Moving empty character slots to another server?
If you would like to make a suggestion, head on down to the Suggestions forum.
If you're trying to report a bug, I'm sorry, this is not a bug.
Paragon Wiki: http://www.paragonwiki.com
City Info Terminal: http://cit.cohtitan.com
Mids Hero Designer: http://www.cohplanner.com
Fourth one down in the "For fun" section.
Wanted: Origin centric story arcs.
If you've only played an AT once (one set combo) and "hate" it - don't give up. Roll a different combo. It may just be those sets not clicking for you.
PM one of the OCR team asking them to move it.
Beastyle, Freitag, 7deCouer or Zwinkyhockeypuck (look at Community Digest for correct spelling of his name, I refuse to spell it right).
You may be able to send a PM to Moderator 05, Moderator 07, Moderator 12 or Moderator 13 with the request as well. I don't think any of them have PM's disabled.
EDIT: Ano as soon as I submitted that post, it's been moved.
If the game spit out 20 dollar bills people would complain that they weren't sequentially numbered. If they were sequentially numbered people would complain that they weren't random enough.
Black Pebble is my new hero.
Thanks for moving this thread to the appropriate forum. I do appreciate the assistance.
Although I must say that I'm a bit disappointed that it's buried in a section called "For Fun!". To me that implies that my concerns won't be taken seriously, nor be given significant merit or consideration. This might seem like a minor or trivial concern to some people, but it really is quite important to me, and I suspect it might be of interest to many others. Because I have reached the end of the line as far as I could by going through the Support Incident route, it seemed to me that the logical next step would be to communicate my concerns here on the forums. I am a paying customer after all, so as a VIP Subscriber I enjoy full posting privileges on these forums and agree to follow the Forum Rules and Guidelines.
This situation has left a bad taste in my mouth. It seems to me that NCSoft cares more about squeezing a few more bucks out of me than it does about satisfying me as a customer. It's such a minor thing, but it has such a major effect -- don't they realize that they'd easily get a few more bucks out of me if they keep me happy (I did mention that I shelled out $100 for points 8000 points already, right)? Instead, the harsh reality of it feels like a cold slap in the face. Consequently, I'd rather not give them another dime. I think I've paid quite enough for now, thanks. It's not that I haven't enjoyed the products and services for which I've paid: I have indeed done just that. But now that I more completely understand the nature of our business relationship, now that I know where the boundaries are, I'll be sure to stay well within them, as clearly defined by NCSoft, thank you.
So I decided to cancel my second VIP subscription (I am keeping my first one active), and I choose not to purchase any more Paragon Points. I will simply continue to accrue those incidental points and transfer tokens that come with the single VIP subscription, and use those to transfer and/or acquire the slots I want on Liberty. If that's how NCSoft wants me to play the game, then that is indeed how I shall play it.
In the meantime, it seems I now have extra gaming money to spend elsewhere. I wonder if SW:TOR is any fun?
Since they charge for moving characters between servers, it seems logical that they would charge for moving character slots to other servers (to pay for the cost of developing a service that a relatively small number of players would actually use).
They've probably discussed this very thing, and decided that the price they'd have to charge for this new service would be the same as buying a new character slot. Which makes the whole thing rather pointless.
i was talking to friends in game, even got turned into a thread one day.
This is a few years ago, waaaaaay before i21.
This was my idea on the whole thing:
Instead of just toon, have the ability to also move empty server slots around with the server transfer tokens.
Either have the prompt: Toon or Slot, when selecting the transfer. Then select the toon/slot from the server you want to transfer followed by the server you want it transferred to.
I play on Guardian, and guardian alone. I have 26 out of 26 slots used, I have 12 slots on each other server i don't use. I don't have a lot of cash to waste on the game, so i can't spend that on server slots to unlock the 22 other slots, but i am willing to use the server transfers that are collecting dust to open up more slots on my server. And i'm sure there are more people like me who have these server tokens collecting dust, glad to either get a few retired toons back home, or just the ability to create new toons.
Dark Energon, Founder of the Freedom Legion SG on Guardian server.
(SG founded on 12-08-'09, Top100: 08-17-'10, Top50: 12-23-'10, Top25: 12-11-'11)
Crab Spider Nephila on Titan Tracker
Weekly events on Guardian: W.A.V.E. & FNFN
Instead of just toon, have the ability to also move empty server slots around with the server transfer tokens.
