Im sorry but im not shifting through all the posts to see if this was brought up so if it was I apologzie.
The ideas set forth are great for the most part (not sure what I would vote for yet) a few just seem like rehashes unintentionally (or maybe im just not seeing the whole vision behind them I dont know). So I thought I'd bring up some stuff that I have thought of, if anybody likes em cool if not then thats cool too. Just my thoughts:
One thing I have noticed that hasnt been touched on yet is a water power set (melee is possible for this). I know we have Ice this and that but that is not the same. I guess it would be more like ranged melee (the way I see it in my mind) and as such may be really hard to do technically (being that Im not a programmer for this I dont even know if it would be possible).
The idea behind it is based on the one villain in dark wing duck (i know that may be silly, but it had some great villains and Dark Wing is one of my favorite heroes from when i was a kid) He controlled the essence of water but was more melee about it then ranged. (Kind of in vain with Mr Fantasioc I guess with how he can stretch so technicall he's fighting melee but from farther away).
I dont know though, dont know if it could work, or if ranged melee is possible in this, or even if thats something you'd consider at all for these classes, as my idea is in no way fleshed out at all, and would require a lot of thought (needs to be balanced, the range on it couldnt be comparable to corruptor or blaster or whatever). I think it would be cool though to have water armor (either full body water effect or waves at yer feet as all turns to water where you stand, whatever) or be able to fight by punching with a small range. Just an Idea I thought of, water armor may even be more feasible, idk, then water melee. Just some stuff that hasnt been touched on at all I thought I'd bring to the plate here.
Anyway, thats all I got atm that I've thought of before you posted this and I thought I'd share the idea. If it's liked cool, if it isn't thats cool too. Just my thoughts