KM or MA?


dave_p

 

Posted

Hiya folks,

I'm looking to make a scrapper for solo leveling, which would be better KM or MA? My secondary will be WP, is one better than the other for soloing or basically the same thing?

Thanks!


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Verren View Post
Hiya folks,

I'm looking to make a scrapper for solo leveling, which would be better KM or MA? My secondary will be WP, is one better than the other for soloing or basically the same thing?

Thanks!
Not the same thing at all. I think it would depend largely on concept. In terms of damage (completely guessing here), I would assume that both sets are roughly on par with each other, doing mostly smashing damage. Both have a some secondary effects that provide mitigation (MA - knockback, stuns; KM - knockdown, stuns, -dmg). I think MA probably edges it out on damage while KM is more defensive.

Both have a martial arts type of feel to them. Many of the KM animations look like kung fu, while MA is a hybrid of a number of styles of mostly kicking fighting arts (e.g., Tae Kwon Do)

Both would solo just fine.


 

Posted

KM does energy and smashing damage. It also has PS which is a bit nicer than BU. Thus KM gets my vote.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fury Flechette View Post
I think MA probably edges it out on damage while KM is more defensive.
I don't know about that. From what Arcanaville and Umbral have posted about it's numbers, I think KM is going to easily surpass MA DPS-wise. Also, since part of KM's damage is energy, it will be less resisted than MA's pure lethal damage, so that also gives KM a nod in the damage department.

So, besides it being all shiny and new, I give my vote to KM.


 

Posted

MA has higher burst damage and a better AoE.

KM has better damage over time from what I've read from posts here.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaidin View Post
I don't know about that. From what Arcanaville and Umbral have posted about it's numbers, I think KM is going to easily surpass MA DPS-wise. Also, since part of KM's damage is energy, it will be less resisted than MA's pure lethal damage, so that also gives KM a nod in the damage department.

So, besides it being all shiny and new, I give my vote to KM.
I actually haven't paid attention that it was doing partly energy damage. So I missed that entirely. I just *assumed* it was smashing damage. My bad.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by SevereCalamity View Post
MA has higher burst damage and a better AoE.

KM has better damage over time from what I've read from posts here.
MA has only 1 PBAoe attack in Dragon's Tail. KM has Burst and a ranged cone in Repulsing Torrent, that's also a KB. *If* you can leverage RT, on paper, KM has MA beat for AoE, but I'd think in practice, MA would be better (and yes, DT >>> Burst). Which is a really, really pathetic thing to say about your set, if MA has better AoE capabilities. *sigh*


An Offensive Guide to Ice Melee

 

Posted

I think with the new addition of EC followed by DT with the increased chance of crit, its makes DT even better when it has a huge crit chance. Seenin 3-5 crits at a time in a big group is awesome.