City of Heroes: Live Forum Archive

This Tank or That Scrapper?

Donna_

By Donna_,
Posted on: 2010-06-09 22:00 in Everything about PvP

 

Posted

I am looking to finish off one of these two for a melee Hero to along with my Sonic/Mental Blaster and Rad/Mental Blaster, but which should I choose?

Fire/SS tank or MA/ELA Scrapper?

Tank

Code: 
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1414;724;1448;HEX;|
|78DA9D945B4F134114C767DBADA5ED96B640E5522E2D885CDA2E942795076304228|
|442238427B52E656C37360B761723DE3F00DE628CB798F8E0F523109FD4A85FC22F|
|E0A7A8E732607875D3FE7F67CE9C3973E64CB7C51B338610F74F0BCD385BB75CB7B|
|C6A3957652350B4AA762532EFE4CF49CB4B97D64A412144374F9667E415E9B8D29C|
|B36563A77C66BB61A5D44C51D6A53457B6B7C05EF11AD2A97AB5C4BC5393607AE6B|
|E112E6D6ED6CD952D29370C32E76CCF91AE1B55836ACDB39D6A8246F3CE75DBB5D7|
|EDBAEDEDB4CD6ED91573D66A78B572D1723DD8BD0BCA1A83EFD71088065FD10C887|
|1300AA225CBC811C2798649C84C107261A19EA62E967DE86A5D24B42D117A8B84C2|
|02E11B6CA2F126BAB648197CCB8C22415F6294082664F773F680FF26641811E95B8|
|4CC6DC2F13B8CBB8C7B8441E8748037F105B202131D3984EF50459003B46027187D|
|22D34508C0D210CF88509E827F407044F525C27D31B82F06F725CE7D49735FD2DC9|
|7214814553544537EEACB348C7421FA7F532B8210115345C4D638D38286F5FF841D|
|136A26C115B7315A604DBBAAA57D97D2743C603C241C7DC4784CE87F42F0C1AA247|
|751247B28911F5C9DAABCCE292AAFABC0C851C02FA8A15B0574F3E63D8710850C29|
|15904A52F9BD1D84FE382116C486F2AE7D1C1007D700BBB4014E738C51808B1E541|
|73D78995C4315C6064372F83AE31A1D6C0A560DD3CFA919187E47AE91F78C0F8C4F|
|84F18F84FC67C25338E7A8DA6B3447AEB13CC3644CF0AA494681F00C5665D5AAEC7|
|381F7947BC178C97845C8BF66BCA5427538B1A92ECCE4264CC418AD8C30A1106144|
|097FE00F6552B56E921BD4AB1FBC67F081472CEA07EFAB10190A2AE9CA032E8D82C|
|6FE053543710A15BCFEBF9E3D633F5DE83CBEF8AB2825106D0DAD0B28177178092D|
|0BAD75940A0E9B5F8CFD33C44E605D27514EA14CA324A13EB18B91C1084804C5408|
|9A2B4A2C450E228ED283D286F509A7F01246DEECA|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
Scrapper
Code:
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1417;713;1426;HEX;|
|78DA9D93D972124114867B58641B3623864012424C42803040F4C2E5C252A355B18|
|25226E64AA52664424611A89929CBB83F80572E51CB8AEB5358BE8A8FE0FE027896|
|06CB5BA7E07C3D67E9FEFB744FEDF6922AC4A39342899C69EBB6DD586D5A7AAF675|
|8DE9ADE329BFE9A5EDA326DA7EB1342A407B146CD681B8656D32DC7D4DB8D539663|
|6786B12563CBE8D88676B66D341DCB6C42F866D78A2F77B60DCBE838DA60A0D6BBD|
|DB676CE743A866D07E965B567189B61E96F6D3B66A715A7B7E5CE2DD33637CCB6E9|
|ECC4CFF6CCA676BABBB9D3A8E9B663583B49D09687FF2E8AA4A7EF155B80AAF0B41|
|8DB84A0C9B84E98BC41F81A062854E516471474B92A8CC384C94537E21BE4299C27|
|942C957E07979B5D2E3797FAB9D4BF4878098ABCACC8E3FDE842D7BEB78C7784B9F|
|784FC1BC22B48F7C90DF8EE904BBD4B88DD23ECBFCF7840187F48F8012A02524580|
|55A8AC629C37E08539439CA0844AA4BCCC9886485896868BE48AFC839F307754964|
|6476130216249C26B288D4BAD716EF614377B8A9B9DE56667B9D9596EF62F986F44|
|36646485D41DA8312E100E5E2424EB041F2C9290CB27D639E13C2027FC1019E5887|
|7F409F521F982907A4A987C46987A4EC8ED120E41D598DCEF589A8E35F58522D500|
|E137E84BCB05D3DCA32AC3E5C35DF3F14FA4C8B507AE8C6C41668E17C831E61979C|
|24C815124B8A16A5A6A98E6E39AE1E39AE3E30A43C2ACDCDA6C822341422EC25009|
|F928234C5883DDCCCBAA79BE4E05BE6A05BE6A05BE6AA50F8432DFE0CB5055945B2|
|82E5064A1C4D01865AEAA30AA842828D4B84AD102741E65161A834845F6AFC257A8|
|CA18F70C3F4EF8C123563CC30F4F089653F7480F7E639494F99BD40FC48653FCEFF|
|3491D4C17B81404BB86A60E4659C7D1153457F1F51A8E741C6DA069E26BFFB33A10|
|103D8ABA8EA1398EE6049A04EA7B8C99BE1098101A154D184D044D144D0CCD089A1|
|49A3D34FD3F43A3F3B0|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|

