-
Posts
1058 -
Joined
-
Finally added a bio for the God of Rock.
Born from the first Rock guitar riff The God of Rock protects all that is Rock and Roll. Fighting in the streets with his children at his feet he defends Rock with a whole lotta love. Forget the hearse, 'cause this cat will never die.
WN -
Quote:You are taking knowledge you have as a player and attributing it to your character's perspective. You are implying your character knows that there is a villain contact in GV called the Television that is unlocked by getting a certain badge.My first criticism is that TV, a contact that requires villains to be exposed to the GV Tower in order to successfully tune in, and a contact that so far only operates within the Rogue Isles, is now suddenly communicating with heroes in Paragon without explanation.
My second criticism is that my hero apparently has no problems that the TV is suddenly communicating with her, and is certainly no cause to question her sanity or call for any other sort of investigation.
As for questioning your sanity....is a Television as a contact anymore insane then many of the things characters in the game run into? Have you ever rescued Baby New Year for example?
One more point. This is a humor based arc.
Quote:What was the deal Nemesis made that involved Blappy? It mustn't have been that important, since Nemesis never bothers to reclaim Blappy after her abduction. Even then, a large criminal organisation like Nemesis being insulted like that by a smaller group like the IL? I'd have thought that the Nemesis group would have called for war on principles alone, especially for a job that Nemesis himself has a personal interest in.
Quote:That's not what I mean. The 30 minutes time limit was part of what I meant when I talked about the urgency being pointless. The problem was that your hero successfully completing it in time is never brought up in the debriefing, and turns out to change nothing in the end anyway. Presumably you would get the exact same results if you just stood still and failed the mission.
Quote:Does TV want to protect and nurture a personality it knows childrens will blindly trust, in a similiar vain to its mission regarding Amanda Vines....
WN -
I can't say I am happy since this is the worst review/rating I have ever received for any of my arcs and surprisingly it's of the arc Venture even gave 4 stars. Responding to some of you comments:
Quote:Really? You wonder how something can be broadcast beyond a single area?.... It is at this point that the news anchor addresses you directly and- wait, what? So yeah, apparently Television has managed to leak its way out of the Rogue Isles airwaves and into Paragons.
Quote:Its not really clear how Television came to Paragon, or why it cares if Blappy went missing....
Quote:...On the advice of a news anchor that spoke to you directly from the TV But hey, I guess your hero wouldnt bat an eyelash if he happens to be Malkavian.
Quote:As an origin arc it works out pretty well, as it doesnt fall into the trap of making your hero second to the authors characters, and the authors villains are distinct and varied enough so it feel like you are fighting an actual super villain team something that the vanilla game so desperately needs instead of all the grunt bashing we end up doing
Quote:Though I do think the author should have made completely new bios for her villains instead of just copy-pasting her normal ones, as I found it jarring having examined a villain only to get their complete life story.
Quote:There were a few inconsistencies in the writing, such as one point in the arc where Television informs your hero that their next task is in a warehouse located in the Rogue Isles, and then in the debriefing it reports that you raided a warehouse in Paragon,
Quote:or at another point where your hero recalls Bright Angel mentioning something that she never did.
Quote:Things that were once relevant to the arc are later never mentioned again. Nemesis who were the driving force at the beginning roll over halfway through and just fade away...
Quote:... the initial urgency of saving Blappy in time for her next show proves to be completely pointless and is not even mentioned in the debriefing even if you succeeded
Quote:and even Television doesnt seem all that bothered about Blappy by the end.
Quote:Ultimately, this arc is an origin story and doesnt try too hard to be anything but, which makes it somewhat tricky to rate. It serves its purpose as to explain the origin of the authors characters, but unless you were really, really into the authors characters (you creepy stalker you) theres no strong hook to play this arc.
Thanks for the one legitimate mistake you found, I will correct that. As for the rest I am not sure if you did not get the arc or got it and just did not like it. Also, I am curious what you rated this arc in game since I got no tickets.
WN -
Quote:Humbly submit the following arcs under the Multi-Arc category:
The Perils of the Tail Pt 1 #44716
The Perils of the Tail Pt 2 #327632
The Perils of the Tail FINALE #331571
Custom Enemy Groups, Save a Veteran Hero, Fight the Freedom Phalanx (sorta), What else could you ask for!
TechSpider/Kinetic Kitten
The rules state that you can't nominate your own arcs.
WN -
-
I just finished this arc and wanted to comment publicly on just how wonderful an arc you have written. A solid 5 star effort and an perfect example for anyone tying to write an arc that would seamlessly fit into canon. I would fully endorse this arc for consideration of Dev's Choice and have no doubt were it considered it would it would be granted. If you have not played this arc, do yourself a favor, grab a team and go play it now!
WN -
Thanks very much for reviewing Trademark Infringement (2220)! A 4 star and two 4.5-5 stars, awesome. I just wanted to address the lack of Bosses two of you mentioned. Besides the main Boss, their are two other Wannabe bosses. Check your settings they should be set to "Fight Bosses even when Solo" for them to spawn. Again, thanks all, I really enjoyed the show.
WN -
Here are mine. Also, you can consider all of these my favorites.
Best Lowbie Arc - (1-25) CTL + ALT + RESET (137561(@Bubbawheat (arc is 15-30)
Best Mid Level Arc – Old Dog, New Trick (81318) @Wrong Bird
Best High Level Arc - Victors Online (97980) @Hellguard
Best Comedy Arc – Captain Dynamic, the Great, Faces the Great Face
(190069) @Aehaed
Best Serious Arc – The American Revolution Remixed (31700) @Silenex
Best Short Arc - The Monster Hop (27861) @Big Daddy Vio
Best Multi-Part Arc The Audition Parts I and II (221240 and 221241) @MRCaptainMan
I had a very, very, very tough time picking many of these and especially the Best Comedy as I have played many deserving. Honestly, most Categories were hard since I had several choices.
WN -
How about:
Name: Death to Disco!
Arc ID: 84420
Creator Global Name: @Wrong Number
Difficulty Level: Medium
Synopsis: It's 2009; Dr. Disco Fever has somehow altered the timeline so that Disco never died. The Star Spangled Banner is played to a Disco beat! Sporting events start with people standing up and "getting down" for our national anthem. Restore the timeline or be stuck Boogie Oggie-ing forever!
Number of EB/AVS 0
Story Type - Humor
Mission Count: 2
Estimated Time to Play: about 30 minutes
or
Name: Have a Blap, Blap, Blappy Day Kids!
Arc ID: 2019
Creator Global Name: @Wrong Number
Difficulty Level: Medium
Synopsis: Beloved kids TV show host Blappy is missing and the police are assuming the worse. Should anything happen to Blappy the kids of Paragon City will be heartbroken. You need to find her as quickly as possible before words leaks out that she is missing.
Number of EB/AVS 1 EB
Story Type - Humor
Mission Count: 4
Estimated Time to Play: 45-60 minutes
Which ever seems more appealing to you. Thanks
WN -
-
Quote:I know that I'm rarely replaying a AE Story Arc more than twice because there's simply too much potential content to find on the AE system.
We have a winner.
I'm not likely to start replaying many arcs when there's so many I haven't played even once yet.
Agreed.
WN -
Quote:Story Loved the concept and execution of the story. A heroic K-9 in trouble and you are the only one that can save him? You had me at "Woof". 5 stars.
Title: Old Dog, New Trick
Arc ID: 81318
Creators Global Name: Wrong Bird
Mission Count: 3
Notes Origin Story, Heroic
Fun Level It moved along at a good pace and kept me engaged through out. 5 stars.
Playability No real problems here though I prefer consistent levels throughout an arc. 4.5 Stars.
Polish Could have used a few more clues to flesh the story out more, but overall spiffy. This arc had the best souvenir I have gotten from any MA arc. It actually evoked emotion. 4.5 stars
Overall Rating - 4.75 stars highly recommend.
Lets up it to 11! The best thing you can do imo is even out the level range.
