Blaster Secondaries
We've made more than a few threads that say the same thing. Hopefully we'll get at least one new secondary with the next round of power customization... whenever that is (hopefully the next issue or so).
MA gets my vote, personally.
Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc: Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory
Be nice if they looked at improving the existing secondaries. Seriously when an at goes from being the most popular on the early part of the game to somewhere around 4th or 5th in the late game, that's telling you there is a problem.
I think it would be nice if they just made double choice to powers instead of making a new secondary. Basically 2 powers to choose from. This would bring life to old toons. It would also allow players to slot Inventions they currently couldn't to allow for a different types of builds. It would also open the ground to making new toons or really have a different spin on a secondary build.
1. Why Soft Cap is Important : http://dechskaison.blogspot.com/2011...important.html
2. Limits: http://paragonwiki.com/wiki/Limits
3. Attack Mechanics: http://wiki.cohtitan.com/wiki/Attack_Mechanics
4. Rule of Five: http://wiki.cohtitan.com/wiki/Rule_o...e_Law_of_Fives
What Grey Pilgrim said. Of course, the reason Blasters have so few secondaries is the same reason Masterminds have so few primaries: the sets are unique. No other Archetype has "Manipulation" sets. True, many of the Manipulation sets use existing powers, but there are always a few totally unique powers within them, and the power sets as a whole have to be created from scratch. Whereas, if you want to give a Defender (for example) something new, the Devs need only tweak the numbers on Fire Blast and/or Thermal Radiation and proliferate them.
Blasters are due for another secondary (and even though I don't use them I think Masterminds could use another primary, but that's off topic). I think we should be top priority on the "ATs due for new powersets" list.
-Preferably, I'd like to see a Rad. Manipulation or Sonic Manipulation (to match their primary counterparts, though Sonic Manipulation is harder to imagine).
-If they decide to port over Dark Blast, I would prefer they do so while also introducing a Darkness Manipulation set.
-A secondary utilizing martial arts is also highly desirable since, for right now, Devices is really the only fitting power set for Natural origin Blasters. And who doesn't like gun-fu?!
@Winter. Because I'm Winter. Period.
I am a blaster first, and an alt-oholic second.
Here is a little thing to think about.
I know everyone who plays blasters would like more secondary choices, and while we might disagree about the form they should take, how would you justify doing it outside of something like going rogue if you were at paragon studios ?
I mean pardon the pun but dual pistols was something of a one shot wonder and as is was used as a carrot to get people to buy going rogue. So how do you come up with devoting more effort to what is essentially a bait and switch kind of AT ?
Edit: TBH at this point and seeing how extremely well equipped blasters handle the new content its very unlikely I will roll another blaster. I have tried and spent tens of billions on the toons and they just aren't there. In the real world range offers a great advantage here its more than marginalized.
Here is a little thing to think about.
I know everyone who plays blasters would like more secondary choices, and while we might disagree about the form they should take, how would you justify doing it outside of something like going rogue if you were at paragon studios ? |
-= idspispopd =-
[size=1]Arc ID: 3155 - Project Prometheus (Seeking Feedback, now with less invalidation)[/size]
At any point between your initial realization that a particular character wasn't meeting one or more of your expectations and your eventual declaration that the entire archetype is useless, Another Fan, did you wonder if perhaps your problem is an internal one?
Same way as they have been doing it, Powerset Proliferation.
|
At any point between your initial realization that a particular character wasn't meeting one or more of your expectations and your eventual declaration that the entire archetype is useless, Another Fan, did you wonder if perhaps your problem is an internal one?
|
A particular ? bump the digit up and add a 0.
And yes I have considered that I might need to lrn2play. But even before the I19 overall boost, I had soloed task forces and pylons with them. Its just an appreciation of where they are lacking.
I have always said that 1-20 blasters are the kings of the game. People talk about brutes being fastest in this range and I will say they aren't playing their blasters right. Right around 20 though the world goes to Hades for blasters and it just keeps heading in that direction. It really was just an aha I was right moment when I saw the devs data dump to kotaku was in alignment with what I had been saying.
