What's YOUR favorite Archer?


Asha'man

 

Posted

As the title suggests, I'd like to know what your favorite archery based toon is. Is it a true TA/Arch defender? An Arch/* blaster? A */TA controller or a red side archer?

I have an Arch/Elec blaster at 30 or 31 but he doesn't excite me right now. I know if I just devote some time to him I'll hit the RoA goodness but whenever I'm at the selection screen I always end up playing some other toon.

I read on another thread about an Ill/TA controller and it re-raised my archery curiosity. What about Earth/TA? It sounds like it would take 3 years and a day to kill a fly but, is it fun? Is it true that Volcanic Gases can ignite the Oil Slick? That combination sounds like fun to me.


So what's your favorite archery combination? And why?



Warning: Undefined variable $userSignature in /var/www/vhosts/cityofheroes.dev/forumarchive.cityofheroes.dev/topic.php on line 334

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Asha'man View Post
As the title suggests, I'd like to know what your favorite archery based toon is. Is it a true TA/Arch defender? An Arch/* blaster? A */TA controller or a red side archer?

I have an Arch/Elec blaster at 30 or 31 but he doesn't excite me right now. I know if I just devote some time to him I'll hit the RoA goodness but whenever I'm at the selection screen I always end up playing some other toon.

I read on another thread about an Ill/TA controller and it re-raised my archery curiosity. What about Earth/TA? It sounds like it would take 3 years and a day to kill a fly but, is it fun? Is it true that Volcanic Gases can ignite the Oil Slick? That combination sounds like fun to me.


So what's your favorite archery combination? And why?
So far I have an Illusion/TA at 50 (Beau Jester on Pinn), an Arrows/EM at 42 (Beau N. Arrow on Guardian) and a TA/A Defender on Freedom (Pointy Sticks, made the day the sets were released but only level 24).

I really like my Illusion/TA -- I think that Illusion is the best primary for the TA secondary. Phantom Army gives you the opportunity to stand back and shoot all your debuff arrows from range, and TA fills in many of the holes in the Illusion set. Illusion lacks and TA provides an Immob, an AoE slow, an AoE knockdown, a sleep and a ranged AoE hold, along with Defense and Resistance Debuffs to make PA better and some much needed AoE damage to fill in when PA is recharging. His playstyle is quite different than my other Illusion controllers. I skipped Flash and Group Invis from Illusion and Flash Arrow from TA, then took Hasten/Superspeed for travel so I could fit in all of all of the remaining TA powers. Fire Blast and Fireball from the APP powers make it easy to light the Oil Slick. Disruption Arrow+Oil Slick Arrow+Fireball is so much fun.

The Blaster is also a lot of fun -- and I'm mostly a controller guy. Rain of Arrows makes the set. Other than Rain, it is OK, but cranking out Rain of Arrows-Explosive-Fistfull does a pretty good job at wiping out a group. Boost Range from the secondary is a huge benefit to the Arrows Primary.

The TA/Arrows Defender seems a little lackluster to me. I suppose it will probably get better in the upper levels once I get Oil Slick, but it just seems to me that the Controller used TA better.


LOCAL MAN! The most famous hero of all. There are more newspaper stories about me than anyone else. "Local Man wins Medal of Honor." "Local Man opens Animal Shelter." "Local Man Charged with..." (Um, forget about that one.)
Guide Links: Earth/Rad Guide, Illusion/Rad Guide, Electric Control

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Local_Man View Post
So far I have an Illusion/TA at 50 (Beau Jester on Pinn), an Arrows/EM at 42 (Beau N. Arrow on Guardian) and a TA/A Defender on Freedom (Pointy Sticks, made the day the sets were released but only level 24).

I really like my Illusion/TA -- I think that Illusion is the best primary for the TA secondary. Phantom Army gives you the opportunity to stand back and shoot all your debuff arrows from range, and TA fills in many of the holes in the Illusion set. Illusion lacks and TA provides an Immob, an AoE slow, an AoE knockdown, a sleep and a ranged AoE hold, along with Defense and Resistance Debuffs to make PA better and some much needed AoE damage to fill in when PA is recharging. His playstyle is quite different than my other Illusion controllers. I skipped Flash and Group Invis from Illusion and Flash Arrow from TA, then took Hasten/Superspeed for travel so I could fit in all of all of the remaining TA powers. Fire Blast and Fireball from the APP powers make it easy to light the Oil Slick. Disruption Arrow+Oil Slick Arrow+Fireball is so much fun.

