City of Heroes: Live Forum Archive

Consider this Brute

Amy_Amp

By Amy_Amp,
Posted on: 2009-08-04 15:58 in Scrappers

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Iggy_Kamakaze View Post
I woulnd't focus too much on regen if I were to do this. First thing I look at is the damage, and I think you got that covered. Then go for defense, in this case, since I know you can cap it would go for that. Then go for HP, followed by regen. You do have the self heal to help your regen up.



jeezzz I forgot I was suppose to work on build for this combo...
Maaaann tell me how! That was the goal initially I guess, although I did want the crazy regen available too. I cannot get my defense capped without gimping myself somewhere. The last build I posted looks pretty good to me though. However, if you can cap the defense, just whisper the secret in my ear. I won't tell anyone I swear it!

 

Posted

First post after a Powerforge! *edit* second dammit.

Humph!

So now I'm trying to recreate what I saw in Mids last night regarding the slotting of the PS proc. Well Mids doesn't seem to react to it at all now. In or out it doesn't change my numbers at all. So am I crazy? Does Mids reflect the PS proc or not? In my copy broked? I also couldn't open the build I posted from the link but using the data chunk worked fine.

Can someone confirm for me that Mids does or does not accurately represent the PS proc please.

Thanks.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Powerforge View Post
First post after a Powerforge! *edit* second dammit.

Humph!

So now I'm trying to recreate what I saw in Mids last night regarding the slotting of the PS proc. Well Mids doesn't seem to react to it at all now. In or out it doesn't change my numbers at all. So am I crazy? Does Mids reflect the PS proc or not? In my copy broked? I also couldn't open the build I posted from the link but using the data chunk worked fine.

Can someone confirm for me that Mids does or does not accurately represent the PS proc please.

Thanks.
No it does not represent the proc at all.

Virtue: @Santorican

Dark/Shield Build Thread

 

Posted

Mids doesn't show the +end proc in action. I'm actually glad it doesn't. It shows the gfc build up proc in action and its very missleading because it shows it as if its always in action. Showing the +end proc as always in action would be a total mess.

"All problems can be solved by throwing enough scrappers at it."

@Riez on Virtue, Protector, Champion, and Exalted server.

 

Posted

Mid's doesn't represent the proc as mentioned already. My simplfied quick calculation method is to add .2 to whatever it shows for each proc in an auto power.

If I recall correctly... the proc is better then any slot in Stamina. It's better then the 3rd slot in quick recovery.

I'd anticpiate someone shortly will come along to do the math (and show thier work).

I gotta make pain. I gotta make things right. I gotta stop what's comin'. 'Least I gotta try.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Santorican View Post
No it does not represent the proc at all.
Gah! Well that'll change things then won't it? Yes PF it will!

Sooo to accurately represent the proc I need to math again dammit.

Here we Gooooooo!

20% chance to get 10% end back every 10 seconds yes?

So that's an average of one proc per 50 seconds returning 11 end on this build, or 11/50 = .22 eps recovered from ONE proc on average right?


*edit* First post after a Shred Monkey!

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Powerforge View Post

20% chance to get 10% end back every 10 seconds yes?


*edit* First post after a Shred Monkey!
Did we ever determine for a fact if it's 10% of real end total or 10% of base end on that proc?

/FPAPF!!

Be well, people of CoH.

 

Posted

What would be the math on that with two +end procs slotted? One in stam and one in QR. I'm sure its not as simple as double thus making it .44 end/sec

"All problems can be solved by throwing enough scrappers at it."

@Riez on Virtue, Protector, Champion, and Exalted server.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rieze View Post
What would be the math on that with two +end procs slotted? One in stam and one in QR. I'm sure its not as simple as double thus making it .44 end/sec
I think it is. That was my intent with the build now, however actually comparing the options I don't see much benefit to using one in Stamina. I did place one in QR to replace the End Mod/Rech. This takes my net recovery from 3.07 down to 2.95 eps. Now we add in the .22 eps gained from the proc that Mids does not reflect for a total eps of 3.17. Not a ton but an improvement nonetheless!

