Do your characters care about the storyline?


Arilou

 

Posted

I play this game for the visuals and the story and the interactivity with both.

My character identities _must_ interweave with the existing story or the game might as well be any of the bland generic FPS's where the plot may well have come from a Christmas cracker.

I have no desire to build a world myself, I can (and do) do that but I come to this game to relax. I want to be told a story and have enough latitude to weave in and out of it as I wish. I want to be part of a story and a setting bigger than me and my imagination... mostly so I can give it a well earned rest.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
If you completely ignored the game's plot, would your characters and their actions still make sense in the game's existing setting?

If a piece of story required your character to feel a certain way or perform a certain action that goes against their concept, what would you do about it?
To answer your further questions I simply don't see this game's core "story" or "plot" as the same one that my characters exist in.

Yes NPCs like Statesman and Lord Reculse are running around doing things in the game world. And yes my characters do things like TFs and trials that involve some of the NPCs of the world. But none of my character concepts rely on those interactions as a basis for their existence.

Most missions are generic enough that if the "text" of the mission doesn't really fit my character I'll just gloss over the details. Most of my RPing takes place with other players directly or in Mission Architect arcs. As I said before the game's general "setting" is just a sandbox for doing what I want, not what it dictates.

I have nothing against people who like to envision their characters directly as "Statesman's sidekick" or as "Arachnos agents" or the like. I just find no personal enjoyment shoehorning my characters to match those things.


Loth 50 Fire/Rad Controller [1392 Badges] [300 non-AE Souvenirs]
Ryver 50 Ele� Blaster [1392 Badges]
Silandra 50 Peacebringer [1138 Badges] [No Redside Badges]
--{=====> Virtue ♀

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post

Let's see if I can't refine the question a tad:

If you completely ignored the game's plot, would your characters and their actions still make sense in the game's existing setting?

If a piece of story required your character to feel a certain way or perform a certain action that goes against their concept, what would you do about it?
1) Possibly, but far less likely than if they didn't. I see no really good reasons to ignore the games plot, as it were. EXCEPT;

2) Bad writing, like the Origins of Power and the Puddle of Annoyance, get summararily ignored for being dross. Source of the CoH-verse powers through time and space? Ok, it's a Mcguffin that is easy enough to not have to mention, no worries.
It is the only thing that ALLOWS me to have more power, and I have to bow and scrape to get that? I think bloody NOT!

So, yeah, thems me views


Quote:
Originally Posted by Zwillinger View Post
GG, I would tell you that "I am killing you with my mind", but I couldn't find an emoticon to properly express my sentiment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Photon View Post
NOTE: The Incarnate System is basically farming for IOs on a larger scale, and with more obtrusive lore.

 

Posted

I don't think my heroes could call themselves heroes if they ignored the things going on in the world around them. However, at the same time, my characters realize there are thousands of other heroes in the city who can see to certain threats. I generally asign my characters to certain areas. For example, one is assisting with the Praetorian War, one with the Rikti situation, and another tends to take on street level crime while most of the cities heores are tied up in interdimensional war.

I, as the player, will sometimes ignore things that happen in game. Rikti invasions are a good example of this. If I am on my way to a mission and a Rikti invasion starts, everyone of my characters would stop to help fend of the invaders. What hero wouldn't? But if I am deeply involved in a story arc, I will pretend the Rikti invasion simply is not happening at that moment.

Another example: When I am doing my marketing in Steel Canyon, I am moving from WWs to the University, to AE to get salvage. Along the way I see hundreds of crimes. Since I consider marketing an OOC activity, I do not stop to assist the citizens in distress because as I see it, I am not really playing my character at that moment. On the other hand, if I see a purse snatching on my way to a mission or to my SG base, I will stop, even on my level 50 hero, and stop the crime.

So to answer your question, yes my characters care about the storyline and the things happening in the game world, but sometimes I do not.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Memphis_Bill View Post
Depends on the character. Most do, to some extent. VEATs ignore their craptastic "special" storyline though.
Ooh, that too.
Webmaster Commander Marian King is head of an Arachnos Regiment. They are loyal and frankly enjoy being the NOT so standard minions. When you need cannon fodder, use the grunts. When you want someone dead? You send the Krimzon Guard.