The Blaster is also a lot of fun -- and I'm mostly a controller guy. Rain of Arrows makes the set. Other than Rain, it is OK, but cranking out Rain of Arrows-Explosive-Fistfull does a pretty good job at wiping out a group. Boost Range from the secondary is a huge benefit to the Arrows Primary.

The TA/Arrows Defender seems a little lackluster to me. I suppose it will probably get better in the upper levels once I get Oil Slick, but it just seems to me that the Controller used TA better.
Thanks Local_Man. Your post on another thread about your Ill/TA is what prompted me to ask. My only experience with Ill is paired with /storm but the thought of Ill/TA piqued my curiosity. And seeing as i'm an altoholic, well, I can't resist. I haven't leveled a Trick Arrow toon past lvl 12 so I'm leaning towards pairing something with TA. But not sure what.


LOCAL MAN! The most famous hero of all. There are more newspaper stories about me than anyone else. "Local Man wins Medal of Honor." "Local Man opens Animal Shelter." "Local Man Charged with..." (Um, forget about that one.)
Guide Links: Earth/Rad Guide, Illusion/Rad Guide, Electric Control

 

Posted

One archer I would strongly recommend AGAINST ever playing if one cares in the slightest about a toon's relative power is an A/TA Corruptor. They just stink. It's a shame, because I like the look and feel of the powers a lot, but I can't come close to pulling my own weight in teams. Playing a TA Corruptor is basically like playing a Blaster with a huge, permanent, damage debuff. TA values are quite poor on a Corruptor, and you don't make up for it in damage - in fact, your RoA comes in at Defender values, for god knows what reason.

It's been speculated on the larger TA thread that a possible reason that the set doesn't get a badly needed buff is the fear of making it too strong for controllers, but even there it's not overpowered or anything - it's just more reasonable because of the far better hold times that Controllers get. It's simply pathetic that it's a secondary for controllers, and yet they get much longer hold times for things like Ice Arrow and EMP Arrow than Defenders do in a primary. And it's not even that great for Controllers! For Corruptors? Miniscule debuffs, holds that should be measured in miliseconds - uggghhhh.


 

Posted

I have a fully slotted and purpled Trick Arrow/Archery and at the moment he's not the value I devoted him to. The debuffs are moderately effective, but with no real superior debuff in the set spammable i.e -recovery; -regen, and the fact that some of the powers don't stack really irritates me. I love TA, but I really wish they would revisit the set. I've heard so many people say TA is great with controllers, but that's because mez/mez is brilliant anyway. TA only debuffs res;def;rec;spd;tohit;dmg and a few awful mezzes: Ice Arrow which doesn't stack (I read this somewhere) and a Tier 9 power that has 300s recharge with a mediocre secondary effect.

Having said that, I can pump those debuffs out like a machine which is why I enjoy him but without a crucial debuff against AV's/EB's it needs assistance which defeats the point of an 'Offender'.

Fury


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wondering_Fury View Post
I love TA, but I really wish they would revisit the set.
Word. I really like EMP as a tier 9, but to me it and OSA are the only things worth getting excited about in the whole set. It needs better overall values and something to make it a bit less squishy, probably a serious AoE to hit debuff arrow, like a flash arrow that didn't suck. I mean dark gets two big time AoE to hit debuff powers, couldn't TA get one?

Anyhow, to return to the original poster's question, I think Archery can be a lot of fun, and TA can be at least ok for controllers.


 

Posted

Wonderful feedback folks. This is the type of information I was looking for. Whether it's positive OR negative.

Keep it coming guys. I may be leaning towards a TA controller but can still be persuaded...

:-)


 

Posted

I can't comment on /TA for controllers, as i've never tried it.

