TW or StJ?


Angelxman81

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
You really seem to be spoiling for a fight, Hopeling
You're right, sorry. I made my point, I'll shut up about it.


 

Posted

It's not difficult to get those IO's any longer. Maybe back in issue 6 they were, but no longer. You could easily get all of them in under a week with H or V merits, regular merit rolls, AE tickets...etc.


When there is no room left in Hell, the Dead shall walk the earth.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
To get back to my initial post, my point was that if you have to have two performance shifters, the numina unique, the miracle unique, stamina, quick recovery and physical perfection, that doesn't really count as making endurance management trivial. That is a gigantic investment. That is essentially what TW requires, but fortunately that is a hurdle that is very leapable.

For instance, I skipped the two performance shifters and my build is not sustainable. That's the difference. Ain't exactly low end, is it?
I categorically disagree with this. I know many regen/wp/elec tw builds which do not rely on that full suite of IO based +end, which function just fine. I myself have one of the most end heavy builds possible, tw/da, and I can get by just fine without physperf and its extra perfshift. My question to you would be, is the only thing you slotted in stam the shifter? Because if so, you are ignoring one of the largest bonuses to end; simply slotting io endmods into stam itself. Or even just SOs.


-------
Hew in drag baby

 

Posted

Okay so when I say sustainable, what I mean is capable of fighting indefinitely with no outside assistance. Inspirations count as outside assistance because you can run out of them if the fight is long enough and it's just one target so no more are dropping, for example. The thing about sustainability is that it's almost an academic issue because situations where there's no remedy at all for endurance problems are vanishingly rare. The reason I brought it up in the first place is that some people do care, and those people are more commonly known as scrapper forum posters.

What I do not mean when I say it is hard for some secondaries to be sustainable with TW on their own is that it is hard for them to be adequate, or to have enough endurance in most situations. That you can totally do. I myself have done that and I love the results. I'm not saying you can't do just fine, I'm saying you may not be able to fire your attacks as fast as they recharge forever in a vacuum.

Now if you're saying that your TW/DA is completely endurance sustainable without cardiac and without ageless, my response is I'd like to see that build because I don't know how you get good end reduction slotting out of the set's expensive but crucial aoes while still using the best available sets, which are obliteration and eradication, plus armageddon at 50. Those first two barely reduce endurance cost at all and must be supplemented with scirocco's dervish or multi-strike for that, except that if you're using oblits you're six slotting them and if you're using erads you're probably four slotting them. Not a heck of a lot of room for improvement, wouldn't you agree? What you could do is slot four erads and a generic endurance but that isn't really how I tend to do things, personally. Armageddon is pretty decent for endurance, but I didn't find the space for it in my reckless pursuit of defense bonuses.

In any case, I say again that titan weapons is a totally playable set with whatever secondary you want, but some of them will have endurance issues relative to other primary combinations because titan weapons objectively costs more endurance when running its better chains than most other primaries.


 

Posted

Thank you all for the wonderful input - I did in fact end up choosing TW for my powerset purchase...as for the secondary I've paired it with for my first character out of the gate?

Well, I decided to be a little contrarian and try something I've seen nary a mention of...Inv...I'll post back on occasion as I level to let you guys know how it goes...


@Mistress Rue
Yes, I RP and play Redside on Virtue - No, Rumors of its demise have been greatly exaggerated

Do you suck at COH/COV? not yet...

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
I don't know how you get good end reduction slotting out of the set's expensive but crucial aoes while still using the best available sets, which are obliteration and eradication, plus armageddon at 50. Those first two barely reduce endurance cost at all and must be supplemented with scirocco's dervish or multi-strike for that, except that if you're using oblits you're six slotting them and if you're using erads you're probably four slotting them. Not a heck of a lot of room for improvement, wouldn't you agree? What you could do is slot four erads and a generic endurance but that isn't really how I tend to do things, personally. Armageddon is pretty decent for endurance, but I didn't find the space for it in my reckless pursuit of defense bonuses.
I never went with geddon, as it simply was too expensive and gave me none of the set bonuses I wanted. And I _really_ wanted to 4slot erad for the bonus hp, but I simply couldnt. In shroud, I had to frakenslot with two purps.... geddon proc and dam/end... 2 erads + erad proc and oblit proc. It got me the same end reduction give or take a few .02ish eps as when I had 2 IO endreduc, oblit proc, 2 erads, erad proc.

My attacks are slotted with oblits everywhere, _boosted_, which may make a difference when comparing builds. Same goes for my mako's bites I have slotted, all of which are boosted where appropriate. Defsweep is omg frankenslotted with hamios, lotgs, and erads.

I do not run either CoF nor OG, so there is no end consumption there, and I do not run hasten. Between the natural +rech and the 5 lotg +rech, the build runs a constant stream of attacks without need. I am not chasing max dps like some tw players, simply because max dps for me is the dps needed to kill _that guy_.

I think the fact that damn near everything I have is boosted might have something to do with it. I spent well over 90 boosters on this one char alone, so....


-------
Hew in drag baby

 

Posted

Quote:
I do not run either CoF nor OG, so there is no end consumption there, and I do not run hasten. Between the natural +rech and the 5 lotg +rech, the build runs a constant stream of attacks without need. I am not chasing max dps like some tw players, simply because max dps for me is the dps needed to kill _that guy_.
Yeah, but if you're dealing, say, two thirds of the damage someone else does, it's a bit misleading to go and claim you're end sustainable, period, without specifics. It's true, no argument, but it's a bit misleading I think.

Technically, almost any character can be made end sustainable in almost any situation by using Brawl and nothing else, which is enough damage to take your average even con boss. Extreme case but hopefully my point is clear: it's always possible to reduce end consumption by reducing damage output.

The issue is being end sustainable while dealing optimized damage (which isn't necessarily "maximum" damage, as some builds might be focused more on survivability or other things, but skipping Hasten on a /DA is for example something I find hard to justify as optimal).

I mean, I'm not picking on your character specifically, it's working for you and that's what important. It's just I believe when we're discussing powerset performance in a vacuum, giving advice to people, safest bet is to assume "standard" goals - maximum damage, maximum survivability.


 

Posted

I prefer StJ- it feels faster, and I'm sure if someone works out the math, the DPS between both sets is quite comparable. Too often on TW I find myself winding up and swinging at a target thats already dead.

Both FEEL pretty awesome and the sound design is great, Street is just a little more Go Go Go. TW is a little more Ally Oop.


Stay Gold, Paragon. Stay Gold.
Nolite te bastardes carborundorum.

 

Posted

StJ has the DPS advantage thanks to the lengthy recharge of TW's attacks, but obviously loses in sheer burst damage. Arc of Destruction, Follow Through, Rend Armor come close to making it respectable though.


Virtue: The-Invictus (Blue)
The Emissary of Justice - Level 50 Fire/Fire Blaster
The Emissary of Justice. - Level 50 WP/Fire Tanker
Mesmerius - Level 50 Psi/Mental Blaster
Nucleoa - Level 50 Rad/Son Defender

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Justice_Bringer View Post
StJ has the DPS advantage thanks to the lengthy recharge of TW's attacks, but obviously loses in sheer burst damage.
I don't know that you can make a blanket statement like that ... well, you *made* it but I don't know if it is true.

Fact: Combat has shown 300+ dps on his TW/Elec Brute and I have gotten 296dps on my TW/SR. That is with T4 Reactive. I don't know any StJ toon (with T4 Reactive) that has posted that kind of dps. Maybe they do but I haven't seen them.