WN
Note- In the interest of full disclosure the author of this arc is related to me. -
You are a tough cookie PW! I have played at least a few 100 arcs by now. Early on I would spend an hour a evening playing (often more like attempting to play) unrated/unplayed arcs. Aside from my own arcs and the ones I have replayed for reviews or just helping people fine tune arcs I can't really think of any I have played three times or more.
WN -
Quote:Ok retry, then as this arc is intended to be humorous.
Love spurned 1934 Can you help out a desperate guy?
Hanging out in Pocket D can become hazardous, you never know when a desperate guy (one of my favorite NPC's over there) spots you and request your help. This was supposed to be your evening of.
Warning, this arc comes with the WORST custom costumes possible. You have been warned, mental health can be in jeopardy here.
Lowdown A love stuck and delusional fellow needs your help rescuing his "One True Love" who seems to be not all that into him. He has stumbled into something that goes beyond his simple aspirations and it is going to take a hero to sort this all out.
Funny Level Mildly Amusing, I found the main character (contact) who drives the story more sad and pathetic than funny. Maybe it is because I am a woman, but I did not see much humor in it.
Fun Level - A cheap Carnie ride.
Lets up it to 11! I liked the customs in the last mission and had fun fighting them, but I feel they may be tough for a lot of ATs. The number of ambushes in the first two missions seem excessive. Double check your spelling and your grammar. If this was my arc I would change One True Love for "One True Love?" and play it more for humor by letting everyone but the main character in on the joke. Hopefully by doing this the arc would be more about saving a love struck fool and you could have an ending that is more heroic feeling.
Overall Rating The idea is a decent one: A love stuck fool in over his head. It can be played for humor for sure, but not so much here. That does not mean it is bad arc, just not one I found all that funny. That said, it is worth a play.
WN -
Quote:Three things are needed IMO:
1. Give MA arcs the same completion bonus that normal missions have.
They've already nerfed missions that contain only bosses, a good move IMO - a mission bonus would equalize things and possibly increase AE usage.
2. Allow arc players to choose between normal rewards ( i.e. drops ) vs tickets.
3. Some focus by the Devs on the Dev's choice designation. Number of dev responses to ANY thread in the section - zero. Dev apathy is killing things from the arc designer side.
I agree on all of your points and especially wish the Dev's would open up a dialog with the players about MA. Continued silence makes it seem like they don't care and plan to leave the current MA issues unaddressed.
WN -
Quote:I don't think anyone is saying I16 is the only thing responsible for the giant drop off in MA activity, just that is the biggest factor.I agree with Eva that the number of people that think MA should be rewarding zero XP is quite small, if not "negligible." That said, I agree with Venture and some others that think there are other factors drawing people away from MA (and the rest of the game, for that matter) right now.
WN -
Alt, I agree with most of what you wrote, however...
Quote:I disagree. For me the real fun is having people play and enjoy the arcs I have made. I would compare it to coming up with a great cake recipe, making the cake and then no one will try it. Disappointing..
It is only fruitless to make new arcs if you don't enjoy making new arcs. I like making new arcs. I think it is fun - regardless if anyone is playing them or not.
Quote:The MA doesn't need to be revived. It is good as it is with i16.
I don't want to see a resurgence of farmers in the AE.
Quote:There are far too many copyright infringement arcs. Paragon Studios needs to have someone in place to hunt down and remove those arcs before the game is sued again.
WN -
Just brainstorming here...I was thinking this morning that if the Dev's would implement "wasting" feature with MA, something like they have with the market it would clear out the search list massively. Something like: If a published mission is not played or edited in 30 days it is marked as inactive and will no longer show up on standard searches. The missions would still be there and if played or edited they would move back to the active list. You could also have a box to check in the search feature "Search Inactive Missions".
WN
P.S. - Excellent post Hydrophidian. -
Quote:Grin,Ok retry, then as this arc is intended to be humorous.
Love spurned 1934 Can you help out a desperate guy?
Hanging out in Pocket D can become hazardous, you never know when a desperate guy (one of my favorite NPC's over there) spots you and request your help. This was supposed to be your evening of.