I put the TA/A defender in the same category as a Grav/Kin troller (meaning: both are powerful in the right hands, pure suckage when played by me )

But...i really enjoy my Archery/Fire/Fire blaster, she's a blast to play -pardon the pun- just shy of lvl 44, amazing solo, great on smallish teams and a quasi-perma crashless 'nuke' is usefull for those rare times i join a steamrolling team. ymmv, of course


 

Posted

My only archer is an Archery / Energy Blaster, but it's one of my favorite characters. Perma-Boost Range makes him a great long range Blaster and I love Rain of Arrows. Archery is definitely my favorite of the weapon-based blast sets. (Sorry Dual Pistols, I'll take good damage and a mini-nuke I can use without faceplanting over fancy animations )


Cascade, level 50 Blaster (NRG/NRG since before it was cool)
Mechmeister, level 50 Bots / Traps MM
FAR too many non-50 alts to name

[u]Arcs[u]
The Scavenger Hunt: 187076
The Instant Lair Delivery Service: 206636

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Asha'man View Post
Thanks Local_Man. Your post on another thread about your Ill/TA is what prompted me to ask. My only experience with Ill is paired with /storm but the thought of Ill/TA piqued my curiosity. And seeing as i'm an altoholic, well, I can't resist. I haven't leveled a Trick Arrow toon past lvl 12 so I'm leaning towards pairing something with TA. But not sure what.
Probably the only other TA controllers I would consider would be Earth/TA for the ultimate in control, or maybe Grav/TA. No controller has more control options than Earth/TA, but I think Earth/Rad and Earth/Storm are more flexible than Earth/TA and bring more to a team. And I really like the pairing of Grav and Storm, such that the only other Grav controller I would consider making is, if they ever proliferate it, Grav/Traps. Wormhole onto a bunch of Trip Mines would just be too funny.

Bad guy's thoughts --> "Ok, I'm just hanging out here in the hallway and . . Who's that? What's he doin'? wha? Huh? Ack! BLAM!"


LOCAL MAN! The most famous hero of all. There are more newspaper stories about me than anyone else. "Local Man wins Medal of Honor." "Local Man opens Animal Shelter." "Local Man Charged with..." (Um, forget about that one.)
Guide Links: Earth/Rad Guide, Illusion/Rad Guide, Electric Control

 

Posted

Mechanically, TA/Dark defender. Dark Blast's -ToHit shores up TA's weakest point, poor damage mitigation when EMP Arrow isn't available. TT and NF both have relatively fast recharge and animation times, and fit TA's AoE-heavy nature well. And paired with Dark Mastery's Oppressive Gloom, Dark Pit becomes a far more powerful tool for personal and team defense than EMP Arrow.

Thematically, TA/Archery defender or Archery/TA corruptor. I still hate the relatively weak combination of these two powersets, due to Archery offering nothing to supplement or complement TA, but I also still adore my Cherokee huntress.

But for sheer, bloody, nasty fun... Fire/TA corruptor. Glue + Rain of Fire + Scourge = OSA on steroids, with 1/3 the recharge time. Not a build I recommend for solo play without leaning on IO sets or teammates to keep you from signing up for a frequent visitor plan at the hospital, but good heavens, it's got some nice damage output.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Luminara View Post
Mechanically, TA/Dark defender. Dark Blast's -ToHit shores up TA's weakest point, poor damage mitigation when EMP Arrow isn't available. TT and NF both have relatively fast recharge and animation times, and fit TA's AoE-heavy nature well. And paired with Dark Mastery's Oppressive Gloom, Dark Pit becomes a far more powerful tool for personal and team defense than EMP Arrow.

Thematically, TA/Archery defender or Archery/TA corruptor. I still hate the relatively weak combination of these two powersets, due to Archery offering nothing to supplement or complement TA, but I also still adore my Cherokee huntress.

But for sheer, bloody, nasty fun... Fire/TA corruptor. Glue + Rain of Fire + Scourge = OSA on steroids, with 1/3 the recharge time. Not a build I recommend for solo play without leaning on IO sets or teammates to keep you from signing up for a frequent visitor plan at the hospital, but good heavens, it's got some nice damage output.
Hmm, some good suggestions here. TA/Dark sounds like a great team player. Does it solo well? Not an absolute necessity but I'd like to be able to run a mish or two solo if I don't have time to build a team. Fire/TA...anything with lots of orange numbers tickles my fun factor. :-)


 

Posted

I'll be the one to say I like my Trick Archery/Assault Rifle Defender. Yeah, I went there. I've never had a problem with redraw. I always throw out the arrow debuffs first, then use the rifle to finish the job. Nothing like lighting an Oil Slick on fire with a Flamethrower. But the real hidden power in the matchup comes from Ignite. Using that on Glue Arrowed foes or Entangling Arrow-ed/Ice Arrowed foes works wonders. Too bad it doesn't come till level 35, but it's WELL worth the wait.