Either have the prompt: Toon or Slot, when selecting the transfer. Then select the toon/slot from the server you want to transfer followed by the server you want it transferred to. |
Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound
Since they charge for moving characters between servers, it seems logical that they would charge for moving character slots to other servers (to pay for the cost of developing a service that a relatively small number of players would actually use).
They've probably discussed this very thing, and decided that the price they'd have to charge for this new service would be the same as buying a new character slot. Which makes the whole thing rather pointless. |
There's no "new service" involved in my request to MOVE one (1) single empty slot from server A to server B. There's no net gain in it for me, and no net loss in it for them. They deduct one empty character slot from server A, and add one empty character slot to server B: that's NOT the same net cost/price as creating a new, second slot on a different server. And that's not the same net cost/price as copying a created/equipped character from one server to another, either (that entails moving a significant quantity of actual data).
As a paying customer for years prior to CoHF, I paid for/earned a total of 17 character slots on Virtue on this particular account. We loyal subscribers were told that we would not lose anything we'd bought or earned when Freedom went live. And officially, technically, we haven't -- NCSoft has been true to the letter of that law.
But here's where that's become less than an ideal bargain, in this particular case. Yes, I still have 17 character slots on Virtue, as a VIP. But 12 of those come with my VIP status -- only 5 of them were bought/earned with veteran rewards or points. So when that account reverts to Premium, only 5 will remain available for me to play, and ONLY ON VIRTUE.
But I don't play on Virtue any more. I've made new friends and joined a new SG on Liberty. So I've got 5 useless slots on Virtue: I bought/earned them long ago, but now they have no value to me. I'm merely trying to salvage some value out of these slots: they do me no good on Virtue, but they'd be well used on Liberty.
Because I had nothing on Liberty prior to CoHF, I had no unlockable slots without VIP status. Consequently, I had to burn both of my 2 Globals and spent my last 400 points on 2 more slots (there's a sale), just to get a total of 16. Subtract 12 when my VIP runs out, and I'll be left with only 4 slots on Liberty. So on this account, I will never be able to play any more than 4 characters there *unless* I either:
(a) spend money to buy more slots on Liberty; or,
(b) spend money to transfer characters from Virtue to Liberty.
Is that technically correct, right, legal? Yes, absolutely, no argument there.
Is that ethically or morally right or acceptable? I don't think so -- that's my argument.
That's what's stuck in my craw about this whole thing. That's what's bothering me. For years I stuck by NCSoft/Cryptic/Paragon Studios. Yes, I've done my share of stone-throwing, but generally, I've been more supportive and positive than negative. I've always appreciated how NCSoft/Paragon seemed more sensitive and responsive to the players, unlike so many other MMO companies that we could all name with loud cursing and gnashing of teeth.
But here is one example of where it seems like NCSoft is acting *precisely* like those other MMO companies we all loathe so intensely, those whose primary concern is for milking as many microtransactions out of their players as possible, with little regard for their feelings or relationships or enjoyment.
Is it really too much to ask that players be allowed to move empty character slots to different servers? I mean, it's tedious enough as it is to have to have strip and delete characters to make alts anyways: isn't that sufficient enough a cost for the privilege of moving the slot to a different server?
Is that ethically or morally right or acceptable? I don't think so -- that's my argument.
|
I agree that being able to move slots would be a great QoL improvement (and that, as long as the slot is empty, there should be little to no charge). But there's nothing immoral or unethical or even unacceptable about *not* being able to move them. All of your cited issues are being brought upon you by your own actions and choices with full knowledge (or the easy potential of it) of the consequences.
Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound
Once a player unlocks a character slot on a specific server, it stays on that server forever, and cannot be moved to another server. If they ever want to play on a different server, there are only these options:
1. Character Slot Purchase: at 480 points for 1 or 800 for 2, that's at least $10. 2. Character Transfer: 800 points (at least $10) or earned monthly with VIP. 3. Become a VIP: $15 per month. There is no approved mechanism for a player to move an unlocked slot from one server to another. I opened an Incident with The Support Team, which confirmed this. I think that this policy is unwise at best, and perhaps unethical at worst. I believe that this is a short-sighted mistake that offends me as a player (a VIP) and ultimately hurts the game in the long run. First, let me make it clear that I am talking about empty "Create Character" slots. I am not talking about created/equipped character slots: that's a value-added service that can and should cost points. This topic of this thread is limited to only empty character slots. I do not see how NCSoft loses anything by making it easy or convenient for players to move unlocked/empty character slots among different servers. If anything, doing so would encourage such players to play MORE, because it gives them the mobility to seek out and find the server the best suits their needs and/or gives them greatest enjoyment from the game. If the player is playing on a server that makes him/her happy, then they're more likely to stay there, keep playing, keep shopping, keep buying points, etc. This is ultimately the best outcome for CoH and NCSoft. But if the player is "locked-in" to a specific server that somehow becomes dull or even hostile, then what recourse does the player have? Can they easily move to another server? No, not really. Yes, they might have a transfer token, or might be willing to buy one, but how will they choose a destination? Without the ability to freely sample the other servers with a new character, why would they gamble a transfer token, points, or real cash on a new server, sight unseen? No, it makes far better sense to give the player the option of using one of the empty slots they've already unlocked, instead. Allow them to move it from server A to server B, so they can at least try it out. What difference does it really make if the unlocked slot is on or the other anyway, as long as the net number of slots is the same? I understand that it's completely within their rights for NCSoft to define how players are allowed to create and use character slots on the servers: I don't disagree with that, nor that they are wrong to do so. I'm just saying that this may not be right or best, either. It might be better and smarter for NCSoft to give their customers a bit more flexibility, so that they might enjoy their products and services more, and as an incentive to spend more money on those products and services. I've been playing CoH since November 2004. I'm a 5+ year veteran VIP with 4 accounts (2 VIP, 2 Premium/Free). Since CoH Freedom went live, I've purchased 8,960 Paragon Points ($100 USD, apart from those included with VIP). So I want to make it clear that I'm not complaining about money, begrudging NCSoft any money, or whining about getting something for nothing. Thanks for your time and attention. Sincerely, Ralph S. Thomas a.k.a. @Rathstar1 formerly of Virtue now on Liberty (which is why I want to move my slots, dammit!) |
Thanks for moving this thread to the appropriate forum. I do appreciate the assistance.
Although I must say that I'm a bit disappointed that it's buried in a section called "For Fun!". To me that implies that my concerns won't be taken seriously, nor be given significant merit or consideration. This might seem like a minor or trivial concern to some people, but it really is quite important to me, and I suspect it might be of interest to many others. Because I have reached the end of the line as far as I could by going through the Support Incident route, it seemed to me that the logical next step would be to communicate my concerns here on the forums. I am a paying customer after all, so as a VIP Subscriber I enjoy full posting privileges on these forums and agree to follow the Forum Rules and Guidelines. This situation has left a bad taste in my mouth. It seems to me that NCSoft cares more about squeezing a few more bucks out of me than it does about satisfying me as a customer. It's such a minor thing, but it has such a major effect -- don't they realize that they'd easily get a few more bucks out of me if they keep me happy (I did mention that I shelled out $100 for points 8000 points already, right)? Instead, the harsh reality of it feels like a cold slap in the face. Consequently, I'd rather not give them another dime. I think I've paid quite enough for now, thanks. It's not that I haven't enjoyed the products and services for which I've paid: I have indeed done just that. But now that I more completely understand the nature of our business relationship, now that I know where the boundaries are, I'll be sure to stay well within them, as clearly defined by NCSoft, thank you. So I decided to cancel my second VIP subscription (I am keeping my first one active), and I choose not to purchase any more Paragon Points. I will simply continue to accrue those incidental points and transfer tokens that come with the single VIP subscription, and use those to transfer and/or acquire the slots I want on Liberty. If that's how NCSoft wants me to play the game, then that is indeed how I shall play it. In the meantime, it seems I now have extra gaming money to spend elsewhere. I wonder if SW:TOR is any fun? |
Actually, I disagree with you: there is a point to all of this. The nut of the issue is that they're charging you twice for the same slot, the only difference being the server on which it is located. There's an initial cost/price for creating a character slot on a server in the first place. But then the question is there really any additional cost involved in moving that empty slot to a different server, versus creating an additional empty slot on a different server.
