Durakken

Renowned
  • Posts

    2381
  • Joined

  1. i'm blaming this on the writer... and producers... and not a good enough director/editor to screw off. the movie is lacking in Oan parts, but even with that fact you could probably cut together better movie largely by cutting away a lot of the hammond scenes, some of the jokey stuff of hal's and splicing footage and adding some voice overs... though it would probably run shorter by a lot it would be a far superior film
  2. Superman according to modern canon doesn't know he's an alien till year 10ish
    Superman also would have debuted just 4 months earlier if they keep to comic chronology so no... they wouldn't know they had made contact with an alien... to a degree... already.
  3. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Nericus View Post
    Yes, I remember this, not sure if it is still canon though with all the GL:Rebirth and Parallax stuff. Back when GL had no series of his own and was relegated to Action Comics, didn't he appear on the Oprah show and Oprah suggest that he use the ring to allow himself to feel fear? Supposedly that was the door that helped let Parallax into Hal.
    It happens in Action Comics when they were doing weekly anthology (i think that's what it is called) issues. Not sure if she said he should do that or if it was oprah but he did appear on an Oprah style show and he said he doesn't feel fear and that he is like a cop...which got a negative reaction due to the perspective that Hal isn't risking his life due to the ring.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Energizing_Ion View Post
    Yeah I was curious why they had Amanda Waller in there...isn't she mainly a bad guy in/against Batman (or just the JL in general? I only know her from the JL/JLU cartoons ).
    Waller is a Justice League and apparently Superman villain type...I've yet to see her in the 7 years of Superman comics I've read so far though >.>


    For those of you who don't know there are 3 GL movie prequel comics...

    Tomar-Re which has him chasing down a bad guy and fighting him on the planet the movie opens to.

    Kilowog which focuses on how legendary various characters are, establishes some of the "new" recruits, but more so focuses on a psychic telling the guardians something bad is going to happen

    Abin Sur which focuses on Abin Sur arresting a criminal for transporting stuff through the Sol System...and he makes a mistake by leaving the cargo behind which crashes to Earth...The rest of this focuses on a young Amanda Waller fighting the machine virus and her winning, and Abin sur being impressed.
  4. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Nericus View Post
    Hal's origin and backstory since GL:Rebirth restored him and the GLC doesn't quite fit with Emerald Dawn.
    That was both stories...

    Emerald Dawn takes place after all that stuff...

    Emerald Dawn's "I'm such a mess up" thing is actually the DUI I was talking about. He drinks and gets into a car accident... and then despite having the ring fesses up to it and serves his time.


    Secret Origin cuts out Legion...and adds other stuff that happens that very well would have worked with Emerald Dawn and i view the two stories as both canon, just slightly focusing on different parts of what is happening.



    Oh btw... The Power Ring actually restructures Hal's brain we find out in one story which is which is the explanation as to why he is such a great GL. Abin tells the ring in such a way as to force it to find a successor among humans, it can't find one good enough in enough time so it creates one that is perfect in Hal Jordan...
  5. I have this fantastic idea guys... Peter Parker... With more angst.
  6. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Nericus View Post
    What is he supposed to do? Curl into a fetal position on the ground in fear and suck his thumb? GL's are chosen for their ability to overcome fear/being fearless. If a new GL transported to Oa caved into fear I daresay the guardians would rip the ring right off their finger and send the person back to their planet.
    The character as portrayed on screen which is not Hal Jordan would act the way he acted at that second...

    Hal Jordan wouldn't have though. He would have went looking for answers.
  7. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Hazmatter View Post
    I admit it's been a while since I last read the Emerald Dawn version of GL's origin, but I thought the movie borrowed a fair bit of Hal's personality from that. The irresponsible jackass who knew he was a bit of a screw-up but couldn't bring himself to admit it and take responsibility for how his actions affected others?
    That's the thing. Hal ISN'T a screw up or a jackass.

    He's angry at the world due to his father's death and that pisses off his older brother. To get away from that he joins the military. His contracts a fatal illness and he want's to go see her before she dies. The military won't allow it so he knock's his commanding officer on his *** and is kicked out, but makes it home too late. So he is angry at Feris and angry at himself when the story starts and he has a "people who get near me die" thing so he's a loner. This leads him to be semi-suicidal and bent on proving his worth, not to others, but to himself... Everyone else considers him the perfect soldier/pilot that is not only willing to do risky things but able to do them.

