Unlimited Respecs in Starter Zone
The idea is sound - I wouldn't object to it being put in the game - but your suggestion of why is kind of ludicrous.
Paragon Wiki: http://www.paragonwiki.com
City Info Terminal: http://cit.cohtitan.com
Mids Hero Designer: http://www.cohplanner.com
/agree with this
if your toons not even lvl 6 just save the costume and reroll |
You're level 6. I've lmade characters where I went, "Hmmm...nope, need to reroll." using the same powersets.
Hell, I've done it because the costume was a bit off and I thought to myself "I'm only level 6" and rerolled.
The only one this would be useful for, and kinda what I'm wondering if that's what you're going for with this suggestion, is Khledians who could then slot out Nova from level 1, without burning one of their own vet specs.
BrandX Future Staff Fighter
The BrandX Collection
At level 10, I'll be able to have 4 Travel Powers!
Yes, I'm including hover, deal with it.
Speeding Through New DA Repeatables || Spreadsheet o' Enhancements || Zombie Skins: better skins for these forums || Guide to Guides
It would be useful for people who want to see what the powers actually do before going into the world, like you can do in some other games. If you can "just reroll" then IMO there isn't a huge argument for why you couldn't "just respec." You could try all of the powers and then leave the tutorial with the ones you wanted. Standard code rant applies.
It would be useful for people who want to see what the powers actually do before going into the world, like you can do in some other games. If you can "just reroll" then IMO there isn't a huge argument for why you couldn't "just respec." You could try all of the powers and then leave the tutorial with the ones you wanted. Standard code rant applies.
|
so that reason also doesnt hold water
I think the OP actually meant looking at the powers FUNCTION not just the FORM.
What does the power do INGAME against enemies rather than what does your toon do when you click the power.
This I think is more inline with what a lot of ppl (myself included) have asked for with the character generator. An actual zone where you can run around and attack those unkillable "dummies" to see how your powers look.
It would be nicer if we could actually fight/defeat something in this zone so you can see how powers like Levitate work and how damaging they are. Of course these mobs dont cound for XP, debt, drops, # of kills, etc.
For example when I first played this game I made a Corruptor and died so often as I didnt know the mechanics and had unrealistic expectations for that AT (a friend told me how awesome his Corr was but he didnt classify he was lvl 50 with full IO Sets).
This would obviously be more helpfull when looking at your toon at level 25+ rather than level 6. By the time you've hit level 25 as a new player (so no PLing) thats a lot of time invested and a "just re-roll" may make some want to leave the game.
I think the OP actually meant looking at the powers FUNCTION not just the FORM.
What does the power do INGAME against enemies rather than what does your toon do when you click the power. This I think is more inline with what a lot of ppl (myself included) have asked for with the character generator. An actual zone where you can run around and attack those unkillable "dummies" to see how your powers look. It would be nicer if we could actually fight/defeat something in this zone so you can see how powers like Levitate work and how damaging they are. Of course these mobs dont cound for XP, debt, drops, # of kills, etc. For example when I first played this game I made a Corruptor and died so often as I didnt know the mechanics and had unrealistic expectations for that AT (a friend told me how awesome his Corr was but he didnt classify he was lvl 50 with full IO Sets). This would obviously be more helpfull when looking at your toon at level 25+ rather than level 6. By the time you've hit level 25 as a new player (so no PLing) thats a lot of time invested and a "just re-roll" may make some want to leave the game. |
I'm sorry but I can't see how anyone can screw up a build so badly before level 6 that they need unlimited respecs let alone 1 respec.
/unsigned |
Oh, I see. Too bad there isn't a Test Server where players can do that before making their final choices on the live servers.
|
Both of these.
You mean a test server that is advertised as an option during character creation.
A test server that isnt a pain to install and actually use (Ive read so many forum threads about problems with the Test Server).
I didnt know we had that?
Even then why should I have to create my character on one server and then recreate on my live server of choice? Its not very intuitive. Its not very user-friendly.
So do we have something? Yes.
Is it sufficiently implemented? Hell no.
"Read the forums" people wll say.
First time MMO players may find the forums daunting.
We should be making the game easier for new players to understand, play around with.
Saying there is no EASY way to test, instead you have to install a 2nd version of the game and make some manual changes so you can test a character and then when ur happy recreate that same character on another server is a half baked idea. Lets flesh it out some.
For those of us who have played the game for a while we know these things. With experience comes knowledge.
The devs are doing a LOT of work to make the game easier for new players.
This would also help.
No, it really won't. The "new" player will start to wonder how he can have unlimited respec's by lv 6 and then have only a limited amount after that. Not to mention the chaos on these forums from the vets who "want this feature extended to all levels or they will quit." Sometimes an idea has to be completely thought out from all angles before making any suggestions. These are just 2 of several that can come up.
No thanks. I don't feel the need to respec a power before it has a few slots and at least SOs. You really don't have a good feel for it until then.
50s: Inv/SS PB Emp/Dark Grav/FF DM/Regen TA/A Sonic/Elec MA/Regen Fire/Kin Sonic/Rad Ice/Kin Crab Fire/Cold NW Merc/Dark Emp/Sonic Rad/Psy Emp/Ice WP/DB FA/SM
Overlord of Dream Team and Nightmare Squad
My last post was of support for an improved character generator with a testing zone (and reasons why) rather than support for unlimited repecs before level 6.
It was based on my first post so I think I may have hijacked this thread unintentionally
Damn tangents
You mean a test server that is advertised as an option during character creation.
|
A test server that isnt a pain to install and actually use (Ive read so many forum threads about problems with the Test Server). |
I didnt know we had that? |
Even then why should I have to create my character on one server and then recreate on my live server of choice? |
Its not very intuitive. Its not very user-friendly. |
For those of us who have played the game for a while we know these things. With experience comes knowledge. |
The devs are doing a LOT of work to make the game easier for new players. This would also help. |
I'm sorry but I can't see how anyone can screw up a build so badly before level 6 that they need unlimited respecs let alone 1 respec.
|
/signed, simply by virtue of it not really having any reasonable downside that I can see.