There's no "new service" involved in my request to MOVE one (1) single empty slot from server A to server B. There's no net gain in it for me, and no net loss in it for them. They deduct one empty character slot from server A, and add one empty character slot to server B: that's NOT the same net cost/price as creating a new, second slot on a different server. And that's not the same net cost/price as copying a created/equipped character from one server to another, either (that entails moving a significant quantity of actual data). As a paying customer for years prior to CoHF, I paid for/earned a total of 17 character slots on Virtue on this particular account. We loyal subscribers were told that we would not lose anything we'd bought or earned when Freedom went live. And officially, technically, we haven't -- NCSoft has been true to the letter of that law. But here's where that's become less than an ideal bargain, in this particular case. Yes, I still have 17 character slots on Virtue, as a VIP. But 12 of those come with my VIP status -- only 5 of them were bought/earned with veteran rewards or points. So when that account reverts to Premium, only 5 will remain available for me to play, and ONLY ON VIRTUE. But I don't play on Virtue any more. I've made new friends and joined a new SG on Liberty. So I've got 5 useless slots on Virtue: I bought/earned them long ago, but now they have no value to me. I'm merely trying to salvage some value out of these slots: they do me no good on Virtue, but they'd be well used on Liberty. Because I had nothing on Liberty prior to CoHF, I had no unlockable slots without VIP status. Consequently, I had to burn both of my 2 Globals and spent my last 400 points on 2 more slots (there's a sale), just to get a total of 16. Subtract 12 when my VIP runs out, and I'll be left with only 4 slots on Liberty. So on this account, I will never be able to play any more than 4 characters there *unless* I either: (a) spend money to buy more slots on Liberty; or, (b) spend money to transfer characters from Virtue to Liberty. Is that technically correct, right, legal? Yes, absolutely, no argument there. Is that ethically or morally right or acceptable? I don't think so -- that's my argument. That's what's stuck in my craw about this whole thing. That's what's bothering me. For years I stuck by NCSoft/Cryptic/Paragon Studios. Yes, I've done my share of stone-throwing, but generally, I've been more supportive and positive than negative. I've always appreciated how NCSoft/Paragon seemed more sensitive and responsive to the players, unlike so many other MMO companies that we could all name with loud cursing and gnashing of teeth. But here is one example of where it seems like NCSoft is acting *precisely* like those other MMO companies we all loathe so intensely, those whose primary concern is for milking as many microtransactions out of their players as possible, with little regard for their feelings or relationships or enjoyment. Is it really too much to ask that players be allowed to move empty character slots to different servers? I mean, it's tedious enough as it is to have to have strip and delete characters to make alts anyways: isn't that sufficient enough a cost for the privilege of moving the slot to a different server? |
This is not something the company has just started doing with Freedom. The policy on character slots being permanent once unlocked has been in effect since the day they feature went live years ago.
So it's funny how this only becomes an issue for the OP after he's found new friends to play with on another server, and is considering dropping to Premium.
He questions NCSofts morals and ethics on this, when the truth of the matter is that he is trying to weasel his way out of buying new character slots on, and transfers to another server.
If anyone morals, ethics, and motives should be questioned it's the OP's.
That's your argument based on what? They tell you the slot is immovable once placed. They didn't force you to switch servers, nor choose for you where the slots were placed, and I doubt they are forcing you to cancel your sub.
I agree that being able to move slots would be a great QoL improvement (and that, as long as the slot is empty, there should be little to no charge). But there's nothing immoral or unethical or even unacceptable about *not* being able to move them. All of your cited issues are being brought upon you by your own actions and choices with full knowledge (or the easy potential of it) of the consequences. |
So here I must eat crow. I was indeed previously warned about the risks associated with adding slots to Virtue. I was not forced to place them there, nor was I forced to switch, nor am I being forced to cancel my sub. NCSoft/Paragon is not being immoral or unethical in any way, shape, or form: they are being consistent both before and after the implementation of Freedom; therefore, I am wrong to accuse them of such. I apologize for doing so. I am man enough to admit when I am wrong and to face the consequences accordingly.
That said, as you even concurred, it would be a nice QoL improvement for NCSoft/Paragon to offer players the option of moving empty character slots from one server to another, for either no charge, or for a nominal charge that's less than those of purchasing additional character slots (480 pts) or transferring equipped characters (800 pts). Does 100 pts per empty slot transfer sound like a fair price?
I'd like to thank all of you who listened to my concerns and offered constructive criticism. I enjoy a good discussion and a lively debate, even when I don't win the argument (which is usually the case :-P ).
This is not something the company has just started doing with Freedom. The policy on character slots being permanent once unlocked has been in effect since the day they feature went live years ago.
So it's funny how this only becomes an issue for the OP after he's found new friends to play with on another server, and is considering dropping to Premium. He questions NCSofts morals and ethics on this, when the truth of the matter is that he is trying to weasel his way out of buying new character slots on, and transfers to another server. If anyone morals, ethics, and motives should be questioned it's the OP's. |
I'm not trying to "weasel" my way out of buying new character slots on another server. I was trying to figure out how to use the character slots for which I'd already paid/earned on another server. I paid for/earned those extra character slots on Virtue prior to CoH:F, and I simply wanted to move them to Liberty, now that I prefer to play there, instead. I made no secret of that, nor did I have any malicious intent.