    The company he works for is bought by Ferris and everyone quits due to not liking Ferris. He is asked to come work by Carol because she knows he is the best. They get into fights because Ferris is struggling to maintain the company and Hal tends to blow up/crash experimental planes.

    if I remember right there is something about DUIs in there too, but that is hardly a "screw up" but rather what an average pilot is like so that also is not a "screw up" in that sense.

    His jackassy appearance has more to do with circumstance than who he is which is coupled with a self hatred and determined focus to do what he wants.

    Quote:
    One thing that I really liked about the movie's portrayal of Hal was the moment after he's dropped off near Abin's ship. He's disoriented at first, then disbelieving when he catches sight of the ship. But the instant he sees Abin's arm drop into view he charges in without hesitation to try and help whoever's in there.
    I liked that too... too bad it lasted all of 3 minutes or less.
  8. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Furio View Post
    Is that Hal when he first got the ring, or Hal after decades(real time) of ring-slinging?
    When he first got the right.

    After he became GL he lost a lot of his anger as it was, but he is often angry at other things, like Guardians being complete tools, Sinestro enslaving his planet, the destruction of his home city etc...



    As said in the other thread... they got virtually everything wrong... and it's mediocre at best and all the changes they made are bad changes.
  9. Durakken

    Well duh.....

    I thought that George Reeve couldn't be replaced...
  10. The problem with Ryan Reynold's Hal Jordan is that it is an unfocused, irresponsible, immature d-bag.

    Hal Jordan is a focused, angry, responsible character who seems to be uncaring due to his focus and anger.
  11. Oh and the only way my mind found the movie tolerable to keep watching was that about 15 mins in i realized the movie was more or less what you get if...

    Someone who knows what GL is all about told someone trying to convince them to like GL and then they told someone else about a geek who tried to get them into their comic thingies and then that person came and tried to tell people what GL is actually about and what the story is about
  12. Researchers develop the game tester? I thought that was already invented and a job position some of us would love to have.
  13. The movie sucked...

    All the action was boring
    All the characters were wrong
    Almost all the story details were wrong with who and what the various things are and how the characters act.

    There were a few "heh" moments and it wasn't "atrocious" in terms of what brought to the table, but when you are that poor to mediocre with the rich history and Monetary backing that GL has. Heck i don't even like Hal Jordan, but he is one of the few Superheroes that have had their origin story rewritten and changed by a lot and both versions are good...but instead of taking either of those they subject you to bland crap

    This is probably the worst...or close to worst Superhero film of the recent past...and after seeing this don't see why people would ever want to get into the DC universe...
  14. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Samothrake View Post
    It seems that the writers of previous generations were quite willing to have heroes have romantic relationships that would develop naturally and even have their characters be happily married. However, the newest generation of writers (those from the mid-late 90s on) only seem to develop romantic relationships with characters in order to torture the protagonists of their stories. (see Women in Refrigerators). Sadly, many of today’s romantic leads for the heroes (both male and female) are created for express purpose for tormenting the hero. Writers are specifically building these characters up so that when they do horrible things to them the readers will have a predictable reaction. (go to WiR and see how some of the writers actually admit this.)
    Which incidentally could be traced to one source in particular... Peter Parker and MJ and how Stan Lee created the character...basically to show that heroes have to deal with problems too which gave stories like How do you deal with a villain dating your guardian or deal with your best friend being a villain or etc... it seems to have escalated to the point everyone wants to show that and forget that some things do work and not every moment of a hero's life has to be tragic... Especially since too much tragedy or too much comedy dulls the care for those events because it's not surprising or shocking, or important but rather annoying, predictable, and boring....

    So wait... could all modern comic's problems be said to be a problem set in motion by SpiderMan 40 some years ago with the creation of Peter Parker and the death of Gwen Stacy? A death that Stan Leee disagrees with, but thought it was ok cuz MJ is such a great character?
  15. Bruce + Selina is the perfect couple

    Bruce + Diana is good, but not perfect... If there was no Selina I'd say she's the next best choice

    Bruce + Zatanna... I think they should play this relationship up more in the brotherly/sisterly love department which is what I was hoping would happen in Batman: The Dark Knight since it focuses mainly on the magical.

    Bruce + Barbara is... let's not go there...

    Bruce + Katherine Kane is funny because Batwoman I his aunt on his mother's side..not blood related.

    Bruce + Sasha was interesting

    Bruce + Jezebel = lame

    I can think of more Bruce relationships but meh...

