Madadh

Mentor
  • Posts

    1401
  • Joined

  1. Madadh

    Radiation Armor

    Looks like a decent set, but as has been pointed out, that's really hard to judge without
    a) Numbers
    b) Having actually played it.


    But, I fairly well dislike the theme. I can't think of comic book precedent, and while I admit that alone isn't reason not to have it, I just don't think of 'radiation' as meaning 'armour'. I'll grant, that the comic concept of radiation 'granting' some type of super toughness is well established, but the Hulk isn't tough using radiation, but as a result of it. I'd much rather have some armour types that are actual armour. Like 'metal plate' and/or classic 'powered armour'. Or maybe an all Parry type set. Or a magical protection type set that acts a lot like Invul, but without the huge Psi hole (obviously the other numbers would have to be lower to keep balance).

    Of course, depending on how the effects look (and how much they can be turned on and off, or tweaked) it may be able to fill a role other than of 'radiation' but sets that are popular in spite of their concept almost always popular because of being on the very high performance end.
  2. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Bubblerella View Post
    I agree. Lucky for me the only defender I've rolled in the last few years has been a Traps/Sonic. I still bring something to a team. Other than that, I go corr all the way.

    Gotta be kidding me... I can't even play a Corr because they under perform defs by so much... I really don't even get what y'all are talking about... Are you perhaps discussing debuff-less defs?




    That said... If you wanna buff defs more than they are already? I'm game. I'll love me some god-mode. Just try not to break the whole game with the overwhelming power..
  3. Madadh

    Melee AT for me?

    If you want an 'epic' combo, then you're going to have to spend for it..


    But, if you're willing, I've got a fav.


    Recently got done with a 3 person Mothership Raid.. When we hit the bowl, the 2 defs died. Lots of crap flying about at that point. I was able to tank everything in the bowl, GM included, with a Shield/Ax brute..

    I was still standing and chopping away when they got back.. and then we got on to spankin the crap outta them...

    Sure, there may be better combos out there, but it's hard to get more epic than that..
  4. Madadh

    Red Side WWD #7

    OK. So, um.. I'm stumped.. The Nav window says, Assault Darrin Wades Island.

    But I tried and can't fly or hop up there...

    I try to enter the topmost ship, as the hero version does, and "You cannot enter," is the message that I get.

    So, what am I missing? I suspect it's pretty obvious, but it doesn't feel obvious to me atm.
  5. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Blood Red Arachnid View Post
    So, to take advantage of the sales for Circle of Thorns and Carnival of Light bundles, I went to go buy them. However, I cannot buy them, and the game gives me the following reason:

    "Your purchase cannot be processed. You may already have purchased the item, or the product is not available in the quantities you specified."

    However, I have bought neither of these costume sets, and I am only buying 1 of each pack. Now, my question is this: Is anyone else having an issue like this? Or if there is some obscure mistake I have made, is there any way to remedy it?

    No. I've never had this problem. I've had the reverse. I paid for stuff I already had at one point, and I think they have 'fixed' that.

    Now, from the only mildly helpful comment to the totally unhelpful...

    Well, be glad that they are helping you not spend money on the Circle of Thorns stuff..... What a load of rubbish...
  6. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Fulmens View Post
    Madadh: The next time you find yourself in a discussion where the other person's trumpeting the joy of playing a blaster, ask questions. ........
    Hey now, don't try to frame me as the blaster champion.... I personally don't enjoy the AT at all... I've never understood why someone would play a blaster.. My point was that my lack of understanding doesn't disqualify them as a viable AT. They may, or may not be a viable AT, but my lack of understanding one way or the other isn't proof at all...

    I much prefer scrappers and tanks to brutes in general, but my preference certainly isn't proof that brutes are a flawed at. I vastly prefer defenders to corruptors but again, my preference is no proof at all.

    I prefer VEATs to HEATs, too, but I'd not infer from that anything about the value of warshades vs widows, either way. My preferences, or other peoples, alone isn't proof of anything. So I'll not overvalue my preferences, nor undervalue other peoples preferences.. If you wish to prove an ATs worth, or disprove it, you'll have to do it in a vacuum to convince me.
  7. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Snow Globe View Post
    In case you missed it, there is an "Officially Unofficial" response further up this thread:

    Didn't miss it. And have seen similar to it. Unofficially official and Officially official aren't similar enough..