Let's look at Stamina now.

I have it 2 slotted with normal IOs. If I were to add a slot to it and use 3 Perf Shifters the set bonus would be+28 HP. That's very desirable to me being /WP. The problem here is that I am at the "rule of five" for that bonus already and don't see a place that I might shuffle things around to make it useful, so three slotting with PS would be a waste. Leaving it Two slotted yields a very small return for pulling one IO and replacing it with the Proc. Now my current recovery is 2.95 (remember we have to add in .22). Removing one IO and adding the proc in it's place drops the recovery to 2.76. Factoring the proc in adds .22 again for a total of 2.98. A gain of only .03 that is also subject to a bit of chance as the proc can't be counted on all the time. Not really worth it in Stamina to me then.

Now stealing a slot from someplace and adding it into Stamina to slot it with two basic IOs and the proc probably would be worth it but I don't see a slot I wanna dump when, according to my math (always suspect ), my attack chain is sustainable anyway.

Whew.

 

Posted

If given the slots to do so, I like to 4 or 6 slot QR with shifters. You hit ED as well as have a rec bonus and other usefull bonuses like aoe def. As well as the +end proc. But that's only if I have slots to spare. Most of the time, I don't. So I settle for 4 slots. That reminds me. Isn't the HP bonus the same as a 3 slotted numina set? If so, you could replace one with Heal IO.

"All problems can be solved by throwing enough scrappers at it."

@Riez on Virtue, Protector, Champion, and Exalted server.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rieze View Post
That reminds me. Isn't the HP bonus the same as a 3 slotted numina set? If so, you could replace one with Heal IO.
That's a good point. If I can come up with a slot to loose somewhere else I could do that. I'll take another look.

 

Posted

When going for +hp and regeneration, I like to consider the vet pet. Also, DN would still do a large amount of -dam to an AV without resistances to the attack they use.

Here's a build that has 2560 life and 83.8 regeneration at one target. It only has roughly 34% defense to all damage types, but it still has 62.5% recharge. The only real thing it lacks is +accuracy from bonuses.

[color:#1E90FF]Villain Plan by Mids' Villain Designer 1.401[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]http://www.cohplanner.com/[/color]
[color:#FFA500]Click this DataLink to open the build![/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Save slot:[/color][color:#1E90FF] Level 50 Magic Brute[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Primary Power Set: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Dark Melee[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Secondary Power Set: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Willpower[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Power Pool: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Fighting[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Power Pool: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Fitness[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Power Pool: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Leaping[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Power Pool: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Leadership[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Ancillary Pool: [/color][color:#1E90FF]Soul Mastery[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]Villain Profile:[/color]

[color:#32CD32]Level 1:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Smite[/color]

