Tank Teaming in the 30's


Adeon Hawkwood

 

Posted

Hey guys,

I'm still testing out a few of my favorite characters after nearly a year away from the game.

One of my fave's was as an old tanker I made (pre I/O era) and I dusted him off, found him broke, and in dire need of a respec.

He's still pretty darn effective without the best of I/O's but I found teaming with him VERY difficult. I think he's level... 31.

I do find ONCE I'm on a team, it goes really well, and you get the old 'I'll friend you' messages, and compliments on tanking, but it's -finding a team- that I'm having trouble with.

I don't have a lot of content on this guy yet, but I'm always LFT.... but this character is hard pressed to get an invite. This has happened over 4-5 evenings and I started to wonder is this a common problem for a tank in the 30's?

No I am not in an SG. As mentioned, I just came back a few weeks ago. I was just disappointed in the lack of team invites for this guy and wanted to know if it was normal or not? (I moved this guy from Guardian to Freedom in hopes of fixing the problem, but no luck.)

Thanks.


Nekron: Beam Rifle / Poison Corruptor and Slayer of Evil!! (Exalted)
Intergalaktic: Fire / Time Corruptor (Exalted)

 

Posted

Okay, what're you doing to get on teams?

Standing around in *INSERT ZONE* going "L31 Tank LFT?"
Using some of your server's global channels to network with people?
Using the boards to find teams?
Starting your own teams when all else fails?



Clicking on the linked image above will take you off the City of Heroes site. However, the guides will be linked back here.

 

Posted

Yeah, hanging around and hoping for an invite usually won't work, even on the "high-pop" servers most of the time, no matter what your AT.

As Hyperstrike says, definitely go and find out what the main global channels are for your server.


Global name: @k26dp

 

Posted

Are you waiting for an invite, or are you actively seeking one? More often than not, I find just stating your level and AT in broadcast is of little use. And when it does work, it's usually the classic PUG horror group.

I use the search tool and look for people already on a team. Then I use this handy little bind:

/bind (insert button) begin chat /t $target, Excuse me, but could your team make use of a $level (primary/secondary) tank?

So all I do is click on a person's name, hit the bind, and hit enter. You can add more to the bind, like maybe a description of your play style so they know you're not just gonna sit around. I find more often than not that this will find me a team when my SG isn't on. Some people may get annoyed by this, but you probably wouldn't want to be on their team anyway.

And of course, you can always for your own team. Don't be timid about it, most people are probably in the same situation as yourself. They're just waiting for someone to send the invite. Good luck!


@Rylas

Kill 'em all. Let XP sort 'em out.

 

Posted

ok. Thanks for the replies.

Just wondering if it was just me. To be honest the only character I have this issue with is my 31 Tank, so I was just wondering if it was a population thing or....?

So thanks for the advice.


Nekron: Beam Rifle / Poison Corruptor and Slayer of Evil!! (Exalted)
Intergalaktic: Fire / Time Corruptor (Exalted)

 

Posted

I usually form my own teams for this very reason but oddly as soon as I finished the team I was on last night I received a message asking if I wanted to join another. I was going to go to bed but I thought I'd take advantage of not being the leader for once lol.


Global @radubadu
Usually playing one of the following toons blueside on Virtue:
Cadler 50 WP/SS tanker
Radubadu 46 Fire/Fire blaster
Hell Runner 35 Fire/Fire brute

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by _Elektro_ View Post
ok. Thanks for the replies.

Just wondering if it was just me. To be honest the only character I have this issue with is my 31 Tank, so I was just wondering if it was a population thing or....?
I keep thinking you are going to post your Tank's name or build or something for us to review.

Do you have a name like "w00t w0ck3ts!!!" or other funky spelling that might be scaring casual observers away?

You say you don't have this problem with your other heroes, so here's a question: How many Tanks to do you suppose most teams" think" they need?

I'm betting it's one, maybe two. So if a team has 1 tank, they're not likely to go looking for more, unless they just want to fill the team. And since you're back from a long break and don't have a set of friends/SG/global channel pals to team with, you're just waiting for some random team to need another Tank and to find you in the Find thingie.

Try this, next time you're online and alone: Pull up the Find thingie. Change the AT to Tank, and the level menu to all levels, and press Find. How many other Tanks are online right then? If it's more than will fit in the results pane, and loads of 'em are not on teams, then you're waiting for some team to pick you at random from all those tanks just for their team.

