Venture

Renowned
  • Posts

    2357
  • Joined

  1. Quote:
    I get what you're saying, but consider for a moment the literal meaning for what you're saying and you'll realise that's actually the problem behind a lot of newer story arcs. Imagine what a story would represent if it tried to use EVERY available gameplay asset. Go ahead, take a minute and imagine it. No think back to Dr. Graves and Twinshot. Does your imagination match those? Because it should
    Sam beat me to it -- an arc that used EVERY SINGLE "asset" would be like those early 90s web pages that used flashing text and italics and bold and ALL CAPS and blaring music and dancing hamster wallpaper...the ones you couldn't click out of fast enough.

    Less is more.
  2. Venture

    SSA #2 Episode 2

    Quote:
    Actually, it does.
    Actually it doesn't.

    As I keep saying, gluing feathers on a rat doesn't make it a swan. This stuff:

    Quote:
    The Midnighters, Resistance and loyalists all have exclusive areas that can only be accessed by people who've joined them, the Vanguard give out special merits and perks to members, temp powers can summon allies, zone mobs can con non-hostile, scanners, newspapers and contacts can all give repeatable missions, and contacts and NPCs can recognize player achievements and status
    ...is feathers. The player having command of an organization would change the game completely. Instead of running missions he'd be assigning them. He wouldn't be out farming mobs to get invention salvage; he's got people to do that for him. And so on. It would change the game from an RPG to some kind of RTS. A tabletop GM can accommodate a change like this; a MMO doesn't have a chance. This is the kind of thing you have to design for from the start.
  3. Venture

    SSA #2 Episode 2

    Quote:
    Meaning when the arc ends, we are NOT backstabbed (at least not so much to truly warrent promptly taking it down), the upcoming issue introduces our new organization as yellow/blue conning NPCs that have taken over various, formerly Arachnos locations, and various maybe even future contacts linked to this organization who greet us in a friendly/fearful and respectful manner.
    Wishful thinking at best. Your ever-so-helpful "assistant's" Sudden But Inevitable Betrayal is all but written on her forehead. The game's structure does not even remotely support the player having an organization at his disposal, never mind having any real political power in the world. Failure Is The Only Option.
  4. Quote:
    I think world-building is just one of the things. From prior to current history, I get the impression that there are a lot of moving pieces at the CoH side of Paragon, and only so many hands to keep said pieces moving.
    I don't care.

    All that matters is the quality of the work. There are no excuses. If they've bitten off more than they can chew they need to scale back accordingly. I'm sure they're all great people off the clock but that's not what I or anyone else here is paying for.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by James Mason
    I'm going to tell you something that I learned when I was your age. I'd prepared a case and old man White said to me, "How did you do?" And, uh, I said, "Did my best." And he said, "You're not paid to do your best. You're paid to win."
  5. Quote:
    Stand by him supportively, providing wisdom and human grounding in an effort to prevent him from completely spiraling into darkness.
    He'd already been there and done that.
  6. Quote:
    Money issues... Really? He took 8 years off to do absolutely nothing? Couldn't even keep up on company issues?
    He sunk a lot of the company's resources into the fusion reactor...and then killed the project when he learned it could be weaponized. We came in during the aftermath of that.
  7. Quote:
    That statement could be attributed to an unreliable narrator though. Either she's using it as an excuse, or she's generalizing based on her specific circumstances.
    Or the person who wrote her dialog in i6 really, really like The Lexx. *sings Brunnen-G Battle Hymn* (*)

    * very badly

  8. Venture

    SSA #2 Episode 2

    Quote:
    You've beaten, subdued and humiliated two arch-villains in front of their own gangs and absorbed said gangs into your organization.
    Yeah, but look at which villains. When I was sent out to get Castillo (and please, let's stop pretending that you're not working for the Contact still) my first though was "what, Operative Jenkins wasn't available?"
  9. The Circle's demonic minions are bound. Akarist mentions in "The Envoy of Shadow" that they now have the means to both summon and control demons.
  10. Venture

    SSA #2 Episode 2

    Prometheus, Silos (both in full-on Smug Snake mode), time travel, forced rescue by Penny Sue^H^H^HYin...now they're just trying to torque people off.
  11. Quote:
    Apart from the director's past movie history. In this case, Inception. Which is surely not so subtle that people who missed it first time round have to make up excuses...
    a) Inception is a case of people missing the point and reading too much into things. There are people who pull the same stunt with Minority Report, claiming everything after Anderton gets haloed is a dream. Spielberg has said, point-blank, "we wouldn't do that to the audience, that would be stupid" but it doesn't stop anyone. Don't even get me started on Total Recall, which also drags in the "director re-interpreting his work" angle, since Verhooven's explanation of the ending varied according to whether or not he thought he was going to get to make a sequel at the time he was asked. Ironically that sequel would have been Minority Report. Of course both movies as well as Blade Runner (no, Ridley, Deckard is not a replicant) were based on the works of Phillip K. Dick, so maybe these issues aren't surprising since at any given moment he probably wasn't sure if he was hallucinating or not.

