Thoughts on Broadsword


Blpup

 

Posted

I thought about rollin' a BS/Nin or /WP after I get my Blaster done. Any idea if its PvP worthy?

Edit: Meant to drop this in the PvP section. Oh wellz.


 

Posted

I made a BS/nin im hoping he will be good in pvp with the double placte so you can use 3 AS in a row


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Blpup View Post
I made a BS/nin im hoping he will be good in pvp with the double placte so you can use 3 AS in a row
The nin placate power does NOT allow you to crit or your AS afterward like the regular placate in the primary. These powers have two different effects. Placate in the primary sets you to untargetable and puts you in psuedo hide status (meaning hide without the defense bonus). This allows you to crit or AS. Smoke Bomb the suck *** power, just makes you untargetable provided that it passes the tohit check. It does not allow you to crit or AS after its used.


Bump and Grind Bane/SoA
Kenja No Ishi Earth/Empathy Controller
Legendary Sannin Ninja/Pain Mastermind
Entoxicated Ninja/PSN Mastermind
Ninja Ryukenden Kat/WP Scrapper
Hellish Thoughts Fire/PSI Dominator

Thank You Devs for Merits!!!!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by TrancEnding View Post
I thought about rollin' a BS/Nin or /WP after I get my Blaster done. Any idea if its PvP worthy?

Edit: Meant to drop this in the PvP section. Oh wellz.
BS/WP is a bit better for PvP than BS/Nin, but don't let it stop you from playing either one you find more fun.

If you go /Nin, Build for KB IO's as well as Recharge and some HP. /WP doesn't need help capping HP or need KB IO's, so you can focus more on recharge.


"the reason there are so many sarcastic pvpers is we already had a better version of pvp taken away from us to appease bad players. Back then we chuckled at how bad players came here and whined. If we knew that was the actual voice devs would listen to instead of informed, educated players we probably would have been bigger dicks back then." -ConFlict

 

Posted

I don't see a BS being nearly as good as EM or Elec, it doesn't hit as hard and has no status effects, or anything for that matter.

I guess just to play something new would be good enough.


 

Posted

I wanted War Mace or Ice Melee


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
I wanted War Mace or Ice Melee
This!!!

I want War Mace way more than Broadsword. And I think Ice Melee is a great idea too.


What's left is to normalize all Assassin Strikes and improve Stalker's old sets (Claw, MA and EM)! You don't need to bring back the missing PbAoE attack. You just need to make the existing ones better! For example, make Slice a WIDER and LONGER cone.

 

Posted

I'd play a warmace stalker, but not unless the AS animation was an overhead smash of some sort rather than a stabbing motion. And then I'd use the shovel weapon.

Assassin shovel to the face.


 

Posted

I'm having fun with my BS/Elec stalker. Seems like a sturdy combination. He's only lvl 12, but the future looks, um , bright.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
I wanted War Mace or Ice Melee
Ice Melee would be a very interesting stalker primary. I dont play stalkers, but i think i would play one of these!






" I don't let me kids play on the Freedom Server" -Oya

 

Posted

War Mace will be the very last proliferation to stalkers, because it would tread on Banes' turf.

I really want Ice and Fire stalkers.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by oriand View Post
War Mace will be the very last proliferation to stalkers, because it would tread on Banes' turf.

I really want Ice and Fire stalkers.
Ice works and both the primary and secondary hopefully will share a place in Stalker's repertoire soon.

Fire, however...DoT vs. Placate doesn't seem to put things in your favor...


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by oriand View Post
War Mace will be the very last proliferation to stalkers, because it would tread on Banes' turf.
Oh you mean Banes already don't step on Stalkers' toes?


 

Posted

I'd pick a well played Bane over a well played Stalker any day.


FM for Stalkers would be my guess next proliferation.


 

Posted

Dot didn't stop spines being used for stalkers, so I don't see why it would stop FM.

They could very well remove FireSwordCircle (proly what will happen) and incinerate (problematic dot power) for AS, and placate which would leave breath of fire as the aoe and scorch, cremate, firesword and GFS as the normal st attacks.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Frosticus View Post
Dot didn't stop spines being used for stalkers, so I don't see why it would stop FM.

They could very well remove FireSwordCircle (proly what will happen) and incinerate (problematic dot power) for AS, and placate which would leave breath of fire as the aoe and scorch, cremate, firesword and GFS as the normal st attacks.
So Assassin's Flame, Placate, Build up, Breath of Fire, Scorch, Cremate, Firesword, Greater Firesword....and Taunt!?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
So Assassin's Flame, Placate, Build up, Breath of Fire, Scorch, Cremate, Firesword, Greater Firesword....and Taunt!?
With our luck we'll get Combustion in that slot...


