Mid's Recharge Glitch?
Your first build has the Force Feedback proc in Footstomp toggled on. That means Mids is behaving as though you had +100% all the time.
Also, the effective global recharge on both builds is identical. Your second build is way overcapped on 5% bonuses. Check the View Active Sets button--you're getting no recharge benefit at all from Dark Consumption, Boxing, Energize, or Tough.
Yup- the green button is clicked on for FF proc in the first. You have too many 5% bonuses in the second build.
I have two builds that I will post below that are coming up with different recharge results for Energize.
First, my SS/Elec manages to achieve Perma Energize: