Ironik

Forum Cartel
  • Posts

    5889
  • Joined

  1. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Samuel_Tow View Post
    You have a very broad definition of "magic," which appears to be "anything that's not otherwise defined." I disagree with that interpretation of the concept, considering City of Heroes already makes a CLEAR distinction between the power of the divine - which tends to be classed Natural - and magical ritual, spell, incantation and enchantment. This is the centrepiece of the story of Tielekku, and by also apparently the theme behind the story of the Well of the Furies, which we call that only because that's the image it took on when Statesman and Recluse drank from it.
    I'm drawing a blank on where the reference to the "divine is natural" is in game. In War Witch's commentary in the Origin of Power arc, she specifically states that Tielekku is the source of all magic in the world, saying that it's separate from the divine, but as far as I can recall that's the only mention of it. I had assumed that meant there was "god magic" (divine) and "human magic" (magic). The whole Circle of Thorns background involves their god warring against other gods, so the CoT aligned with demons, which introduced "demon magic." As far as I can recall (and at this point I just blow past the text so maybe I've forgotten it) there is no mention of the divine in those CoT arcs -- it's all about dark magic.

    Quote:
    You also assume that items like Excalibur are "magic," when there really is no clear evidence that they are, or indeed that they are supernatural in general.
    Hero-1 became an Incarnate after the Lady of the Lake gave him Excalibur, and he was chosen to lead the all-magic Omega team because he was the most powerful magic user. To me, that pretty much says that Excalibur is magic, so by extension the Girdle of Hera would be, too, since they come from the same group of gods.

    Quote:
    We see them do things we cannot expect, yes, but we cannot infer that they are "magical" in the definition of City of Heroes any more than we can infer that the Green Lantern ring is magical in nature simply because its effect looks like magic. "Unexplainable" is not a definition for magic.
    Since everything else the gods give to humans is magic, then inferring that Excalibur, etc., are magic seems relatively straightforward.

    Quote:
    As I understood the power of the Well to work was in granting both opportunity and inspiration. A Scientist blessed by the Well will simply be able to have ever better ideas and be ever more capable of following through with them. A mutant blessed by the power of the Well will be more likely to develop benevolent mutations which improve their powers, as opposed to developing cancer. Magic users, furthermore, will find themselves better able to cast their spells, channel their magic items, draw on their magic blood and so forth.
    See, it's this part that smells of retcon to me, and I don't buy it. Every other time the Well of Furies has been mentioned, it's in relation to bestowing magical properties upon people or items. It's only recently the Well has transformed from a literal water well to a metaphorical source of power. But even then its effects are described as magical. I believe in the Cannon Fodder thread it was stated that the Greek gods still exist, they just choose not to manifest directly, instead imparting their powers upon Incarnates. I haven't seen any mention that is being changed now.

    Quote:
    The well has no "power" in the literal sense of the word. The well cannot actually "do" anything. It needs us to act through our powers, ideally on its behalf. The true power of the Well is the power of the people who "drank" from it.
    Again, this is a departure from established lore, because it is explicitly stated that the Well is a repository for power, altering those who drink from it into Incarnates. Hero-1 is the sole exception to this in official cannon, getting his abilities from Excalibur and the Lady of the Lake, who has some connection to the Well. I don't think they clarified whether she's a conduit or a god herself. If they're using Hero-1's backstory to say that the Well is but one of many conduits of magic, that's fine, but it doesn't change my basic stance that Incarnate stuff is magic.
  2. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Dolphin View Post
    There's a Doctor Who joke in there that I'm not going to touch... LOL

    And if anything needs rebooting, it's Star Blazers!
    Something like Space Battleship Yamato?
  3. I totally forgot someone: Garret Hedlund. He played Sam in Tron: Legacy, Achilles' cousin in Troy and Beau in Country Strong. He can pull off action scenes, can be reckless or laconic or psychotic as needed, and is a terrific actor. The guy's a total chameleon.

  4. Quote:
    Originally Posted by EvilRyu View Post
    I rather loved the voice acting in Thundercats.
    We need a phrase like "rose-colored glasses" for hearing.
  5. Quote:
    Originally Posted by SkarmoryThePG View Post
    I dunno, it sounds more clunky than shvingy to me.
    If you mean this moment right here, then there must be something wrong with your sound card. That's definitely the metal-on-metal drawing-the-sword zing sound.
  6. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    Yep.

    The Incarnate felderkarb officially marks the point where you should really start treating all game text as if it only said "click here to fight mobs".
    I see what you mean, but I actually started doing that with the Origin of Power nonsense since it instantly invalidated at least a dozen character backstories, especially my 117-year-old mutant who was told that no mutants existed before 1938.
  7. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
    I don't remember seeing the words "magic" or "gods" anywhere during Ramiel's arc - the nearest is in the cutscene, where it says Incarnates are "godlike beings" - but it then says that "Links to the Well appear throughout the universe, choosing the most powerful. It has many names and many forms." - it's just presented as a vague cosmic power source, not as something that's magical.
    Call it what you will, it's still magic. Despite not coming right out and saying that the Well is magic, there's still a lot of hints that something supernatural is going on. Until they put in something that convinces me the Well's ability to give you a boost through what is essentially wish-fulfillment is actually some sort of cosmological constant like gravity, then all of the talk about magical items (Excalibur, Hera's Girdle, the power of Zeus, etc.) is something I'm going to take at face value.