But now you're ready for Step 2! Click a few of those dudes and invite them to your team! Then change the AT to something else, and invite a few more people! If you're feeling really wild and crazy, try changing the AT to Peacebringer or Warshade! If you think YOU feel excluded, just think up how infrequently people deliberately go looking for Kheldians!!!


 

Posted

Like I said, I was just asking for opinion. I certainly didn't mean to tell people they don't 'invite me enough' or something of that nature.

The reason I wanted to know if anyone else had this problem was to get a sense of :

Is it the archetype? (That's a whole other discussion on whether people know they need a tank, or there are too many tanks, etc. etc)

-or-

Is it a population thing at level 30+?

Because if it's just me, that's ok. I'm ok with forming teams. Probably not now because my tank is very dated, but eventually.

The reason I said it doesn't happen to my other toons is not so much my choice of naming convention (though I don't think any of the names would offend anyone. , but instead I was wondering if it was just people think they do better without a tank, or bad luck, or his level.

Just sort of an informal poll. While my tank is a lot of fun, I did get a lot of teams with him a year ago. So I wondered if it was just me or I'm seeing the result of a population drop.

Thanks again.


Nekron: Beam Rifle / Poison Corruptor and Slayer of Evil!! (Exalted)
Intergalaktic: Fire / Time Corruptor (Exalted)

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by _Elektro_ View Post
Is it the archetype? (That's a whole other discussion on whether people know they need a tank, or there are too many tanks, etc. etc)

-or-

Is it a population thing at level 30+?
I think it's an archetype thing. When I'm forming a team I very rarely go out looking for a tank. If I get a Tank through passive recruiting (i.e. global channels or broadcast) all well and good and I'll generally grab one if I see them with a LFT flag up but when actively recruiting I tend to look for Defenders and Controllers first followed by Scrappers, Blasters and Kheldians, Tanks come last unless I've got a team with poor mitigation (i.e. one with no Defenders or Controllers or the ones I do have are the low mitigation sets like Kin or TA). I've got nothing against Tanks but they tend to bring the least to the team in terms of killing speed.

I do like taking a Tank on most TFs, but that tends to be a security blanket more than anything (with the exception of some of the TFs with problematic AVs like KHTF, Kahn or STF). Most AVs are actually pretty weak if you've got half decent buffing/debuffing and a lot of the time a good team doesn't need a tank but having one makes me feel better.


 

Posted

I reckon the population sub 45 is very shabby until GR comes out.


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

<QR>

As others have mentioned, "networking" will be your best long-term solution to your teaming issues - building up a base of players who are reliable teammates.

Most servers have a badge channel for teams looking for badges, including TF/ SF badges and the like. Although such channels are generally used only for looking for badge teams, they can help you build a base of teammates for non-badge-related, "everyday" teaming. There might be other channels on your server that specifically cater to normal teaming. There could even be social channels that can help provide teammates, or help you build a network base.


 

Posted

I think what u should do is get on a certain global channels and see if that helps but I would still like to know how are you looking for a team. That might be the problem, Ive noticed on freedom a lot of times everyone is doing AEs and missing out on all the other benefits of the game, it is sad when I see a lvl 50 that has less badges then me when i am on a lower lvl toon even with out my vet rewards. Why don't you bring your tank to tanker Tuesday when it comes to freedom.


 

Posted

Finding teams is something people post about from time to time throughout the forums, and it has little to do with your AT (there are some who are like the posters in this thread that only look for certain types, but that's not the only approach... plenty of people like me just look for whoever is on and take whatever people want to bring. All Tanker teams can do great, same for Defenders, Controllers, etc. No need to be picky at all).

Anyway, some simple tips to help with finding teams:

1. Make global friends. Do this after you have teamed with someone a couple of times or if they make a really good impression. People have a lot of alts, and this guarantees you will be able to find them no matter what. This ensures you'll have a pool of reliable teammates, and probably someone that will play at the same times as you (something people can forget when looking for people).

2. Find an active SG. Easier to find teams this way. They are out there, so post in forums, track them down after teaming with them, etc.

3. Most importantly, join your server's channels. These have developed as the place for players on each server to hang out, post that they're about to start a mission, TF, etc. This makes things better and less scattershot than just broadcasting. It's also easier to get to know people here, as it uses their global name, not just the character they are on currently.

Case in point. I have had a couple of alts on Champion for Tanker Tuesdays, but never really noticed TFs or anything starting while playing there at odd times (Victory is my home server). If I were to go with that experience, I would wonder if not much is going on around Champion. But then I joined the main channels, and suddenly saw lots of chatter, TFs starting, etc. Channels are where the activity is at.

