Steampunkette

Legend
  • Posts

    1724
  • Joined

  1. Quote:
    Originally Posted by EvilGeko View Post
    Yup. That was some good writing there. Also made me wonder if Statesman is a better constructed character than we've given them credit for.



    NAW!!!
    I lol'd

    -Rachel-
  2. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    No, you don't. And there are only two beers left in the house so I can't deal with the rest of this pile of epic fail.
    When the Stone Temple Pilots changed their name from Mighty Joe Young they did not magically become a new group of people. They still had played the songs from their Demo.

    When Kara's Flowers added a guitarist they renamed themselves Maroon 5. They are still the people they were before.

    When Cole was crowned Emperor 25 years ago the remnants of organized crime joined together to become the Syndicate. 15 years ago when being Psychic became a faux pas and Tub Ci faked his death the Syndicate started sucking up psychics. It did not magically become a group of people put together by Cole and his Regime. They did not magically -stop- being criminals for 30 seconds before starting up again making themselves criminals AFTER the fact.

    Please, Venture, put me on ignore. Because that's where you're going.

    -Rachel-
  3. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    For every action there is an equal but opposite reaction.

    [SIZE=2]

    When you broaden the terms that far you make everything the direct result of everything else that has ever happened.

    You're blaming escalation on one half of the people involved and saying "Damn any other argument". Every action has an equal and opposite reaction is true. Mm Hmm. Yup. Which means the Syndicate helped to create itself. The actions of the government did not happen in a vaccuum after all.

    However, organized crime existed BEFORE Praetoria existed. Cole's response to their existence may have ESCALATED the conflict, but it didn't -create- the conflict.

    Want to go back further? The Syndicate is the fault of the US Government of Praetorian Earth, since that was the inception of the Mafia as we know it, today. Oh! And the various groups which spat on the Hmong.

    You can go alllllll the way back the causal chain if you like, Venture. But the Syndicate were criminals before Praetoria was a twinkle in Cole's eye. The regime did not create the Syndicate. It just helped them Coalesce. The Mafia did not become something else after the Prohibition. They were still the Mafia.

    -Rachel-
  4. Ooooooo....

    This bodes well... >.>

    -Rachel-
  5. Both Pinnacle and Triumph have RP populations of note. And guardian, to a lesser degree.

    -Rachel-
  6. Perfect! Thank you, Eiko Chan!

    oh... but that means after every level-range I'll have to do another morality mission just to get back to Resistance so I can run the next Crusader arc....

    Ah well!

    -Rachel-
  7. So I could have a Responsible Loyalist kill Interrogator Kang or kill Reese as a Power Loyalist and do the Crusader Arcs as an undercover Loyalist...

    Crap... Really didn't want to let either of those things happen...

    Could I play a Loyalist and do the initial Warden arc to become a deep-cover loyalist to do the Crusader arcs from that point?

    -Rachel-
  8. One for the road, Westley.

    *trows a fish at the Philotic Knight*

    -Rachel-
  9. And Ben has it right!

    Neither side is -truly- heroic. One side wants everyone to obey all the laws and follow all the rules or die. The other wants everyone to make their own rules, or die.

    It's a Fail/Fail situation! The only possible mitigating factors are the individual's own actions. Wardens cause wide-spread mayhem and chaos, Loyalists try to halt wide-spread mayhem and chaos by killing a smaller amount of people.

    -Rachel-
  10. Is it impossible to do the Crusader arcs as a Loyalist or the Power arcs as a Resistance member?

    I know the first Power contact (Deputy Assistant of Information) is in the "Loyalist Lounge" but can an undercover resistance agent get in?

    And can an undercover loyalist ever enter the Resistance Underground, where pretty much all the contacts for the Crusader arcs are located?

    Haven't ever tried... But I think I might want to do the Crusader arcs as an undercover Loyalist stopping their various evil plans...

    -Rachel-
  11. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Divus View Post
    I find it interesting that by the end of my first character's sojurn through Praetoria many of the Resistance contacts I dealt with were dead...usually by my hand:

    Jackhammer: Dead
    Hatchet: Dead (or in Mother's clutches)
    Vagabond: (Who I felt slightly guilty about) Dead
    Beholder: Returned to mother's clutches, basically dead
    Wardog: Dead
    Crow: Dead (I'd kill him many times over if I could)
    Steffard: Accident, I shouldn't have tried to do the Cutter Cain arc coterminously with the save the seers. It cuts Steffard out of the contact chain immediately.

    There may be an opportunity to go after Richochet, but I always go try and save my team in the Power arc she appears.

    Loyalist side
    Interrorgator Washington
    Reese...I shouldn't even put him. He's a stain that won't go away.

    The idea that you can inflict such losses on the Resistance, but don't really dint the Loyalists, is kind of disappointing in a way. But, I felt no guilt for the bulkof the gankings I delivered...except for Steffard, but that was an accident.
    Don't forget Warrant! He dies in one of the power arcs, too!

    -Rachel-
  12. For those of you curious as to what I did there, I call it the argument of opposition.