  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage[/color]
  • (3) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance[/color]
  • (3) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (5) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
  • (7) [color:#FFE600]Mako's Bite - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 1:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]High Pain Tolerance[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Miracle - [/color][color:#FFE600]+Recovery[/color]
  • (11) [color:#FFE600]Miracle - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal[/color]
  • (11) [color:#FFE600]Miracle - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 2:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Mind Over Body[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance[/color]
  • (7) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Endurance[/color]
  • (9) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Recharge[/color]
  • (9) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 4:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Fast Healing[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]+Regeneration/+Recovery[/color]
  • (5) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal[/color]
  • (15) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance[/color]
  • (50) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Recharge[/color]
  • (50) [color:#FFE600]Regenerative Tissue - [/color][color:#FFE600]+Regeneration[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 6:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Boxing[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage[/color]
  • (45) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (45) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance[/color]
  • (45) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 8:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Hurdle[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFC000]Jumping[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 10:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Indomitable Will[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge Speed[/color]
  • (13) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense[/color]
  • (13) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 12:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Siphon Life[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage[/color]
  • (15) [color:#FFE600]Mako's Bite - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage[/color]
  • (17) [color:#FFE600]Mako's Bite - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (19) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Recharge[/color]
  • (37) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance[/color]
  • (37) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 14:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Tough[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Steadfast Protection - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/+Def 3%[/color]
  • (40) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance[/color]
  • (40) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Endurance[/color]
  • (40) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Recharge[/color]
  • (43) [color:#FFE600]Impervium Armor - [/color][color:#FFE600]Resistance/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 16:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Health[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal[/color]
  • (17) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance[/color]
  • (48) [color:#FFE600]Numina's Convalescence - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 18:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Dark Consumption[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFC000]Recharge Reduction[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
  • (19) [color:#FFC000]Recharge Reduction[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 20:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Weave[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge Speed[/color]
  • (21) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
  • (21) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
  • (23) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Recharge[/color]
  • (23) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
  • (25) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Endurance[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 22:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Stamina[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Performance Shifter - [/color][color:#FFE600]Chance for +End[/color]
  • (37) [color:#FFE600]Performance Shifter - [/color][color:#FFE600]EndMod[/color]
  • (50) [color:#FFC000]Endurance Modification[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 24:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Rise to the Challenge[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Doctored Wounds - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal[/color]
  • (25) [color:#FFE600]Doctored Wounds - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance[/color]
  • (27) [color:#FFE600]Doctored Wounds - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Recharge[/color]
  • (27) [color:#FFE600]Doctored Wounds - [/color][color:#FFE600]Heal/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
  • (29) [color:#FFE600]Doctored Wounds - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 26:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Quick Recovery[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Performance Shifter - [/color][color:#FFE600]Chance for +End[/color]
  • (29) [color:#FFE600]Performance Shifter - [/color][color:#FFE600]EndMod[/color]
  • (33) [color:#FFC000]Endurance Modification[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 28:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Soul Drain[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFC000]Recharge Reduction[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
  • (36) [color:#FFC000]Recharge Reduction[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 30:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Heightened Senses[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge Speed[/color]
  • (31) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense[/color]
  • (31) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
  • (31) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense[/color]
  • (33) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
  • (33) [color:#FFE600]Serendipity - [/color][color:#FFE600]Endurance[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 32:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Midnight Grasp[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance[/color]
  • (34) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (34) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (34) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Chance of Damage(Negative)[/color]
  • (36) [color:#FFE600]Hecatomb - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 35:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Combat Jumping[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge Speed[/color]
  • (36) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
  • (39) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 38:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Maneuvers[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Recharge Speed[/color]
  • (39) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense[/color]
  • (39) [color:#FFE600]Luck of the Gambler - [/color][color:#FFE600]Defense/Endurance[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 41:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Gloom[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Apocalypse - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance[/color]
  • (42) [color:#FFE600]Apocalypse - [/color][color:#FFE600]Chance of Damage(Negative)[/color]
  • (42) [color:#FFE600]Apocalypse - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (42) [color:#FFE600]Apocalypse - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (43) [color:#FFE600]Apocalypse - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Recharge[/color]
  • (43) [color:#FFE600]Devastation - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 44:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Darkest Night[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFC000]Endurance Reduction[/color][color:#FFC000] IO[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 47:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Summon Widow[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Soulbound Allegiance - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (48) [color:#FFE600]Soulbound Allegiance - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage[/color]
  • (48) [color:#FFE600]Soulbound Allegiance - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 49:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Strength of Will[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFD700]Empty[/color]
[color:#1E90FF]------------[/color]

[color:#32CD32]Level 1:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Brawl[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Accuracy/Damage[/color]
  • (46) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance[/color]
  • (46) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Recharge[/color]
  • (46) [color:#FFE600]Kinetic Combat - [/color][color:#FFE600]Damage/Endurance/Recharge[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 1:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Sprint[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFD700]Empty[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 2:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Rest[/color]
  • (A) [color:#FFD700]Empty[/color]
[color:#32CD32]Level 1:[/color] [color:#1E90FF]Fury[/color]