 

Posted

Stone stalkers FTW.
See my sig.


Official Offline Psychopath of PWNZ
"Hey, sneak up, stab someone, and sneak away...or kill them with Iceland at a distance. Either way, no one knows what the hell happened!" -Umbramancer, on Assassin's Boulder
Echo So'kar reference shots ||| Punkicide reference shots

 

Posted

I just think Broadsword stalkers are OP if used right. Scrappers put out the most damage with Broadsword and now that Stalkers can get that "Extreme" damage crit off. Its over.

I got a fully purped out BS/WP Scrapper on freedom. Fought my friend who was purped out BS/Regen, I destroyed him. Like 5-2.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo_G View Post
So Assassin's Flame, Placate, Build up, Breath of Fire, Scorch, Cremate, Firesword, Greater Firesword....and Taunt!?
Oy! Blaze of course.

Na I dunno, I counted 6 powers last night +as,bu,placate, but I think I double counted buildup

I vote for FE in the primary.

scorch
FS
Breath
AS
Bu
Placate
Cremate
FE
GFS

I dunno what they would do with incinerate because if dot was ever an issue incinerate is the embodiment of that issue.

Maybe FireSwordCircle...

So my vote in no particular order, though all are probably too good to ever happen.
Blaze
FE
FSC


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Deft_Bow View Post
Ice works and both the primary and secondary hopefully will share a place in Stalker's repertoire soon.

Fire, however...DoT vs. Placate doesn't seem to put things in your favor...
And Spines doesn't have a Toxic DoT? hmmm ... I want an Assassin's Roast :0 animation like "drink chemicals" and "Breathe of Fire" combined ... Muha ha ha


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Frosticus View Post
Oy! Blaze of course.

Na I dunno, I counted 6 powers last night +as,bu,placate, but I think I double counted buildup

I vote for FE in the primary.

scorch (yes)
FS (yes)
Breath (Definitely or as the AS :P)
AS
Bu
Placate
Cremate
FE (doubtful, Blaze :P)
GFS

I dunno what they would do with incinerate because if dot was ever an issue incinerate is the embodiment of that issue.

Maybe FireSwordCircle...No Stalker has ever gotten a PBAoE before, Cone...Yes

So my vote in no particular order, though all are probably too good to ever happen.
Blaze
FE
FSC

1-Scorch
2-Fire Sword
3-Breate of Fire or Combustion
4-Assassin's Flames (something like the Carnies that use Fire)
5-Build Up
6-Placate
7-Cremate
8-Blaze
9-Greater Fire Sword

This would be my guess for Fire Melee being prolificated over as.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by TrancEnding View Post
I thought about rollin' a BS/Nin or /WP after I get my Blaster done. Any idea if its PvP worthy?

Edit: Meant to drop this in the PvP section. Oh wellz.
The only experience I've had with Broad Sword is combined with Electric secondary. Mine is currently 12 and my "Stalker-Guru" buddy's is lvl 38. The mixture of Defense with Resistances is something to behold. It's kinda like my lvl 50 Katana/Fire Aura Scrapper. Very durable with dual layers of damage mitigation using both Defense and Resistance coupled with a good heal and tier 9 God-mode, Power Surge. I've seen my buddy crash from Power Surge...hit a blue...hit Energize...and Power Sink...and keep rollin' in mob's corspes

The difference as I see it for Ninjutsu versus Willpower is one utility set for another. Nin is more defensive with a good heal and some tricks, where WP is over time heals/regen rate with some defense and resistance rolled in. Nin has a "god-mode" and WP has a self-rez. So it depends on what attributes you are looking more for your PvP toon.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by MurderousMalk View Post
1-Scorch
2-Fire Sword
3-Breate of Fire or Combustion
4-Assassin's Flames (something like the Carnies that use Fire)
5-Build Up
6-Placate
7-Cremate
8-Blaze
9-Greater Fire Sword

This would be my guess for Fire Melee being prolificated over as.

Blaze as number 8 that is like a stalkers wet dream


 

Posted

I'd play the heck out of FM for stalkers if it had blaze. Never happen, but man it would be sweet.

I really like having a strong ranged attack on my melee toons to minimize chasing after things that run away cause I'm wailing on their buddy. I however, don't really like waiting until the 40's for that to become an option.