Edit: here is a point of comparison for you
My fire/mental blaster likely the best performing blaster I have
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1436;694;1388;HEX;|
|78DA6593E94E135114C7CFED22505A6959A4652F050B850EA DA0C42D2802094A4D8|
|5C44F621D61522669DA4929897EF31104515C1EC007707D29 97EFC6D433E77F0B35|
|6DE0FCEE9CE5FECFDD72CF5682442F964885EE94CCFDFDC23 2DB9A55F5E7CCA2BD4|
|36D4414D3AEC2A6592E5ABBC69A5DB590966844B60E1CA752 AD1939AB5C334B859C|
|59B69D839259B32BE5C87A79CFAAB2DF680C02F94AA5646C3 996B51B94E186653A7|
|6B918928F35BBB857E3AFAE4668D7AAEEEFD94E6CD5B1778C 8660CEDCB1D8B8E3E7|
|51EE31C5FFB7A8F1ABFBE8849124CF5BE09DC0F71EF820383 C4BF7D2B1221AA7734|
|7C04B41FBA1E03667283DAD4269001305306D1022ED905C66 EBD5E9DE450F5196CE|
|CF030B82F06541F08A609C77D82FD3D7957F865C573770812 36D8878DAFAA49568A|
|F7223D1BFEC1CA663B61D5AA9E393D4F47E013E6386AFC037 C10ADB4EA4FB3B913E|
|80BC21540D217DE4BB20BCC0F07929C16D845046A1B8845EB 3ED824B75A1D92CB0C|
|A36A22391FF226B6C7BB47A4F56963E9201E60463069016CC 7E94AA376CFB544096|
|D8774FF620B501E4652BD239F91AB82F50DC6BBF3ED2FE3CB 9AEB907C0A660764BE|
|0E5BC986E33D6AFDCCD1CBBE475E19EE12036DD3F684A2BF1 02F018D816249E08B2|
|8F043E9E6F581FD5308E2A1516CC2D6217239C31AA3346919 14046C23DD324BD92C|
|6D0FA385A9F40CF49AC2089D6DD2B37A90F7DF2AAA85FBC06 5C076E089237057FC2|
|44535A770ABAD3D09DD69D1D3166B4F00C8467A198867E1AC 2DDBC0203339111175|
|72FBB32FA6A64DCC9A334E43B7D54FCC73F8AFB1AEFA75E4F B544332D9E6C8B67BE|
|C5B3D0E2D93853E147214BCFFB4EDF2D2949EA089F3ECDFA0 FBE544A17A8B42CE7D|
|799CBA31ECAF59A5897C399BE2BF8D95C332535BF9B6B8E44 B7FBC423A737263738|
|1F90964473BB696C368D9F368D977ADC2A8CFF015EB8E302|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
I really would have loved to squeeze aid self in here but it would have gutted the offense and a good portion of the defense.
vs My claws/sr brute.
