If you care more about damage than toughness then yes. The two things the brute has going for it are more health, so those defense numbers and resist numbers go further, and a higher resistance cap so they can buff themselves to 90% resistances with oranges in a pinch.
Weight training: Because you'll never hear someone lament "If only I were weaker, I could have saved them."
all things being equal, it looks like the scrapper comes out on top in a a couple of things, mostly damage, even in others, mostly defenses and a power choice in the epic pool with one having an end reducer and the other an endurance mod.
the DEF and RES are identical (in my build)
D S/L 40.9
D Neg 34
R S/L 51.8
R Neg 47.9
but damage-wise a scrapper, before crits are considered, beats out the brute running at 75% rage
Shadow Maul 280 vs 324 (648 w/crit)
should I scrap the brute and start over?
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1593;745;1490;HEX;|
|78DAA5934B6F125114C7EF30504A7917E88BB6D0421F3C4A4 BD4C4C7C2A8D5A4494|
|9B06D5CA90DA5239D480107D4B273E742DDE8C285AF181317 EA17307EA2B6BEBE01|
|DE73FE17DA84A51338BFB9E7FCCF63E6DE291CAC7A8478725 968BE6BD552B3B9BD5|
|9B64A8D8661390AA58A591EDCAFD76BF1DD7AC5298418EFC6 B60B46D53072AB25EB|
|3E6EA3BDC8AA71CFA83555EC8AB55FB7826BB53DC3326AAD5 CF7C65BACD7ABB91B6|
|665AF65D62A1E5EAD1BA5865CF8BB8B5DC36AEE998D20AFD7 6A8FCCA6B96356CD56|
|3B78BD61967357EBBBEDED42A9D932ACF6981CED9CFC5B34A 326FFA2E3104E5D882|
|9611B045C0CFB10E0660C7818A9D359A3F2262A06A6358A0C 268059760EC5801946|
|D3A99244C7A61DDA48377F041C33D252A0A3ACAE4390F8C94 84297842E23750EE8E|
|C8E69AEED4900E8EB435F1FFA3E9472A79AD65914E40ADC04 3618C35B4040278487|
|195999E54296706505F5D5A4CB8D0710EE8EBC842E3D5E35B 1179384D17B04938C6|
|0AE25A9F36B1A8FE0F772FD31B419F3312682C00C379A041E CBACA018E2ACE00B1B|
|09269F4A84C4F42B5E4D6758A7107FC6B19CCC0AA99942116 EBF1006028C5488619|
|7BA88D245A04B42370FDD0274235237AA74A3D0A5A04B4397 86EE40EAC6D5338EBF|
|E151E26F81F73CEDCC07E023F08911945951553D8AEA6954C FA27A16D5435237059|
|D3685EA4BA81E96911876458B21B28CC803199955076EF60B 225F19F96F8014CCF1|
|99ECD8E60E799EA523E098B129776551755DC45B4E015B329 2515D33E89A45D7CF5|
|E2172C8B1E5E22C5E06F249465B765D51C76865021B6E17EA EAC81F9DACF53E4FD1|
|DEFB7C84C69E98BDF719FED7F5DDD3EDE5DAA0D3B645A648E 61699DB64EE90B94BA|
|64466874C998FE68F5EB6FF3C0D7481CC453297C84402D23C 27A593BE1D37190F19|
|2F191F193F99009910990932EFC8745C3259C733777EC91A9 A76FAF97FF779FE9CF|
|6E06DFF3D71E91AF621F19A3737F192918773A5EF85A7FB3C F93ECFD93ECF993ECF|
|C98BFE077F362830|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|