Core I5 or Core I7?


Father Xmas

 

Posted

Hello all, I've come to ask for your advice...

I've been out of the computer know-how market for a bit while I've been concentrating on other things, like family and school. However, I got a nice little holiday bonus and have been thinking about (finally) upgrading my Win7 64-bit rig.

I have a decent video card (geForce 460GTX), but what's really holding my system back is everything else, like the Core 2 CPU, PCI-E v1 mobo, and DDR2 RAM. The GPU barely flinches, but my CPU (especially) is slammed at 100% when I play games like DE:HR. So I'm looking at upgrading my 3 core components - CPU, mobo, & memory. Especially since the Mrs. primarily uses the PS3 as a Netflix and BluRay player these days.

I'm pretty comfortable in regards to the specs on the latter two, but when it comes to Intel CPUs, I'm a little confused. I know Core I5s don't support HyperThreading and don't have an integrated memory controller like the Core I7s do, but how important are these things? Are they worth paying an extra $100 for?

Can you help a gargoyle make an informed, yet frugal decision on a possible upgrade to his aging gaming fig? If so, thanks in advance


 

Posted

Only going to talk about the Socket 1155 CPUs here. I'm ignoring the much more expensive Socket 2011 CPUs.

Actually, i5 does have an integrated memory controller, dual channel just like the i7. Even the ones before the current Sandy Bridge line.

The difference, besides the price between the i7-2600K and the i5-2500K is hyperthreading and 8MB of Level 3 cache instead of only 6MB and an extra 100MHz to the base clock speed. All that for only 50% more money.

Unless you run one of the thread happy applications that review sites like to benchmark with to show the difference between the two, such as video compression or ray trace rendering, then you really don't lose much choosing the i5-2500 over the i7-2600.


Father Xmas - Level 50 Ice/Ice Tanker - Victory
$725 and $1350 parts lists --- My guide to computer components

Tempus unum hominem manet

 

Posted

Exactly the person I was hoping would see this with exactly the sort of info I needed. Once again, I am in your debt sir. This will make selling the idea to the Mrs. much easier, if I can save $100 or so off the CPU alone.

Edit: and thanks for the confirmation and extra link TS


 

Posted

... and I should now be getting my new hardware before XMas Thanks again you two


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Obsidius View Post
Hello all, I've come to ask for your advice...

I've been out of the computer know-how market for a bit while I've been concentrating on other things, like family and school. However, I got a nice little holiday bonus and have been thinking about (finally) upgrading my Win7 64-bit rig.

I have a decent video card (geForce 460GTX), but what's really holding my system back is everything else, like the Core 2 CPU, PCI-E v1 mobo, and DDR2 RAM. The GPU barely flinches, but my CPU (especially) is slammed at 100% when I play games like DE:HR. So I'm looking at upgrading my 3 core components - CPU, mobo, & memory. Especially since the Mrs. primarily uses the PS3 as a Netflix and BluRay player these days.

I'm pretty comfortable in regards to the specs on the latter two, but when it comes to Intel CPUs, I'm a little confused. I know Core I5s don't support HyperThreading and don't have an integrated memory controller like the Core I7s do, but how important are these things? Are they worth paying an extra $100 for?

Can you help a gargoyle make an informed, yet frugal decision on a possible upgrade to his aging gaming fig? If so, thanks in advance
I run i5-2500k with never a moments problem. However, I only use my PC for gaming. If you use yours for not only playing games but editing vidious and photos then I read an i7 260-k is good value. But, if you use professional multi-media apps, then an i7 3930-k is recommended (by courtesy of What To Buy - PCGamer).


There is always a lot to be thankful for, if you take the time to look. For example, I'm sitting here thinking how nice it is that wrinkles don't hurt. ~Author Unknown