Regeneration secondary question

I'm thinking about making a /Regen character and was wondering if it was "better" on a scrapper or brute? I'm leaning toward a scrapper, but given the brute's higher HP level, it seems that a brute will benefit "much" more from Regen. I did a weak search on the topic...but I couldn't find anything informative. Has anyone looked into this in any detail? Or is it all a wash?

Thanks everyone!

Regeneration is dependent upon Max HP, so yes, the regen will perform much better on a brute.

I've got no clue how much difference it actually makes in terms of in-game capability but you are correct that a Brute will have more ability to regain HP due to the same regen translating into a higher effective HP/Sec and more effective self heals.

Another comparatively minor advantage for the Brute is that a Scrapper with Dull Pain and the HP Boosting Accolades will be pretty close to their HP cap (they'll be 1% short with 95% slotting in DP) so they won't be able to take full advantage of any HP bonuses you might have from other sources (i.e. set bonuses) whereas the Brute has a much higher HP cap so they can use HP bonuses without going over the cap while DP is active.

That's what I was asking, though I phrased it poorly. Is it really worth it, or not? I like the fact that scrappers can pick up +DEF in their PPP (if you go that route), while brutes can't (I don't believe). Plus, scrappers hit their damage peak instantly, while brutes have to build up to it.

Thanks for the thoughts about HP cap, Adeon. That gives me something else to ponder. Now, as to my primary...

Only one answer: play both!

Since I did, I'll tell you the brute is noticeably sturdier. It's not a huge difference, but it's there. Also brutes get a taunt aura where Scrappers don't.

Could be considered an advantage our disadvantage, but Brute gets an aggro aura in Integration where Scrappers don't. This means a brute can effectively tank...it also means the most likely will take more dmg in the long run.

I had forgotten about the taunt aura. I'm used to taking brutes with damage auras, so I was a little concerned there. I guess I'll roll a brute ?/Regen. I'm thinking Kinetic Melee (mitigation) or Titan Weapons (AoE and bonus defense)...or SS (never played SS). Decisions, decisions...

Thanks for all the replies, guys! Have a safe and happy 4th!

The new brute ATO proc is making me want to remake my claws/regen scrapper as brute. Kinda worried after getting all the IO's for the new toon I'll like it more then the original. :/

The new brute ATO is cool but I don't think it's an especially good fit for /regen, despite the thematic similarity. Why not? It gives endurance discount and regen is a set that already comes in under par for endurance burning. Now a /fire brute, that could take advantage of the new proc... too bad nobody plays those!

Even though the OP has already decided to go brute I'll chime in and agree that regen is noticeably superior in brute form. When your entire schtick is being a big bag of hit points it's helpful to go all the way on it.

I always wondered if you had to play a regen brute a little differently - because many brutes tank for teams and regen basically means you eat everything thrown your way - all debuffs and damage.

I have a /regen guide in my sig...My 1st 50 was a Claws/Regen scrapper back in 05-06 and my current main is a SS/Regen Brute...it hits like a Mack Truck...and survives in many places nobody else can go...if you want a good build I can post mine...though it is expensive...you could go more cost effectively but you couldn't run my attack chain with any less recharge.

I have some really good tips and slotting advice in my guide...it will really help you hit the ground running.

KM/SS/TW are all good for the set...

I would say TW or SS but KM is also a great choice though it has less mitigation in the form of knockdown and stun than the other 2 respectively...and regen likes mitigation.

...which would put stone melee on the map also - tons of mitigation there.