4. Form your own teams. Plenty of people are looking for teams, but fewer are willing to form their own. This is hardly a chore with our ability to bind, cut and paste, etc. Form a team message, and post it on your server's channels, and look for people using the search function. Doesn't take long, and it gets easier the more you do it. People like playing with people they know, and they'll get to know you.


Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc:
Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grey Pilgrim View Post
Finding teams is something people post about from time to time throughout the forums, and it has little to do with your AT (there are some who are like the posters in this thread that only look for certain types, but that's not the only approach... plenty of people like me just look for whoever is on and take whatever people want to bring. All Tanker teams can do great, same for Defenders, Controllers, etc. No need to be picky at all).
I assume this was partially directed at me and so I feel a need to explain my comment above a little better. If someone asks to join my team in response to me broadcasting a LFM call I'm not going to turn them away because of AT, similarly I tend to filter the search window for people with a LFT flag up and ask them if they want to join regardless of AT (unless their search comment describes them as a healer). The only time I care about AT is when I'm sending tells to people who don't have their LFT flag up. At that point the number of people available means I have to prioritize somehow so I'm going to start with the people who bring the most to the team and those people are the ATs that have the best force multipliers (i.e. Defenders and Controllers).

Quote:
4. Form your own teams. Plenty of people are looking for teams, but fewer are willing to form their own. This is hardly a chore with our ability to bind, cut and paste, etc. Form a team message, and post it on your server's channels, and look for people using the search function. Doesn't take long, and it gets easier the more you do it. People like playing with people they know, and they'll get to know you.
This is very true, making a team is a lot more reliable than trying to find one.


 

Posted

Ah, I generally don't prioritize on my mission teams, as I mostly just want to get a full team and keep it there. TFs are a different matter... I'll usually shout out for debuffs or a Tanker if needed, but most people are willing to swap characters if the team is lacking a bit. Even then, you don't have to be too picky with a lot of TFs. Newer TFs, though... yes, as the devs managed to make them a bit more challenge heavy.

At any rate, I was mostly saying that in general... some people tend to be AT snobs, and for no good reason. The great thing about CoX is about how you can make very diverse teams work. Just wanted to clarify for the OP.


Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc:
Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory

 

Posted

Everyone already said most of what I'd respond, but there is one thing:

Are you in the right zone? A 30 tank should not be in Atlas or SC shouting LFT. Sometimes I'll ask if they want to join my 15 or 25 team, but to them it means a loss of powers, so I often don't bother. Go to RWZ [and exemplar until you're 35] or get sidekicked in Talos. I really don't know where the correct zone for 30 is.

I'll agree that I'd rather have a controller than a tank. Tanks don't deal much damage and if I can get some aggro mitigation by lockdown, it makes it easier on me.

That said, 90% of the time I made my own team. If I shout LFT, I'm going to have other stuff planned like fretting around WW. Blind invites I always turn down. I have had horrible luck with them. I also turn down 90% of invites where they ask me to join their team. Granted, until recently I only ran radio mish teams, but I'm in a good SG now and I'm paying attention to the channels. My old SG was only farming, and I find it boring and feel I've missed some of the content by going up in levelling too fast.

Lastly, the name. This was mentioned before. A name is very important when a person is searching for players. I've had great luck with odd names like Coconut Infinity [my wp/elec tank] and Candyjet [ill/storm controller]. Anything that has illusions to curse words or leet speak, I won't tend to invite them. I fear their playstyle is like their naming. You can hit the random button for your costume, but if you have a horrible name, you get skipped.

Yeah, my solution is form your own team. Unfortunately, I'm not confident in my abilities to lead a TF team.

And for heaven sake, when teamed, don't be the "fast tank." I'll give you one star and never team with you again.


 

Posted

I took a lot of what was said in this thread and mulled it over.

I have a shield scrapper that I have been really enjoying so I thought I would start all over again on a shield tank and play him very differently than my scrapper... and team a lot more.

Within minutes I'm out of the gate with my new tank, doing what I can to see if a lowbie team is firing up. I end up on a Winter Lord team that is mostly high level people... in fact I'm the lowest.

Two people ended up dropping from the team which was full at the time. I make note of it and wonder if they dropped or we should get more?

A response I got from a blaster on the team was something to the effect of:
" OH NO! We lost a tank... Whatever will we do?!?!?"

