-
Posts
1673 -
Joined
-
Quote:I offered it hoping you could relate to it, because it seems as though you dont understand the basic mechanics of this game.Everyone has access to everything, but not equal access. You obviously offered the hockey analogy so you you could shoot it down. Straw Man.
Please explain how, when you create a toon, that you dont have the exact same choices available to you as everyone else. Perhaps you dont have a toon over 20, and therefore cannot play a H/Veat. Besides that possibility, you have the exact same choices as everyone else. No more, no less.
Quote:So, let's get back to CoH. Endurance use is not equal. Defenders use the same endurance for their Energy Blasts as Blasters, but do half the damage. Thus, they use twice the endurance defeating the same foes. That's not equality.
How many blasters can solo a GM with less endurance usage than that defender? Different toons shine in different circumstances. How many scrappers can solo a GM with the same endurance cost? How many tanks?
Thats not equality, because you are comparing apples to oranges. Apples and oranges taste good, and are interchangeable as a snack. Thats balance.
Quote:I haven't suggested anything radical. I haven't suggested changing anything except endurance.
Quote:Actually, I've been told exactly this. From the FIRST reply, I've been told to build better, frankenslot and get teammates.
Quote:No one has even remotely said that. You dont need to purple a build. You dont need to use sets. You dont need to franken slot. You dont need to use IO's at all. You dont need to use stamina, you dont need to use physical perfection. You dont need to use conserve power. You dont need to use temp powers. You dont need to use accolades. You dont need to use inspirations. You dont need to combine inspirations to get exactly the one you need. You dont need to use end reductions in your powers. You dont need to use powersets that have end managment powers in them. You dont need to rely on team mates with end recovery powers. You dont need to use brawl and your origin power. You dont need to pause for a second between attacks.
Tell you what though, sure helps if you do.Quote:Interestingly, I'd agree Blasters need more damage, specifically because damage is their defense. If they can't take their foes down rapidly, they don't last long. However, that's another thread.
You want to give everyone more End. Please explain to me how that will balance your choice AT vrs another one... The blaster will STILL take down the mob using less endurance than the defender... so how is that equality? Now you are also willing to argue that blasters need more damage, so they will take down the mob using even LESS end than this defender of yours? You are confusing me. Please clarify. -
Majority matters not. What he is looking for is a "signifigant percentage" Apparently 10% is signifigant. The other signifigant percentage of 90% can be out right ignored.
-
Quote:Would you be willing to trade weaker damage, or buffs, or debuffs, or recharge, or accuracy, or defence, or resistance, or mez protection for the reduced endurance? Not I.Probably as 95% (if not 100%) of the Super Strength builds posted on those boards have Footstomp, right. But we're talking here about a particular defining power in a given powerset (as BU is a defining power in the whole blaster AT). And there are such powers for every powersets/AT, give me one powerset and I'll give you a power in it that is likely to be present in almost any Mids build posted on this forum.
For the travel powers, if 95% of the builds used one specific travel power and not any of the others, it would likely mean there were some inbalance too. But that's not the case.
Stamina is probably the only power, with Health, that you can find in 95%+ of the posted Mids builds in this forum, whatever the AT/powerset choice is. And Health, even if a very good power, is there most of the time as a Stamina pre-requisite. Hasten is a popular choice also, likely to be present in more than half of the builds in those boards, but nowhere near Stamina I think. (I have no evidence for those figures of course, and I hope you will agree they give a fair account of how things are going, because I wont give any)
I really do think it says something about stamina and the basic endurance recovery vs consumption in the game. Does it make CoX a "tedious" game, or does the whole endurance concept need to be redone ? Certainly no. I like it how it is for the most part as I said before. Could it use some tweaks making stamina less "mandatory" and the endurance constraint a bit lighter sometime, or the global recovery just a bit higher ? I think it could. Just my opinion though -
Also, If the thread was nuked, you will never know what was said....
-
Quote:Its SO's... Stamina is great, but SO's roxxors the boxxors.My list of constraints pre-20 was given in response to the claim that endurance woes are the primary reason people race to level 20+. I certainly do think it is one reason. I think it is inaccurate to claim that it is the sole reason, in support of the claim that something should be done about pre-20 endurance.
