ice/fire vs fire/ice
I have no experience with Fire/Ice but I have a 50 Mind/Ice and a 50 Ice/Fire.
I like both. Icy Assault does good damage overall and Power Boost is always useful to have. Fiery Assault does excellent damage and Consume is a nice addition, as is the huge damage boost from Fiery Embrace if you decide on the Fire APP.
IMO neither Fiery nor Icy really has decent built in AoE capability to speak of given that you will spend a lot of time up close and a lot of your damage comes from cones. Ice Sword Circle is at least a little better than Combustion. Most of the AoE damage comes from the APPs, from Hot Feet, or in certain contrived circumstances, from enemies hitting each other while confused by Arctic Air.
Ice Control versus Fire Control is really hard to rate. Fire Control tends to have more players and IMO its the easier choice of the two. I find that Ice Control in general has a very rough time in the 40s-50s range until it can get IOed. Once you get some defense and (especially) perma-dom up though it is fairly solid if a bit harder to play than many other Control sets.
Ice/fire
I have both at 50, and the Fire/Icy is MUCH more fun. Only lvl 35 Commons slotted, but Power Boost is up 3 outta 4 spawns, so it's PB+Flashfire+Firecages to have an AoE Hold! Then I rush into melee with Hot Feet and Chilling Embrace, the Imps race to catch up, and the Sword starts chopping.
Only ranged attack I have is Bitter Ice Blast, because it's nommable, and controls. But the Dom lives in Melee (and been accused, rightfully, of being more psycho than the Imps)
Whereas the Ice/Fiery was my first Dom... pro'ly only reason he got to 50. I've still been struggling for decent playstyle (currently ranged) on him (tried both doms as Ranged or Melee, yay dual builds) that doesn't leave me wishing I was on something else... I'm tempted for an IO build, but I've got enough inprogress toons... he may just wind up gathering dust.
But, regardless, its your toon. Obviously, both sides have adherents.
I am the 99%. Occupy the World.
Minister of Infinity's Secret Police, Official Mooch of dUmb and League, Official Purveyor of Free Straws, the Most Interesting Man in the World.
http://www.change.org/petitions/ncso...city-of-heroes
I have a theme in mind for a character(thermal energy conversion) and one of these 2 combos would be awesome..Im just torn as to which way to go. Ive played both primaries to 50 as a controller but this is my first real dominator and I know that that can change up the playstyle a bit for ice at least.
This is kind of what Id imagine as pros/cons for each just on observation. Either way I plan to get fire mastery for extra aoe dmg
ice/fire
-very nice control(so a 'safer' option I s'pose)
-pet can help mez when dom isnt up
-better overall ST dmg
-consume for extra end in a pinch
fire/ice
-more dmg from primary(hot feet and imps..esp nice if something happens to cold resistant)
-more hard control
-ice dmg less commonly resisted
-better benefits from permadom(if Im remembering Domination mechanics right)
Im currently fiddling both thru mids to see which one I like better on paper per se.
@Injenius~Virtue
Stonefather - 50 Stone/WP/Soul brute
Sable Affliction - Earth/Dark/Fire Dom
Wild Cipher - Beast/Time MM