Code: 
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1400;699;1398;HEX;|
|78DAA5944B6F125114C7EF30439102056C81BE4B5B5A6829D3B2F391B446DB266A5|
|12AA9356A24A44E0B3A01C2501F3B3F802B37AE5CFB1DF493F88E7B13A3EEC573CE|
|FF52DD3B81FFEF3ECE3DF77F867B293DD90C2BF56C4319A14B6ECDF3AA173BC75DC|
|75FAA1D350E8295DA2327EDB9AD6E40299594996AC9711DC7DEAC751EA299C2F0A6|
|73E8343DC7DE6FB86EBBF5D8E9C42F37EB4EC76976ED7E23526EB55C7BBB7154EF3|
|69A4761DDEB361DCF4367C7A9B56926DAEFDC773A5EBDD14E6DB51B0736B6A9B48E|
|DD6AA9E6759DCED35132B544DF6FAAFFF42C5526CC29DF2E7043605504030F0845F|
|58E230D09F7A92BD4C8AAC1CBC096E03DCF23C03472323490119C5A00B2820F1461|
|22CE326F1A9CDBDA130CED0A8A15609D30A50C7A897ED834FDB0B9027F2B70BBA26|
|D525C0069552027963F9206B5E560429286478098E03B4D8590DB1F5AF489874359|
|1AAB0B4EC34A06C632B069D24E115D40242526B3A8378B7AB3A87719F506283CAA5|
|D449121867CABC8FE83A6E2F26A7B463C8F7D018B960E63A97F18058CC0F9C86FC5|
|B99371E9250DD969D4C47BA65509BD61E2A55495792128A625ED27D294FC543D2B7|
|55D328C5E158C97806B82C9B2E033058EE97C63C837897C69E4FB493AA10B9880F3|
|79E00BE9942E600A054CE31798461DD33EB19C46396914F08B3A33FA64CE2CCB4EB|
|3592007E405F34B8224D53BA7FDCD619379645FC45E710A58D0010B897F67161177|
|602A95D3E720B72649978A800D1404CBABC06B1447FF0079AC52F959193AA444368|
|67CF68604AFAE0317045F696A4DAF59EBD1A326AD936B68EA6B58C0C12EE0981770|
|BE77FEC6D18757962D7D2169C490916DEBE48EFED7F326DCCF13DC1DA4568544EDB|
|1EC73F716CB6D963B3C7697E51E4B95A5F736DC771A3DC386CEB29C6339CFF29C83|
|027CED422C619608CB104B9425C632CC9264196779C5D2FB03F0E7F1AC|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|

TW/Elec Optimization

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by BillZBubba View Post
Did we ever determine for a fact if it's 10% of real end total or 10% of base end on that proc?

/FPAPF!!
I was on my Fire/Stone Tank a few nights ago and she has ~113 or ~115 max end, but the proc still only reported giving 10 back in the healing channel. That could be a display error, though.

The only way to concretely test it that I can think of is to have your recovery floored while detoggled, then watch the Combat Attributes to see how much end it gets when it fires.

 

Posted

I'd try to boost lethal/smashing to 45% defense and sacrifice the other defense levels. Going from 35% lethal/smash to 45% lethal/smash is going to cut incoming damage by 66% in probably over 90% of your fights. Keeping in mind, if an attack is part smashing and part dark.. having 45% defense to smashing gives you 45% defense to that attack, reguardless of your dark defense %.

I don't think going from high 20s to mid 30s defense to the other types will impact you as much getting that last 10% in lethal/smash.

I gotta make pain. I gotta make things right. I gotta stop what's comin'. 'Least I gotta try.

 

Posted

OK so here's my first crack at it...
I think endurance is ok with the accolades.
I'm coming up short on recharge for the chained you mentioned.
2036 hp without accolades and 474% regen.
accuracy is a little lower than what i'd like it to be...


