I'm a Mastermind and a Master Jerk!


Adeon Hawkwood

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Candlestick View Post
When the team is steamrolling, and taking no damage, and everything is fine, do I bubble? No. Waste of time. They don't need it if nobody is taking damage.

But when the **** hits the fan, teammates start dropping, and the team is having difficulty? You best be buffing.
This is reasonable.


T. Hayes
@The Cleansing

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
My pets are what is going to keep me, a TANKERMIND, alive. Let's do some math. i'll keep the numbers estimated and enhanced as I do in my build:

Tough: 18% resist s/l
Temp Invuln:48% s/l
Total: 66% resist s/l

Bodyguard Mode:
6 pets mean I take 2/8 = 1/4 = 25%

This means, I get effectively 75% resist to all.

The toggles don't stack, but they do help.

So, lets say a baddie smacks me for 400 Damage. Ouch!

Good thing I have minions on Def/Follow, so I instead take 100 Damage. Much better!

But wait, what if it was a freak show tank or the like giving me that stomping? It would then me Smashing or Lethal damage, right? CORRECT!

So, 400 damage... resist 66% (400*.34)= 136

Now, BG Mode distributes the damage: 136 damage and resist 75% (135*.25)= 68


I just turned 400 damage into 68 damage.

Did I mention that I'm a Tankermind?

You are dismissed.
If you get on a team that has a Brute built to take lead or a Tanker, you will not be asked nor expected to tank for the whole team. The team will see you as a mastermind, and as such, expect you to play the role of a normal mastermind: Using your pets as damage and providing buffs/debuffs as determined by your secondary. Tankermind? Fantastic. A team will still expect you to do otherwise, and will probably get pretty cross if you run in and show up the actual tank.

If I was on any of my heavy defense Brutes/any Tanker I play and had an MM run in, I'd ask him to knock it off and let me do my job. No one wants their role on a team invalidated by you just because you can.


My guides:Dark Melee/Dark Armor/Soul Mastery, Illusion Control/Kinetics/Primal Forces Mastery, Electric Armor
"Dark Armor is a complete waste as a tanking set."

 

Posted

More raging plz. Sounds like Tank envy, Nalrok_AthZim.

You know, the funny thing is, I haven't had a single tank or brute complain about me being in melee with them. I guess they like my big bubble or leaderships or something. IDK. Confuses the hell out of me...


T. Hayes
@The Cleansing

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
More raging plz. Sounds like Tank envy, Nalrok_AthZim.
I'm not raging, I'm telling you what I'd do in the situation. And why exactly would I have Tank envy? My Dark/Dark is nigh-impossible to stop (note: stop, not kill, I use Soul Transfer with great pride) and my Stone/EM is impossible to kill. If the team has a character that can easily fill a specific role, why do it for them? Do you ever see Defenders trying to outdamage Corruptors? (I know that's not an everyday thing but I'm just making a point.)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
You know, the funny thing is, I haven't had a single tank or brute complain about me being in melee with them. I guess they like my big bubble or leaderships or something. IDK. Confuses the hell out of me...
Do you run in with them or before them?


My guides:Dark Melee/Dark Armor/Soul Mastery, Illusion Control/Kinetics/Primal Forces Mastery, Electric Armor
"Dark Armor is a complete waste as a tanking set."

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
My pets are what is going to keep me, a TANKERMIND, alive.
Problem #1: You think it's about you.

Cooperative Attitude: Missing.

Quote:
Let's do some math.
Incorrectly set-up math problems lead to incorrect results.

Interogative: If you're so great, why was the rest of the team having problems? Obviously, you weren't able to hold aggro if the other MM kept dying, were you?


Quote:
Did I mention that I'm a Tankermind?

Repeatedly. And you obviously can't play it well, either, or your teammates would not be having a big argument about getting some defense, would they? Maybe, just maybe, they were on to something there and you are just not seeing reality.