I think the OP actually meant looking at the powers FUNCTION not just the FORM.
What does the power do INGAME against enemies rather than what does your toon do when you click the power. This I think is more inline with what a lot of ppl (myself included) have asked for with the character generator. An actual zone where you can run around and attack those unkillable "dummies" to see how your powers look. It would be nicer if we could actually fight/defeat something in this zone so you can see how powers like Levitate work and how damaging they are. Of course these mobs dont cound for XP, debt, drops, # of kills, etc. For example when I first played this game I made a Corruptor and died so often as I didnt know the mechanics and had unrealistic expectations for that AT (a friend told me how awesome his Corr was but he didnt classify he was lvl 50 with full IO Sets). This would obviously be more helpfull when looking at your toon at level 25+ rather than level 6. By the time you've hit level 25 as a new player (so no PLing) thats a lot of time invested and a "just re-roll" may make some want to leave the game. |
BrandX Future Staff Fighter
The BrandX Collection
It was a small QoL suggestion, not a complaint in disguise. I don't really see how it could have generated so much controversy. If it happens great, if not, whatever. I think the amount of effort you're going to to say it should never happen is kind of over the top though. Other games have this feature without the world coming to an end or people being guilted out of using it. :P
|
And if you think my position that it's virtually impossible to screw up a build so badly that a level 6 character is unplayable unless they get unlimited respecs, then please prove me wrong by posting examples of those screwed up builds.
I have no problem admitting I'm wrong if you can prove a level 6 character actually needs a respec because the build is screwed up.
I think that Tex's logic is sound... if it can be argued that it is useless to give respecs because you should just make the character over... then what is lost by allowing them to "fix" their current character?
you can preview all the powers from within the character creator before even loading into the tutorial during the power customization screen
so that reason also doesnt hold water |
Are you F-ing serious? You actually expect players who are new, possibly new to the entire genre of MMOs to install this game, install the game again (regardless of method) and then play around on servers that will count for nothing on their actual characters to experiment and learn about the game... and THEN go back and make sure they remember everything they just learned and make the character again? Man, if you want people to not play this game... wow.
Perhaps... but if you are truly new to the game (or perhaps MMOs as a whole) you may not have a clue as to how the powers WORK. Yes, it says Immobolize, or Hold or Stun... but you may not have a handle on what that all means or how it plays out in the real game world. Sleeps are an excellent example of this, they SOUND useful, until you see how they actually work.
|
a majority of sleep powers arent even given out till like the 20s, which by then it would just be easier to respec unless you really didnt like the toon as a whole and its not like its that much work to get to 20 in the first place even without PLing
all i see the suggestion as is letting you run around the tutorial while your still in the character creator so you could go back and repick powers, but that will prolly never happen because once the character is generated the devs have stated that to change powersets and/or ATs would be a very complicated task to do, which is why it was mentioned that powerset or AT respecs will probably never happen
the reasoning for this is sound, but its something that is extremely unlikely to happen if ever happening at all, and as mentioned its not very hard to reroll the toon if its before lvl 10, and even up to 20
also a note about the sleep and stuff, poeple do read the power descriptions, and it does say that sleeping foes are easily woken, held foes cannot act, ect
Actually my original logic was "some other games have this and it looks really polished." You have to exit the tutorial to enter the game anyway. I can see why this might not be implemented (lots of things aren't), but fighting it tooth and nail is just... well to me its like taking a firm stance along the lines of "Under NO circumstances should a Merit vendor be added to Perez Park." May heaven shine its light on the Suggestions forums.
if they want to see how the powers work they should just roll the toon up and actually play it, thats what the tutorial zone is for, 0 xp is given except for the few small quests that are given and you cant leave till you finish the quest chain
|
a majority of sleep powers arent even given out till like the 20s, which by then it would just be easier to respec unless you really didnt like the toon as a whole and its not like its that much work to get to 20 in the first place even without PLing |
all i see the suggestion as is letting you run around the tutorial while your still in the character creator so you could go back and repick powers, but that will prolly never happen because once the character is generated the devs have stated that to change powersets and/or ATs would be a very complicated task to do, which is why it was mentioned that powerset or AT respecs will probably never happen the reasoning for this is sound, but its something that is extremely unlikely to happen if ever happening at all, and as mentioned its not very hard to reroll the toon if its before lvl 10, and even up to 20 |
also a note about the sleep and stuff, poeple do read the power descriptions, and it does say that sleeping foes are easily woken, held foes cannot act, ect |
Also, it is significant to note that for someone just starting out, they lack the long-term perspective in some cases that we Veterans have about the game and how it works. Do all new players understand how easy it is to get to Level 20? I know when I was new, the journey from 1 to around 15 took forever (and each power selection was overwhelming since it was my first MMO and first forray into this game)! And seemed as if I would NEVER get to the lofty heights of 20 let alone, 50.
I think the starter zone should have a contact who grants unlimited respecs while you are in the zone. As a safeguard, only characters under level 6 would be allow to use the feature. Once you leave the starter zone you would use the normal respec system. While it only affects a small number of powers, committing to your first 3 power choices when you know nothing about the game or your character can mess you up early on (particularly, not knowing to slot Stamina). Particularly with ATs like Controllers where your choices might be something un-straightforward, like: Mezmerize, Dominate, Levitate, Confuse (assuming you could actually hit lvl 6 in the zone), Entangling Arrow, Flash Arrow, Glue Arrow.