    The Mafia, before and After the Prohibition used different techniques. There are also different families in the Mafia than there originally were. But it is still the Mafia.

    The Syndicate is a bunch of Organized Criminals. They joined together when it became apparent that they couldn't stand apart. They picked up Psychics as a tool and a new weapon against the police force. But they're still Organized Crime, they haven't changed a bit at their core.

    It would be Hypocritical to say the Mafia is still the Mafia, when their tools and weapons have changed, but state that the Syndicate became something else when they added new tools and methods to their arsenal.

    The point? The Government did not create the Syndicate. The Syndicate created the Syndicate.

    -Rachel-
  13. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    Like an underground resistance group striking out against the gendarmes and grabbing resources.



    I'm an Italian from New Jersey.



    No, the US government imported the Mafia with a little piece of legislation called the 18th Amendment. Some historians have even argued that it was intentional.
    So! You accept and admit that Organized crime entering the nation is not created by the government, and accept that the changes the group undergoes in the nation are not the fault of the government at hand?

    Then the Syndicate is not a creation of Praetoria. But the remnants of Organized Crime pooling their resources and using the latest "Tool" to make themselves stronger against the police force.

    -Rachel-
  14. Honestly... I hold neither responsible for the actions of those in their group. I hold the PC responsible only for his actions.

    However when I see people saying that Responsible Loyalists are Villains because of their connection to Cole I feel obliged to point out that Wardens (by similar standards) are villains for being allied with Scott and the Crusaders.

    "Oh! But the Wardens don't hurt or oppress anyone except for that one time in the Enriche plant!" and neither do the Responsible Loyalists, save that one time when they take in a criminal instead of helping him break out his daughter. Their only act of "Oppression" is through an omission of action, while the Wardens actively condemn the populace of Praetoria to pain and suffering.

    Neither is -truly- heroic. Neither is -truly- villainous, through their own actions. If you back the camera up just a little they both become easily condemned by their allegiances.

    -Rachel-
  15. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    That's just not true, and if you're going to ignore what's actually said in the game then there's no point in continuing the discussion.
    Read This and tell me how it sounds. It doesn't read as "Psychics trying to avoid being eaten" it reads as "Generic Criminal Group"
    [/quote]

    -Rachel-
  16. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    There is a huge difference between a bunch of criminals, or even small gangs of them, and one huge monolithic criminal organization. The State created the latter.
    Correlation does not equate to causation. The "Syndicate" formed because Cole and his people set out a better equipped and more capable squad of officers to police the streets. They were still criminals before that. Everything that happened after that was a matter of escalation. The Seer Program started, psychics who became outlaws used their powers to hide and the Syndicate worked with them, becoming better hidden against the Police force's new tool: Psychic Detection.

    The US Government didn't create the Mafia. Criminals banded together because they were stronger together than alone. They were criminals before they banded together, they're still criminals.

    The sale of Ice Cream and the number of shark attacks across the globe both increase during summer months. That doesn't mean sharks are attacking people for the ice-cream on their fingers.

    -Rachel-
  17. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    No. They are all psychic. Read the Syndicate entry on ParagonWiki.
    They only recruit people with psychic potential. Not psychics. There is a difference. A person with psychic potential may never realize their ability. A Psychic has psychic ability.


    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    It is more or less stated in various places (e.g. Kang's arc) that they are. Some of them might have been criminals to begin with that that's immaterial. For at least 15 years they've lived in a totalitarian government that has declared their very drawing of breath a crime.
    Just as immaterial. They were criminals before that law was put into place. Your statement was wrong in that you described them as -created- by the government. they were not. They were criminals before it was fashionable.

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    Tub Ci is not even the leader of (or even a leader of) the Syndicate. He's Wu Yin's bodyguard. The leader (maybe even founder) of the Syndicate is not named and is killed off off-screen as the Nova Praetoria arcs begin. According to McKnight's arc Tub Ci was presumed dead 15 years ago -- which is when the Seer program went online and when the Syndicate was formed. Hmm....
    Yipee hurray? He was still the leader of the Tsoo. Meaning he was a Criminal before 15 years ago he faked his death. Meaning the government of Praetoria did not "create" his criminal nature or involvement in the Syndicate. You continue to be appallingly and shockingly wrong in your assertion that the Praetorian Government "Created" the Syndicate.

    -Rachel-
  18. Maybe to some degree. But they are the remnants of organized crime. While they might have "Renegade Psychic" as another crime on their rap sheet it's not the only thing they've got on there. And it's also not the -first- thing on their rap sheets, either, if the canon is to be believed.

    The Syndicate isn't just a bunch of psychics trying to avoid imprisonment. It's a collection of criminals who grabbed ups some psychics for protection and eventually, themselves, became psychic. Either because they started snagging mostly psychics or the constant tampering awoke psychic power, or because Tub Ci has always had psychic potential.

    But Tub Ci was a criminal before Psychics were outlawed/contained.

    -Rachel-
  19. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Venture View Post
    The Syndicate is composed of psychics trying to avoid becoming first Borg drones and then Tilman's lunch.
    You are so incredibly wrong that you've broken reality. Congratulations, you have divided by Wrong.