Warning, this arc comes with the WORST custom costumes possible. You have been warned, mental health can be in jeopardy here.
I sent you a tell about this, but in case you missed it. I got to the 2nd mission and finished it, but the mission would not end so I was forced to abandon the arc. Check into it and lmk when it is working properly so I can rerun it.
WN -
Quote:Play host for your arc. Start a group up and lead them through it. If you're really interested in getting the word out, make alts on other servers, rinse and repeat. If you can't get a group to stick together through the whole arc, there's a problem you need to address in either the arc or your presentation of the arc. You'll get much better and much more honest feedback if you're actually present.
If you don't want to put forth any effort to present your work to others, you have only yourself to blame when noone cares enough to play ARC ID 398281 based on a one sentence descriptive blurb.
I can't speak for everyone here, but I bet most MA authors that read these forums have done everything you mentioned and more to promote their arcs. I know I have. That said, most people don't read the forums and trust that the system provided will give their arc a real chance of being played, but it won't. If you don't promote you need to be lucky really to get any plays. I don't believe that is the expectation of the average player and I really don't feel that is how it should be.
WN -
Quote:This is not a "doom and gloom" thread it is simple observations. MA has been on a downward spiral for at least a month pre-I16, but I16 has greatly accelerated this effect. As an example pre-I16 my arcs got plays fairly regularly (though some way more than others), but they all got plays. As it stands now since I16 was released I can count on one hand the number of plays my four arcs have gotten. The few plays come mostly from one arc and two of the arcs have gotten 0 plays.In short, I think the title of the thread is an example of the doom and gloom mentality that's accompanied every big change to CoH since its inception.
Quote:No slam intended to the OP, but MA isn't in need of "saving." It's in need of fixing. There's a difference.
WN -
Quote:Hmm, how about a not so romantic RomCom? Perhaps a bit to much comedy for this arc but I leave that to your discretion
Love spurned 1934 Can you help out a desperate guy?
Hanging out in Pocket D can become hazardous, you never know when a desperate guy (one of my favorite NPC's over there) spots you and request your help. This was supposed to be your evening of.
Warning, this arc comes with the WORST custom costumes possible. You have been warned, mental health can be in jeopardy here.
And about your arcs, sounds familiar, done that one before. Hmmm got one that does not rign a bell, will give it a try.
If this is a comedy arc please submit it to Wrong Number's Ha Ha hut for a review. Also, next time you are in game please check and see if you have run all four of my arcs.
WN -
I am guessing most people, like myself, are very discouraged by the treatment the Dev's have given Mission Architect and how it seems fruitless to make new arcs. Most of the review threads have dried up and the flow of new arcs has slowed to a snails pace.
This trend seriously depresses me because I felt the Mission Architect was the best innovation this game has seen. I joined this game shortly after launch (pre-issue 1) so I have seen them all. Honestly, before I14 I was starting to consider canceling at least one of my familys accounts, but Mission Architect really breathed new life into the game. I had so much fun writing arcs, got so much pleasure having other players enjoy my arcs and the amount of enjoyment I got from playing the new content other players created was exciting.
Now however, I feel MA is on life support and fading fast. The issues I see are:
1 It is just way too difficult to find the real arcs in the sea of test, farm or abandoned arcs for the average player.
2 The reduction in exp that has reduced MA farms has also badly curtailed the average player from playing in MA and it's hard to blame them.
3 The rating system that buries excellent arcs with 100s plays on page 300 plus because they are only 4 stars. Think what you will, but with the current system anything other than a 5 star rating is negative because it reduces the chance of your arc being played.
4 Devs Choice is poorly implemented and not used. The few lucky people that got Devs Choice (most during Beta) have enjoyed page 1 treatment for six months.
I sincerely hope something is done to address the issues with MA and it is done in reasonable time fame. My question to everyone is can it be revived and if so how?
WN -
Last call for submissions before I shut this review thread down!
WN -
An arc that I really enjoy would be perfect for this:
The Monster Hop (Arc - 27861)
It features all the old Universal monsters.
WN