I13 - Beating a dead horse


ChaosAngelGeno

 

Posted

** Spoiler information: You've read 1000x posts like this before **

Hello Devs!

I have been away for quite a long time since Issue 14 when I felt there was nothing else left in CoX but AE farms (Could hardly find any *normal* teams at the time), lack of lvl 50 content and a broken PvP. Now I'm loving this game again except for the PvP which I tried hard to enjoy but it's not the same fun either losing or wining.

You've spent many hours, days, weeks, months and years thinking and tweaking PvP. IMO this time could be used into developing new content instead.

So let's remember why there are so many changes with I13:

1 - People whined too much.

And you tried to change PvP, nerf it, boost that, try to balance it and that until you gave up but everyone is still whining! Listening to everyone with different options can be troublesome.

Just leave it like the old Issue 6 days, pretty much like PvE except minor NEEDED changes like mez suppression, people can't 1 shot anyone (i7 change I think), brutes earn fury much faster and so on. We had many different classes with different powersets PvPing at the time and it was much more fun, I have never played FoTMs and got my *** kicked many times by a variety of different classes on different toons, that was fun. I am not really sure about IO sets within this PvP system.

Couldn't you make it like an event? Open Sirens Call or Bloody Bay to these old rules and see how successful are these changes?

I remember there were so many changes before I13, many fail-attempts that made nonsense, defense was godlike today and useless tomorrow, felt like we were playing a beta game.

Keeping things simple sometimes is a better option.


50 Ice/Ice/Force Blaster *
50 Ice/Fire/Fire Tanker
50 Kin/Sonic/Power Defender
50 Ice/Storm/Psi Controller
50 Stone/WP/Soul Brute
50 Spines/SR Stalker

Pinnacle | Virtue

@Black Heart

 

Posted

Would be fun to see a new zone get the 'lets see what we got' version that week or month.

Great way to test out changes they want to make without it being permanent. Great way for the player base to see what's up, and give their input. Great way to see by how many use the zone that month if they are on to something yes or no. Alternate between Siren's Call, Bloody Bay, Warburg, Recluse's Victory and even set it to the Arena as an option to play under those rules.



Dark Energon, Founder of the Freedom Legion SG on Guardian server.
(SG founded on 12-08-'09, Top100: 08-17-'10, Top50: 12-23-'10, Top25: 12-11-'11)
Crab Spider Nephila on Titan Tracker
Weekly events on Guardian: W.A.V.E. & FNFN

 

Posted

No HD, No TS week in RV would be pretty sweet.


 

Posted

guy above me i don't think you actually know what a necro post is.

yes please old school pvp rules(pve rules) in a new pvp zone or one of the old ones i'm easy either way.


 

Posted

*Reads title: I13 - Beating a dead horse

*Reads first line:
[QUOTE=Z_e_r_o_NA;4041658]You've read 1000x posts like this before[QUOTE]

Looks like post/thread/subject necromancy to me, it even has that fresh undead smell.


 

Posted

tbh I miss things like my storm controllers or kins being good in the arena more than I miss zone PvP w/o TS and HD, but I know I'm the minority there.


 

Posted

Here is an idea - people who pay for the game...get hd/ts off.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by ChaosAngelGeno View Post
*Reads title: I13 - Beating a dead horse

*Reads first line:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Z_e_r_o_NA View Post
You've read 1000x posts like this before
Looks like post/thread/subject necromancy to me, it even has that fresh undead smell.
But the post date is today. Old hat, new post. Penalty is withdrawn. 1st down.


 

Posted

Quote:
=ChaosAngelGeno;4041916]*Reads title: I13 - Beating a dead horse

*Reads first line:
Quote:
=Z_e_r_o_NA;4041658]You've read 1000x posts like this before
Looks like post/thread/subject necromancy to me, it even has that fresh undead smell.
you said necro post.... never even heard of necro thread/subject lololols.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rikti View Post
tbh I miss things like my storm controllers or kins being good in the arena more than I miss zone PvP w/o TS and HD, but I know I'm the minority there.
this comment irks me.
rikti, at the point, you have zero clue what works and doesn't work.
justin spent the first half of i13 on a fire/storm making people cry. he spent the other half on an earth/elec.
march was extremely effective on kin during the first freedom league.
dex on his kin/elec defender made many many people cry in kickballs.