Code: 
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1395;699;1398;HEX;|
|78DAA5934B4F534114C7E7F6F6524A5B4A296D79B5D0079667856822EAC24491444|
|3139028468D4D83577AA1B64D5BA2ECFC00B8D1850BC5D7C7D04F22F8D81B7CAF4D|
|3DE7FCA76C5C7A03FFDFDC3367CE99FF746EFEC1825FA987E794E1BB502E361A85F|
|3F5EDA66DE58B1BCEBAF228A5A21228E4EDB26DE7168AF52D0C63082FD877ED4AC3|
|CEAD39E572AD7ADFAE872E554A76DDAE3473ED817FB95A2DE7169D66C56E34F0B26|
|4176B4E6523D87EB963D71B25A716D0991BA526CDC62ED69CF51CDAAC56B7CB857C|
|B1D1B4EB3BFDB4A909FA3F54EDA765A929975273CA35096405EE716042D0B1A918E|
|F798121AB0C15A3415C756464669F2730631A270D0E75CE02270419A41F5086893C|
|655E93198B0ECAD221AB458FFA4E638FDE9C679990525D2BC015817F1588985CA03|
|B2CF84031AFAEE38D48E92855F12164F910EADE17433D07409F04937F146F2EDB23|
|6F1E5A15D08502976990551FE92528FE5A46709EE036552F9C87283B846C57083D7|
|A4F21A34FF31321AC53C24FA571DF63C1E41381413522306C4660380AC35118CEC0|
|B04979317DCAB194ECAC3F01A40599A4E017650CC80FD5B2069E538BB01A7C067C7|
|5B1D3E12FC0A120B1234E3E930EE9EA437092C0F9247030A361819B7611D776E2C8|
|1BD54EDBFC4D18D1BFE0080C256128094369184AE35EA51D4127154EE9EB95DA959|
|3997924F841B1315D6F6C5342C7B6807B8023C89680B2609DEEC5B85E35FE465A4C|
|BC06F6801782C997C02BC14FD2297D7853E8358D5ED368328D9633E835835EDF283|
|FA77BE53AE5421EF7021EC02F98F3015D8218399EC52A631637730E3773D87DF481|
|D21F7F154BFF4496DDFA6BA488219145F7D107FA5FCF5B7FBB9777A58B2AAE92A8A|
|B2C6BFC7A9DE506CB4D8EDD62B9CD526069BD3B5A1D9CE70D9D6639C37296659793|
|3C3E121F8B9F25C0D2CD1264E96109B344590659F6585A7F01C7F8F98F|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Powerforge View Post
I think it is. That was my intent with the build now, however actually comparing the options I don't see much benefit to using one in Stamina. I did place one in QR to replace the End Mod/Rech. This takes my net recovery from 3.07 down to 2.95 eps. Now we add in the .22 eps gained from the proc that Mids does not reflect for a total eps of 3.17. Not a ton but an improvement nonetheless!

Let's look at Stamina now.

I have it 2 slotted with normal IOs. If I were to add a slot to it and use 3 Perf Shifters the set bonus would be+28 HP. That's very desirable to me being /WP. The problem here is that I am at the "rule of five" for that bonus already and don't see a place that I might shuffle things around to make it useful, so three slotting with PS would be a waste. Leaving it Two slotted yields a very small return for pulling one IO and replacing it with the Proc. Now my current recovery is 2.95 (remember we have to add in .22). Removing one IO and adding the proc in it's place drops the recovery to 2.76. Factoring the proc in adds .22 again for a total of 2.98. A gain of only .03 that is also subject to a bit of chance as the proc can't be counted on all the time. Not really worth it in Stamina to me then.

Now stealing a slot from someplace and adding it into Stamina to slot it with two basic IOs and the proc probably would be worth it but I don't see a slot I wanna dump when, according to my math (always suspect ), my attack chain is sustainable anyway.

Whew.
I've already done the math for all of the Perf Shifter slotting in both QR and Stamina here.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Iggy_Kamakaze View Post
OK so here's my first crack at it...
I think endurance is ok with the accolades.
I'm coming up short on recharge for the chained you mentioned.
2036 hp without accolades and 474% regen.
accuracy is a little lower than what i'd like it to be...