Show me the math that explains why you couldn't hold aggro, kid. Then we'll talk how to fix it.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Candlestick View Post
When the team is steamrolling, and taking no damage, and everything is fine, do I bubble? No. Waste of time. They don't need it if nobody is taking damage.

But when the **** hits the fan, teammates start dropping, and the team is having difficulty? You best be buffing.
This is reasonable.
This makes no sense to me as a Ninja/FF/Mace Tankermind myself. Bubbles are proactive, you want them on the team BEFORE **** hits the fan. When **** does hit the fan, you want to be spamming Force Bolt, Repulsion Bomb, and Provoke (as a Tankermind), not buffing. Particularly with the way that ambushes have been coming in GR, this mentality isn't reasonable to me at all.

And as a highly active Nin/FF/Mace bubbler that uses Provoke, Force Bubble, Repulsion Bomb, bow attacks, command macros, and more during combat, the only way that you are not finding time to consistently buff all of your pets as well as buffing most of the team is that you are being lazy or flat out refusing to do such, which is what the OP basically stated.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by JuliusSeizure View Post
This makes no sense to me as a Ninja/FF/Mace Tankermind myself. Bubbles are proactive, you want them on the team BEFORE **** hits the fan. When **** does hit the fan, you want to be spamming Force Bolt, Repulsion Bomb, and Provoke (as a Tankermind), not buffing. Particularly with the way that ambushes have been coming in GR, this mentality isn't reasonable to me at all.

And as a highly active Nin/FF/Mace bubbler that uses Provoke, Force Bubble, Repulsion Bomb, bow attacks, command macros, and more during combat, the only way that you are not finding time to consistently buff all of your pets as well as buffing most of the team is that you are being lazy or flat out refusing to do such, which is what the OP basically stated.
The thing is, usually you can tell when the team is going to start having problems. I rarely see a team go from steamrolling, taking no damage, to all of a sudden, bam, teamwipe. There are indicators to this sort of thing. A Dominator goes AFK, or leaves the team, which causes incoming damage to skyrocket. That Thermal corrupter leaves, taking his buffs with you. You notice peoples health bars start yo-yoing. It's at this point you need to start buffing.


::edit::

But I do agree. A Nin/FF is not exactly a highly active MM set. You generally have plenty of time to buff, and quite frankly, I don't see a reason why you shouldn't be.


 

Posted

I think I would just tell the team that you are a tankermind, and your primary goal is dishing damage and taking in damage and it is fair. Also, forget about it negative players. Usually I find most whiners are actually players who believe that they are good, but actually play terribly. I hope you do bubble prior to AV/HERO fights or in special situations, but I think it's fine overall not to bubble everyone, expecially the brute or tank (if they are half decent, they won't need bubbles except at early levels). Pets running wild can actually be one of the most dangerous things on a team in some cases, so better to control their leash.

Of course, I could argue that a good MM should be able to bubble and control the pets and tankermind ;-P, but a good tank and a good brute should not need a bubble. I bubble squishies and only bubble the tanks/brutes prior to big battles or in early lvls.

P.S. Make your bubbles super bright red or green and then people will not ask for them as much. Make them dark grey and they are barely seen, so people will not notice they are on or off much. Either strategy works pretty well actually for bubble/player relations.

Cheers


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Candlestick View Post
The thing is, usually you can tell when the team is going to start having problems. I rarely see a team go from steamrolling, taking no damage, to all of a sudden, bam, teamwipe. There are indicators to this sort of thing. A Dominator goes AFK, or leaves the team, which causes incoming damage to skyrocket. That Thermal corrupter leaves, taking his buffs with you. You notice peoples health bars start yo-yoing. It's at this point you need to start buffing.

This to me sounds like some one who has actually been on a team and bothered to notice someone's situation besides their own.

Working Brain: Engaged.


Quote:
But I do agree. A Nin/FF is not exactly a highly active MM set. You generally have plenty of time to buff, and quite frankly, I don't see a reason why you shouldn't be.