 

Posted

any suggestions, on one or the other?

These are for zone fun btw...

 

Posted

Starting from the top...

Tanker issues,

1) This is slotted to be a ragdoll, Knockback is not fun in pvp unless your delivering it.
2) Both shields, Fire + Plasma are over slotted, There is no point in using the extra slots for such little defense after DR hits you.
3) You have slotted the Glad Armour def proc... imo a waste of 2+ billion inf on this toon.
4) You don't have hurdle, or any jump powers, you won't be able to get over the small walls in Rv nevermind anything bigger.

From your build I would tweak it as such.....

Code: 
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1412;716;1432;HEX;|
|78DA9D935B4F134114C7677BA1946E694B2D9472A7405BDA2ED4272F89C608C4029|
|52AC893DA2C38B41B9B85741723DE3F804F12C54B7C543F83F1498DD1EFA01FC4B7|
|7A2E03CAAB9BF6FF9BCB993373FE3B5BB93BA70BF1E4BCD0F48B4DD3716A6BA67D5|
|BB6FC15B36E6D86CA76F19234DDD1EA7A352084E8E7C9DA9CDC92B6238D054BB6F6|
|6A17765BE6809AA9C8A694C6EAEE0EB457DD96B4EB6E2356B61B129AAE71D8E8AA6|
|E6F378DD51D296FE9D45CB05C5B3A4E8C3A65FB8EE5581B56D372F7C26ABADE702D|
|BBDE33BF636D1AF366CB6DD42AA6E3C2EE4938560EFE9F83201AFC45DB270C68948|
|4679A5124F8661849C090287409F540F8A207673A9618CB84CE0A6385F005B26B9C|
|DDAF2D51A2AE654685A05F66AC10BAAB040336F1F2267EEF7D4AD47D8F107DCC784|
|4E86908C216611C9CF6F35E1E7F9E864E1CC357384C80034480CBE98035413514CC|
|52D437880A294342EC442FFB92642792EC4B8A33A4214398C3BDE15F74ACDE9F845|
|4CA8B18ECA05E00E222CA89C8395A3AB808C888E132639DD20E5F238C5E61436055|
|8C9DD062091A9AFA2D707127CCC4D5BEF167B4C5E80BC63E61EC80E081B80467F02|
|6D8C431B674EC0121FD90E085B83E55761F979DE6B2D35CF604973DC1657F0797FA|
|95D9FD6C6FE118C2906F80F7F50CF0C927A2FF161009A0726943C74A8BC2CC889A1|
|9E16C1946092EC6B8BA18E3593A7726C7C81072538C3CA34C3809AB26E916B67D93|
|EF6868FA3DE30343657F0BBDB8D887D79655573C7B20F0DD145E128AAF18AF196F0|
|8CF213CAFC2F305CA375364188C1942A944F801C6191C2E0C7E453EA87756D53BCB|
|4E94D88941DFD1D7063F78C4B2EFE8735523559F1A80118D46727F63DAC128450A0|
|EFEAFE7A37E982E7815BFFE35942A88B68EADEB2837B07B135B26B6365036B1DBFE|
|A41F96103985E73A8D7206E52C4A02CE279E626420041242D151C228DD281194284|
|A1C2585F216A5FD071012F41E|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
Scrapper Issues