    b) The Dark Knight Rises is not Inception. It is its own movie and has to be evaluated on its own terms. Arguing that the ending is ambiguous because the same director made Inception is like expecting characters to walk off of movie screens in every Woody Allen movie because he made The Purple Rose of Cairo or expecting every Terry Gilliam movie to end with "it was a dream" because he made Brazil.
  12. Quote:
    Now fit that all in with the ability to create multiple challenging bug-free missions, just as challenging new NPCs, and do it all on both a deadline and a shoestring budget.
    Not hard. In fact, having a solid story makes the rest of the process easier.
  13. Quote:
    Better? Worse? I don't know. Like I said, just an alternate take on how it all works.
    It's not worse because there's nowhere to go from rock bottom.

    The whole Well/Fountain/Box/Whatever thing is just silly. Doesn't jive with how superhuman powers are acquired and developed as shown in the game. Doesn't fit with technological advancement seen in the game. If it was "planned all long" then the plan failed catastrophically; more likely it's a retconned-in attempt at a meta-explanation and it shows.
  14. Quote:
    Blade Runner: Unicorn. Sometimes director subtlety is lost on people....
    And sometimes directors creatively reinterpret their work after the fact, and sometimes people read way too much into things. There is no reason to believe the end of TDKR is anything but what it appears to be.
  15. Quote:
    Its certainly far more reasonable than the microwave vaporizer from Batman Begins that vaporizes water contained in metal pipes but does nothing to the walking bags of mostly water that are standing around unprotected.
    <treknobabble>Different harmonic frequencies, obviously.</treknobabble>
  16. Quote:
    When an iconic figure like Dumbledore bites it you know someone means business.
    Fixed.
  17. Venture

    Man of Steel

    Quote:
    We know that Zack Snyder can do great, gritty action that looks great.
    We do?
  18. Quote:
    Or maybe it's just Alfred's imagination.
    I've heard this theory but I didn't see anything in the film to even suggest the ending wasn't what it appeared to be.

    But then people keep borking up the end of Inception, too. (No, it was not a dream, and the point wasn't whether or not the top fell, it was that he stopped looking to see if it did.)
  19. Quote:
    Some sort of martial fighting ability? Or at least the ability to get out of the truck before it wrecked. Bruce would have gotten out, and this is Talia whose skills are supposed to be as good as Bruce's.
    Actually I don't remember it being said at any point that Talia has League of Shadows combat training. As for her accomplishments in the film, "It is not supreme excellence to fight one hundred battles and win one hundred victories. Supreme excellence is to win a victory while fighting no battles at all." -- some dead Asian guy.
  20. Quote:
    Whatever the situation, calling the story inconsistent is less effective and less accurate than more specific words would be.
    Or, you can just use the word the way the vast majority of English-speakers do.
  21. Quote:
    Granted it isn't The Dark Knight and nor should it be.
    If it falls short of TDK it is only because Ledger hit it out of the park.
  22. It's entirely possible that his mind wasn't exactly on crimefighting at that particular moment.

    Also, I don't remember anything about such scars being indicative of membership in the League. It's a bit of a leap to go from "has a scar" to "is lying about her identity" and even further to "is secretly the arch-villain responsible for ruining my life and plotting the destruction of the city".
  23. Quote:
    If the containment breaks down, it seems to me that there's a potential for the energy particles given off by the fusion reaction to cause a fission reaction to occur. As I recall, isn't that the basic premise behind some nuclear bombs?
    No. Other way around. Fission reactions are used to ignite fusion.

    Decades ago one of Jerry Pournelle's friends asked him how to make a nuclear reactor explode like an atomic bomb (for a book the friend was writing). Pournelle said "put an atomic bomb in it and set it off". The friend, FWIW, didn't like that answer and ignored him. (I don't think the book ever achieved liftoff; can't imagine why.) Reactors don't explode like nuclear weapons (except, perhaps, a breeder reactor but AFAIK even that is real long odds). They can misbehave in a number of ways but they don't go kaboom. Fusion reactors, as previously noted, are even more fragile that fission ones. If the proper conditions aren't maintained the reaction will just stop. We've been working on maintaining those conditions since the 70s and from what I've heard we're actually farther away now than when we started. That's how difficult the reaction is to establish and maintain.

    Of course, this is the kind of thing you have to overlook in a superhero movie. The dubious physics involved in the fusion reactor wasn't exactly the most improbable element of TDKR.
  24. Quote:
    I've suspected for a while now that Brawler and the Regulators are in control of some part of the 'dyne trade in Paragon City.
    So, basically, they're the Rampart division?
  25. It was a much better film than The Avengers. The popcorn crowd will probably find The Avengers to be a better movie. But de gustibus non whatever etc.