Robots too. Buff up, run next to spawn, put Assault Bot and Battle Drones on aggressive. Works even on Task Forces/Strike Forces 90% of the time. The middle of a fight is actually an excellent time to buff because I'm usually doing nothing except scanning for problems. Once a team is buffed and I'm hovering over the lead tank/brute with Dispersion Bubble, problems magically vanish.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Candlestick View Post
The thing is, usually you can tell when the team is going to start having problems. I rarely see a team go from steamrolling, taking no damage, to all of a sudden, bam, teamwipe. There are indicators to this sort of thing. A Dominator goes AFK, or leaves the team, which causes incoming damage to skyrocket. That Thermal corrupter leaves, taking his buffs with you. You notice peoples health bars start yo-yoing. It's at this point you need to start buffing.
I think that's reasonable, and it's a format that ANY buffer should follow.

What I don't think is reasonable is the idea that Corruptors and Defenders should buff the team but a Mastermind should not. Let me pose these questions:
  • How much DPS does a Corruptor or Defender contribute to the team while buffing/healing mid combat?
  • How much DPS does a Mastermind lose while buffing/healing mid combat?
There is a drastic drop in offense for Corruptors and Defenders while buffing-- it basically goes to 0 as long as they are animating a buff/heal. Meanwhile, a Mastermind loses very little by making even a remotely conserted effort to keep a team buffed because the pets provide most of this AT's DPS and agro. You can effectively be one of the highest damage dealers and draw significant agro while just standing in the middle of a spawn tossing around bubbles. No other AT can do this, so why limit yourself and your team?


 

Posted

I feel so liberated on my Bot/FF mastermind because I don't have to constantly swap between firing attacks and putting shields on my teammates. Since my bots are doing damage, I'm free to keep their health topped off and keep shields on my fellow players and my pets.

I'd say it is easier to keep bubbles up on everyone as a mastermind than as a defender or controller.


Queen of the Amazons, WP/DB
Sound Judgement Son/Son
Cobra Lily Plant/Kin
Celestia, FF/Psy
Nefertiri, Storm/Elec
Pixie, Ill/Rad
Guardian Server

 

Posted

I have a no nonsense attitude towards villain ATs that don't buff. I give them no nonsense. Evil doers don't care unless there is something in it for them.
If you come to hero side then the concern counts when concern is needed to be had. Are people dying around you? Are people slower without your buffs? Are you always finding other ways to contribute, including saying something funny?


He will honor his words; he will definitely carry out his actions. What he promises he will fulfill. He does not care about his bodily self, putting his life and death aside to come forward for another's troubled besiegement. He does not boast about his ability, or shamelessly extol his own virtues. - Sima Qian.

 

Posted

MM's should have a macro saying "full time buffs on teammates as long as there are full time buffs on my pets".

Thank you!


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazuo_Kiriyama View Post
The goal is to be able to enjoy playing my MM without having to divert my attention to something a defender, corrupter, or controller can do.
Defenders? Sure, they have the highest modifier for the powers, but the more bubbles the better, right?

Controllers? No my friend, it's their secondary too. Between a controller or a MM I'd place the buffing hat on the MM as they have more free time than a controller.

Corrupters? As above with controllers--the MM has, or can make, more free time.

So what you are essentially saying to a team leader is, "Hey, if you want buffs, kick me and grab someone else because I think it's their responsibility."

I don't think that was your intent, but that's how it came across to me. Having played a Thugs/FFer up into the 40s I understand your pain. Playing a FFer on a 8 person team is hard let alone having the 6 additional sets of buffs to contend with. Before joining a team I'd always ask the lead what they expected me to do. Most said, "I don't care, kill things" or "Take alphas". If they said, "Buff" I'd refuse the invite. Knowing what the expectations are can prevent a lot of bad feelings.