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1409;682;1364;HEX;|
|78DA65946B53125118C7CF2E20099A100898888A1882B1CAD 4EB9A2973C69219CD6|
|E63178696036C31C87049AD37CDF40D6A26BB7C8C6EAFFB06 DDFB1456EFCBE8D9E7|
|7F321A1838BFE7FCF7B99D6777C96D2D0C0871FFA4D0BCA7A B8566337FAAD16E495|
|7AE50B64CE11642F859C8E764554A835C369B51280BB2246B 4D69ACB5EBB2913F2F|
|4B55B9259BFEA55A453664AD65FC3506563636AAC6B22CD4A D5AD9C39BB5BA94C54|
|13617AD72A54517B0CBC9A2655A35193E53B74C0375D636DA D57CAED06CC9C67684|
|1A4AD3CF1C14EAD371897542521CB80A5C6378AE033718537 9C63B3B40E32887F09|
|191157A90111CC62EC0786FBB293F0D7E4EF839E117825F91 BA70A82E1C52D8D240|
|113019070BC04DC6DC5B5D888008D1545DC8AEBB90AF0FD9F B504B525AB74AEBBEC|
|3A18736812DC6E16DE02E23718FF191D67EA415FDB32CC529 8B5755F242F2FD8729|
|72C0243B627092A54FB40EA998A1184B41606E8F30262A14E 057DDF99FF35CA33B8|
|CC927C053CCFC1923FB40B7A33ED02680B45A00F942C0675A 8755C1610C20827144|
|E050A28261A173C1700905CB8C588531710B752DC6DC6D864 6471B51471BE9D0477|
|C217B54151A45EA9802EE82C36D778A90B1B0666F9C248DAB 9871784DA0C709F438|
|460E711513E73216B53BADE633FD53B79D8EFC02F680DF8C6 48791C6D84D7A8E661|
|0E59CC15453986A0A534D61AA694C5592FBAC729F7DC1198E BE045E01AF1999378C|
|71EAD280BB6E5CE4C6B3ABC005CDCEF7952ECDAB87673EC33 151E7FE2B465FFB64E|
|91E65BE47C9F628C77A94E33DCAA2AD68E76CA5B3DC7375C5 A9DE5A523456FA7DFB|
|2F5E67D7B3FFB20A0DAD7FFF27B9B44B7CCEC4593E6702874 F2EF12E89194C9DE07|
|BFDAD3BD10C27FAE1E9FA237888FBF58891790CEC305603F6 8A7E563DDC39DB97BB|
|EC2B5DF67A97FD07B6ACEC68|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
For about a tenth the effort I get considerably superior performance.
We have the worst secondaries in the whole game........... ive pretty much just accepted it at this point. 7 years and they are almost all terrible.
Psynder LVL 51 Fire/Fire/Scorpion Blaster
KnightWidow LVL 51 NightWidow
Shiver LVL 50 Ice X3 Dominator
Knight'Shade LVL 47 DP/Dark/NRG Corrupter
Currently Marking Out For: Chris Sabin, Player Dos, Daniel Bryan, Portia Perez, CM Punk
-= idspispopd =-
[size=1]Arc ID: 3155 - Project Prometheus (Seeking Feedback, now with less invalidation)[/size]
-= idspispopd =-
[size=1]Arc ID: 3155 - Project Prometheus (Seeking Feedback, now with less invalidation)[/size]
Not directly, but look at how they pieced together MM. The same could be done for a number of other power sets, some easier than others of course. Dark, Rad, MA could be added fairly easily compared to creating something completely from scratch. (yes, yes, insert standard code rant )
|
Fire has been improved by leaps and bounds but its still not very good compared to other ATs secondaries. What I wouldnt give to be able to spec into /MM.
Psynder LVL 51 Fire/Fire/Scorpion Blaster
KnightWidow LVL 51 NightWidow
Shiver LVL 50 Ice X3 Dominator
Knight'Shade LVL 47 DP/Dark/NRG Corrupter
Currently Marking Out For: Chris Sabin, Player Dos, Daniel Bryan, Portia Perez, CM Punk
Blaster secondaries don't match other powersets. At best they borrow bits and pieces likely to cut down on the cost of creating something for just one AT.
|
It really was just an aha I was right moment when I saw the devs data dump to kotaku was in alignment with what I had been saying. |
Edit: here is a point of comparison for you My fire/mental blaster likely the best performing blaster I have I really would have loved to squeeze aid self in here but it would have gutted the offense and a good portion of the defense. vs My claws/sr brute. For about a tenth the effort I get considerably superior performance. |
The tradeoff for me is that Spin is basically the sum of the meleer's tricks in practical circumstances, by which I always mean speed TFs. It's a doozy, of course, but here's an example of what I mean from last week's WTF that I ran a hundred freaking times. Full team, +2 level, DP/EM blaster admittedly more incarnated than my KM/FA scrapper. Mission 1: Both characters are equally good at running directly to the end and wiping out the Penelope Yin guards and surrounding spawns. Getting mezzed hardly matters when a single window of opportunity results in a hail of bullets which kills everything and knocks the bosses onto their butts. Mission 2: Whee, the riders. My blaster has no problem taking on the rider spawns solo. Why? Cause famine can't terrorize and drain what isn't standing next to him. My scrapper basically has to sit around for teammates to catch up and then we all bum rush. It works but it is less amusing. Mission 3: Both of them are great at rescuing the poor, trusting hostages. Mission 4: My scrapper can kill a yellow in five seconds, but after that he's basically a cheerleader for the rest of the team. No room in the build for holds, either, as I bypassed an epic to softcap s/l more efficiently. I'm pretty sure that my blaster could solo hami if I could figure out a way to handle the final phase. Mission 5: No difference. Oh, and my blaster has vengeance and resuscitate, while my scrapper only had room for the former.