Also, fully agree with people naysaying (rightly) people who tie their characters stories directly into canon Big NPCs. You know 'Son of Mako' or 'First cousin twice removed of Scirroco' kind of junk.

King, as an example, does have interaction with Recluse, as has been shown in fiction chunks for her. The interaction boils down to;
1) He's the boss. She follows his orders
2) She's a minion. A tough one but, frankly, he could annihilate her if he so chose
3) The KG are good at their job. Which means they get all the tough gigs.

It works, I think. The other members and Union RPers seem to have no objections either, which given some of them sits well with me

Edit: Also, agreed with the 'game plot happened, but 'Someone else did it''. I.E. 'Someone' destroyed the Psychronometron in Faultline with the help of Penny Yin. But it happened. None of my chars were directly involved.
They have helped fight back Arachnos and Sky Raiders while keeping the peace, however, along with beating up high ranking Arachnos and Raider personnel. It's very easy to edit writing slightly to avoid god-moding the game.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Zwillinger View Post
GG, I would tell you that "I am killing you with my mind", but I couldn't find an emoticon to properly express my sentiment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Photon View Post
NOTE: The Incarnate System is basically farming for IOs on a larger scale, and with more obtrusive lore.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by BrandX View Post
Taking on Longbow becomes a bit different. But then, I don't add things to the Longbow, like...you know...them attacking innocent civilians (which I still have yet to see any Longbow NPC do...who knows maybe the devs will change that at some point).
I can't say how the Arbiters feel about things (I suspect that they don't actually give a hang) but in the USA, it's not a criminal offense to simply be a member of a gang.

When Longbow comes down the street, broadcasting their "we're the only people who know what this world REALLY needs" arrogance and turning their flamethrowers on people who are doing nothing more than lounging on a wall or standing on a corner having a conversation, all while talking down to those same people and/or insulting them, then they are, in fact, attacking innocent civilians.

You can justify by saying "Yeah, but I just know that they were going to be breaking into that pawn shop as soon as my back was turned", which would fly just fine with Longbow but which any non-corrupt Judge would throw out of his courtroom.

Most/all of the gang bangers in the Isles are immigrants, or so it appears. They aren't citizens, though I'd look askance at the characterization of them as being something other than civilians. Either way, like I said, I don't the Arbiters actually care a whole lot, so it's not really an issue from anything other than a moral standpoint.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
I'm seeing some very interesting replies so far, and it's confirming what I suspected - most people integrate their characters into the story to a greater extent than I do. It's a bit surprising that so many make standalone characters that don't directly relate to City of Heroes, though. That I hadn't expected.

Let's see if I can't refine the question a tad:

If you completely ignored the game's plot, would your characters and their actions still make sense in the game's existing setting?

If a piece of story required your character to feel a certain way or perform a certain action that goes against their concept, what would you do about it?
I'm not really sure how to answer that, since plot really creates settings. Most of my characters care, to a greater or lesser extent, although only one couldn't really exist outside the game world as defined; that one being the result of Shivan goo bonding to a fresh corpse, losing her memories as a result and being re-taught by Longbow.


 

Posted

It all depends on the character.

Some are intimately tied to the story, while others couldn't care less.

For example, I have five characters who are "loyal" Praetorians (one, Over Seer, is actually very deep cover for the Resistance). They deeply care about the Praetorian storyline, but now that they are on Primal Earth, I am needing to do some mental gymnastics to explain what they are doing in Paragon City until Cole's invasion when they rejoin his forces and betray Paragon City.

I have other characters whose concepts required them to be heroes with villain archetypes, so they sped through Praetoria so they could be part of the story of Paragon City like they were supposed to be (I may reroll Lady Warhawk with I21, as I haven't had the chance to get her out of Praetoria yet and Street Justice may be the set she is looking for).

With all of my characters, it is really their personal stories I am concerned about, and I tend to pick the missions and content that would appeal to them. I have the hardest time of this with Villains, because most of the contacts treat you like a lackey, and most of my villains wouldn't stand for that. Many of the new villain contacts, who either treat you as an equal or grovel at your feet, are a step in the right direction (there are other problems, though, like many of my characters have no desire to see themselves cloned once, much less create a clone army of themselves).