    Of course there is also

    Dick + a cacophonous amount of ladies that I can't remember most of their names

    and...

    Tim Drake + Stephanie Brown
    Tim Drake + Cassandra Cain (never took off, but hinted at and toyed with shortly)
    Tim Drake + Cassandra Sandsmark (meh...teen drama crap)

    Tim Drake + Tamera Fox ...

    I have no idea what the Tam Fox relationship is. They are engaged in the public eye of the DCU, but that's an act, but they're close enough that she knows he's Red Robin so... who knows...
  16. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Wooden_Replica View Post
    Bab's becoming Batgirl again, a definite demotion, in many ways Bab's as Oracle has grown a lot and isn't the same babs who was Batgirl, and in many ways much more effective, I'd rather see her grow the Oracle role even more

    Cassandra, only slight demotion, she grew out of the Batgirl role, and is now at the same stage as Dick was when he first established himself in the Nightwing Role, she needs to develop her Nightwing

    Stephanie Keeping her as Batgirl would be ideal( but improve the custome please), so if Bab's becomes Batgirl, so does that make the second Bat Family role from? Although I will add, she would've been fine if she had stayed Spoiler to begin with
    It's not demotion/promotion thing...
    Barbara left the mantle of Batgirl. She grew out of it and became stronger character before she was paralysed.

    Cassandra left because she felt she didn't belong and had to find herself. If she came back and became Batgirl again she'd be saying she has found herself and no longer needs to run from the family that she found.

    Stephanie worked hard to earn the role in universe. She wants to be Batgirl not because of the title, but because of acceptance of her being part of the family. To take that away is shows a callousness of several characters that just doesn't exist... Batman only has that persona to the mass public, if he was callous then he wouldn't be doing what he is. Would Stephanie dropping the mantle regress her character? No, in fact it would grow her character in many ways due to the crap that would happen to get her to do it. What it means though is that Stephanie has something heinous happen to her (which poofing out of existence I consider heinous) or Barbara Gordon stops acting like Barbara Gordon and that character regresses... or both which is most likely the case.



    DC is asking us to trust them... them being Jim Lee, Dan Didio, Marv Wolfman, Grant Morrison, and Geoff Johns... All names that one looks at (save for Didio) and is like woo they are all pretty good at this whole thing... I doubt they'll mess it up.

    But let's be honest... in recent years these are the guys that have been messing up whether it has been year after year of "OMG ****'s gonna change" events or developing a MMORPG universe...or just decisions about titles such as Young Justice and the direction of characters that are just terrible.

    The only one I'd say hasn't messed up is Grant Morrison, but apparently tons of people hate his run on Batman and they want to pretty much erase it. He's doing what they want to do while maintaining canon and working with it.

    And really, after the interview on GL:EK with Johns and Didio who brag about needing to change Hal's origins to bring him back... come on... seriously? Why would you trust them? Sure they brought a few good elements out and are generally good at one shot story arcs with directives, but generally it seems the more free reign you give these guys the worse they are.... it really isn't them who has made the characters or stories worthwhile but rather the little guys that are being over shadowed and tossed out now.
  17. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Ms. Mesmer View Post
    You mean Cassandra Sandsmark, yes?
    No.

    For a very brief time and hardly ever shown Superboy and Batgirl had a relationship. She would from time to time sneak out and visit him which took a few days so it was hardly brought up in the Batgirl comics while I don't know how much or if it was ever brought up in Superboy comics.
  18. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Samothrake View Post
    So, if everyone thinks Oracle is dead, this then opens up Barbara being Batgirl again.
    No it's not. There are better candidates to take up the mantle or retain it and not move the character back... Like Cassie Cain rebecoming Batgirl would be a step forward for her... Stephanie staying Batgirl would be her moving forward... Barbara would be her moving backwards....

    Quote:
    However, it still doesn't explain the magically walking and doing gymnastics paraplegic.
    Read more BoP... She has gained some movement back already due to various things.
  19. Which ones are the best?

    Lois and Clark are perhaps one of if not the greatest couple I think...
    In Universe Sue and Ralph Dibney are considered the best...

    I personally love the Tim Drake / Stephanie Brown couple and the Dick Grayson / Barbara Gordon relationship when they're allowed to be together and not fighting.

    Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle is probably character development wise perhaps as great as Lois and Clark, but not as Iconic.