    Just come out and say it. Or really put forth serious effort to fix it..
  8. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Xyzor View Post
    Get a room, you two! ;P
    n|m
  9. Skip Mace. Go for ranged def. Hurricane means fearing no melee... If you do that, elec is really solid, but you have a range of choices.
  10. Quote:
    Originally Posted by docbuzzard View Post
    Personally I don't see why Crab Spiders aren't more popular. They can to be what a blaster ought to. You can have decent defense, status protection, and solid ranged offense. Yes, they do less than high end blaster builds, but they also live through things.

    Blasters should either get some real forms of damage mitigation or do stupidly high quantities of damage. Anything else is unbalanced.

    Well, my Huntsman build VEAT also does that very well, but my best ranged damage build.. TA/AR def. Redraw, lol. I'll light the world on fire, and often do.. Full Auto into a spawn debuffed and burning in oil is awesome. Blasters should be 1/2 that cool. Def capped makes it stupid fun.
  11. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Stealth_Bomber View Post
    Agreed, but it's not unreasonable for the OP to put this here for increased visibility. Back before Defiance 2.0, the Blaster community went TWO YEARS without a Redname post addressing the issues we brought up (in those days it was Castle, because our assigned AT rep never really posted after his/her initial greeting of "Hi I'm the Blaster rep").

    Blasters currently underperform. Many experienced players are voicing their concerns in the Blaster forum and have some excellent ideas (i.e. Fulmens, Arcanaville). Some here describe the Blaster forum as a "black hole" and that's not too far off actually; I worry that we will go another extended time period before someone updates our AT again.
    And it is encouraged for reposting where applicable.. And as far as general balance between ATs, this is not just a good place, but perhaps the best place.. I welcome this discussion here.
  12. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Agent White View Post
    Well we better replace him then.
    Possibly the funniest line in MP history. Because it was live and so contrary to expectations.. I laughed till I think I hurt myself first time I heard that line...


    Edit: Just realized I'm WAY off OP topic. Sorry...
  13. Quote:
    Originally Posted by PrincessDarkstar View Post
    Lol I wasn't calling you unreasonable, I just mean you know your mind well, which is good. Sometimes it is good to 'argue' with someone who can explain why they think what they do, I don't often let people get away with not agreeing with me

    Fair enough. I'm compelled to agree with you yet again.. I particularly enjoy hearing your explanations of how you think while you are disagreeing.. They are always well explained.

    I love when the interweb isn't an argument forum, but instead is a decent avenue of respectful discussion...
  14. I was due my 5 year yet badge 4 days after freedom. I reported it about a week after it was overdue.. Got the same canned response so many others have reported. Same reported tracking problem. I've re reported it a couple of times since, just to see if any progress has been made and the reply has been the same. I can't guarantee, but it seems pretty plain to me that freedom's new system broke the old. And I don't think (outside of some really weird outliers) we will see vet anniversary badges any time soon.

    Edit to add: If anyone really wants, I'll re report it again, and notify y'all of the response.. I'm not sure, but I may be close to case zero on this... At least, I've not seen anyone miss a vet badge by less than a week.. And still be waiting...

    Point being, I think yearly vet badges are totally broken beyond repair. I just wish they'd come out and say so as opposed to continuing to dangle hope. The longer they dangle hope, the more people get added to the list of folks expecting yearly vet badges that aren't getting them.
  15. Quote:
    Originally Posted by PrincessDarkstar View Post
    Since the missions are locking into the ozone after you do them once I haven't repeated them on any character yet.

    I don't know if that sucks the most, or if it is not having new missions to run for Hybrid.

    Dev1: Hey we have a successful game don't we?
    Dev2: Yeah pretty much
    Dev1: Well lets totally change it!
    Dev2: Great idea! Lets double the size of the teams you need!
    Dev1: Nah, triple!
    Dev2: And lets not give them any solo content either!
    Dev1: We are onto a winner here

    So, back to my norm. I totally agree with this.... As I usually do with PrincessDs posts. I just don't get the mindset that decided this was a good plan...

    But, I'm willing to just abstain from Hybrid for a while. I've got plenty of alts that aren't Incarnate +3s yet, and several alts charging hard for 50, too, so it's not like I'll lack for entertainment while I wait on other ways to get Hybrid.
  16. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Seldom View Post
    Quite right. My apologies, as I was running my mouth I messed up my comparisons. It has been corrected.
    No need to apologize, I'm sure.. I manage to mangle 99% of what I try to type.. It's partly because of that extremely poor typing skills that I'm always in editing mode... It certainly wasn't intended as a slight, just an observation.

    Edit: A simple glance at my post history will show about 4/5s have been edited... For a reason. Because they needed to be...
  17. Gir is pretty awesome...

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by houtex View Post
    My favorite toon is Gir. Duh. Although there is something to be said for the awesomeness that is Stimpy, but definitely Gir wins hands down.