New story arcs coming soon (ARC IDs will be aded when I finish the arc):
So, you want to join the Hellions? (level 1-14 Villainous arc)
Sparks & Steel (level 5-20 Heroic arc)
and
So you want to join the Skulls? (level 1-14 Villainous arc)

 

Posted

Sam, it saddens me to hear you don't try to play in the game world. That is to say, it's not bad or wrong that you just play *with* the game world rather than *in* but it's just depressing. Like how AE is majorly used to farm (heck even i occasionally farm in the 30s for cash for basic IOs).

For me, I can't say all my characters 'care' about the overarching story but the general feel, yes. When I make a character whose nemesis is the Council or Carnival, I aim their wrath that way. Some of my characters are affiliated with in-game groups or are conceptual figure heads for specific origin/power types so they'll literally have their hands in anything involving tech or thr Tsoo.

Since all of my characters are linked somehow, then theres some links to the game if not directly, then indirectly.

BUT...even though i do this, i keep the background loose enough (or have back up to the background) so in any instant i want to write a book or create something using these characters, i can erase any traces of CoX to avoid legal issues.


 

Posted

I write a brief background for all my heroes. A number came from the ruins of Baumtown, and their stories were set in motion by the initial Rikti invasion. Others are aliens responding to the crisis on Earth, but for them, the crisis is the ascendency of what we know as the Circle of Thorns, since they have battled the equivalent organizations and their Satanic allies on their own worlds.

And so on. To that extent, my heroes are involved in the story.

The story and I have parted company where things got goofy and weirded out. When I am gravely told about various things that are goofy, I just cover my ears and hum. Never happened. If signing on to such goofy lore is a prerequisite to content, I do not proceed with the content.


"How do you know you are on the side of good?" a Paragon citizen asked him. "How can we even know what is 'good'?"

"The Most High has spoken, even with His own blood," Melancton replied. "Surely we know."

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
I'm seeing some very interesting replies so far, and it's confirming what I suspected - most people integrate their characters into the story to a greater extent than I do. It's a bit surprising that so many make standalone characters that don't directly relate to City of Heroes, though. That I hadn't expected.

Let's see if I can't refine the question a tad:

If you completely ignored the game's plot, would your characters and their actions still make sense in the game's existing setting?
Most of my characters could probably do what they do independent of the established storyline. I could easily come up with alternate stories and enemies they could be fighting instead of Arachnos or the Legacy Chain.

I don't do this, however, so that I can stay involved in and engaged in the missions I am playing. The first character I run any new content with has their story adjusted to fit the new content. Once I know the story and how it turns out, I only run characters who would care about that particular plot through that story.

By keeping their stories tied to the game world, and taking my characters' motivations into account, I keep the game fresh for me after seven years and 150+ alts (with more on the way, CURSE YOU I21!!!!).

Quote:
If a piece of story required your character to feel a certain way or perform a certain action that goes against their concept, what would you do about it?
I try not to do this. If a story arc would run counter to the character's motives, I try to avoid it unless I absolutely need to in order to get to the story they need to do. I.e.; Peter Themari - Nicholas Scratch could care less about the Longbow incursion into the Rogue Isles. His aspirations go far beyond Lord Recluse's little domain. Corrupting the soul of an innocent and turning that hero down the path to Evil? Oh, yes, Nicholas Scratch NEEDS to be a part of that (he is a devil, after all, it is his nature to befoul all he touches).

I have some fairly generic heroes and villains. I try to run through new content with them first, as there is less chance I will be blindsided with a twist after I have begun the arc. I wish I had done Willy Wheeler's arc the first time with a different villain than Black IC. I figured out that Willy was a dupe who was working for a hero by the end of the second mission. Black IC would have turned Willy over to Arachnos then and there (or killed him). Instead, I had to do some mental gymnastics to explain why Black IC continued to play along (she did contact Arachnos, and was hired by them to continue on and see how deep it went and determine if Arachnos was being betrayed from within or if it was an outside agent).


New story arcs coming soon (ARC IDs will be aded when I finish the arc):
So, you want to join the Hellions? (level 1-14 Villainous arc)
Sparks & Steel (level 5-20 Heroic arc)
and
So you want to join the Skulls? (level 1-14 Villainous arc)

 

Posted

Mine don't all care about the over-all City plot, but given that I do see them as existing in the same basic setting as that story and its characters, I often use City NPCs and lore as a part of their backgrounds or basic concepts... I wouldn't presume to make someone of mine Statesman's long-lost sister or anything like that, but I don't see anything wrong with working bits and pieces of the world into my crew. It gives them more context, I think, and a more solid foundation *as* CoX protagonists.