stop regurgitating the crap you hear and think about what you say before you post.

people in this game are horrible. you can pretty much make anything work, and back then we didn't even have incarnates. judgement and interface have narrowed the damage gap so that everything plays a lot more like it did in i12... it's just that people are far too dumb to see that, so they'll complain because it's cool to hate on incarnates.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by recalx View Post
this comment irks me.
rikti, at the point, you have zero clue what works and doesn't work.
justin spent the first half of i13 on a fire/storm making people cry. he spent the other half on an earth/elec.
march was extremely effective on kin during the first freedom league.
dex on his kin/elec defender made many many people cry in kickballs.

stop regurgitating the crap you hear and think about what you say before you post.

people in this game are horrible. you can pretty much make anything work, and back then we didn't even have incarnates. judgement and interface have narrowed the damage gap so that everything plays a lot more like it did in i12... it's just that people are far too dumb to see that, so they'll complain because it's cool to hate on incarnates.
I almost forgot how much fun that Kin/Elec was. People didn't think Doms could do anything but hold in 8v8s before this league either. People do need to think outside the box more BUT there does need to be some changes with DR caps. If everyone had the def/res DR numbers as scrappers that would make it more interesting as well as ofc HD/TS out the window. Small changes could do a lot but it may be too late. Now its not keeping your player base it is getting them to quit other games to come back. Odds are bad. GL CoHers


 

Posted

I mostly miss the zone PvP, just grab a random toon and go there and have some fun.

Been trying to actually find the PvP on Virtue these days, only real action I could find was RV and that's a shame, SC and Warburg used to be very fun! I would often find SC crowded with tons of people.

And the action I found in RV was kinda lame, seemed like everyone was using the same AT with the same set of powers.

I can't see the reason of why there are hardly anyone pvping now a days but all the changes since i13 since apparently CoX has a larger playerbase now than before, I would rarely see a server going yellow and red back then.

Had a lot of fun with some chars those were never meant to be a fotm pvper such as my Em/Stone brute in SC, kin/sonic defender, spines/SR stalker, ice/ice blaster, mind/psy dom, archery/em blaster, MA/Invul scrapper, Cold/fire corruptor and ice/fire tanker. Also had a few "OP" ones mostly for arenas like Ill/Rad and Ice/Storm.

I got so many kills on my Cold/Fire corruptor in Warburg I used to lol at people rage quitting the zone because supposedly corruptors were op. FS + Sonic Nuke on MMs on my Defender? Priceless! I got a few MMs this way, that was VERY funny. Also I had all the toons above with reputation maxxed out at least once.

Now it feels like we need a char specifically built for PvP, it was much more casual friendly back a few years.

Hell, I wouldn't mind having bloody bay as a ruleless PvP zone, at least there will be someone to play with...


50 Ice/Ice/Force Blaster *
50 Ice/Fire/Fire Tanker
50 Kin/Sonic/Power Defender
50 Ice/Storm/Psi Controller
50 Stone/WP/Soul Brute
50 Spines/SR Stalker

Pinnacle | Virtue

@Black Heart

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by recalx View Post
this comment irks me.
rikti, at the point, you have zero clue what works and doesn't work.
justin spent the first half of i13 on a fire/storm making people cry. he spent the other half on an earth/elec.
march was extremely effective on kin during the first freedom league.
dex on his kin/elec defender made many many people cry in kickballs.

stop regurgitating the crap you hear and think about what you say before you post.

people in this game are horrible. you can pretty much make anything work, and back then we didn't even have incarnates. judgement and interface have narrowed the damage gap so that everything plays a lot more like it did in i12... it's just that people are far too dumb to see that, so they'll complain because it's cool to hate on incarnates.
Ok bro sorry I haven't kept up with this game like you have. I was under the impression that storms weren't nearly as effective as they once were and so were kins. Sorry if I was wrong, I haven't exactly played a million hours since i13. I would experiment with **** myself and form my own opinions, but it's kinda hard to win with anything when you're broke and have no means of farming PvP IOs (which seems to be the standard for anyone who has money - again, tell me in a non-dickish way if I'm wrong).