Blasters are great if you ask me. All you need is extreme damage baked into more than one or two single great powers and the high level game is your oyster. One thing I am starting to come around to is the idea of turning all nukes into crashless nukes. Why should the weapon sets have all the fun?
Cascade, level 50 Blaster (NRG/NRG since before it was cool)
Mechmeister, level 50 Bots / Traps MM
FAR too many non-50 alts to name
[u]Arcs[u]
The Scavenger Hunt: 187076
The Instant Lair Delivery Service: 206636
I'm not going to argue that blaster secondaries are particularly good, the only ones I can personally stand to play being EM and MM. Even with those I only take the utility powers, slot up the mandatory attack, and forgo the melee and psi aoes. Instead of looking at blasters as half an archetype, I see them as meant to do everything in their power to leverage the hell out of the primary and those utility powers. To that end, blasters in general get more freedom than most combinations in any other AT to pick the pools they want and slot them as fully as they want.I don't remember the specifics offhand but didn't that chart show that blasters at level 50 were still in the top five most played ATs? A drop in popularity from number one at low level of course, but the majority of ATs didn't even make the list. As we know from other dev comments, several ATs are in the neighborhood of 1.5% usage. Maybe it varies by server but I rarely see a trial team that doesn't have more than one blaster, and possibly never one that lacks any blasters.Unfortunately I lack mids but I assume the blaster has huge recharge and ranged and/or s/l defense and the brute has an inexpensive softcapping build. I have a lot more level 50 and IOed out scrappers than blasters myself so I know how that can be. For instance, Spin can do 300ish damage every five seconds without even that much recharge while Fireball struggles to keep pace for thrice as much bling. Meanwhile the meleer is not at risk and the blaster occasionally is.
The tradeoff for me is that Spin is basically the sum of the meleer's tricks in practical circumstances, by which I always mean speed TFs. It's a doozy, of course, but here's an example of what I mean from last week's WTF that I ran a hundred freaking times. Full team, +2 level, DP/EM blaster admittedly more incarnated than my KM/FA scrapper. Mission 1: Both characters are equally good at running directly to the end and wiping out the Penelope Yin guards and surrounding spawns. Getting mezzed hardly matters when a single window of opportunity results in a hail of bullets which kills everything and knocks the bosses onto their butts. Mission 2: Whee, the riders. My blaster has no problem taking on the rider spawns solo. Why? Cause famine can't terrorize and drain what isn't standing next to him. My scrapper basically has to sit around for teammates to catch up and then we all bum rush. It works but it is less amusing. Mission 3: Both of them are great at rescuing the poor, trusting hostages. Mission 4: My scrapper can kill a yellow in five seconds, but after that he's basically a cheerleader for the rest of the team. No room in the build for holds, either, as I bypassed an epic to softcap s/l more efficiently. I'm pretty sure that my blaster could solo hami if I could figure out a way to handle the final phase. Mission 5: No difference. Oh, and my blaster has vengeance and resuscitate, while my scrapper only had room for the former. Blasters are great if you ask me. All you need is extreme damage baked into more than one or two single great powers and the high level game is your oyster. One thing I am starting to come around to is the idea of turning all nukes into crashless nukes. Why should the weapon sets have all the fun? |
I could go back and forth on this but I doubt either one of us would change the others viewpoint.
But our experiences seem to diverge.
Mission 1 of Lady Grey, that last room is a 4 to 6 break free moment. The spawns are usually doubled and tripled and even mammoth amounts of aoe will not drop them before they can land a mezz on you.
Mission 2: The riders have something for everyone and if they don't the spawns surrounding them do
Mission 3: Getting the hostages killed isn't much of a test for anyone.
Mission 4: Scrappers have soloed weakened hamidon can't recall of ever hearing a blaster do it. Maybe a nice incarnate challenge ? The incarnate abilities do throw the old performance expectations out the window.
Mission 5: The scrapper is in much better position to have the temp power from mission 4 if needed. While I don't have vengeance or resusicitate I do have aid other. Should I offer him as a healer ?
Edit: Agree with you about the crashless nukes but its amazing how many people are vehement about their crashing nukes. Even so, Full Auto needs some love.
I only mention venge and resuscitate because they're fantastic utility powers to have on pug teams. I guess it would also have been worth mentioning that I keep a tray full of phenomenal lucks and whatever big oranges are called on all my 50s. This does not strike me as cheating as any character can easily do this without ever having to buy them on the market. So yeah, are the riders hard? Sure, until you use a couple of the many aces up your sleeve. Blasters also have enough hit points that rebirth is crazy effective on 'em.
You can say that scrappers can also leverage inspirations and incarnate powers, and you would obviously be completely correct. While these things can make anyone unkillable, though, they can't add the same amount of damage to anyone, in my opinion. Sure judgement is amazing for a scrapper but that's once every 90 seconds. Blasters get judgement too, and they should have no qualms dropping it and everything else they've got on anyone who looks at em funny with all the defensive perks they have always had access to, and newly have access to.
I just wish they werent so loaded with bad powers. Yes we have like 2-3 great powers in some sets but for every good power there are 3 useless awfully bad ones.
Fire has been improved by leaps and bounds but its still not very good compared to other ATs secondaries. What I wouldnt give to be able to spec into /MM. |
My /Fire took a while to really get a feel for and I didn't really get it down until I ran a /Energy that focused almost exclusively on the melee attacks. It was a learning curve at the time and I got a number of people yelling at me, because Blasters were supposed to be ranged only. It was surprising how survivable a Blaster could be in melee, but you did have to be careful, mostly when dealing with AoE mezzers. I've got a DP/MM now that is going to be in melee quite often due to all of the PBAoEs.
That said, I do think it would be nice to see a secondary that focused a bit more on range instead of melee. Would be an interesting change of pace. I'd also like to see Martial Arts as a secondary so...
-= idspispopd =-
[size=1]Arc ID: 3155 - Project Prometheus (Seeking Feedback, now with less invalidation)[/size]
Be really wild to have boost range in a secondary that actually has ranged attacks.
|
Ha! To me, thats the opposite of what should happen. EM works pretty well, wouldnt you want to spread that around? TK thrust is my favorite MM power. I get good use of other ones, but thats a workhorse for me when i solo, and helps on teams for myself and the occasional butt saving of the defender or troller standing in back by me getting hammered on.
I dunno. I would love to see a dark manip set, but I hope it isnt 6 blaps and a build up and a ST immob.
Liberty server
Eldagore lvl 50 Inv/ss, co-founder of The Legion of Smash
3.5 servers of alts....I need help.
May the rawk be with you.
Arc #'s
107020 Uberbots!
93496 A Pawn in Time
Cascade, level 50 Blaster (NRG/NRG since before it was cool)
Mechmeister, level 50 Bots / Traps MM
FAR too many non-50 alts to name
[u]Arcs[u]
The Scavenger Hunt: 187076
The Instant Lair Delivery Service: 206636
i wanted to make a new toon .
i like blasters ,brutes & doms.
i have a bunch of brutes & doms
Blasters have the fewest secondaries of any AT can we at least port some of the dom sets over to blasters to even em out like thorns an stone its only fair i think . sure i would like MA an some kind of Dark
but at this point ill take any thing new .