (thus lose the -tohit).

Oil Slick Arrow: I don't seem to have the problems you do lighting this. There were problems in the past. It use to refuse to light when street sweeping or in outdoor missions. That hasn't been too much of an issue for a while. Mind you, I'd love the recharge timer to be reduced. That's doubtful to happen though.


"The danger is not that a particular class is unfit to govern. Every class is unfit to govern." Lord Acton

Madam Enigma's History

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Madam_Enigma View Post
My views on the OP's suggestions:

Entangling Arrow: This power is just fine IMO. It's easily able to stack enough to immobilize some of the more annoying AV's (read ones that love to run). It's no web grenade, true. But then the sets with web grenade don't have a plethora of -run speed and -recharge powers either. By the way, don't all powers with redraw (aka weapon sets) tend to have a small acc mod boost?

Flash Arrow: Ok, this I could almost agree with. It's a rather meh power. It's unresistable -tohit is the only real reason to use it usually. And that's a small amount. Ideally I would rather the -acc get boosted and the -perception be removed.

Glue Arrow: Say what?! Are you looking at the enhanced values or unenhanced values? You did know this power use to have a 6 second recharge and either 45 second or 1 minute duration when initially on test right? And the devs (possibly correctly) decided that a self stacking -recharge was too strong. Mind you, I'd love to see it's -recharge boosted. I'm not seeing it happening though. By the way, what is the other -runspeed power in trick arrow that gives -90% to run speed? It's not Oil Slick, that gives -3.20 max run speed but no run speed penelty other then that. Glue does that, plus a base of -90% runspeed.

Ice Arrow: Yeah, I'd like the debuffs increased. I'm rather doubting it'll happen though.

Poison Gas Arrow: Say what?! Allow it's sleep effect to stack? And how pray tell are you going to do that? Why would you want it to do that? With a duration that's half the recharge rate, you have to be heavily slotting recharge to get this perma to begin with. You'd then have to have insane +recharge from other sources in order for it to be self stacking to begin with. But then if your doing that glue arrow doesn't need a stronger -recharge debuff. It's self stacking already.

Acid Arrow: I could aprove of the aoe increase. But why are you asking for a nerf to it's recharge? The devs have stated in the past that it and disruption arrow have lower -resist values because they can stack together. And I'm not sure, but I think acid arrow can self stack.

Disruption Arrow: Uhm, as far as I know it doesn't have a cap for how many foes it can affect at once. As for adding -acc to it, erm... probably not. See my suggestion for flash arrow instead. Enemies would either run out of the disruption arrow's effect radius quickly (thus lose the -tohit) or die extremely quickly (thus lose the -tohit).

Oil Slick Arrow: I don't seem to have the problems you do lighting this. There were problems in the past. It use to refuse to light when street sweeping or in outdoor missions. That hasn't been too much of an issue for a while. Mind you, I'd love the recharge timer to be reduced. That's doubtful to happen though.

Wrong on Acid I'm afraid. Acid Arrow cannot stack with itself, it's specifically marked as such. It will stack with Disruption. Together they just equal Freezing Rain or Tar Patch in effectiveness (in a much smaller AOE of course).


I'd be all for upping the AOE of Acid Arrow to 12 and allowing it to self-stack.


Disruption Arrow has a 10 enemy cap but since it constantly reapplies the debuff every 5 seconds it can move around those affected (but from City of Data it looks like it'd still never be greater than 10 people). Why this is is beyond me since anything else is 16 AFAIK. I'd give it a -100 regen debuff and up the target cap to 16.


As for Poison Gas Arrow, if the -damage was increased to 30 seconds, it was given a 30 second -150 regen debuff and was allowed to self-stack I'd like it (the sleep is fine, although I'd accept that being changed to a Fear but then you run into the Cottage Rule).


I'd also up Glue Arrows -recharge to -35 or so.