Brutes as a tank


BBQ_Pork

 

Posted

Situation - MA mission with 8 people. only spawns freakshow bosses. there are 10 of them per spawn.

what brute secondary is going to survive this outside of stone? dont assume any outside buffs are present as with the villain side population on infinity such things cant be considered reliable.


 

Posted

Any that are soft-capped.


 

Posted

so a billion-dollar brute then? oof.


 

Posted

Nah, don't need that much to soft-cap SR.

A better answer would be whatever secondary on a Stone Melee primary. None of the Freakshow bosses have knockback resistance/protection and Fault can be doublestacked relatively easily to permastun bosses - it can be done with just SOs against even-cons.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
it has gone from unconscionable to downright appalling that we have no way of measuring our characters' wetness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brillig View Post
It's hard to beat the entertainment value of Whackjob Wednesdays.

 

Posted

i'm thinking more along the lines of a dm/shield

i was able teo build one that wasnt TOO expensive that capped positionals. the expensive part was the lotg's i put in other spots and the single steadfast protection 3% def. i dont think mako's bite, performance shifter (outside of the one), and touch of death are super expensive anymore. obliteration and aegis might be though. this is what i came up with. i like the idea of a self heal in siphon life and the dmg buff in against all odds stacking with soul drain and fury in said situation

(yes i'm buildling a farming toon that isnt ss/fire that can also do dev created content that is far less BORING to play than my mm's)

below is the build. when you ignore the lotg recharge baddies it doesnt seem like it would be all that expensive. i could be wrong - i havent looked at touch of death, mako and oblit pricing in a while i just know the ones i have arent selling at all

<font class="small">Code:[/color]<hr /><pre>| Copy &amp; Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1387;675;1350;HEX;|
|78DA9D935B4F534110C7F7F4C201DAD296D2965B8516A1207 0A4E883970713450C8|
|62618821A406A4397B6D214D29644DFFC003E28177DF28BE8 37F01A3F8726467DF4|
|5267E6BF2521BE79D2FE7F7B6667766667F7641FCEF9957A7 C4559BE6B957CBD9EB|
|B5ADB6B686F365F2C6F2A5B291513432EAB2B5A3B73F9DA36 868330CFE92D5DAD6B|
|67B954D69542EB35BC502DE99AAE369CD6C0BFB4B35371167 57EB75C2DE265BEDCA|
|8EA7ABD535E9677B52E048CBD586A9057F4FA6E79D331D9F7 72D97CBDA16B8F7AA9|
|A409FA7F51ADA7E955AB84B472AD01EB02CF3D6043D09613B CA1BD2ACB444569905|
|16D3D82F610705ED039039C137C6E055194B5A5D8E42F0225 4157197820086D0BDE|
|522E3772B9DCC81542AE6EE47A470E5E38B8BD0B16D7D73D2 FE8B901C40909F5953|
|C6C93DEDE927DC48A00D2F7227D2FD2F723FD7B5ABD03AB5B 1D93980162B4980F33|
|CA87C2BC640A1853A0498FFA40E141AB532CC18CC47D230D2 B3179C3FB2E360D1E0|
|087825347C073E085C0A6A523A60D91DB926DF8A66C6F7845 D04E0E51D386286286|
|B17A12AB27B1DE47AA286E59B2501C6527D1CF11F4F33B4DF 559B6D4D7D72F258F1|
|860E3A74F625690A2800153DF0066C64E206EF321A03709E9 CD0F1A0F990319C27D|
|18C37D48E340D23890340E640207F289EA4F99A8D44FD9D2C 42FE0B7E08C720BFEE|
|0AD29E0FD8C9AECA3D88D9B4CE3A8D8338EFB3A85FB3A9511 4CCF02B8BD1E729F34|
|1B9C44DFA6D0B769F4ED3EA5754C61CE53319D7D06EC03078 2CC217024C853D40CA|
|2AC1914964908063DC79F26FDB8618BFF58963CC79F94B2C4 32CF3E5641C1E1FF9F|
|57FE56AE8E5B7C5797595658EEB0DC65596559635967D960C 9C9C57E7D1C1DBCC00|
|55D64B9C47299E5093BD93E121F8B9F25C0D2C5126409B144 58622CFD2C2F599A7F|
|019254FD53|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|</pre><hr />


 

Posted

If I remember right, Freak Tanks are supposed to be weak to Energy as well as stuns, and EM does lots of energy damage and stuns...