    We got Marry Jane and Peter Parker

    Cyclops and Jean Grey

    How bout Conner Kent and Cassandra Cain? They were cute together in their scenes together especially with the fact that Cass could smack Conner and have it hurt, through his invulnerability.


    Is Wonder Woman and Steve Trevor a good couple? Theoretically shouldn't they be as Steve's the reason Diana left Themyscira?

    Anyways, who are the best hero couples? How important are they? and how iconic are they?
  20. Emperor Aquaman
    King of Markovia (forgot his name) attempts to sign a Non-Aggression Pack with Atlantis. He's betrayed and captured by Atlantis... and used to to sink Europe and the plan to use him again...
    The War between Atlantis and the Amazons is revealed to have been triggered by Mera being killed or something and Atlantis assassinating Hypolita on the day of the wedding.
    Revealed that Tara Markovia is on the side of the Amazons and moved Themyscira to avoid getting hit by the sinking of Europe

    Citizen Cold
    Citizen Cold hero of city, but as his citizen ID he is a thug.
    Mirror Master revealed to have been "killed" locked in a mirror where if he comes out of the mirror he dies or if someone comes in the mirror they die... Rogues are still villains.
    Wally West Appears to be a paid assassin...and looks to die s the cliff hanger.

    FrankenStein and the Crusaders of the Unknown
    Frankenstein is found in the artic tundra, saving a soldier, Shieve... he goes on to form an unit with him. A scientist mutates 3 people and they become the "crusaders" making the unit a 5 man unit... they help win the war and then is betrayed and put in stasis.
    They escape in 2011. In the fore ground is Superman's pod. The unit exits and decide to go to the scientist's place to see if they can find note on reversing/stabilizing their mutations.

    Deathstroke and the Curse of the Ravager
    Arrrr. He's a Pirate. He attacks other ships...busts metas out of a prison.
    They are searching for Rose Wilson (Ravager)


    more to come...
  21. Ms. Mesmer, the "dawning of the age of superheroes thing seems to be a quote from a different interview of some sort and plugged into the article by the writer, not a quote from anyone they interviewed right then and there.

    The 5 year compression literally can't happen from a "main event" stand point... 1year later, Batman year one, 52, and No Man's Land each take 1 year of comic time

    So it would go...

    Y0 = Superman Arrives on scene
    Y1 = Batman Year One
    Y2 = Dick Grayson becomes Robin, is fired. Becomes Nightwing. Jason Todd become Robin. dies. Tim Drake becomes Robin.
    Y3 = No Man's Land
    Y4 = 52
    Y5 = OYL
    Y6 = Current Year

    it just doesn't work. It would compress all history in the DCU into Year 2, with the comics from 1987-2006 happening between Y3 and 4 and everything after OYL happening in Y6

    Assuming that Batman is 23 when he starts that makes him 29 currently. It makes Dick Jason and Tim all 18. Makes Barbara 20 and Damian as long as he isn't a fast grown clone type being conceived when Bruce was 15... or younger, considering training.

    I don't see them "keeping the main events" and making it a 5 year history, especially with Zero Hour and CoIE stating a 10/15 year timeline

    The JLA forming as far as I know has always been placed y3.

    I'm betting that at the end of Flashpoint they are going to post timeline of how the universes all collapses into creating the "new" DCU
  22. Ms. Mesmer, You read that wrong...

    They didn't say that all of the DCU is going to be compacted into 5 years. They said that Action Comics and JLA will be set 5 years before contemporary, and whether that us when superman arrives on the scene or not is a dif question...

    If it is the case that all the history is taking place in 5 years there will be massive backlash worst than just rebooting because they are just showing how dumb they are as writers... if not then we'll see


    also if they try to say this is just like CoIE...CoIE's end result universe already existed and was the main cannon.. where as this isn't


    They also say this isn't "Earth-#" implying flash is going to fail, the 52 universes are destroyed and we enter into the mega multiverse or a single universe again... but with that info it makes flashpoint a crappy read because we know he is going to fail...
  23. If all the important events still happened then why is there a need for a "reboot" to change the costumes? the teams? What?

    It seems like they want to shuffle characters around and change their designs and just not give a reason behind it... lame.
  24. To be fair many people who have brown hair did have red hair at some point as red hair tends to darken with age...

    I for example had dark auburn hair with dark orange-ish beard which has slowly turned dark brown hair with medium tone brown beard.

    So we could say that Bart Allen's brown/red hair thing is just him at different ages.