    There is a Magic origin in the game, Mu is a magic-based gene pool, Omega team was specifically comprised of magic users, the Rikti are now seeking magic... on and on. If they're going to switch gears and start saying that what we call "magic" is actually technologically manipulated dark energy or something, then come out and do it. But that's going to make a lot of people unhappy. "Magic" as a generic concept is pretty well understood and is accepted to be part of this universe. Everything regarding the Well of Furies has been about mythological gods and the supernatural magic powers they possessed, and how the most powerful NPCs are likewise incarnates of those mythic gods.

    No matter how much they "character develop" the Well of Furies to not be a physical well, there is still a ton of lore about how it's magic.

    Regardless of how the boost is given, whether it's by magical means of "Power Spirits Activate!" or some form of nanotechnology rewriting a character's DNA, some of my characters aren't going to participate in that. Because I want them to have the story arc of *my* choosing, not have one forced upon them.
  8. Quote:
    Originally Posted by GibsonMcCoy View Post
    I don't remember that at all. Not saying it wasn't there, it's just I don't recall seeing it.
    It's there. The movies are terrible, but not because of that.
  9. Spider-Man. For me, he's the ultimate superheroic creation. Smart but insecure, heroic but unloved, funny and can walk on walls.
  10. Although probably quite a few years before the time of most people on here, I always liked Thundarr the Barbarian. It's sort of a post-apocalyptic mash-up of Conan the Barbarian and Star Wars. He even had a lightsaber-like sword and a Wookiee-like buddy.

    Were it up to me, I'd completely eliminate the Fantasy elements altogether and focus entirely on the Science Fiction side of it. It reminds me a lot of the Philip Jose Farmer novel Dark Is The Sun, where these primitive people trekking across a dying Earth kept encountering tech which was just bizarre but totally cool. Thundarr felt like that to me as a kid.
  11. Downward Facing Dog has gone terribly wrong here.
  12. That looks amazing. By "that" I mean "both of those."
  13. Sexists. I get zero compliments on my awesome posing beside a tripod, but the hot chick gets people fawning all over her. Sure, be that way.
  14. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Zikar View Post
    Once again, I'm the only person who like Origins.
    Well, you're the one who keeps banging his head into those low pipes.
  15. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
    Actually, they've made a point of distancing the Incarnate system from the original idea of it being the power of the gods - it's now just an undefined source of power, and it doesn't have to be a a magical/fantasy source of pwoer at all.
    That's not how I read it. All of the lore on the GR site and Ramiel's arc indicates that you get some sort of magic turbo boost. That's why you can just walk all over those ubermenschen in that "Ouroboros in flames" mission. Some of my characters I've created with the game's backstory in mind, so it's not a big deal. For some of them, though, getting magical steroids doesn't sit well with their concepts.

    It's similar to the "evil clone" arc in Talos (I forget the contact's name) -- he's not cloning my robots, so I just ignore it. I've actually become quite adroit at doing that throughout the game, to the point where it's second nature now and I just mentally edit things out on the fly.
  16. Holy frijoles, Sho, that's a lot of work.

    I read The Hard Call and I highly recommend it.

    Jurassic Park clearly has tongue-cam.
  17. I see they've decide to completely forgo adding details. Cutbacks are a *****.
  18. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Santorican View Post
    Yo Cyclone Yasi I'm real happy for you and Imma let you finish but Hurricane Floyd was the best storm of all time
    My anal-retentive math-centric bother crunched the numbers and says those pictures aren't quite accurate. Still, it's gigantic and scary nonetheless.

    On a similar subject, here's the Storm of the Century from 1993. I remember this one vividly; it was quite a doozy.
  19. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Arilou View Post
    Unless you, you know, ignore the visual (because I know MY characters don't punch using the exact same move amillion times ) and what you're doing is in fact climbing up the back of the Titan, unscrewing an armour plate and start tearing out cables.
    Exactly. The game mechanics aren't varied enough to show what some of my characters are doing, like my Natural Dual Blades guy is essentially doing a combination of gymnastics and parkour to get to a Titan's vulnerable spot to slice and dice control cables and hydraulic hoses. On the other hand, my Martial Arts guy wears homebuilt armor enhanced with alien technology to basically just punch Titans in the robotic nads.
  20. Yeah, that's the in-game "shving!" noise made when you draw a sword.
  21. I'm really hoping we get a lot of variety in the pack. The canine head we've seen so far is awesome and perfect for my dog samurai from a parallel Earth, Tsuba Inu, as I had an Akita in mind when creating him, but it'd be great to have floppy ears like hounds and folded-over ears like Pugs (and even the ability to choose one folded ear and one upright ear for that Scamp look). Plus the slider affecting the snout would let us make a lot of different animals from wolves to raccoons to foxes.

    A variety of bird beaks would be awesome, too. The eagle head shown so far is really cool, but it'd be terrific to have duck bills, parrot beaks, raven beaks, chicken beaks and sparrow beaks. Allowing the slider would change a chicken beak to a sparrow beak, too.

    Probably pie-in-the-sky, but that's a hopes thing.
  22. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Ironik View Post
    I went to the movies this afternoon and it was 12 here in NH. They're calling for 18-24 inches tomorrow. Even with all the sunshine we've had this past week, I think we still have a good 2 to 2.5 feet of snow on the ground, so that should be interesting.

    Edit: here's what the snow looks like now. We'll see how much it's changed by Thursday. That's a regular table, so that's about 3 feet tall.


    ...and about an hour ago. With the bright sunshine, it's gorgeous here today.



    The thing I love about New Hampshire (as opposed to my native Ohio) is that clouds only last a couple days. I don't think I've ever gone an entire week without seeing the sun here, whereas in Ohio you can go months without seeing the sun, because there's nothing to divert weather from rolling in off the Great Plains.