Code:
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1395;699;1398;HEX;|
|78DAA5934B4F534114C7E7F6F6524A5B4A296D79B5D0079667856822EAC24491444|
|3139028468D4D83577AA1B64D5BA2ECFC00B8D1850BC5D7C7D04F22F8D81B7CAF4D|
|3DE7FCA76C5C7A03FFDFDC3367CE99FF746EFEC1825FA987E794E1BB502E361A85F|
|3F5EDA66DE58B1BCEBAF228A5A21228E4EDB26DE7168AF52D0C63082FD877ED4AC3|
|CEAD39E572AD7ADFAE872E554A76DDAE3473ED817FB95A2DE7169D66C56E34F0B26|
|4176B4E6523D87EB963D71B25A716D0991BA526CDC62ED69CF51CDAAC56B7CB857C|
|B1D1B4EB3BFDB4A909FA3F54EDA765A929975273CA35096405EE716042D0B1A918E|
|F798121AB0C15A3415C756464669F2730631A270D0E75CE02270419A41F5086893C|
|655E93198B0ECAD221AB458FFA4E638FDE9C679990525D2BC015817F1588985CA03|
|B2CF84031AFAEE38D48E92855F12164F910EADE17433D07409F04937F146F2EDB23|
|6F1E5A15D08502976990551FE92528FE5A46709EE036552F9C87283B846C57083D7|
|A4F21A34FF31321AC53C24FA571DF63C1E41381413522306C4660380AC35118CEC0|
|B04979317DCAB194ECAC3F01A40599A4E017650CC80FD5B2069E538BB01A7C067C7|
|5B1D3E12FC0A120B1234E3E930EE9EA437092C0F9247030A361819B7611D776E2C8|
|1BD54EDBFC4D18D1BFE0080C256128094369184AE35EA51D4127154EE9EB95DA959|
|3997924F841B1315D6F6C5342C7B6807B8023C89680B2609DEEC5B85E35FE465A4C|
|BC06F6801782C997C02BC14FD2297D7853E8358D5ED368328D9633E835835EDF283|
|FA77BE53AE5421EF7021EC02F98F3015D8218399EC52A631637730E3773D87DF481|
|D21F7F154BFF4496DDFA6BA488219145F7D107FA5FCF5B7FBB9777A58B2AAE92A8A|
|B2C6BFC7A9DE506CB4D8EDD62B9CD526069BD3B5A1D9CE70D9D6639C37296659793|
|3C3E121F8B9F25C0D2CD1264E96109B344590659F6585A7F01C7F8F98F|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
That's very interesting there. Certainly there are things I don't like but it can't be denied that you hit the softcap across the board. Well done. I'm going to spend some time deconstructing that.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by BillZBubba View Post
Did we ever determine for a fact if it's 10% of real end total or 10% of base end on that proc?

/FPAPF!!
It is base endurance, it gives a 20% chance to grant 10 points of endurance.

Virtue: @Santorican

Dark/Shield Build Thread

 

Posted

Holy crap. 45.5% defense to SLFCEN on a WP?

Makes my post in that other thread much more salient.

Super reflexes isn't super when everyone can get it.

Be well, people of CoH.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Santorican View Post
It is base endurance, it gives a 20% chance to grant 10 points of endurance.
I'm still gonna dispute that. I routinely get rewards above 10 endurance on those toons of mine that have more than 100 endurance.

 

Posted

I'll check again tonight. I should be seeing Bill Z Bubba grants you 11 endurance or whatever the message is since he's got all the powerbuff accolades if it's 10% of total end.

Be well, people of CoH.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by BillZBubba View Post
I'll check again tonight. I should be seeing Bill Z Bubba grants you 11 endurance or whatever the message is since he's got all the powerbuff accolades if it's 10% of total end.