 

Posted

I know how you feel and trust me it is not something that is limited to MMs. I tend to shy away from buffing sets with my MMS.. My 50 level Thugs has DM as a secondary and so does my 49 level Demon Summoner. I've even told people I hope you have awakes because my Rez is one nasty disorienter and when its recharges I use it. So the chances it will be available if you face plant are slim.

However I have played a LOT of controllers and defenders and just love dealing with players that obviously have no clue how hard it is to keep an entire 8 man team buffed or even what powers you have available. I had a Blaster SCREAM at my ILL/EMP for Clear Mind almost constantly in a mission full of Lost Bosses. Until I finally sent him a tell and informed him that ..
1) I am the only player on the team that I can't buff and half the time while your screaming for help I am being held myself and I am out or breakfrees and

2) At this level CM isn't even available to me yet so you are screaming for a power I couldn't give you if I wanted to.

When I team with whatever I try to take care of my team mates as best I can. Hey as long as I'm alive and have 7 other team mates around me I can always re summon a pet/minon. I have never played a FF but I have Thermals and a Kin and trying to keep everyone on fire can be tricky and even tiring after a while. It's easy for a Blaster to stand there doing nothing but clicking one attack after another to scream for MORE CM, MORE FORT.. all they need to do is worry about the target in front of them and which one to target next. I'm trying to keep 7 targets buffed and at times they are scattered to the point where the only way to get to some of them is to rush THROUGH a mob and hope I survive. Ummm guess what depending on where most of the team is .. If that means the Scrapper that decided to rush ahead and aggro his own private mob dies while I keep the other 6 team mates alive then Scrappy better have some GOOD respites cause I am staying with the TEAM.


�We�re always the good guys. In D&D, we�re lawful good. In City of Heroes we�re the heroes. In Grand Theft Auto we pay the prostitutes promptly and never hit them with a bat.� � Leonard
�Those women are prostitutes? You said they were raising money for stem cell research!� � Sheldon

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Talen Lee View Post
Who teams with masterminds?
....Henchmen?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hockeypuckhead View Post
MM's should have a macro saying "full time buffs on teammates as long as there are full time buffs on my pets".

Thank you!
I support this.

You want the full attention of my buffs? Then pony up.


Where to now?
Check out all my guides and fiction pieces on my blog.
The MFing Warshade | The Last Rule of Tanking | The Got Dam Mastermind
Everything Dark Armor | The Softcap
don'T attempt to read tHis mEssaGe, And believe Me, it is not a codE.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wicked_Wendy View Post
I know how you feel and trust me it is not something that is limited to MMs. I tend to shy away from buffing sets with my MMS.. My 50 level Thugs has DM as a secondary and so does my 49 level Demon Summoner. I've even told people I hope you have awakes because my Rez is one nasty disorienter and when its recharges I use it. So the chances it will be available if you face plant are slim.

However I have played a LOT of controllers and defenders and just love dealing with players that obviously have no clue how hard it is to keep an entire 8 man team buffed or even what powers you have available. I had a Blaster SCREAM at my ILL/EMP for Clear Mind almost constantly in a mission full of Lost Bosses. Until I finally sent him a tell and informed him that ..
1) I am the only player on the team that I can't buff and half the time while your screaming for help I am being held myself and I am out or breakfrees and

2) At this level CM isn't even available to me yet so you are screaming for a power I couldn't give you if I wanted to.

When I team with whatever I try to take care of my team mates as best I can. Hey as long as I'm alive and have 7 other team mates around me I can always re summon a pet/minon. I have never played a FF but I have Thermals and a Kin and trying to keep everyone on fire can be tricky and even tiring after a while. It's easy for a Blaster to stand there doing nothing but clicking one attack after another to scream for MORE CM, MORE FORT.. all they need to do is worry about the target in front of them and which one to target next. I'm trying to keep 7 targets buffed and at times they are scattered to the point where the only way to get to some of them is to rush THROUGH a mob and hope I survive. Ummm guess what depending on where most of the team is .. If that means the Scrapper that decided to rush ahead and aggro his own private mob dies while I keep the other 6 team mates alive then Scrappy better have some GOOD respites cause I am staying with the TEAM.
Reminds me of running any of my /Rad, /Pain, /Kin, or /Dark characters.