 

Posted

Freakshow: weak to energy.
Have some energy damage and some minor EndDrain in thier attacks, which /Elec laughs off.
Have 1/2 End when they rez, which Power Sink nueters.


 

Posted

now consider the same mission but instead of freakshow bosses, it's all super arachnoids


 

Posted

any decent invul brute would not have a problem with that. You get such good S/L resistants. I am confident my Dm/Fa, Ss/invul, Ss/Fire and Dm/wp could handle that set up pretty easily. Having said my Ss/invul and Dm/fa are runing 2 plus billion builds


 

Posted

I can easily take 10 bosses with my /EA. I regularly run an all boss mission solo with him and herd the aggro cap without a problem. My /EA is softcapped to all defenses except negative energy and psi


 

Posted

[ QUOTE ]
I can easily take 10 bosses with my /EA. I regularly run an all boss mission solo with him and herd the aggro cap without a problem. My /EA is softcapped to all defenses except negative energy and psi

[/ QUOTE ]

A well-built EA will have no trouble surviving most situations, but still won't be a good "tank" though because someone will be stripping aggro off of them on a team. You can get the attention back with an AoE, but a few seconds later it's just going to turn around after it's been shot again.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
it has gone from unconscionable to downright appalling that we have no way of measuring our characters' wetness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brillig View Post
It's hard to beat the entertainment value of Whackjob Wednesdays.

 

Posted

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I can easily take 10 bosses with my /EA. I regularly run an all boss mission solo with him and herd the aggro cap without a problem. My /EA is softcapped to all defenses except negative energy and psi

[/ QUOTE ]

A well-built EA will have no trouble surviving most situations, but still won't be a good "tank" though because someone will be stripping aggro off of them on a team. You can get the attention back with an AoE, but a few seconds later it's just going to turn around after it's been shot again.

[/ QUOTE ]

This is very true. It is very hard to hold aggro with /EA without taking taunt.

edit: OP's question was what will survive, I was answering that. The only brute I have played that can tank is my /stone, the rest of mine can soak up the alpha but that isn't tanking


 

Posted

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I can easily take 10 bosses with my /EA. I regularly run an all boss mission solo with him and herd the aggro cap without a problem. My /EA is softcapped to all defenses except negative energy and psi

[/ QUOTE ]

A well-built EA will have no trouble surviving most situations, but still won't be a good "tank" though because someone will be stripping aggro off of them on a team. You can get the attention back with an AoE, but a few seconds later it's just going to turn around after it's been shot again.

[/ QUOTE ]

This is very true. It is very hard to hold aggro with /EA without taking taunt.

edit: OP's question was what will survive, I was answering that. The only brute I have played that can tank is my /stone, the rest of mine can soak up the alpha but that isn't tanking

[/ QUOTE ]

can the stone also kill said bosses without a kin corruptor around?

say it's those same super arachnoids with their super high regen.


 

Posted

A very expensive /Stone build can counteract the -recharge penalties of Granite. Since the Brute damage cap is so high, you'll almost always be doing less damage per hit but it'll be a relatively small difference compared to Granite Tankers.

So yes, you can kill them with a Granite Brute. You just don't need a Granite Brute to survive them.


Quote:
Originally Posted by PleaseRecycle View Post
it has gone from unconscionable to downright appalling that we have no way of measuring our characters' wetness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brillig View Post
It's hard to beat the entertainment value of Whackjob Wednesdays.

 

Posted

I have 6 different level 50 brutes and of those my stone/stone, dm/wp, and wm/ea can all survive the all boss farm spawns without any problem. I prefer the wm/ea because of all the AoE he has and it makes killing the bosses much faster.

I haven't tried using the stone/stone to run all boss missions yet but I used to run around the Fab regularly and herded up huge numbers of mobs, most of the time it would include multiple bosses. Stone armor is just not as efficient of a killing machine as some other secondaries.


 

Posted

I would go with Smash Melee/Brute Armor. aka close your eyes and click on something.


 

Posted

Anyone tried mace/shield? How does that measure up?


 

Posted

thread necrosis ftw!

btw, tanking just fine on my sm/wp

i'm surprised after 5 years fault has never been nerfed..


 

Posted

um... the biggest gap i see is 5/12 to 5/20... thats hardly necro.

WP compared to stone:
So this other guy? He's a terminator too, right, like you?
TERMINATOR; Not like me. A T-1000. Advanced prototype. A mimetic polyalloy.
JOHN; What does that mean?
TERMINATOR; Liquid metal.

of course just like arnold still wins, stone is still the better tank.