The problem that I've always had is that it's not constant. I've gotten 10 end, 11 end, 10.56 end, and a bunch of other numbers less often. I've yet to actually see the number be stable as would be expected if it were a constant value. What makes me believe that it does scale with max end rather than base is because in all the times I've tested my performance in game, it's always meshed with the calculations I've done assuming that it scales with max end.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Umbral_NA View Post
I'm still gonna dispute that. I routinely get rewards above 10 endurance on those toons of mine that have more than 100 endurance.
Well I've been playing my Fire/regen with two ps procs and none of them so far have gone above 10 points. He has all the endurance accolades.

Virtue: @Santorican

Dark/Shield Build Thread

 

Posted

Here's where I'm at... lower recharge... but retains good hp/regen.


Code: 
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1410;702;1404;HEX;|
|78DAA5935B4F1341188667DB2DA527DA52DA7228A5142894C3D226249E2E4CB4623|
|0342936885163D3E04857366DB35B3CDCF903BCF2C62B35FE0DFD2502EAB542E2E9|
|07D4EF308BDEBB81F7D99DF9F69D77BEED549F56C2423CBF2CB4D055ABE9388D2BF|
|6414FFAAACD3D733758B58DDC75BBF9583A7E21448AA61A55694969549AF63EDFA6|
|79B8221FCAB6238D1DD3B2BA9D27D28E6FB45BD296ED9EE1DE846B9D8E65AC9BBDB|
|6741C7ED894CDAED9DE8BA899BD560F9EA2EED403693B2DB39BBED635770D5EA6DE|
|39B01AD5A6D393F6B351085584FF53E15E7D9FA801F242AF13625B84F19B848C092|
|88BD99017F1115FD0E82D5D94341CF294196B047D9B30B04538C46A2EF76979B899|
|170359C2E03463863092064C8AD412BD7502F55E8EE6F572B411CE94E54C050E7A0|
|4EA63778F8FD70DF2BAC13AE13B4CF9D51EFD29DA4038C960DB21B61D62DB18DB1E|
|8306D856049264E40397901A0AAD5043FC3014518B476E51D5306718BE417BFA045|
|351DA7CDF13E5990CA7CB72BA1438C495439CD7C99E83275D889CE2209424544922|
|47EB8EBEF4105E113EC358920BB42417A4183F40D3BC773DDDA2E21993F188B0BC4|
|F285B845F50382638EDD8A907BF46EE1BE384A0419409F55126B87BD3DCBD69EEDE|
|0C77CF0B75932AF2E41A7562B644289409BF616A4A7D94A9022D3E3B4F282C10E68|
|B8C4506FFF0BEA0B9B2CD73B38AAA492E7F02E6D416E6BE52E845DEC2326F418768|
|0BCA63813D16D5BB2E7761B125156EE90D3572F92D61C5A0382BAB8C3261F51DCDC|
|5C1D850C6061BAF2A4397692829B1B1A774C89D3F621C1332FAD979F4AAF3385EFF|
|B7CD456EF3E6DF3AF8834BD47475246144A39175FDEC94FED7F53EECFA04B682705|
|70711DB283BF8781BE50ECA5D1CBB87721FA581D2FF10769346CF63A00B2817512E|
|A1BCC0227F082484124689A00CA144516228099414CA38CA6B94FE1F7CB6F361|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|

note: I'm still going to do this as a claws brute rather then DM... the damage chain/endurance balance is better that way at this recharge.... not to mention the "eat this" factor of claws animations.

I gotta make pain. I gotta make things right. I gotta stop what's comin'. 'Least I gotta try.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Santorican View Post
Well I've been playing my Fire/regen with two ps procs and none of them so far have gone above 10 points. He has all the endurance accolades.
The best way to test this is while in an -end/-recovery crash state. Someone that has the proc and at least 110 max end on any AT with a nuke or elude like power needs crash and watch the "end bar" (not the chat box) and see how much you get. Hopefully, it will fire douring the crash the first try.

"All problems can be solved by throwing enough scrappers at it."

@Riez on Virtue, Protector, Champion, and Exalted server.