My mistake was believing that owning the slots entitled me to use them on any server I wished, even though NCSoft/Paragon Studios previously made it clear that the slots I was claiming would be restricted to the specific server on which I'd claimed them. I forgot that this was a condition of this perk prior to CoH:F -- I mistakenly believed that this was a new condition implemented with CoH:F.
As I've indicated in a previous post above, I now know and admit that I was wrong, and I apologize for that, and for my disparaging comments about NCSoft/Paragon Studios.
That said, as you even concurred, it would be a nice QoL improvement for NCSoft/Paragon to offer players the option of moving empty character slots from one server to another, for either no charge, or for a nominal charge that's less than those of purchasing additional character slots (480 pts) or transferring equipped characters (800 pts). Does 100 pts per empty slot transfer sound like a fair price?
|
Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound
My mistake was believing that owning the slots entitled me to use them on any server I wished, even though NCSoft/Paragon Studios previously made it clear that the slots I was claiming would be restricted to the specific server on which I'd claimed them. I forgot that this was a condition of this perk prior to CoH:F -- I mistakenly believed that this was a new condition implemented with CoH:F.
|
Okay I won't dispute that your memory was faulty on the details and I'll apologize for my snarky comment, and it may have been a while since you unlocked extra slots, but we have always gotten some variation of a pop up window asking us if we were sure if we wanted to unlock a slot on a given server because once unlocked it is permanent.
Currently the pop up looks like this.
Now I'm sure there are people that just click yes without reading but that's beyond the devs control. They can't force people to pay attention.
I was thinking 80-120 points at most. But the problem is that I don't actually know how difficult the process would be on their end. It *seems* like it should be easy to re-lock a slot and give you back a Global slot to spend, but the reality may be far more complicated than that.
|
'I don't like the look of it at all,' said the King: 'however, it may kiss my hand if it likes.'
'I'd rather not,' the Cat remarked.
'Don't be impertinent,' said the King, 'and don't look at me like that!' He got behind Alice as he spoke.
'A cat may look at a king,' said Alice.
Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound
There's no "new service" involved in my request to MOVE one (1) single empty slot from server A to server B.
|
It also opens up a can of worms. If you can freely (or more cheaply) transfer a slot you bought, people will wonder why you can't transfer the 12 slots you "bought" on every server when you got a VIP subscription. And then they'd wonder why you should have to pay for additional slots at all, since you're given dozens for free on the other servers. And if you can transfer an empty slot for free, why should you pay for transferring a slot that holds a character?
Historically, inter-server operations have been treated as resource-intensive transactions and have had a monetary cost associated with them.
That would be an amazing rip-off. You could either buy slots while keeping the ones you've already bought or, for the same price, you could buy slots and lose the slots you've already bought.
|
In order for someone to lose slots they'd have to have fewer slots than when they started. You can't lose something you didn't have in the first place.
Exactly how are you losing any slots? The idea is to move the slots you already unlocked to a new server. You'd have the exact same number of slots you unlocked only they'd be reassigned to a different server.
In order for someone to lose slots they'd have to have fewer slots than when they started. You can't lose something you didn't have in the first place. |
Let's say you have a bonus slot on Virtue which cost you 480 points. And you want to move it to Liberty, so you pay 480 points to move it to Liberty because you're too stupid to see the con. Now you've paid 960 points and you only have one bonus slot, which is on Liberty rather than Virtue.
Or, when faced with that ridiculous pricing, you can be aware of the con and spend 480 points to just buy a new slot on Liberty without losing the slot you had on Virtue. Now you've paid 960 points and you have two bonus slots - one on Virtue and one on Liberty.
So you could either have one slot for the price of two, or two slots for the price of two.
Surely that was apparent and you're just having me on?
Goodbye may seem forever
Farewell is like the end
But in my heart's the memory
And there you'll always be
-- The Fox and the Hound
They would have to write code for this, and provide a mechanism for you to choose the option. That's a new service. It costs them money to write and test code, and inter-server transactions are always tricky things to program. Since only a small subset of the user population would likely use this new service, it's not something that would benefit all users equally. So it would make sense to charge for this service only when it's used.
It also opens up a can of worms. If you can freely (or more cheaply) transfer a slot you bought, people will wonder why you can't transfer the 12 slots you "bought" on every server when you got a VIP subscription. And then they'd wonder why you should have to pay for additional slots at all, since you're given dozens for free on the other servers. And if you can transfer an empty slot for free, why should you pay for transferring a slot that holds a character? Historically, inter-server operations have been treated as resource-intensive transactions and have had a monetary cost associated with them. |
Here's how I figure today's code for the existing slot unlocks works:
Step 1: Player purchases Character Slot token(s) from the Market.