1) Why on earth are you slotting for defense? Aegis bonuses are not worth using in pvp
2) Same issue with the def proc IO... really no sense in having it in there
3) Crane kick is seriously under slotted for dmg
4) General yuckiness...

Here is what I would suggest.

Code:
| Copy & Paste this data into Mids' Hero Designer to view the build |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|
|MxDz;1418;718;1436;HEX;|
|78DA9D93D96E125118C7CF3050CA56C04A17BAD01D28302D776ED1A8AD096DC7A25|
|DE2858A537ADA4E4420331363EF7C00AF346935A6972EAF60BCF2397C05E3F602F8|
|2D078CB74EE0FF3BF39DEF7CE77F96319FAD4485787E4D6803371B96EBD6B6EA8ED|
|56E4B27605A8776BDDFB44A07B6EBB5824288B16E5FCD940D290DD3723CDB6AD4AE|
|3B9E9BE9F5ADC803D974A5B1DA9075CFB1EBD0FDA4E5242BCD23E9C8A667741BD16|
|AABD5306ED95E53BA6E985EB6DA52EEC754FCF0C8B39B87497AAB349FDAAEBD6737|
|6CEF38B9DAB6EBC68DD6FE71CDB45C4F3AC723E02D0FFF1334494F2720167C42948|
|52FCBC811FC794681D0F75820BEC5001A8DD285A151CF22A1BFC458269C06559AE8|
|F8B535AA105D27243608E74CC626E13B94D555599DCB86B96C98CB46B9EC6B281BE|
|0B27AE01D0D9D7A4F98FEC02890CD379017548B0B3EA2D0F41E61B6CED86748C2DC|
|3D4056FC001721E522C4D3CFB1993976B1C02EFAA07484F344244715662014E3902|
|FC61E06FEC14FA81DE7042D5EA45082F116862695D7247B5DB4186CB9C8968B6CB9|
|98D311BFA0DEA0DAE0C12AD93ABFC958274C998CDB84204C92E2E903A9ABD098104|
|36B1A2E7AA84298DCA5BCC91DC61D3E4C1835AC3664F8256DF0C809E31561FC9430|
|0B79A32A6FF42B85D269B2991E258C8728F81B4C8FA98D1B2BD1727C41F4C2A1890|
|E3CE20C2219B51F992B00BF2EB28AF92E7913F27C29176B747C3A0C9C512E66F8DC|
|16F814B37C7C593EBE18E4CDABA3984F71DE3415DA86AA395521C7F7AAC4F7AAF49|
|171E6C36DDF81BC82B2582852CF528961309608E532E30B8D8AC3BC865AAAC1F326|
|20B4ACAC2CF3452933C6FDBDCF137EB82F1BFEDEA7A722557FEF23131A45327F733|
|AA144AFC2FF3E9FA2DD72A1BB61D06D942A88B68BADFB280FF0F521B62C6CEDA1D4|
|F1B5F339DA3510BF80BE2EA25C42B98C92427F2F3033180189A0445162280328719|
|404CA204A1AE50CA5F3072EECF898|
|-------------------------------------------------------------------|

Consciousness: that annoying time between naps.

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Golden_Pie View Post
but which should I choose?
Without looking at the builds, just based on the toons, the fire/ss will definitely be the stronger one.