He went on this sarcastic rant and I had to think about this thread. I realize it may have been his attempt at humour but I couldn't help notice the attitude he took was somewhat mirrored by the rest of the team.

I found this very disappointing and I didn't really say anything in the team window as I wanted to see how this opinion would be reflected in the team without my tainting the conversation.

I really don't know what changed. A game mechanic? A perception of ability? A population fall off?

Honestly I don't know, but I DO in fact recall how easy it was for my 30's tankers to find teams a year ago. I do recall being invited to 'tank'. It was a sought out ability at the time and since I came back from a long break I have a very strong understanding of the difference now from a year ago.

Some of you are suggesting I don't know how to look for a team. I concede that I may not being looking for a team in the most efficient manner possible and I WILL change that; however, it is still a fact I don't have to try that hard for any other toon I have been firing up since my return to this -great- game. (Though it should be noted the tank is the only 31 level character I tried teaming with, every other toon is level 29 or under).

So I will take some of your suggestions and I might just be experiencing 'bad luck' on this as well.


Nekron: Beam Rifle / Poison Corruptor and Slayer of Evil!! (Exalted)
Intergalaktic: Fire / Time Corruptor (Exalted)

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by _Elektro_ View Post
A response I got from a blaster on the team was something to the effect of:
" OH NO! We lost a tank... Whatever will we do?!?!?"

He went on this sarcastic rant and I had to think about this thread. I realize it may have been his attempt at humour but I couldn't help notice the attitude he took was somewhat mirrored by the rest of the team.

I found this very disappointing and I didn't really say anything in the team window as I wanted to see how this opinion would be reflected in the team without my tainting the conversation.

I really don't know what changed. A game mechanic? A perception of ability? A population fall off?
The problem is that this game doesn't rely on the Tank/Healer/DPS team balance metric that other MMOs do. Unfortunately some people don't realize this and insist on trying to build teams that way. This produces a backlash from people like the blaster you mentioned who go out of their way to bash on the very concept of ever doing a Tank/Healer/DPS team in CoX. Of course most sane people take the middle road and will utilize a Tank/Healer/DPS style team if they get one but are neither going to specifically seek it out nor actively avoid it.

As for why you're getting fewer invites than a year ago, I think it represents a shift in the attitudes of the player base. More and more people are realizing that a Tank is not necessary for most content so they aren't specifically seeking one out. You should still be able to get teams but you'll probably have to go to them rather than waiting for them to ask you. As others have said, join global channels, set your LFT flag and keep an eye on broadcast in level appropriate zones.


 

Posted

I wonder if the soft-capped scrappers essentially ended the "Tank/Emp/Damage" model. For some content, it's difficult to do without a tank. However, early in the game most have the same defenses (none). Mid-game, tanks gain better defenses but fall behind in damage. By the late stage of the game, when the tank can shine, the damage dealers hit the "Mob? What mob?" mode when they can take many mobs out in ten seconds or less.

In the same sense, the Emp is often shrugged off. Lower level, you HPs are so low, you may die with or without the Emp (though CM vs. CoT is a gamesaver). Upper level, most folks have their self heals or such to off-set the damage they may take with battles that last longer than 10-15 seconds.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Adeon Hawkwood View Post
The problem is that this game doesn't rely on the Tank/Healer/DPS team balance metric that other MMOs do.

Agreed, however based on my personal experiences a team that has that "balance" will be smoother and more efficient. Of course YMMV.


Global @radubadu
Usually playing one of the following toons blueside on Virtue:
Cadler 50 WP/SS tanker
Radubadu 46 Fire/Fire blaster
Hell Runner 35 Fire/Fire brute

 

Posted

Re: WL

The difficulty is dynamic. I've talken a level 5 in there and only gotten wiped out a few times. The reason for teaming is...I guess to have your hp spread bigger or something?

I've also taken a 2 into a zombie fest and didn't die once.

I don't see the point in teaming for that.

Teaming for Rikti, that's another matter. Badges.


 

Posted

Elektro, there's no real rhyme or reason to getting invited. It doesn't matter who I'm playing, I'll get random tells sometimes (or tells from people I know), other times I don't. It really doesn't have bearing on the character I'm playing, either. It happens with Scrappers, Blasters, Tankers, etc.

Your experience is anecdotal, as is mine. But through all the posting and attitudes I've seen, there are some that are picky and some that aren't, and it's going to come out in a wash. Just play and have fun, and don't let other people dictate your fun.


Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc:
Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory