What's a powerset to use with Stone Armor?

I've been playing a stone/axe so far up to level 20, and I'm starting to run into a serious problem that I hadn't considered when coming up with the build: knock back + Rooted = big hassle trying to kill enemies. I can only imagine this problem will get worse when I finally get up to granite.

So, looking into the other possibilities, the only other one that looks interesting to me is /electricity, since it has no knock back, and the last power is a teleport power, to save me having to slowly lumber up to my enemies sometimes.

I've got a lvl 50 stone/stone melee tank and the Knockdown /Knock up of most of the Stone Melee powers make for fun "smashing". If you go this route don't slot for +kb as it will turn the KD into KB. Hurl is the only power that has inherent knock back and is nice to use on a runner.

There are still mobs out there that are weak to kb, like clockwork, that will still get knocked back. It also seems to be a bit endurance heavy to me, but nothing that can't be worked around.

Mids' is not correct about all powers it lists with a Knockback. Some powers only knock enemies down. Read the power descriptions to see which ones do that.

Don't expect to do any serious damage as a Stone Tanker. Once you get Granite Armor, its extreme survivability comes at the cost of you moving slow, having slow recharge, and doing less damage. All of that is worth it, if you want to be the toughest meat shield in the game. If you can't stand those penalties, make something else.

As a Granite Tanker, you are mostly a taunt-bot. Keep enemies attacking you by taunting and using various attacks. It doesn't matter what set you use, as long as it doesn't knock back. I prefer Fiery Melee for the largest radius PBAOE melee attack in the game. It works great if you are trying to taunt a spread-out group.

I found that the Stone/Fire combination worked very well; it of course lacks any mitigation in the secondary but once a stone tanker matures it has all the durability it'll need so you really don't need mitigation from the secondary.

I'll definitely second the suggestion for TP... it's almost mandatory for a stone tanker to have mobility in combat without toggling off the mez protection. I personally really don't like TP as a travel, but I still have it on my Stone tanks for combat mobility. It's either take TP, build for massive runspeed IO bonuses or always team with a kinetic for speed boost.

By the way, Stone Melee doesn't have knockback, it has knockDOWN instead. Look at Mids, any power that lists knockback of MAG 0.67 will not KB even level foes unless they're weak to KB like Clockwork. Looking over the Axe set I don't see any knockback powers there either; everything's either knockdown or knockup (which will send mobs straight up, then straight down at your feet). You'll only get knockBACK if you're fighting lower level mobs or a very few specifically weak to KB.

I took a stone/axe all the way to 50. I can tell you that you don't really notice it that often. Most of the enemies just fall down at your feet due to the knock down/up. I also took TP to be able to move around when I needed to. If you find yourself knocking back too many enemies for whatever reason, you can either take a ranged attack from the ancillary/PPPs or you can just taunt them so they will (eventually) run back to you. I really enjoy using /axe though.

I'm not sure if the "clarification" on Stone Melee and what is kd/kb was directed to me or not. If you read my post you'll see that I stated that for the most part SM is Knockdown/Knock Up; unless you slot the KD powers for MORE knockback, which will turn the KD into KB. Slotting knockback enhancements will take that .67 mag and make it stronger which WILL put it over the kd threshold to changing them to KB.

Again, Hurl Boulder does Kb as it's at least a mag 6 if not higher effect.

So, if it was directed at me, please re-read my original post. If it wasn't, ignore me.

There really aren't any strong synergies between Stone Armor and the attack sets pro or con. The slows from Mud Pots may work together with Ice Melee.

The primary criterion would be that the low level attacks recharge quickly, which puts Energy Melee at a strong disadvantage, but then Energy Melee has no advantages, synergies, or purpose now. Almost any of the other sets would not be that bad with Stone.

I think it's safe to assume that the player who is willing to put up with Stone Armor wants to be a main tank for a team running difficult content. As such the power sets that make you even tougher (Dark Melee) or contain team friendly AoE powers to help with aggro and keep your team safe (Stone, Ice, Fire, Electricity) are worth a look.

<《 New Colchis / Guides / Mission Architect 》>
"At what point do we say, 'You're mucking with our myths'?" - Harlan Ellison

My personal pick would be either Dark (for the defense synergy and speed) and Electricity (teleport attack, lots of AoE).