Kin:
"Sb plz, sb plz, sb plz, sb plz"
I usually just say "Next person who asks for speed boost loses their privilege. I'll SB you when I freaking SB you."
"zzzz. zzzzzzzz. zzzz! SLEPT STUNNED HELD STUCK!"
Response: "Little busy trying not to die and hold the boss who's holding you, hold on to your pants"
"you need to heal the team"
Response: "Stop killing my target before I can heal you off of him."

Pain:
"heal plz"
"em plz"
"rez? rez? rez? rez?"
"do you have pb? I want PB"
Responsse: "Hang on," "I'll get to you in a minute," "Busy," and "You're not a melee AT, so no." <--- this one reserved for idiot blasters/corruptors

Rad:
This section consists of telling people to stop killing my @#$%ing anchors first and then listening to them whine when they die during the alpha. I'll also mention people getting uppity when they run out of the radius of AM and don't get it, then ask why I didn't wait for them.

Dark:
"rez plz"
Response: I rez them, they don't click the thing to rez.
"rez plz"
"It's not up"
"WTF WHY"

"heal plz"
And then they run away from me.


My guides:Dark Melee/Dark Armor/Soul Mastery, Illusion Control/Kinetics/Primal Forces Mastery, Electric Armor
"Dark Armor is a complete waste as a tanking set."

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by gameboy1234 View Post
Frankly, I don't care how impressed you are with your own pets. You're teammates will exceed their capabilities in all respects. Not bubbling the team is just dumb. If you don't want to bubble, play solo. That's fine. But if you take a buffing toon and team, you'd better be prepared to buff.
I'm going to have to agree with a lot of the other posts in this thread. First of all, it's not a matter of ONLY buffing your pets. It's not, as another poster put it, "If you want bubbles for your team, kick me and get a Corruptor because I don't think that's my job." It's "My PRIORITY is my pets. If you want someone who is going to buff you FIRST, then kick me and get a Corruptor, because he's not going to HAVE any pets to buff."

Whether or not the pets are stronger than my teammates is irrelevant. They are MY pets, they are the source of most of my abilities, and they are the purpose for me being on the team. If my pets die, then I am a petless Mastermind; a weaker Corruptor with only three attacks. If that's what you want, then that's what you should have invited.

If you want ME, then you want my pets. And if you want my pets, you want them buffed. Unless you are going to take it on yourself to ensure my pets are buffed and protected, I'm going to assume that's my job. (And honestly, no one else can buff my pets as easily as I can myself)

Quote:
I also have a level 50 /FF mastermind, and I spend most of my time on a team making sure everyone is buffed. Sure, I don't always manage to get all the bubbles on everyone all the time, but I give it my best shot.
And if you're going to go on the assumption that you are NOT going to get all the bubbles on everyone at all times, then you have to have a priority. You can't have it both ways. Either your priority is your team, at which time your henchmen are not buffed at all times, or your priority is your henchmen, at which time your team is not buffed at all times. You say yourself complete buffing isn't possible.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jade_Dragon View Post
And if you're going to go on the assumption that you are NOT going to get all the bubbles on everyone at all times, then you have to have a priority. You can't have it both ways. Either your priority is your team, at which time your henchmen are not buffed at all times, or your priority is your henchmen, at which time your team is not buffed at all times. You say yourself complete buffing isn't possible.

First, to be clear, on a team my priority is for the teammates. I buff them and let the pets die because I figure the team is actually better at keeping me alive by killing stuff. Yes, there are incompetent teams but those are an outlier.

Second, complete buffing is possible. The only reason someone isn't buffed is because:

1. I forgot.

2. They wandered out of range and I couldn't get to them.

Normally it's easy to buff the team then go buff the pets too, but I often don't. Endurance is a consideration here. If I'm running lots of toggles then I really can't spare the extra End. Also often the team is competent enough that my pets have no aggro, so there's no point.