-
Quote:No one has even remotely said that. You dont need to purple a build. You dont need to use sets. You dont need to franken slot. You dont need to use IO's at all. You dont need to use stamina, you dont need to use physical perfection. You dont need to use conserve power. You dont need to use temp powers. You dont need to use accolades. You dont need to use inspirations. You dont need to combine inspirations to get exactly the one you need. You dont need to use end reductions in your powers. You dont need to use powersets that have end managment powers in them. You dont need to rely on team mates with end recovery powers. You dont need to use brawl and your origin power. You dont need to pause for a second between attacks.The claptrap coming from most of the people giving Ultimo_ grief is saying what amounts to "Poor people are poor because they want to be. Otherwise they'd be rich like me." It's nothing more than e-peen waggery from the usual wastes and Ultimo_ would do best to just turn his crap filter on.
Tell you what though, sure helps if you do.
Wow... 16 ways to help end recovery, and I bet I missed a few.
There are no have nots in this game. There are alot of cant-be-bothered-to's. No one is stopping you from doing what you want to do. Petless MM? Sure! Blappers? Okay! Scrankers? Why the f not? A big green Encreddible Bulk? Sorry... not the way we roll.
What would you do to rebalance the game for more end? What would you give up Johnny? -
Quote:There is nothing exclusive in this game. Any rewards I earn, you have the same ability to earn them as well. We log in in the same place. There is no City of Africa where you log in impoverished and malnourished. Everyone has access to everything. Everyone can do the same thing.Actually, SinisterDirge, I'm all or equality. Personally, I like a level playing field. I'd LOVE it if everyone had access to everything because everything was the same. If this were so, then it would be skill and cunning that would win.
Quote:However, I'm not suggesting anything so radical, though you seem to be implying I am. All I've said is endurance should be recalibrated. From the reaction, you'd think I was suggesting destroying everything.
The little guy has been inquisitive enough to post repeatedly here on these forums, asking where everyone is, how do they do this, that, and the other thing, but I have never seen them post about sucking end. You are not the Narod.
Quote:I play Hockey. I'm a goalie. I have exactly the same equipment and team composition going for me that my opponent does. It's down to skill. I'm not required to give up my stick and pads after facing the first 10 shots, and the other team doesn't get to have 20 players on the ice. That's the kind of thing I see in CoH.
No, you dont have to give up your pads and stick and face 20 guys. Do players not rest on the benches besides the intermissions? They all play 60 mins each game, more if it goes into overtime? Christ, can I be on your team?
Quote:The checkers analogy is similar. Both players have the same pieces with the same abilities. It's down to skill and cunning.
Quote:I've said before, it's not about my personal builds (plural, since I'm not referring to just one character or AT). Endurance use is excessive FOR EVERYONE. My opinion, of course. It does seem to me, however, that if everything were as rosy and dandy as you are making out, there wouldn't be any threads like this, by me or the many others who have made the same observation.
If they are silent, how do you know what they are thinking, and why they quit? How about the vocal many that quit after ED, or GDN, or because they got bored from lack of content, or *gasp* lack of a challenge? -
Quote:I'm just illustrating a point, the numbers here are meaningless. I'm saying if someone is suffering a disadavantage relative to others or to the NPCs, then there may be a problem that needs examining.
How about you make a mmo. Call it Vanilla Hero. Every person that logs on is allowed to create as many characters as they want, you can dress them up however you want, but everyones powers, and effects are all the same. No single toon is better in any situation than any other. The villians are defeated in the exact same way, every time, because they also, are exactly the same, only dressed different. Everyone has the same aoe's, there are no vet powers, because thats not fair to the new people who just started, and you dont want to make them feel uncomfortable. You also want people to stay, so you need to give them something.... maybe more costume options?
Sound good? Pretty sure I would want to roll toon after toon in your game...
Have you played any real life sports? Do you ***** about who you play checkers with, and refuse to play them again, because they beat you, and that is not fun?
Heres a life lesson for you bub. The best way to learn, and get better at something, is to play with/against players that are better than you. If you dont challenge yourself at all, you stagnate. Life does not come to you on a silver plate, and yet, alot of people still manage to have fun.
Endurance is fine as is. The low level game is fine as is. Show me one complaint from a first timer on the boards ******** about end.