Edit: I guess I should stop posting here, since apparently anyone who quit the game for a lengthy period of time isn't allowed to talk lest they be wrong. God forbid you be like Katalyst or whoever else that is actually helpful with their posts without being an *******. I quit this game over 3 years ago and came back and moved a couple of characters to Freedom about a month ago. I feel I've been pretty humble whenever I lose a duel (which happens most of the time these days), yet whenever I ask a dumb question or make an incorrect comment you and the gang try to drive me away from this game again because people that don't know every detail of i13, i14, i15, etc. etc. are a waste of space or something. ****.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rikti View Post
Ok bro sorry I haven't kept up with this game like you have. I was under the impression that storms weren't nearly as effective as they once were and so were kins. Sorry if I was wrong, I haven't exactly played a million hours since i13. I would experiment with **** myself and form my own opinions, but it's kinda hard to win with anything when you're broke and have no means of farming PvP IOs (which seems to be the standard for anyone who has money - again, tell me in a non-dickish way if I'm wrong).

Edit: I guess I should stop posting here, since apparently anyone who quit the game for a lengthy period of time isn't allowed to talk lest they be wrong. God forbid you be like Katalyst or whoever else that is actually helpful with their posts without being an *******. I quit this game over 3 years ago and came back and moved a couple of characters to Freedom about a month ago. I feel I've been pretty humble whenever I lose a duel (which happens most of the time these days), yet whenever I ask a dumb question or make an incorrect comment you and the gang try to drive me away from this game again because people that don't know every detail of i13, i14, i15, etc. etc. are a waste of space or something. ****.

not trying to drive you away.
trying to keep you from becoming the archetypal post-i13 pvper.
teh downs is contagious.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daknah View Post
If everyone had the def/res DR numbers as scrappers that would make it more interesting as well
i'd just go at implementing two DR functions. one for self-buffs, and one for team-buffs. the team buff one operating at scrapper levels for squishies.


 

Posted

I never really pvp'd much but didn't mind it too much.


Really just needs to have an objective-based pvp...like capture the flag, hold this point, something other than "kill someone" pvp for someone like me to get into it.

Edit:

Hence, why I liked the SG base raids more than zone pvp (or arena pvp).


Leader of The LEGION/Fallen LEGION on the Liberty server!
SSBB FC: 2062-8881-3944
MKW FC: 4167-4891-5991

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Energizing_Ion View Post
I never really pvp'd much but didn't mind it too much.


Really just needs to have an objective-based pvp...like capture the flag, hold this point, something other than "kill someone" pvp for someone like me to get into it.

Edit:

Hence, why I liked the SG base raids more than zone pvp (or arena pvp).
There are actual minor objectives, BB got shivans, SC bounties, WB nukes and RV somewhat of a spot-capture game it's just not rewarding enough, also I think the bounties system should be in every PvP zone.

Maybe a system that earns you PvP Reward Merits so you can exchange them for PvP IOs, special inspirations and costume pieces, this would bring a lot of people to PvP zones.

Base raids were fun but highly exploitable, I haven't done them since most of my SG quit the game


50 Ice/Ice/Force Blaster *
50 Ice/Fire/Fire Tanker
50 Kin/Sonic/Power Defender
50 Ice/Storm/Psi Controller
50 Stone/WP/Soul Brute
50 Spines/SR Stalker

Pinnacle | Virtue

@Black Heart

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daknah View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by recalx View Post
this comment irks me.
rikti, at the point, you have zero clue what works and doesn't work.
justin spent the first half of i13 on a fire/storm making people cry. he spent the other half on an earth/elec.
march was extremely effective on kin during the first freedom league.
dex on his kin/elec defender made many many people cry in kickballs.

stop regurgitating the crap you hear and think about what you say before you post.