I think that communication is the key here. If you don't intend to buff a team, please say so up front. I think many teams will opt out. Also, I've teamed with plenty of MM's who did buff a team, and were darn good at it. It seems the norm. The only MM I teamed with who didn't also skipped half his bubbles, and was generally an idiot anyway. It was hard, but my widow said nothing and then found an excuse to leave soon afterwards.

My 2 Inf.


 

Posted

Two things I'll say up front to the OP:

1) Nothing wrong with your play style. Works fine with some teams or players, not others, but that's THEIR play style talking. Have some respect for it. Especially if they're jerks about it. I'm one of those odd people that likes being obnoxiously polite to jerks. Amusement often ensues.

2) I tend to have 2 different play styles with buff MMs. a) Buff my pets, and trust my team mates to have a modicum of survival instinct, and b) buff my team mates to the exclusion of my pets which are, after all, easier to replace mid-fight.

When first being added to a team, I'll typically ask something along the lines of "Do you guys want me to buff you all instead of my pets, or do you know what you're doing?" Astute observers will note that "both" is not an option. Don't allow them to assume it is. More often than not, I end up doing option b (my preference), at their behest.

And if another MM on the team wants you to buff him and/or HIS pets... laugh... a lot...


Where to find me after the end:
The Secret World - Arcadia - Shinzo
Rift - Faeblight - Bloodspeaker
LotRO - Gladden - Aranelion
STO - Holodeck - @Captain_Thiraas

Obviously, I don't care about NCSoft's forum rules, now.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nalrok_AthZim View Post
Pets can be resummoned indefinitely.

Teammates can't.
Conversely, even the squishiest team mate is often more durable than the toughest pet.

My point being that there are two ways to view the situation, as I pointed out above.


Where to find me after the end:
The Secret World - Arcadia - Shinzo
Rift - Faeblight - Bloodspeaker
LotRO - Gladden - Aranelion
STO - Holodeck - @Captain_Thiraas

Obviously, I don't care about NCSoft's forum rules, now.

 

Posted

I'm kinda surprised this is still going.

I felt the urge to give a little update to my experiences.

I have continued to go on with my play style. I give buff where it's needed. Team does bad, then hand out some buffs. I respec'd and picked up Provoke after deciding that someone's advice in a guide I read wasn't for me.

I was on a team a few nights ago when I was doing my Tankermind thing full time. Without stretching the story, we had no deaths until after 4 missions. In that mission, the team acquired not 1, but 2 tanks. I took a break to grab some enhancement for my new level (47). Upon returning to the mission, I found nearly everyone acquainting themselves with the floor. The team regrouped. I chose NOT to hand out buffs. Returned to what I was doing on the team and, what do you know, things went smoothly again. Two bad tanks? Perhaps. It felt nice knowing I could handle +4 Arachnos and Carnies though. Team effort though. Can't write off the people I'm taking point for.


To respond to a few posters:

-When a troublesome blaster dies and a tank is tanking, is it the tank's fault that the blaster died? I won't take responsibility for another MM that can't control itself.

-If I'm playing with a Tank/Brute. I'll let them charge ahead at first and get a read on them. Then, I'll charge in with them. If they move too slow for me, I'll take point. If they have a problem with it, I would probably revert to the previous step. Haven't had that yet though.

-My play style has me attacking and re-summoning/training somewhat often. When running 6 toggles (Yes, I have stamina and I slot for END), sometimes the END is low and I don't have blues to spare. I usually keep them for my re-summons when things go bad for my ninja comrades. All in all though, it really comes back to my play style. I'm not going to min/max when it's not needed.

On a final note, I've done some low level TF. Low enough where I'm not equipped to tank as well as I would normally. In this instance, I did put myself in a more supportive role.


T. Hayes
@The Cleansing