 

Posted

Sterling Archer


Infinity and Victory mostly
dUmb, etc.
lolz PvP anymore, Market PvP for fun and profit

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Asha'man View Post
So what's your favorite archery combination? And why?
For me that's a tie.

Archer/Psi Blaster versus Thugs/TA mastermind.

Both are just so much fun just from the character conceptions, but the powers fit the character conceptions so well that it just makes the combos so much better.


 

Posted

Archery/Kin Corrupter. FS + RoA =


[U][URL="http://boards.cityofheroes.com/showthread.php?t=251594"][/URL][/U]

 

Posted

My Plants/TA Controller is a control and debuffing monster. It also gets great control early. By level 12 it had Seeds of Confusion and 2 ST holds. Getting the Fire Epic gave it enough damage, when combined powers in the primary and secondary, to be able to solo pretty darn well, too, though it isn't in the same realm as an Illusion ot Fire controller.

It's a build I don't see often, but I thought it was a whole lot of fun.


Too many alts to list.

 

Posted

I have an Archery/Devices Blaster that I'll give a shout out for. Probably not quite as many other tricks as some other secondary pairings for Blasters, but it's a fun concept. I named him Menelmacar, in honor of the Orion constellation in Tolkien's stories. Devices works great with that for a modern hunter character... concept is king for me.

Lot of fun with it, too. Not usually too necessary, but you can do fun stuff like lay trip mines in a mob, then have the same mobsters set them off when RoA gets them running.

Targeting Drone does make it particularly easy to riddle everything in sight with arrows, too, and Smoke Bomb and Cal Trops up your survivability nicely. Taser + Stunning Shot is nice for taking bosses out of the equation as well: generally quite useful on a soloing Blaster.


Guide: Tanking, Wall of Fire Style (Updated for I19!), and the Four Rules of Tanking
Story Arc:
Belated Justice, #88003
Synopsis: Explore the fine line between justice and vengeance as you help a hero of Talos Island bring his friend's murderer to justice.
Grey Pilgrim: Fire/Fire Tanker (50), Victory

 

Posted

I am going to have to say my FF/Archery defender is my favorite (see sig). Although I must say my Earth/TA is quite fun as well.


 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Asha'man View Post
Hmm, some good suggestions here. TA/Dark sounds like a great team player. Does it solo well?
If it didn't, I wouldn't have gotten it to 50, or have almost 1000 hours of actual play time on it.

However, my definition of "solo well" may differ from yours, so what I consider to be delightfully good might actually be painfully slow and tedious for you. I also need to note that I pursued an IO build, so I did have some extra "oomph" with it, but that build wasn't really fleshed out until after it hit 50, so most of the actual leveling was with a very roughly frankenslotted/common IOed/SOed build, and I was happy with it even at that point.

Now, with the IO build complete... well, simply put, it's the most fun I've had in this game. Was before and still is. I haven't found any combination, in any AT, that I've enjoyed as much, or wanted to keep playing as much as I want to keep playing my TA/Dark. It is the game, for me, at this point. Everything else I do, every other character I play, is just a diversion to keep me from getting burned out on my TA/Dark.

And since I spend almost all of my time solo, I'd have to say that yes, I do believe it solos well. For whatever that's worth.

My Fire/TA corruptor, though... it's a strong second. I'm really liking that one.


 

Posted

I think my fav archer by far is archery and mental manip love rain of arrows and psyscream.


 

Posted

So far, I'd say my favorites would be Arch/Storm*, Thugs/TA, and Illusion/TA. Plant/TA is good too.

* This combo hasn't been mentioned yet, I think. Storm debuffs and knockback work well with Archery; keeping me alive, letting me do more damage. Although purple Fortunata bosses still hurt ( some kicked my tail, last I played ). And soon I'll be able to stack Stunning Shot and Thunder Clap to stun bosses ( I understand that should work ). And I have hopes for the effectiveness of Rain of Arrows combined with Freezing Rain.


Arc #40529 : The Furies of the Earth

 

Posted

I only really have two Archery characters. An Archery/Fire blaster, and a TA/Ar defender. While the blaster kicks some *** (Give me your tired, your poor, your undead...), I really enjoy playing the defender, so she'd get the nod if I had to pick one.


They ALL float down here. When you're down here with us, you'll float too!

@Starflier

 

Posted

Quote:
Originally Posted by Slax View Post
Sterling Archer
Bah, beat me to it.


@Demobot

Also on Steam