people in this game are horrible. you can pretty much make anything work, and back then we didn't even have incarnates. judgement and interface have narrowed the damage gap so that everything plays a lot more like it did in i12... it's just that people are far too dumb to see that, so they'll complain because it's cool to hate on incarnates.
I almost forgot how much fun that Kin/Elec was. People didn't think Doms could do anything but hold in 8v8s before this league either. People do need to think outside the box more BUT there does need to be some changes with DR caps. If everyone had the def/res DR numbers as scrappers that would make it more interesting as well as ofc HD/TS out the window. Small changes could do a lot but it may be too late. Now its not keeping your player base it is getting them to quit other games to come back. Odds are bad. GL CoHers
I can understand where Rikti is coming from, and also the viewpoints expressed by Barrier and Dex. The truth is, the game has changed and so the roles have changed as well. Instead of being able to Kin and throw damage around like I was able to do on Kin/Psy pre-I13, I had to play more of a Support/Disruption role in the past Freedom Leagues. I'll admit that it was certainly a much different mindset that I needed to adjust to, but it wasn't a terrible change. The whole "Kin Effect" (unsuppressed movement) got essentially cancelled with the option to remove Travel Suppression as a whole, but there were still people out there who liked the control given by IR (Vinnie).

Things change, life moves on, and you really just have to adapt to keep going or let yourself drift into the background and remember the "good old days".


@Ethical Inquiry

 

Posted

Woooooooooooooooooo ChaosAngelGeno quoted me. I'm a nobody and I got quoted in a sig yaaaay. This officially validates my self worth and if at any time in the future he changes his sig and removes my quote I will drop everything and commit Seppuku because my honor is lost, death before dishonor.

Oh wait there's a thread topic here... um... yes recalc DR numbers so that when I'm on my sonic/sonic Def and pass out +Resist shields, they ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING for the squishies instead of being murdered by ridiculous DR numbers and epic armors granting +Res to all. I mean not that I don't like a PvP mechanic that completely invalidates the buffing potential I usually wield in PvE but... ... ...no wait yeah I don't like that at all. Sorry, unless I'm buffing a Regen Scrap in Sirens, cus then I make them Jesus, good thing every Scrap is Regen or I might feel more useless than I already do. Oh well I guess making some powers useless is the only way for the Devs to please the people who aren't me and stop the whining... except people still whine.

Lol Necro thread. Lol Necro Om Nom Nomicon. I belong here...


"Look, personally I just want a new issue to feature changes that don't cause a mass exodus of players..."
Issue 17: We Didn't Break Anything!
How to suck at CoX
Literally the Best Build Ever: Years in the Making

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rikti View Post
God forbid you be like Katalyst or whoever else that is actually helpful with their posts without being an *******.
Don't bring me into this.

Oh, and FWIW, barrier brings up good points, he is just far more direct about it then I would be.


@TheKatalyst
My **** is bleeding.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Katalyst View Post
Don't bring me into this.

Oh, and FWIW, barrier brings up good points, he is just far more direct about it then I would be.
These forums need more posts from Vex teaching people the difference between then and than.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by NecroOmNomNomicon View Post
Woooooooooooooooooo ChaosAngelGeno quoted me. I'm a nobody and I got quoted in a sig yaaaay. This officially validates my self worth and if at any time in the future he changes his sig and removes my quote I will drop everything and commit Seppuku because my honor is lost, death before dishonor.

Oh wait there's a thread topic here... um... yes recalc DR numbers so that when I'm on my sonic/sonic Def and pass out +Resist shields, they ACTUALLY DO SOMETHING for the squishies instead of being murdered by ridiculous DR numbers and epic armors granting +Res to all. I mean not that I don't like a PvP mechanic that completely invalidates the buffing potential I usually wield in PvE but... ... ...no wait yeah I don't like that at all. Sorry, unless I'm buffing a Regen Scrap in Sirens, cus then I make them Jesus, good thing every Scrap is Regen or I might feel more useless than I already do. Oh well I guess making some powers useless is the only way for the Devs to please the people who aren't me and stop the whining... except people still whine.

Lol Necro thread. Lol Necro Om Nom Nomicon. I belong here...
Your welcome.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by ChaosAngelGeno View Post
Your welcome.
you're.

goddammit kids, l2engrish


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daknah View Post
These forums need more posts from Vex teaching people the difference between then and than.
These forums also need to keep you logged in when you tell them to, but we can't have everything we want, particularly since we are PvPers.


@TheKatalyst
My **** is bleeding.