Post up your build, and I will gladly roll that toon, and play it without standing in the middle of a mob huffing and puffing. You are not posting this crap for new people, you are asking for it for yourself. -
Quote:You sacrifice nothing. You have a full attack chain, with enough accuracy to only miss from bad luck, and recharges in half the time. Plus costing much less endurence. How is that a sacrifice?Yes, you can make endurance issues inconsequential, but you sacrifice your ability to hit and damage your foes in the process, which only exacerbates the endurance problems again. As I say, I don't want to fight my powers and struggle to use them, I want to fight the enemy and struggle against THEIR powers.
-
Quote:Of course, no one has 10% endurance. Everyone starts with 100% What you do with it, and how you spend it are up to you. Don't spend it all in one place.What I mean is, if they're dying more than others are or an inappropriate amount. If Scrappers had 10% of the health of everyone else, they'd die a lot more, and that would be why. Further, if EVERYONE had 10% of the health they have now, they'd ALL be dying a lot because they lack the health (or defenses) to withstand the enemy attacks.
I would love to hear though, what would you recommend doing to re-balance everything if your end reduction hopes make it into the game. What are you willing to give up, to make it worth it to you. Now try to convince everyone else to give it up as well. -
Quote:From what I see here on the boards, new people comming to the game dont ask about endurence, or how to solve those woes. They ask why are the servers dead?, Why is there no one on the streets? What is the leetest toon I can build. Come to think of it, I dont think I've ever seen an introductory post complaining about end problems.SinisterDirge, part of my concern is that new people coming into the game, finding those first 10 levels or so unentertaining, may just leave. The streets are deserted enough already, I think we need to consider that we want more new players enjoying the game sooner, and I see improving endurance woes as being very helpful in this regard.
I am not Mind Over Matter but I would say its because it is the only power that is freaking recharged and that hellion has my last sliver of hp all over his fists. -
Quote:What do you mean if thats why they are dying alot.? Of course thats why they are dying. Thats why everyone dies. You can't die without running out of HP.SinisterDirge, I think endurance should be restricting characters, just not as much as it does. I've said it several times in this thread, even. I'd also agree that if characters are dying too much, then they may need more health or defense to compensate if that's why they're dying a lot. Also, while a significant portion have said things are fine, I'm also seeing a significant portion saying there may be a problem.
I wouldn't want foes to lay down, I want to be able to fight them and not have to stop midway because I'm out of endurance. I shouldn't be more of a threat to myself than my foes are. That is, my foes should defeat me because they DEFEAT me, not because I have to essentially stop fighting.
Here is another tip for when you find yourself running out of end mid fight. Fight slower. Instead of blowing your load in the first 10 seconds of the fight, wait a second before you hit the next power. That also gives your other powers more time to recharge. Now, you wont have to stop mid-fight to recover end, and you wont need to stop to wait for any powers to rechage. No stopping required. Varry Nice! -
Quote:Hell, you don't even need vet powers anymore. You can't run a mish without 3 temp powers dropping on you these days...
I well understand the frustration of being able to unable to solo effectively. When I started this game, I built a pure support toon to help my regular team mates out for hazard zone hunting. Once they got to a lvl that they had stamina, and other ways to survive longer, they no longer needed my help, and considered my toon a xp leech. It was a hard lesson, but I learned it, and it didnt turn me off the game, just people. I never rolled another toon that I couldn't solo with.
That was before respec's, debt cap, temp powers, half mission debt, xp curve, endless brawl, IO's, mission bonus xp, inspiration combination, ED, free origin power, no debt before lvl 10, etc.
The Devs have made it very easy for a toon to level up to a point where you can slot SO's. Never mind stamina. -
Two /Traps corruptors with maneuvers. 40% def, and a bit of status protection without IO's.
Fire for most damage. -
Quote:Nope. Haven't tried a petless mastermind either, or a "MAN" build. I do have a lvl 39 emp/psi that I can solo with thouigh.You tried soloing a lvl 1 FF/rad def before the I17 defender changes with no vet attacks?
Also, not directed to you personally Minotaur, but I always love when people say without this, or without that. Why wouldn't people use everything at their disposal? Hell, you don't even need vet powers anymore. You can't run a mish without 3 temp powers dropping on you these days...
Another bit on topic. Didn't the lvling curve adjustment effectively allow people to lvl faster while using less endurance? The game gets easier and easier. Do people really want the hellions to just give up as soon as the hero enters the mish? "Oh ****! its _____! Nevermind guys, lay down, playdead. Give him your xp's." -
Quote:Tell me then, what limits do you think a toon should have? If endurance is fixed to your expectations, but you find yourself dying alot, would you like more hp? While standing in a spawn waiting for your powers to recharge, do you think about how much fun it would be if all your powers recharged instantly? I mean, you never see the Thing stop punching because his punch hasn't recharged...SinisterDirge:
Endurance should be part of the game. I said that in the first post. However, it shouldn't be a "constraint" on fun. As it is, it's excessively constraining.
I agree soloability is important, but I do think EVERY character should be comparably able to do so.
Honestly, where do you think the devs should balance things?
Every character I have rolled is able to solo. Some faster/easier than others but they can all solo.
Quote:The point here is to see if there is a significant percentage of the population that feels as I do, and if so, to be able to show that to the devs for consideration.)
Quote:Why should it change? Because it's NOT FUN, and that's the only measure that really matters.
If I may recommend one more band aid though... I still forget about it on practically every toon I roll. When fighting, turn off sprint. -
Quote:Wasn't trying to attack your point of view, just offering an alternate one as to why people like to solo. If I wanted to solo an emp, it would be paired with Illusion.Lucky for you there are hundreds of possible combinations that excel at solo'ing.
Don't misread what I said, I have no issue with people solo'ing or toons being designed to do it. I specifically said that I believe it is flawed to design this game so that every toon excels at solo'ing. Unfortunately, the devs seem to crumble to people that want their emp defender to be as competent as their scrapper while those same people fail to take in to account that said emp brings way more to a team.
I agree with you, not every toon should excel at soloing, just like not every toon should be capable of taking down a pylon, or gm.
People forget that when the Dev's say every toon "can" solo, they definately don't mean at +4/8. -
Soloability is a big draw for me in this game. I dont like to burdan a team I am on with constant afk's because my son has decided to feed the pet fish to the toaster/etc. Appeasing my wife is another one. If I can't drop the game in an instant without letting the team down, then I can't team. Beside's it is unfair to the team.
-
End is a constraint, like HP. I learned early on that slotting for end reduction cuts down on the rest period between spawns. Dont forget to eat your blue skittles either. You can combine 3 of any type to make one you need, so that helps as well.
Quote:The sad thing about blasters, is they use all that endurance up on just damage, while having piddly secondary effects that wont help their survivabily at all.They(Defenders) have such poor DPE (combared to say blasters or tanks) that they tend to use up more endurance to do the same damage as blasters and scraps. It sucks for a defender to use a power that 2/3s (or less) as much damage as a blaster but has it cost the same amount of endurance -
-
Quote:That was Frosticus.Someone or another actually mathmatically proved a while back that a high recharge Fire/Fire dominator has the highest possible DPS in the game (in ideal conditions of course)
He was in the 350+ DPS range. -
Quote:Step 4) Blame alcohol, irritable bowel, or syphilis.I love Fire_Minded topics.
Step 1) Ask for advice.
Step 2) Don't get the advice you wanted to hear.
Step 3) Rage/troll.
Step 5) Apologize.
Step 6) Rage/Troll.
Step 7) Quit the internets.
Step 8) Repeat.
Four more and its a twelve step program... -
Knowing your past and how hot headed you are, you might want to head to the pvp forums to develop a thicker skin. You are going to need it when you are in the zones.
-
Quote:...really? He did not say lrn2play... You don't have to play at +1. You dont have to use IO's You can turn it back down to +0. If you still can't beat the widow/whatever, try to use a different aproach.Actually, I generally find them to be a hassle to make. I don't play this game to craft. I play to be a super-hero.
You are basically saying that you have to have IOs to play 'effectively'. Another shut up and learn to play.
One piece of advice I give to all squishies, is don't stand infront of a boss that deals cones. Widows deal cones. Even if your sidekick is taking no aggro at all, he is going to be taking just as much damage as you. You might recommend to him to stand behind the boss and attack it.
If you are playing at +0/1, Then your original post where it says the mission is being run at +1 to the leader is misleading and easily confused. -
...why am I not suprised. Oh well, not as disapointing as when I took Ice storm on my fire tank to slow the mobs down for my burn patch... that didnt work so well.