scrapper vs brute
lol im guessing that means this has been asked before.
If either has half a brain, it will be 0-0 100% of the time.
I stand on crates on the cargo map and spam web nades. Seeing everyone always ragequits out I am undefeated. Therefore brutes are obviously best.
Duel me.
I will work on my sig pic more when I have time.

yuo can do that in regin two, nub!
Always in melee=PvE
The best comics are still 10�!
My City of Heroes Blog Freedom Feature Article: "Going Rageless?"
If you only read one guide this year, make it this one.
Super Reflexes: the Golden Fox of power sets!

WARNING: I bold names.

I didn't see the OP as a question about fight clubbing, but about a simple 1v1.
He's talking about how brutes play, not giving some rule about the duel. Just because the brute may try to always stay in melee, doesn't mean the scrapper has to do the same.
lrn2understand
which one would win in pvp if they were the same powersets, played at same skill level?
I heard both sides of story from players in game, some telling me brutes would win because they would always be in melee, building fury, whilst others say scrapper because crits are more reliable.