I do things like making Mei a Nemesis operative, for instance... Palrah works for Vanguard. Shade was a Praetorian PD officer before she was drafted into the Powers Division. Mister Bibbles is the feline familiar of a Cabal witch. Mister Mistoffolees served a similar role for a Legacy Chain sorcerer. Kestrel still works for Scirocco. That sort of thing.... I don't let City's story limit what I do, particularly, and I'm perfectly willing to play a little fast and loose with established canon to make something work (For example, creating an entire species of Shard-native Rularuu bird-things-), but I like having connections between my characters and the established world.

As for City missions that go "against character"... There have definitely been a few of those. (See my post in the "emotional impact" thread re: Kes and Scir's patron arc for just one example-) I usually still run them with the characters. Sometimes I consider them IC and just deal with the railroading as "unavoidable circumstances"... Other times I just write it off as OOC and don't worry about it. As much as I like my characters as characters, I also like playing the game as a game.

That said... I have avoided contacts (Phipps you jerk, I'm looking at you. >_>) and auto-completed missions a few times when they seemed particularly "off" for someone. It's just not my typical response.


@Brightfires - @Talisander
That chick what plays the bird-things...

 

Posted

My characters fall into two categories; those I created before ever playing CoH, and those I created FOR CoH.

Ironically, the bulk of my characters created prior to ever seeing this game have been adapted in a way that makes the game setting, and in some cases, specific storylines, intergral to their existence.

My main toon, Kavik the Wolf Boy, was an agent of a secret branch of the U.S. military in his original continuity. On Primal Earth, he's part of the Vanguard, and worked closely with Dark Watcher once his 'security clearence level' was high enough. The original version is a werewolf seeking the origins of lycanthropy, but he doesn't believe in magic and tries to disprove or rationalize all known instances of magic. This translated in CoH into his desire to shut down the Tsoo, CoT, and BP, as they are dangerously depleting the natural energies of the Earth / Universe, by his understanding of how magic works. As a werewolf he took special interest in the Council to the abominations they often created in the name of science, an element of the character unique to this setting.

Kavik eventually traveled to the Shadow Shard with Dark Watcher on one of the many frontline initiatives during the Coming Storm, but was lost in that realm for several years. While there the energies of that reality changed him, and when one of Rularuu's aspects was killed in battle with Earth's heroes, Rularuu tried to transform Kavik's new body into a suitable host for a replacement aspect. To avoid this Kavik went back in time to before the Coming Storm and merged with his former self, but this just gave the present-day Rularuu a foothold on Earth, so every time Kavik uses his new cosmic (Incarnate) powers, he loses more of his humanity. This all came from a need to justify a werewolf that could go toe-to-toe with god-level foes, but was also vaguely inspired by a Lovecraftian plot I'd subjected the original character to, years ago.

On the other hand, his Praetorian Earth counterpart wound up living in the Tunnels, and was eventually rounded up for experimentation by Neuron, becoming Kavik the Ghoul Boy. When the Resistance freed him he joined their cause, and adopted a very black and white view of morality. Now that he lives on Primal Earth, he even feels that Kavik the Wolf Boy is little better than the scum he fights, due to the primal toon being a vigilante willing to work with villains on Vanguard assignments.

Other characters, like Kid Kilovolt, are simply superheroes with back-stories completely unrelated to anything going on in paragon City, the Rogue Isles, or Praetoria. KK operates in Paragon City because that happens to be where the action is. His Praetorian counterpart the Kilovolt Kid is a willing member of Powers Division, but really he isn't so much loyal to a cause as he is working with whatever 'system' is in place to uphold laws and catch criminals. Neither version of KK relies on CoH lore for their origins or motivations.


 

Posted

Most of my characters, especially the first few to run through a certain set of content (CoH, CoV, Praetoria), are pretty integrated into the setting. They did those things that the missions say, if perhaps not quite how the mission text has them react; those events and experiences are blocks of foundation around which I weave their personal stories, through their reactions. If there are things that character would not do or contacts they would not work with, I don't.

