Werner

If Mids' is correct, it looks like 69.2% resistance to endurance drain at level 50, unenhanceable. It's a lot. I don't remember any endurance drain problems leveling my Katana/Dark, and that included Sappers, though perhaps I've forgotten. I agree that purple shields would be helpful if you need any extra help.

Generalizing a bit from what BrokenPrey said, the only sense in which Dark Melee/Super Reflexes may be worse is that when I built mine (I12), I felt it was THE top performer for AV soloing. Now, due to new sets, new IOs, and a number of buffs, a lot of combinations are its equal or better in that regard. But it hasn't gone downhill in any absolute sense, and depending on when "a long time ago" was, it may have gotten significantly tougher since you last fiddled with it.

Dark Comes with a self heal, which is a big help. If you go with Fire, you'll be somewhat squishier unless you splurge for the Medicine pool and Aid Self. Not squishy, mind you, just squishier, more dependent on greens. But Invunerability's hit points generally move slowly enough to give you time to react.

On the offense front, the main difference between Fire and Dark is your AoE potential. Fire has it; Dark doesn't. So I guess it depends on what you mean by "able to fight". Either will fight just fine, but Fire will tear through larger spawns faster due to better AoE. And with Invuln, you're better off in large spawns.

So I guess my recommendation would be Fire/Invuln. It's tough enough for most things, and will put out more damage. But if you really want to feel Invulnerable, go with Dark/Invuln.

As for how to build it, your first three pools are Fitness, Leaping and Fighting. From Fitness, take Hurdle, Health and Stamina. From Leaping take Combat Jumping (and Super Jump if you want a travel power). From Fighting take either prerequisite (you won't be using it) and Tough and Weave. Your fourth power pool should probably be Speed, Medicine (only on Fire) or Leadership. All have different flavors of what they do for you. Speed brings Dull Pain back faster, and helps out your offense. Medicine gives you a heal, so is pretty straightforward. Leadership gives you Maneuvers for a small defensive boost, and if you take Tactics, you can stick a Gaussian set in it (it could also go in a Build Up power). I personally went with Hasten on my Brute that I'm leveling, but I'm not convinced I made the right choice yet.

From your secondary, I recommend taking everything except Unstoppable. Some people like Unstoppable, but I'm not a fan of crashing tier nines, and I'm already pretty unstoppable. If you go with Dark Melee, Siphon Life is your key attack since it heals you. It's probably worth frankenslotting in the mid game since it's serving double duty as a heal and an attack, and should be spammed in your attack chain.

Pick up a Steadfast Protection unique. Red side, I just put in bids for recipes as infamy came in, and ended up with two of them by the thirties (so one went to storage). Blue side I have buckets of them so it's never been an issue.

End game builds are a different story. A survivability-spec Dark/Invuln is capable of taking on multiple AVs at the same time without temporary powers or inspirations. Probably something to worry about when you get leveled up, unless you like knowing where you're going.

If you want a very tanky build, Dark Melee/Invulnerability is a very good choice (I'm leveling one now red side). But you'd also be fine with Fire/Invuln. And you can also build Shield Defense to be very survivable, even on a budget.

Quoting myself from another thread:

You don't really need help from the Primary either. I played Dual Blades/Willpower to 50 on a Scrapper, and I think to about 30 on a Brute, both on the influence earned while leveling. "Very Squishy" is not how I'd describe it. I suspect this is a build or play style problem, not a lack of expensive set bonuses problem.

I'll agree that it's even hardier with Broad Sword or Katana, though.

Does being the reincarnation of Bubba count? Because that would be a lot closer.

Yeah, I'm assuming fairly extreme levels of recharge to run the very best possible chains. I certainly wouldn't be surpised if Claws is better at more down-to-earth levels. I'll open the new window... yeah, for basic slotting, Bill has Claws at the top for Scrappers.

I'm pretty sure you could do a Dual Blades/Electric Armor without Stamina. Haven't tried it, but it certainly sounds doable.

Oh, VERY nice. OK. Now I feel bad about trying to point out where I thought he was coming from. Turns out he's coming a MUCH more offensive place. I agree that reporting him to the Mods is the right response. I hope you get banned, Pur3Z. You've lost all sympathy from me and I can't believe I wasted time defending you.