    Unlike you, however, I'll tell you -why- you're wrong. The Syndicate -CONTAINS- Psychics, Venture. Might even have some psychics in charge. But the Syndicate is composed of Tsoo and Mooks and other organized crime gangs bunching together to keep out of prison.

    Big difference, between being composed of and containing.

    -Rachel-
  20. Quote:
    Originally Posted by The_Dude73 View Post
    I just like the idea of a catfight between the two of you.
    Sadly, I'm incapable of Catfighting. =-(

    My father was a Drill Sergeant and taught me how to fight early on, in case some boy got me alone somewhere... Plus I'm 6'3" tall. >.>

    -Rachel-
  21. Quote:
    Originally Posted by Scarlet Shocker View Post
    just ignore?


    It's a troll. It's autistic.

    what alternatives do you have?
    I've got her on ignore... But everyone freaking QUOTES her... So even on Ignore it's right -theeeeeeeeeere-

    -Rachel-
  22. I'd love to see a Pet Power Pool created.

    Tier 1, immobile attack pet. Minor damage and fairly slow attack rate with moderate HP

    Tier 2, Immobile Taunt pet. PBAoE 16 target Taunt with a 25 foot range at 400%. Pet has low health so 2-3 hits will kill it. It's a distraction, nothing more.

    Tier 3, Buff Pet. PBAoE pet with a minor bonus to defense, damage, and damage resistance for all within a short range of it. Numbesrs similar to maneuvers/assault unslotted.

    Tier 4, Buff Pet. PBAoE +Regen +Recovery pet. Numbers similar to health+stamina unslotted.

    Could be neat. >.>

    -Rachel-
  23. Quote:
    Originally Posted by The_Dude73 View Post
    By the way, I think Golden Girl is just trolling you guys, at least on some level.
    Like how she takes a single line out of a large post with various points and paragraphs of explanation, then tosses off a "Cutesy" one-liner with an infuriating smiley face at the end to show her superiority complex?

    Ayep.

    -Rachel-
  24. Quote:
    Originally Posted by The_Dude73 View Post
    LOL

    Yeah, if Stalin and Pol Pot had been capitalists, then they could have really done some damage!
    The Civil War started over Capitalism. The North wanted higher tariffs on cotton, wheat, textile/food exports with lower tariffs on machinery or other goods. The south (while larger) was less populated by the north and felt threatened by the democratic superiority of the Northern states. Secession was the alternative. The Abolition of Slavery was a minor issue in the greater scheme of the war.

    World War 2 was inspired by Capitalism. After WW1 Germany was in the greatest economic depression it's ever seen. Hitler and his national Socialist Party came into power because people wanted better money-handling methods and practices. However, Hitler's "Socialist" regime was hardly socialism. All it did was give him greater power after he eliminated all other political threats and started consolidating power as the Chancellor of Germany. Greed and Capitalism lead to his rise, since most people couldn't get -jobs- outside of Germany if they had german blood.

    Every War Britain has Ever gotten into has been based on Capitalistic greed. Whether it's taking over the Ivory Coast or trying to reclaim the American Colonies due to the large amounts of cash they and the companies under the monarchy were raking in from the goods shipped in.

    Yeah... pol pot and Stalin weren't capitalists. But they also weren't Socialists, according to the original meaning and intent of the word.

    The best example of true Socialism in action would be the Native Americans and other tribal people throughout history. The Hunters hunt, the Gatherers Gather, everyone works and everyone is better off for it. If someone is sick or injured they are tended while the work goes on around them. In a Capitalist Society the injured or ill just don't earn any cash during the time they're not working.

    -Rachel-
  25. Two things. To EvilGeko's "How do we know Hamidon isn't a Hero" line.

    The Hamidon Wars lasted a LONG time. That's why so much of the world's population is dead. Everyone in Praetoria knows the Devoured are going to kill them. There is nothing to indicate that between Praetoria and Primal Earth there is a great deal of difference in the Will of the Earth or a Titanic single-celled organism.

    The Sonic Barriers aren't -just- to keep out Hamidon, they also defend against the Crystals and Boulders and all the other DE monsters. Heck! The Flower Vendor bot explains that synthetic flowers are popular because there is -no- chance of Devouring Spores infecting people. That indicates that the threat is present enough that people are still taking precautions.

    There is no evidence that the Hamidon or the Devoured are heroic in any way shape or form. Environmentalist Plantlife does not become LESS angry at humans, just because there was a nuclear war. One would imagine they'd be far -angrier-.

    To Valorin.

    The Battling with the Hamidon is basically over. Same thing with the Devoured. There just aren't enough people to fight -them- and the Resistance and the Syndicate and the Crusaders left in Praetoria. The Sonic Barriers keep them outside the City and the Clockwork have Flamethrowers so they can burn any DE-infested corpse that manages to get too close to the city before the wall finishes killing it.

    They do not send troops out to fight the DE because it would be a pointless waste of human life. The Wall is enough to keep them out and the Clockwork could fight any that managed to get in (God Forbid it should happen)

    -Rachel-