Later characters tend to eschew running official content (yet again) in favor of more generic and/or player-created content - other people's missions (that I can include or ignore in "my story" as I wish), radio and tip missions (ditto; plus, as they're more generic, I can weave my own narrative around them), and the occasional AE arc when someone in my circle is motivated to write one. Official arcs that are fun and/or fundamental enough to that character may get played. And of course, there's no-combat sitting-around-the-base RP to fill in the gaps.

I believe I play this way, in these two different styles, to minimize not only boredom with running the same arc(s) on yet another alt, but also implausibility. Many arcs are fixed in or assume a certain frame of time - quite a lot of them, in fact, only make sense if this was still '04 or '05, shortly after the game's launch, when things like the true nature of the Rikti, or Crey, or Nemesis, or the Malta Group, or Oroborous were not open secrets to most of the super-powered population. It's a bit silly to have Agent McQueen congratulate you on preventing a second Rikti invasion while dropships cruise through the skies of Founders Falls. A character I create today is not going to be the one to reveal the Clockwork aren't really robots, or uncover the connection between the Sky Raiders and Nemesis, or deliver the cannisters that start the Outbreak. Someone else did those things, years ago.

Then there's the stuff I ignore outright, like the official background of AE (you expect me to stick my head in this thing? how stupid do you think I am? no, really) or the Origin of Power arc (just bad writing) or the VEAT arc (ditto). And while some of my Incarnates are following the canon path, others are coming into the power or potential they've always had through other means and/or as it becomes possible to represent that in-game.


My characters at Virtueverse
Faces of the City

 

Posted

Depends.

Fortunate Daughter, my fortunata (heh) is an Arachnos lackey and likes it that way. (she's possibly not too terribly bright) she'll gladly fight whoever Lord Recluse tells her too, while simultaneously not feeling any animosity: It's a job, and she'll gladly hang out with the people she just tried to murder while on duty. To her the Praetorians are just another "beat up" people. Although she did spend a couple of missions in Praetoria.

Most of my heroes aren't directly involved with the story, but it does affect them: They want to defend their world against whatever threatens them. The coming Storm, Praetoria... It's not personal, but they are threats to be fought, for the safety of Primal Earth.

My Praetorians tends to be the ones most intertwined with the story, obviously.


"Men strunt �r strunt och snus �r snus
om ock i gyllne dosor.
Och rosor i ett sprucket krus
�r st�ndigt alltid rosor."

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
If you completely ignored the game's plot, would your characters and their actions still make sense in the game's existing setting?

If a piece of story required your character to feel a certain way or perform a certain action that goes against their concept, what would you do about it?
All of my characters would be fully realized heroes, villains, or whatevers in a game that doesn't have the CoH as a backdrop, except perhaps the ones I made specifically as Praetorian counterparts to my existing characters.

Okay, I do have Fitheal, a leprechaun who came to America to help his old friend Snaptooth and fight the snakes, firbolg, and everyone that Snaptooth told Fitheal was after his gold (pretty much every NPC group in-game, according to Snappy). I would not have created him were it not to be an ally to the Redcaps. And as such, I did take him blueside to do the Croatoa content, even though a lot of it has him fighting redcaps. For Fitheal, it was all about simple greed. Even redcaps can't be fully trusted when there's gold to hoard. I would definitely NOT play him in a fantasy game, or DCUO or Champions Online, or any other venue that doesn't include something similar to the sinister redcaps and their intrusion into modern society.


 

Posted

I spend too much time thinking and writing down my characters' concepts, back stories, etc. that I cannot even begin to imagine 'locking' myself into the CoX world; there's just not enough in it for me.

Mind you, this is a personal state of mind/opinion. I'm a fantasy/magic heavy guy and while I do enjoy some science and technology based stories/worlds, I have a tendency to lock myself on the magic/fantasy side.

Basically, what I'm trying to put here is that the CoX world has too much science for most of my concepts, while, at the same time, not having enough magic for them.

So, while I, as a player, do enjoy the story and the world put into being by the developers, my characters, on the other hand, have very minor interactions (if any), in terms of back stories and whatnot, with the plot of the game, or whatever mission I'm running.

I mostly try to find a way/reason for my characters to 'end up' in Paragon City/the Rogue Isles and that's pretty much it in terms of 'playing the CoX story as the character'.