Massively interviews War Witch at SDCC


Angelxman81

 

Posted

I was hoping it wouldn't be that blatant, but I fear it is.

I would have liked it if you didn't know which choice would take you which way, myself, and had to decide on your own from the actual text what might happen.


Dec out.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
I was hoping it wouldn't be that blatant, but I fear it is.

I would have liked it if you didn't know which choice would take you which way, myself, and had to decide on your own from the actual text what might happen.
You know that would totally screw over the people who dislike difficult tasks like reading and spurn common sense right? That sort of thing isn't done in games much anymore. Joe public can't cope.

Seriously though, I get the feeling that they want to make it abundantly clear which road you are going because going back would take a lot of time. That doesn't mean that the consequences of an action have to be simple or boil down to an obvious outcome. Just that you know where your alignment is going to shift as a result.

I know what you are getting at though. The first time I played Dragon Age and made my decision after dueling Loghain...I had no idea that maybe later on I would have liked to reconsider it. It was actually nice to not realize the longterm consequences of my actions.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
I was hoping it wouldn't be that blatant, but I fear it is.

I would have liked it if you didn't know which choice would take you which way, myself, and had to decide on your own from the actual text what might happen.
Well, it's clear that one choice is for the Resistance and one choice is for the loyalists - but does that mean it's always clear what's the right thing to do?
For example, think about the Primal Earth Freakshow mentality, with them raging against "the system" - then think how Praetorians with the same mentality would react to a geuine tyranny? If you're an evil anarchist, who thinks all authority is bad, then just imagine how you'd react to a real dictatorship.
Or, while you might be a jackbooted thug swaggering around and enforcing the dictatorship, the Syndicate, for example, are still an actual criminal organization - so just because you might spend the morning arresting the family of someone who spoke out against Tyrant, that doesn't mean you couldn't spend your afternoon fighting genuine criminals.


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
Well, it's clear that one choice is for the Resistance and one choice is for the loyalists - but does that mean it's always clear what's the right thing to do?
For example, think about the Primal Earth Freakshow mentality, with them raging against "the system" - then think how Praetorians with the same mentality would react to a geuine tyranny? If you're an evil anarchist, who thinks all authority is bad, then just imagine how you'd react to a real dictatorship.
Or, while you might be a jackbooted thug swaggering around and enforcing the dictatorship, the Syndicate, for example, are still an actual criminal organization - so just because you might spend the morning arresting the family of someone who spoke out against Tyrant, that doesn't mean you couldn't spend your afternoon fighting genuine criminals.
This sounds very odd coming from you. How would you survive in this environment?

Head asplode??


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Slashman View Post
This sounds very odd coming from you. How would you survive in this environment?

Head asplode??
By ignoring the subtleties and using lots of winky emotes i imagine.


Dr. Todt's theme.
i make stuff...

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Slashman View Post
This sounds very odd coming from you. How would you survive in this environment?
By following the morally correct path


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden Girl View Post
By following the morally correct path
What if there IS none? What if each path results in innocents getting hurt or killed either immediately or overall as a result of your actions?

Which is the morally correct path then?


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Slashman View Post
What if there IS none? What if each path results in innocents getting hurt or killed either immediately or overall as a result of your actions?

Which is the morally correct path then?
The one which harms the fewest people while fighting the dictatorship


@Golden Girl

City of Heroes comics and artwork

 

Posted

Unfortunately for you there is hardly a concrete value for "fewest dead people". In the case of an open civil war between Praetoria's enforcers the Resistance members, the casualties would sky-rocket on both sides.

You either get in and cover your hands in blood or you watch on the sidelines, waiting for a stray bullet to reach you.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
Hee, you're talking to GG. Her brain doesn't have the part that recognizes ambiguity.
It's highly doubtful that's the only part her brain is missing.


P.S. Oh look...I forgot to put a stupid winky at the end of my statement.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Decorum View Post
Hee, you're talking to GG. Her brain doesn't have the part that recognizes ambiguity.
Isn't that the hilarious part, though? Even if her ideology is the polar opposite of Emperor Cole's, their propaganda and modus operandi sound the same.