Just came back and time for a new scrapper!


Morbid Star

 

Posted

Okay, after being away from the game for a while, I have come back and I am itching to roll a new scrapper. I basically have it narrowed it down to four choices, and I would like some input on them:

Fiery Melee/Fiery Aura
Fiery Melee/Shield Defense
Electrical Melee/Electric Armor
Electrical Melee/Shield Defense

I really only have three major concerns with these choices: will Fiery Aura/Electric Armor give me enough protection, does Shield Defense's Mez protection being on a recharge timer hurt me in any way (as opposed to it being a toggle), and will Electric Melee dish out enough damage for me to solo.

Thanks everyone!


Characters I am Currently Working on:
Corcra Dragan - MA/Regen Scrapper (Hero) - Virtue
Chronian Phoenix - Time/Fire Defender (Hero) - Virtue
Mindzeye - Psy/MM Blaster (Hero) - Virtue
Valence Vixen - Elec/Elec Stalker (Villain) - Virtue

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Purple_Dragon View Post
will Fiery Aura/Electric Armor give me enough protection
Enough protection for what? Leveling, yes. Low budget AV soloing, no.

Quote:
does Shield Defense's Mez protection being on a recharge timer hurt me in any way (as opposed to it being a toggle)
Not really. Just stick a recharge or 2 in there and stick it on auto and you'll barely notice a difference.

Quote:
and will Electric Melee dish out enough damage for me to solo.
Yes. It's an excellent blend of ST and AoE damage.


 

Posted

I like Fire/Shield myself. Tons of AOE and top tier single target damage as well. You'll need to IO out the character to hit the softcap, but once that happens you really are a juggernaut of destruction. Electric/Shield is also great, I've just never really liked the electric set outside of lightning rod. For secondaries, Fiery Aura is great for damage but will be more squishy and harder to supplement with IO's. Same with Electric Aura. Hope this helps.


"We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm." - George Orwell

 

Posted

Thanks for the input so far guys! I think I am going to go with Fiery Melee as a primary, but I guess I should have been a little more specific in asking questions about the secondaries. So I am wondering how Fiery Aura, Shield Defense, and Electric Armor fare in the following situations:

PVE Leveling (Mostly Soloing)
EB/AV Soloing
PVP Combat

Thanks again guys!


Characters I am Currently Working on:
Corcra Dragan - MA/Regen Scrapper (Hero) - Virtue
Chronian Phoenix - Time/Fire Defender (Hero) - Virtue
Mindzeye - Psy/MM Blaster (Hero) - Virtue
Valence Vixen - Elec/Elec Stalker (Villain) - Virtue

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Purple_Dragon View Post
PVE Leveling (Mostly Soloing)
PvE leveling, they're all roughly equal. All three sets are on the "low" level of the survivability scale and provide different benefits: Shield is pretty much all damage, Elec is a bit of damage but mostly utility in the form of endurance assistance, and Fire is pretty much a decent mix of the two.

Quote:
EB/AV Soloing
Well, any of them should be able to solo EBs without much effort. They're EBs. I'm not entirely sure any of them would be able to solo AVs without a decent bit of investment and, as soon as you start talking about investment, Shield wins hands down. Softcapping defense does more for you than almost anything you can do with Elec or Fire, and AAO's +dam easily beats out any damage contribution of a normal damage aura.

Quote:
PVP Combat
While I'm not a PvP expert, nor do I even make the vaguest supposition of being so, I'm reasonably confident that Shield is pretty laughable at PvP: defense is supposed to be pretty much useless thanks to high player accuracy and +tohit. Between Fire and Elec, I'd probably put more money on Fire thanks to have FE for better burst damage and endurance modification of any kind being relatively useless in PvP (which is kind of Elec's schtick).


 

Posted

PVE Leveling (Mostly Soloing)

any combo can do this easily

EB/AV Soloing

any combo can do EB's easily, but the shield's with a high budget is best suited for AV's and out of the fire or electic prime, fire is more ST damage than electric

PVP Combat

not all too well versed in the PvP area but i know def gets borked in it, out of yer choices , fire/fire has the highest burst damage in the game with BU+FE, but it does lack a "god" mode tier9 which */ele has, as well as its end draining potential in several powers such as Power Sink which is vicious in PvP


 

Posted

Let me be direct, if you're interested in PVE and all that that entails (content, EB/AV's, rikti challenges, farming, TF's) you want FM/SD out of the ones you've decided on. Fire Melee has one of the best single target attack chains out there and very respectable AoE with FSC. No mitigation to speak of, but compensates with more damage (fire DoT) and is less resistable damage type in regards to alot of the endgame. Shield Defense is the shiny new toy, the big daddy of the defense sets and substantially boosts you're offensive capabilities while at the same time being top notch in the defense department. You'll be able to softcap your defenses later in the build, but can get it to levels where a single purple inspiration will easily softcap you for little investment while leveling up. You'll love Shield Charge, nothing more can be said, it's a deal sealer.

PvP, thats a whole nuther ball of wax. Defense is close to meaningless and targeted AoE's are worthless as targets don't stand still. From what I've seen, /Regen is king here.


 

Posted

I love my Fire/Shield, not so much my Fire/Fire. /Fire works great as a Tank set where you have higher base hit points, but I feel I little squishy as a scrapper.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Hyperstrike View Post
English does not borrow from other languages. English follows other languages down dark alleys, hits them over the head, and rifles through their pockets for loose grammar.

 

Posted

Thanks for the advice everyone! I think I have settled on Fiery Melee/Shield Defense. Thanks for all the input!


Characters I am Currently Working on:
Corcra Dragan - MA/Regen Scrapper (Hero) - Virtue
Chronian Phoenix - Time/Fire Defender (Hero) - Virtue
Mindzeye - Psy/MM Blaster (Hero) - Virtue
Valence Vixen - Elec/Elec Stalker (Villain) - Virtue