Fury, I did find your initial reply to be reasonable based on one reasonable interpretation of the original post (which is the same as my interpretation on first reading). Some of this appears, on further review, to be just a misunderstanding since Pur3Z got the build from a friend (who got it from the forum) instead of getting it directly from the forum. He therefore wouldn't have known who the build came from and what it was capable of, no matter how well known this is on the forum, since he's not a forum regular. He didn't specifically pass it off as his own creation, just asked if it was any good. Yes, perhaps "forum convention" says that unless you say you got it from someone else, you're claiming that you made the build yourself. Pur3Z doesn't know "forum convention" since this is pretty much his first time posting. So people are kind of jumping on him for violating unwritten "rules" that he wasn't aware of. So while I understand exactly where you're coming from, and it's exactly where I'd have been coming from had I been the first responder, I can understand him getting upset now that we know more of the story.

Calling you a "Feggat", however, went over the line. And Pur3Z, even if you don't think it went over the line, I hope you can see that name calling, even if you personally feel it's a reasonable response to being "attacked", isn't a great way to win friends and influence people?

At this point, Pur3Z has been red repped into the toilet, I'm going to guess for the name calling. Hopefully that's enough to satisfy the people upset with him?

Pur3Z, you at least got your answer (the build is great), even if you didn't like HOW you got the answer. You've learned that the Scrapper forum wants you to be explicit about where you got the build you want feedback on, or we'll make some assumptions that you didn't intend, and are probably quite shocked that we made. Yes, you can easily claim that this means we have reading comprehension problems, but that's not really it. We just have some unwritten rules about what needs to be stated and what doesn't need to be stated. To pick another random unwritten rule, unless PvP is specifically stated, we're talking about PvE. So if you ask for advice on a build, you're going to get PvE advice, which can get you killed in PvP. Since you don't know all the unwritten rules and seemingly strange assumptions we may make, you're better off giving us too much information rather than too little, even if it seems to you that nobody with a basic grasp of the English language would misinterpret what you're saying (and what you're not saying). So you're hopefully now in a much better position to avoid this sort of forum brawl in the future. I hope you'll continue to post and look for advice here, even if we all got off on the wrong foot.

And why am I trying to be forum counselor? *sigh* It's like I've never seen people argue on the internets before.

Well, all builds are compromises in some way. There's no best build for everything. What I'm saying is that if you build Katana/Electic for maximum possible DPS for pylon soloing, you might not have the survivability you need for AV soloing. And if you build it for the survivability for AV soloing, you're not going to have the highest DPS.

A low-compromise AV and pylon soloer is Dark Melee/Shield Defense. Also worth considering is Fire/Shield, which has a little compromise on the survivability front (it "must" pick up Aid Self) but gets better AoE for general game play. But both are very popular builds, at least on the forums, so don't fall into the category of "a little different." But I think ONE of the following three items will likely need to go:

• a little different
• great for AV soloing
• top times for pylon soloing

Thanks, Umbral. I wanted to answer this, and I was trying to calculate Fire Blast correctly, and I THOUGHT that's how it was calculated, but then the numbers I had on my Tanker spreadsheet didn't match that OR Mids'. No idea what I did wrong on that spreadsheet. I need to fix it to avoid confusing myself in the future.

Difficult due to the difficulty of getting good ranged and AoE defense with a secondary that provides none of either. But should be doable with the right build. I've NOT actually tried to put together a build like this, though, so this is just general rather than specific experience talking. If it were me, I'd assemble a good build first before committing. Well, no, actually I'd probably just play it 1-50 first since it sounds like loads of fun for leveling, THEN figure out if it was worth going further with it.

Edit: Won't top the pylon charts, but with the right build, won't be too far off the pace either.

Edit 2: The build to place on the pylon charts might look significantly different than the build to solo AVs. Doing both at once would probably be compromised at both. Not that compromises are bad. A compromise might make for a better all-purpose build.

I just hope that Super Strength gets ported soon, in whatever form they port it, so that this monthly argument can at least be about something real.

No, they've never been available on Scrappers. Yes, they will probably be available at some point in the future. Powerset proliferation is one of the goals of the devs. Many sets have been ported so far. Many more to come.