    ---

    My favorite character to play in the game is currently my Brawl only Brute, Brawling Humiliator, Pinnacle, 50 and goin' Incarnate already. Soloin' EBs Bashing faces. A singular accomplishment and I still cackle madly when he does something that he really has no business doing, like participating and completing and definitely NOT causing the fail of a Master of Miss Liberty Task Force.
  18. Quote:
    Originally Posted by PrincessDarkstar View Post
    Fair play

    I should know not to try to change your mind lol
    Hey now!! I'm not unreasonable. Or at least I certainly try not to be. You are always able to make me consider things I might not have before. Some things are just more subjective (and thus dependent on styles of play) than others.

    And, that said, it's certainly no picnic trying to change your mind, either.
  19. Quote:
    Originally Posted by PrincessDarkstar View Post
    Thankfully with me scrappers are my fave AT and are far from mistreated (Though not giving my energy melee is a sin they will surely be punished for in due time).

    But for me there was once a time when I saw stalkers join the team and prepared to carry a passenger, now I have the same feeling with blasters.

    If they do the same damage as scrappers they should be just as survivable. I actually think they do less damage (Excluding certain combo's on both sides) which says a lot.
    Well, Scrappers are way up towards the top of my list, too, so, I don't feel overly slighted. But my far and away fav is defenders. And so I look at every addition to the team as just *more!*. I never feel like I'm carrying anyone, just empowering them. I see your point though.. I just don't think that way. And, truthfully, while I've seen very few true scary blaster game changers, I have seen them. So I've always written it off as a difference of player skill in gameplay and build design.

    Your point re: scrapers vs blasters is very, very valid, though, and I honestly don't know what to think about that. I'll have to ponder that a bit, because, as I've admitted, I don't generally give blasters much thought.

    I always enjoy our discussions, because you manage to be non-confrontational, yet still very challenging, and make me really think....
  20. I think your point is well made. I just don't agree. I think it's a big enough boost to help in those critical situations, and lasts long enough to get you through them usually, and is up pretty often, often enough that is should be available a lot of the time in those situations.
    But, I'll go ahead and kick the foundation out from my position by admitting that I'm only looking at the numbers and comparing it to other powers I'm familiar with. I've not actually used Hybrid, so I could be way off base. But the numbers don't look horrible next to Archmage or some of the tier 9 powers (or even some of the APP/PPP powers).

    I may change my mind when I get to play with this toy, however.

    But, again, it may come down to play style.

    Edit: Of course, it's impact may also be affected by the build it's used on, too.. I could be picturing it's use on one type of build, and your test samples could be on a very different type of build..
  21. You 2 may have a point. I'll refrain from offering my opinion on this topic going forward on account that I just don't know enough to discuss the topic in detail. It seems everyone complains about how their poor AT is treated, tho, and I can discuss in detail about most, of the ATs, but not so much about blasters. I've never liked them, always felt they were overly fragile, and I personally just don't even bother to play them any more. But I've been told repeatedly that they are just awesome, and my impressions are wrong, or a factor of my playstyle. And I've seen some very effective blasters that would seem to support those claims..

    So, while your counters seem to have merit to me, I've been told many times I don't know what I'm talking about when it comes to blasters. And there is merit to that point. So, I'll bow out, but point out that, as everyone claims their fav AT is the poor mistreated one, you'll have to make a great case... Better than I was able when I pointed out the flaws of blasters...

    Good luck..
  22. Yeah, you really can't go wrong with an Earth/Fire. Enjoy! And welcome to the game.
  23. I really wish I was going to be more helpful to you, but they are SO different...

    Dom's tend to be safer, and push more damage, but more fragile if someone goes unmezzed. Defenders usually do less damage, but are generally have better defenses to fall back on if things get out of control.. But, that's not always true. Part of the problems is that defenders vary a LOT from powerset to powerset and in design. But both rad/ and storm/ defs can be vary safe..

    Wow, um...

    Really... Any of those sound fun, tho that said, I've not played any of those exact combos except rad/rad, which is truly awesome. But all of the otehr 3 sound quite doable.. Only Strom/Energy causes me any pause. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE storm, but if all your attacks do KB, I can see you flinging enemies off of your Freezing Rain zone, which isn't ideal. Yes, there are ways around it, but that combo would be the one I'd be most wary of...

    Edit: Wow! What Seldom posted while I was writing mine is a very, very good summary.. Pretty much.. Um, what he said.
    2nd Edit: Though, I think in Seldom's 4th paragraph, 4th sentence, he meant to start, "Every defender primary plays incredibly differently, while dominator primaries..."