Shiverwraith

Player created content... hrm, I seem to recall someone suggesting CoH should add this. Someone that got shouted down by forum trolls, that player created content would never work. Funny how things change. =)

[ QUOTE ]
I said, "no" can be a legitimate reply, but only if the post it is responding to does not pose an argument to which the "no" is in response.

For example:
I post, "Do you think Blasters should be nerfed?"
"No" is a perfectly acceptable response.

I post, "Blasters should be nerfed because of (Several reasons)."
"No" is not suffcient in this case because an argument has been presented.

Posting "Yes" would be sufficient. Saying "Yes" refers to the reasons given in the argument above, so reiterating them is unneccesary.

Simply saying "No" refers to nothing. Which reasons does it refer to, if any? Does it refer to the initial premise? There's no way to know. Having no point of reference, it is a meaningless response.

[/ QUOTE ]
what he said!!!

[ QUOTE ]
Sure, they could have, but the point is that the /no contributed just as much to the conversation and the other respondents. None of them were ideal answers, as all could have provided quantifiers for thier positions. But under present guildlines only /no is being vilified.

[/ QUOTE ]
no was rude
no did not addanything
no was pointless and worthless spam for padding yuor post cost
no was lazy

teh op shuldnt have to come back and ask why you didnt like what they suggested. i agree that /signed and such doesnt add much to the discussion which is why they shuld allow polls in teh suggestions forum. taht way the lazy dorks can click no or whatever the poll maker puts ion and not crap up the thred with spam

;salute
;dance

I agree 100% with the OP. It's about time we have some constructive discussion going without worrying that your thread will be crapped all over by negative people who don't have anything to add but want to be seen injecting their insipid and pointless opinion without backing it up.

Yes, I took the time to type this properly. A thread of this magnitude deserved it.