Step 2: Player selects "Unlockable" slot on Server A.
Step 3: Player is prompted about redeeming slot token, player clicks Yes.
Step 4: System unlocks slot in Server A.
I'm thinking that the only new code that might need to be created is the addition of a new "Move" button to the top menu bar, next to the "Unlock", "Renames", and "Transfers" buttons. Here's how I suggest the code for an empty slot move might work:
Step 1: Player purchase Empty Slot Move token(s) from the Market.
Step 2: Player clicks on "Move" button on Server A where they have empty slots available (this button would be greyed-out/invisible/zeroed on any server where they do not have empty slots, just like it is for Unlocks/Renames/Transfers).
Step 3: Player is prompted about redeeming slot token, and asked to choose a target server (B).
Step 4: System unlocks a slot on Server B.
Step 5: System locks an empty slot Server A.
So it seems to me that most of the code is already there: it simply needs to be re-purposed and made available for QA and player testing.
In order for someone to lose slots they'd have to have fewer slots than when they started. You can't lose something you didn't have in the first place.
|
Now you're telling me to go buy new slots on Liberty. Sure, I could do that (in fact, I did buy 2 more slots for only 400 pts, because they're having a sale); however, I'd be doing so to gain MORE slots, not to re-purpose the slots I already own on Virtue.
My point was not to gain more slots, but rather to re-use the slots I already own. I simply wanted to avoid paying twice for something that I thought I'd already paid for. But now that I know that I cannot do so (under the current terms of use), that point is moot.
Once a player unlocks a character slot on a specific server, it stays on that server forever, and cannot be moved to another server. If they ever want to play on a different server, there are only these options:
1. Character Slot Purchase: at 480 points for 1 or 800 for 2, that's at least $10.
2. Character Transfer: 800 points (at least $10) or earned monthly with VIP.
3. Become a VIP: $15 per month.
There is no approved mechanism for a player to move an unlocked slot from one server to another. I opened an Incident with The Support Team, which confirmed this. I think that this policy is unwise at best, and perhaps unethical at worst. I believe that this is a short-sighted mistake that offends me as a player (a VIP) and ultimately hurts the game in the long run.
First, let me make it clear that I am talking about empty "Create Character" slots. I am not talking about created/equipped character slots: that's a value-added service that can and should cost points. This topic of this thread is limited to only empty character slots.
I do not see how NCSoft loses anything by making it easy or convenient for players to move unlocked/empty character slots among different servers. If anything, doing so would encourage such players to play MORE, because it gives them the mobility to seek out and find the server the best suits their needs and/or gives them greatest enjoyment from the game. If the player is playing on a server that makes him/her happy, then they're more likely to stay there, keep playing, keep shopping, keep buying points, etc. This is ultimately the best outcome for CoH and NCSoft.
But if the player is "locked-in" to a specific server that somehow becomes dull or even hostile, then what recourse does the player have? Can they easily move to another server? No, not really. Yes, they might have a transfer token, or might be willing to buy one, but how will they choose a destination? Without the ability to freely sample the other servers with a new character, why would they gamble a transfer token, points, or real cash on a new server, sight unseen?
No, it makes far better sense to give the player the option of using one of the empty slots they've already unlocked, instead. Allow them to move it from server A to server B, so they can at least try it out. What difference does it really make if the unlocked slot is on or the other anyway, as long as the net number of slots is the same?
I understand that it's completely within their rights for NCSoft to define how players are allowed to create and use character slots on the servers: I don't disagree with that, nor that they are wrong to do so. I'm just saying that this may not be right or best, either. It might be better and smarter for NCSoft to give their customers a bit more flexibility, so that they might enjoy their products and services more, and as an incentive to spend more money on those products and services.
I've been playing CoH since November 2004. I'm a 5+ year veteran VIP with 4 accounts (2 VIP, 2 Premium/Free). Since CoH Freedom went live, I've purchased 8,960 Paragon Points ($100 USD, apart from those included with VIP). So I want to make it clear that I'm not complaining about money, begrudging NCSoft any money, or whining about getting something for nothing.
Thanks for your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Ralph S. Thomas
a.k.a. @Rathstar1
formerly of Virtue
now on Liberty
(which is why I want to move my slots, dammit!)